Skip to content

Thinking Clearly, for the Curious

How to tell what's true: claims, evidence, numbers, cause and the phone in your hand, as one argument that builds.

(about 5 MB) Saving for offline reading… 0 of 0 chapters Saved for offline reading · · Couldn’t save. Check your connection.
Bookmark this page or add it to your home screen to open it without internet. How?
  • Android, Chrome: ⋮ menu → Add to Home screen
  • iPhone, Safari: Share → Add to Home Screen

Why it matters

  1. Chapter 1 A rumor in December In 2000 people died in Kathmandu over a sentence that was never spoken. What was everyone so sure of?  
  2. Chapter 2 How sure Is “a serious possibility” one chance in five, or four in five? Belief as a dial from 0 to 100, and how to keep score.  
  3. Chapter 3 Taking someone's word Nearly everything you know, someone told you. Believing everyone fails, and so does doubting everyone.  

Claims and reasons

  1. Chapter 4 Saying what you mean An oracle told a king a great empire would fall. It never said which one.  
  2. Chapter 5 What holds a claim up Winning someone over as a scholar, not a king: what an argument is, and how to see what holds its point up.  
  3. Chapter 6 Missing steps Holmes named Afghanistan in a second, by steps he never said. Every argument leans on those, and that's where it breaks.  
  4. Chapter 7 Broken arguments A bishop joked about apes, and a president lined up dominoes. Most bad arguments break in one of five places.  
  5. Chapter 8 Persuasion Nepal’s cigarette packets are made to frighten. Is that a trick? When a feeling, a crowd or a tradition fits the claim.  

Where a claim comes from

  1. Chapter 9 Whom to believe In 1983 a magazine paid millions for Hitler’s diaries, and experts vouched for them. Whom should you have believed?  
  2. Chapter 10 Stories and what's missing Paintings from sailors who came home can’t tell you about those who drowned. Who isn’t in the picture?  
  3. Chapter 11 Reading sideways The photo of a flood in Gorkha was taken in Chile. Fact checkers don’t read a strange page closely: they leave it.  

Numbers without heavy math

  1. Chapter 12 Big numbers, small numbers A number alone rarely says whether it’s big. Share it out, compare like with like, and ask: out of how many?  
  2. Chapter 13 What averages and charts hide Half the patients died within eight months. One biologist lived twenty years. What an average leaves out, and what charts bend.  
  3. Chapter 14 Who was asked A magazine heard from 2.4 million Americans about who would be president and got it badly wrong. How can 1,000 do better?  
  4. Chapter 15 Chance and coincidence Real chance comes in lumps and streaks. Why rare things happen every day, and how chance fooled even the experts.  
  5. Chapter 16 Rare things and good tests A mammogram finds most cancers, yet a call-back means cancer for about one woman in 23. Counting people shows why.  
  6. Chapter 17 Changing your mind by the right amount After the 2015 earthquake, a text “from NASA” named the hour of the next one. How far should a clue move your mind?  

Cause

  1. Chapter 18 Together is not because Pellagra clustered by house and fell when sewers came. Careful doctors called it a germ. It was something else.  
  2. Chapter 19 Getting better anyway A flight instructor found shouting worked better than praise. Why he was wrong is why nearly every remedy seems to work.  
  3. Chapter 20 A fair test Why would people trying to save babies add perfume to an antiseptic, so that nobody could tell the bottles apart?  
  4. Chapter 21 Without an experiment Nobody can toss a coin to decide who smokes. So how did the world become sure that smoking causes lung cancer?  

How science decides

  1. Chapter 22 Ideas that can lose In 1919 Einstein’s theory said exactly how far starlight would bend. If the stars had stayed put, it would have lost.  
  2. Chapter 23 When science goes wrong Hungry students who ate radishes gave up sooner. A hundred studies agreed. Then 23 labs tried it together.  
  3. Chapter 24 Experts and agreement Cochrane’s logo is a chart of trials on newborn babies. Why do many studies added up beat any one of them?  
  4. Chapter 25 What facts can't settle Nepal counted 429 tigers in 2026. Science can say what more tigers will cost, but not how many we should want.  

The phone

  1. Chapter 26 The feed Why does a feed carry whatever stirs us, and what does that do to what we believe?  
  2. Chapter 27 The news For 34 years, fewer young children died in Nepal each year than the year before. Why isn’t that news?  
  3. Chapter 28 Made by machines A crowd in Bhaktapur drawn by AI, a voice that wasn’t his: when looking can’t tell, look at what’s around it.  
  4. Chapter 29 Money traps A famous face offered Rs 535,500 a week from a “government platform”. How is a money trap built, and why does it work?  
  5. Chapter 30 Health claims In 2020 Nepal’s leaders wore a card said to keep the virus away. Eight questions that take any health claim apart.  

The one source you haven't checked

  1. Chapter 31 Shortcuts Told Everest is shorter than 45,500 feet, people guessed 34,000. Told it’s taller than 2,000, they guessed 11,000.  
  2. Chapter 32 Scouts and soldiers A French officer found that his army had jailed the wrong man, against his own side and prejudice. What let him see it?  
  3. Chapter 33 When the evidence points at us In 2010 cholera reached Haiti, and the genes pointed to Nepal. How would we judge that evidence if it pointed elsewhere?  
  4. Chapter 34 Disagreeing well A relative forwards a fake. Does correcting them only make it worse? The research says no. How to do it kindly.  
  5. Chapter 35 Deciding without being sure Nobody knew which year the earthquake would come, and strengthening schools was still right. How sure is sure enough?  

How to use this book

This book is for finding out about the subject, not for an exam. Read it from the start, since each chapter builds on the one before. There are questions to tap and things to try along the way.

Written by Science Playground. Every fact here has been checked against reliable sources, but these chapters have not yet been reviewed by subject experts. If you find a mistake, tell us.