On 14 December 2000, the Indian channel Star Plus showed an interview with Hrithik Roshan. He was the new star of the year. His first film, Kaho Naa… Pyaar Hai, had opened early that year and made him famous almost overnight, and he was in the news all year. The interviewer was the actress Simi Garewal, and his father and mother sat in and answered questions too. Nepal didn’t come up.
A little over ten days later, people all over Nepal were sure that on that show he had said he hated Nepal and its people. Students marched. Indian businesses were attacked. On 26 December, in Kathmandu, police fired on a crowd attacking shops and a cinema showing his latest film. Four people were killed that day. Some reports put the toll at five, and it isn’t clear which is right. About 180 were injured, 30 of them police. One of the dead, a newspaper reported, was a twelve-year-old schoolgirl, hit by a stray bullet inside her home in Thamel.
He had never said it. Nobody produced the remark, on tape or in print. He denied it, and so did the interviewer and the channel. “The fact is I love Nepal as I love India and have tremendous respect for the Nepali people,” he said, and added that his family’s cook in Bombay and his own personal assistant were both Nepali. Within days Nepal’s own government called it “an individual’s unsubstantiated and repeatedly refuted remark”.
So people died over a sentence that was never spoken. That is what this book is about. Not the riot itself, but the small question underneath it, which can be asked of anything you hear: what is this resting on?
How a sentence nobody heard got around
A Nepali paper, writing a week after the shooting, traced the story back to a small daily, the Chitwan Post, published in Narayanghat. It didn’t report the interview. It reported a rally in Narayanghat protesting against the interview. About a week later the national papers were suddenly full of the same story. And none of the papers, the same writer pointed out, and none of the student unions marching in the street, had tried to find out whether he had really said it.
That would not have been hard. The interview was not a secret: it had gone out on television. After the shooting, the Nepali Times did the obvious thing: its reporters found the interview on the star’s website, played the whole show, and found no mention of Nepal anywhere in it. By then the shooting was over.
Meanwhile the rumor did what rumors do, which is to pick up passengers. Many of the people beaten in Kathmandu weren’t Indian at all. A Nepali journalist, writing about it years later, recalled that the rioters attacked anyone who “looked” Indian, which meant Madhesis from the Tarai, and even dark-skinned people from the hills. Vegetable sellers, many of them from the Tarai, were hit especially hard. He remembered, too, that afterward Madhesis in Kathmandu held a silent march with placards carrying a plain fact: Madhesis are also Nepalis. A Madhesi engineering student who was in Kathmandu that winter said years later: “Prior to the Hrithik Roshan scandal in December 2000, I used to consider myself a true Nepali. That incident turned me into a Madhesi.” A false sentence about a film star had become a wound between Nepalis.
It became politics, too. Student unions called strikes, and the city shut down. A group of the ruling party’s own members of parliament moved against the prime minister, and other groups, on the left and the right, found their own uses for the anger. One Nepali paper wrote at the time that it wasn’t about Hrithik anymore. The government ordered cinemas to stop showing his films, and cable companies took Indian channels off the air. On 4 January the ban was lifted, and the matter faded about as fast as it had flared.
Who started it? Nobody knows. Some people at the time thought the protests were too well organized to be spontaneous. The prime minister said the violence looked like part of a conspiracy, and set up a commission to find the rumor’s origins. If it ever said what it found, we couldn’t find it. Whether someone misheard something or made it up on purpose, nobody knows. Twenty-five years on, that is the honest answer.
What it was resting on
The strangest part is how sure people were.
In the middle of it, the BBC’s Nepali Service interviewed two politicians from parties on the left, at a time when students close to one of those parties were in the streets. The interviewer asked each of them the same thing: what was the proof? One answered, “No, I don’t need to give proof about whether he said it or not. The Nepali people have already done that.” The proof, he said, was on the Star channel. The interviewer said the channel had not confirmed it. He answered that the channel might have tried to erase it.
The other leader gave a different reason. He hadn’t seen the interview himself, he said, but he had heard of people who had, and besides, the government had banned the films until the actor apologized. “That also proves that his statements are true,” he said, “it does not matter if I heard or watched it or not.” Asked about the actor’s denial, he said that if so, it should be taken into account, and it could be true. He had heard of the denial, he said, but not read it. He also said the way the protests had turned on people looked suspect, and asked for a high-level inquiry.
It would be easy to laugh at that, and unfair. Follow the reasons back, and they are reasons nearly everyone uses every day. The papers said it. So many people believe it. The government acted on it. Each of those is usually decent evidence, because most of what is in the papers is roughly true, and most of what crowds believe is too. Here, though, the reasons leaned on each other. The ban came because of the riots. The riots came because of the papers. The papers came because of a rally. The rally came because of something someone said someone had seen. Count the people who believed it, and there were a great many. Count the people who had actually heard Hrithik Roshan say it, and as far as anyone knows, the number was zero.
That’s the shape of a lot of false things. They look as if they are standing on a great pile of evidence, and the pile turns out to be one claim, repeated. A thousand people who heard it from the same place are one source, not a thousand.
Why it matters now
Nobody in this story had a smartphone. In 2000, about one Nepali in 500 used the internet, and about one in 2,400 had a mobile phone. The rumor had to travel the old way: a rally, a small paper, the big papers, the street. Even so, less than two weeks passed between the broadcast and the shooting in Kathmandu.
Today Nepal has about as many mobile phone connections as people, and almost half of Nepalis use the internet. A claim doesn’t need a week and a printing press. It can be passed on in seconds, forwarded by people who trust whoever sent it to them, just as the readers of 2000 trusted their papers.
People have known for a long time that a lie is quicker than its correction. In 1710 the writer Jonathan Swift put it this way, in a London paper called The Examiner: “Falsehood flies, and the Truth comes limping after it.” A neater version, about a lie getting halfway around the world while the truth is still putting its shoes on, is usually credited to Mark Twain or Winston Churchill. There is no good evidence that either of them said it. Even the saying about lies travels under a false name.
Something like this, for instance, might reach you on any phone. (It’s made up for this book, and so is the tea.) A forwarded video says that हिमाली बुटी चिया, Himalayan herb tea, made from a plant that grows only high in the mountains, cured a grandmother’s diabetes in 30 days. It says the doctors know and are hiding it. It says 95% of the people who tried it got better. And it’s half price, but only today.
Nobody will riot over a tea. But the video, like the rumor, wants you to do something: to buy, to forward it to your family, perhaps to trust it over a doctor. And like the rumor, it gives you reasons. A real grandmother. A number. A secret. A deadline. Each of those is a claim resting on something, and it’s worth knowing what.
What you can’t do, and what you can
It would be nice to say the answer is to check everything yourself. It isn’t possible. You didn’t see the 14 December interview, and neither did nearly anyone who marched. Most of what anyone knows, they were told, and knowing whom to trust, and how far, is a skill of its own.
So the skill isn’t checking everything. It’s knowing what a claim is standing on, and how much weight it can hold. A rumor about a film star can be idle talk, and believing it a little costs nothing. The moment it’s about to send a crowd into the street, or send your family’s money to a stranger, it’s worth one afternoon and one question. That’s about all the Nepali Times needed in 2000.
The rest of this book digs into what claims rest on, one layer at a time: the reasons given, then who is saying it, the numbers, the claim that one thing causes another, the way it was tested, what the person telling you stands to gain, and in the end the layer people forget, which is how much you want it to be true. The forwarded video turns up again along the way, and near the end it gets taken apart whole.
Underneath all of it is a question that sounds simpler than it is. The people in the street in December 2000 were completely sure. They were as sure as anyone ever is of anything, about something that had never happened. How sure should a person be?
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
