Skip to content

← Economics

Plans and Goals

Chapter 34 · Nepal's Economy

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. Why a market economy plans
  2. Seventy years of plans
  3. How a plan is made
  4. The Sixteenth Plan
  5. Seventeen goals for the world

In 2019 Nepal set itself a target: for five years the economy would grow by 9.6% a year on average. By the plan’s last year it would invest 41.6% of everything it produced, sell abroad the equivalent of 15% of it, and draw in foreign investment worth 3%. These were the Fifteenth Plan’s numbers, and they were meant to be the first long stride towards a country that would be prosperous by 2043.

As the five years ran out, the National Planning Commission wrote down what had happened. Growth had averaged 2.6% a year. Investment was 24.5% of output, exports 7%, foreign investment 0.2%. Part of the reason arrived in the plan’s first year: Covid closed the country, the economy shrank by 2.4%, and the Commission reckons about 1.2 million more people fell into poverty. Covid wasn’t the whole of it. The war in Ukraine raised the price of fuel and much else Nepal imports, politics at home stayed unsteady, and in any case most of the plans before it had missed their growth targets too.

What’s odd is not the miss. It’s that a country whose shops, farms, buses and banks are mostly private, and whose prices are mostly set in markets, writes such a document at all, every five years, and has done since 1956. The Sixteenth Plan, the one running now, runs to nearly three hundred pages. Who is it for?

Why a market economy plans

In the Soviet Union a plan was an order. The state owned the factories, and the plan told each one what to make, how much, and for whom, as the chapter on markets and plans tells. Nepal’s plans are a different kind of thing. The Commission’s own vice-chair calls the Sixteenth a साङ्केतिक योजना, an indicative plan: it points, it doesn’t command. The government can’t tell a hotel to open in Pokhara or a farmer to grow ginger. Of the Rs. 9,483 billion the plan says the country must invest over its five years, about 67% is expected from private firms and households, 30% from the government, and the rest from cooperatives and communities.

So why bother? There are a few honest reasons.

The first is that some of what a country needs takes longer than a year to build, and only the government builds it. A highway, a hydropower dam, a transmission line or a new university is planned, bought and built over five or ten years, but budgets come one year at a time. Without a longer view, each year’s budget starts the easy half of a dozen projects and finishes none, which is one of the troubles the chapter on the budget describes. A plan is meant to say, in advance, which projects come first and roughly what they will cost. The Sixteenth Plan’s hope of four times as much power-station capacity in five years is that kind of promise: no single budget could deliver it.

The second is that a great many separate people have to move in step. A road to a new industrial area is useful only if the power line arrives too, and the power line is useful only if factories come. Ministries, provinces and municipalities each have their own budgets and their own ideas. A plan puts them on one page.

The third is a signal. A business deciding whether to build a factory wants to know what the government means to do about roads, power and taxes. Lenders abroad, and the countries that give aid, want to know what the money is for.

The last is a yardstick. A plan with numbers in it can be checked, by the Commission, by the newspapers, by anyone, and the Fifteenth was.

Nepal isn’t alone. India set up a Planning Commission in 1950 and wrote five-year plans for decades, until in 2015 it replaced the Commission with a new body, NITI Aayog. China, which mixes markets with a strong state, still plans: its lawmakers approved the Fifteenth Five-Year Plan, for 2026 to 2030, in March 2026.

Seventy years of plans

Nepal’s First Plan ran from 1956 to 1961, drawn up by a planning commission chaired by the Prime Minister. The whole of it was to invest Rs. 330 million. The Fifteenth planned for Rs. 9,229 billion, about 28,000 times as much, though a rupee bought far less by then. Counting the First, fifteen plans came before the one running now. Ten ran for five years and five for three, and there were three years with no plan at all, the last two from 1990 to 1992.

Each plan has had its own hopes, and the hopes changed with the times. The Ninth, from 1997, made reducing poverty its one objective. The Tenth took in the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals, and the Fourteenth their successors, the Sustainable Development Goals, which come at the end of this chapter. The Fifteenth was the first step of a long-term vision for the year 2100 in Nepal’s calendar, which is 2043, under the slogan “Prosperous Nepal, Happy Nepali”.

The one number nearly every plan since the Fourth has carried is a growth target, and the Sixteenth Plan sets them all out beside what came.

0246810average growth a year (%)Third, 1965–70Fourth, 1970–75Fifth, 1975–80Sixth, 1980–85Seventh, 1985–90Eighth, 1992–97Ninth, 1997–2002Tenth, 2002–07Eleventh, 2007–10Twelfth, 2010–13Thirteenth, 2013–16Fourteenth, 2016–19Fifteenth, 2019–24targetwhat camemet or beat it
Figure 34.1 Each plan’s target for average yearly growth (the ring) and the growth it got (the dot), in percent, from the Third Plan to the Fifteenth. A long line means a big miss. Teal dots met or beat the target; the Third and Fifth Plans set none. The Fourteenth’s result is the revised one. The years are fiscal years, which start in mid-July. National Planning Commission, Sixteenth Plan, Table 1.1.

By the Sixteenth Plan’s count, three plans out of eleven hit their growth target: the Sixth and Seventh in the 1980s, with modest targets, and the Fourteenth, from 2016 to 2019, which got 7.4% against 7.2%. Even that one is a close call. Growth figures are revised for years afterwards, and the Fifteenth Plan, written with the early figures, had put the Fourteenth at 6.9%, just short. Most plans aimed higher with each round, and the gap between hope and result grew. The Fifteenth aimed highest of all and fell farthest.

Growth isn’t the whole story, though, and the Commission says so. In its own summary, the social targets did satisfactorily and the growth targets fell short. Thirty years ago a quarter of Nepali women could read; by 2021 it was 69%. Electricity now reaches about 97% of households. The number of mothers who die in childbirth has come down to 151 for every 100,000 births. These things follow from schools, clinics, roads and power lines, which governments do build, more than from the factories and investment they can only hope for.

So a fair reading is that the plans have been better at listing what a government should spend on than at forecasting the whole economy. Growth depends on far more than the government: the weather and the monsoon, what India does, what migrants earn abroad, what investors expect, a pandemic. A target of 9.6% says what the country wants. It isn’t a promise anyone could keep.

How a plan is made

The National Planning Commission, राष्ट्रिय योजना आयोग, is the government’s advisory body on plans. The Prime Minister is its chair, a full-time vice-chair runs it day to day, and alongside its full-time members sit the chief secretary and the finance secretary. Its duties are set out in the National Planning Commission (Formation and Operation) Order, 2074, and its part in the budget in the Financial Procedures and Fiscal Responsibility Act, 2076. The Commission works under a larger body, the National Development Council, which brings the leaders of the parties and the chief ministers of the provinces into the discussion when a plan is being settled.

The Sixteenth Plan was made like this, as the newspapers reported it. In the middle of 2023, about a year before the Fifteenth ended, the Commission began, and its full meeting agreed an approach paper, आधारपत्र, a short statement of where the plan would go and what it would put first. Committees were formed for each broad sector, and the Commission’s timetable had ministries, provinces and local governments sending their suggestions; in its foreword the Commission thanks all three levels of government, the political parties, experts, private business, non-governmental organizations and the countries and agencies that give aid. In April 2024 the National Development Council met to discuss the draft, with the Prime Minister and the Commission’s vice-chair speaking and the leaders of the parties and the chief ministers of the provinces taking part, and the plan took effect with the new fiscal year in mid-July 2024.

Provinces and local governments write plans of their own. The Local Government Operation Act, 2074, in section 24, requires every municipality and rural municipality to make a periodic plan for its own area, in line with the federal and provincial ones, so a ward’s road and a national highway are meant to fit one picture.

A plan spends no money. Money is spent through the yearly budget, and the link between the two is a three-year spending plan, the medium-term expenditure framework, which the Commission prepares with the finance ministry. It ranks projects, sets each ministry’s ceiling and says which goals each spending line serves. Then the Commission watches what happens and writes reviews like the one this chapter began with.

Social, Explained’s Grade 10 lesson on periodic plans, in Nepali, sets out the same history and the current plan’s aims the way the school course does.

The Sixteenth Plan

The Sixteenth Plan runs from 2024/25 to 2028/29, and its vision fits in three words: good governance, social justice and prosperity, सुशासन, सामाजिक न्याय र समृद्धि. It names thirteen areas where it wants the economy to change shape, from raising farm and factory productivity and creating jobs, through roads, power and cities, to poverty, public finance, governance, climate, and leaving the list of least developed countries.

It is also much more cautious than the Fifteenth. Here are some of its headline targets, set against where things stood when it was written, mostly in 2022/23:

  • growth of 7.3% a year by the plan’s last year, from about 3.5%;
  • income per person of $2,351 a year, from $1,456;
  • poverty down to 12%, from 20.3%;
  • inflation down to 5%, from 7.7%;
  • unemployment down to 5%, from 11.4% (a figure from 2017/18, the last full count when the plan was written);
  • literacy up to 85%, from 76.2%;
  • power stations able to make 11,769 megawatts, from 2,962;
  • internet reaching 90% of people, from 69.2%.

Behind those sit more modest-sounding aims that may matter as much. The government should spend 90% of the money it budgets for, up from 80%. The gap between the better-off and the poor, measured by the Gini coefficient of the chapter on inequality, should narrow a little, from 0.300 to 0.280.

The plan counts on Nepal leaving the United Nations’ list of least developed countries in 2026 (the date has since been moved to 2029, as Chapter 36 tells), and hopes to meet the Sustainable Development Goals by 2030 and to reach upper-middle income by 2043.

Will it? The record says growth targets are the hardest part. The plan’s 7.3% is a target for its last year, not an average, and no plan except the Fourteenth has averaged more than 5%. But a target is a choice of direction as well as a forecast, and the Sixteenth’s other targets, on power, schools, the internet and spending what is budgeted, are closer to things a government can do itself.

Seventeen goals for the world

Nepal’s plans now carry a second set of targets, and those are shared with every country on Earth. In September 2015 all the members of the United Nations adopted the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, with 17 goals and 169 targets to reach by 2030. The goals run from ending poverty and hunger, through health, schooling, equality for women, clean water and decent work, to cities, climate, oceans, forests, peace and working together. They followed the Millennium Development Goals, and they are meant for every country, rich and poor.

The world is behind. The UN’s report for 2025 found that of the 139 targets it could measure, only 35% were on track or moving well, 48% were moving too slowly, and 18% had gone backwards since 2015.

Nepal took the goals into its plans, and the Commission set itself milestones for 2019, 2022 and 2025 on the way to 2030. Each line of the budget now carries a code for the goal it serves. In 2024 the Commission reported to the UN on how far the country had come. By the 2022 milestone, across the 238 measures it could check, it had reached 58.6% of what it meant to, and was 41.7% of the way to 2030. At the pace so far, it expected to get about 60% of the way by 2030. Its strongest goals were ending poverty, schooling, reducing inequality and cities; its weakest were decent work and growth, industry, responsible use of resources, and peace and strong institutions.

Here is where Nepal stands on four of them, all as the Commission measured them at the 2022 checkpoint.

Ending poverty went best of the four. On the poverty line the goals were set with, the share of poor people fell from about a quarter in 2010/11 to under 4% in 2022/23; on the new, higher line drawn for that survey, it was about a fifth, as the chapter on poverty explains. Social protection, the government’s allowances and other help, reached 47% of people, beyond its milestone. The share of households using a bank or other financial service went from 40% to 62%. But only 44.7% of households lived within half an hour of a market, against a milestone of 66%.

On hunger, few Nepalis go short of food altogether, about one in twenty by the Commission’s measure. Hunger in Nepal is mostly hidden: the share of small children too short for their age fell from 36% in 2015 to about 25%, still one child in four, and 43% of children and 34% of women had anemia, too little of the blood’s red pigment, most often for want of iron.

In schooling, nearly every child starts: 97% were enrolled in primary school. Fewer finish: 77% completed primary school, against a milestone of 93%. And of those in school, too few were learning what they should: in Grade 5, the targets for Nepali and English were missed.

Decent work and growth was the weakest of every goal the Commission measured: 31.5% of its 2022 milestone. Income per person grew by about 1% that year, against a milestone of 4.5%. Of jobs outside farming, 81% were informal, with no contract, leave or pension. More than a third of young people, 35%, were neither working nor studying nor in training. Unemployment was put at 11.4%, still the figure from the 2017/18 survey, against a milestone of 10%.

On these four, an outside judge sees much the same. The Sustainable Development Report, published each year by the Sustainable Development Solutions Network, a network of researchers and universities set up in 2012 by the UN’s Secretary-General, scores every country on all 17 goals from the latest data, giving each goal a color for how far the country still has to go and an arrow for whether it is getting there fast enough. In its 2026 edition Nepal ranked 90th of 169 countries, ahead of India (94th), Sri Lanka (92nd) and Bangladesh (110th), behind Bhutan (73rd). It marked ending poverty as on track with challenges left, hunger and schooling as improving but not fast enough, and decent work as stuck. Of the four, both the Commission and the report put decent work last.

That weakest point is the same as the plans’. Building schools and clinics, paying allowances and running power lines are things a government does directly, and Nepal has done them, as both its plans and the goals show. Making jobs, enough of them, paid enough, in Nepal, depends on millions of private decisions to invest, and that is where the plans’ growth targets have missed for decades and where the goals are most behind. It is also why so many young Nepalis earn their living abroad, the subject of the chapter on leaving.

A plan, then, is a country’s statement of what it wants and what its government will do towards it, written every five years and checked at the end. Nepal’s have been honest enough to show how far growth fell short, and useful enough that the schools, roads and power lines they listed mostly got built. The Sustainable Development Goals hold the country to the same kind of yardstick, alongside the rest of the world, and both measures point to the same unfinished task: work that pays, at home.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.