Skip to content

← World History

Gunpowder Empires

Chapter 22 · The Worlds Between

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. Guns, land and taxes
  2. The Ottomans and the Safavids
  3. Akbar and Aurangzeb
  4. China, Russia and Japan

On Thursday nights in the late 1570s, the Mughal emperor Akbar held meetings in a hall he had built for them at Fatehpur Sikri, his new capital near Agra. His court historian, Abu’l Fazl, lists who came. There were Sufis and philosophers, Sunni and Shia scholars, Brahmans, Jains, Charvakas, who trusted nothing but the senses, Christians, Jews and Zoroastrians. In 1580 Jesuit priests, Catholic missionaries from Europe, came to court and joined in.

Akbar, by most accounts, never learned to read, and it doesn’t seem to have slowed him down. Abu’l Fazl says that books were read aloud to him every day, from beginning to end, and that he marked with his own pen the place where the reader stopped, and paid the reader by the number of pages. He had the Mahabharata, almost a hundred thousand verses, put into Persian so that his court could read it.

Akbar ruled one of a handful of very large empires that, around 1600, held about half of the world’s people. Picture the map. In Istanbul sat the Ottoman sultans, ruling Turkey, the Balkans, the Arab lands and Egypt. Next door the Safavid shahs ruled Iran. The Mughals ruled northern India, and would rule much more. China was under the Ming, and from 1644 under the Qing. Russia was spreading east across Siberia, and Japan, after a century of war, was being joined under one family, the Tokugawa.

Nobody counted the world’s people in 1600, but by the best estimates there were about 556 million. China alone had about 160 million of them, and the land that is now India, Pakistan and Bangladesh about 135 million, so more than half of everyone alive lived in those two places. All of Latin America, most of it now ruled from Spain and Portugal, had fewer than 9 million. Europe’s ships had reached every ocean by then, but nearly everyone on Earth still lived under rulers whose power came from land.

People in 1600, millions (world: about 556)050100150China160India, Pakistan, Bangladesh135Western Europe74Africa55Rest of Asia44West Asia21Russia, Ukraine, Central Asia21Japan19Eastern Europe17Latin America8.6USA, Canada, Australia2.3
Figure 22.1 How many people lived where in 1600, in millions, counted by today’s countries and regions, from the best estimates there are. The two gold bars, China and the subcontinent, held more than half the world between them.

So here is this chapter in brief. Every one of these empires faced the same problem: how do you hold a country weeks or months wide together, when a message travels no faster than a horse? They found much the same three answers: guns, which only a ruler could afford in numbers; land, or rather the right to collect its taxes, lent to officers in return for soldiers; and taxes counted with a care that no earlier state had managed. Each empire did these things in its own way.

Guns, land and taxes

Cannon cost a fortune, so only a ruler could pay for many of them, and a cannon could knock down the castle wall that kept a rebellious lord safe. Abu’l Fazl wrote that guns were the locks that kept the state secure and the keys that opened the door to conquest, and boasted that apart from the Ottomans, no country had more of them than Akbar’s.

Two American historians, Marshall Hodgson and William McNeill, gave these states a name: the gunpowder empires. McNeill’s idea was that wherever one ruler could keep the new cannon to himself, he could unite larger lands than before. The name stuck, but the idea has been questioned. The Ottomans and the Safavids made their first great conquests before they had many guns, and even after the Safavids added musketeers, most of their soldiers fought with swords, lances and bows until the 1700s. Many historians now use the name loosely, for empires of the gunpowder age, and look harder at the other two answers.

The second answer was land. A ruler with a hundred thousand horsemen couldn’t pay them all in coins from the capital. So he gave each officer the right to collect the taxes of some villages, and in return the officer kept horses and men ready for war. The ruler still owned the land. The grant could be moved to another district, and it wasn’t meant to pass from father to son. That way an officer grew rich from his villages but never came to own them.

The third answer was counting. To know what each district could pay, the state had to know its fields and its harvests, and these empires measured, surveyed and wrote things down on a scale that astonished visitors.

The Ottomans and the Safavids

The Ottomans had begun as a small state in Anatolia, and in 1453 they took Constantinople, the old Roman capital, which became Istanbul. Their most famous sultan, Süleyman, ruled from 1520 to 1566. He took Belgrade, crushed the Hungarian army at Mohács in 1526, and in 1529 reached the walls of Vienna, where his siege failed. With his chief judge, Ebussuud, he brought the sultan’s own laws into line with Islamic law, and Turks remember him as Kanuni, the Lawgiver. He ruled at least 25 million people.

His best soldiers were the Janissaries, foot soldiers with guns, and many of them came through a levy called the devshirme. Every few years officials went through Christian villages in the Balkans and took boys, about one for every forty households. The boys were made Muslims and trained to serve the sultan alone. The cleverest went to the palace school, and some rose to be grand viziers, the sultan’s chief ministers. The horsemen, meanwhile, lived on grants called timars, the right to the taxes of a district in return for service. As guns took over the battlefield, the sultans needed more paid foot soldiers and fewer horsemen, and from the late 1500s many timars were turned into tax farms that sent cash to Istanbul.

Most of the sultan’s subjects in the Balkans were Christians, and there were Jews in every city. They paid a special tax and kept their own faiths. Historians used to say that the Ottomans ran them through a neat “millet system”, with each religion governing itself under its own leader, all set up when Constantinople fell. Historians now think that picture is mostly a later one. What really existed was a set of arrangements that changed from place to place and century to century, and Christians and Jews often took their quarrels to the Muslim courts by choice.

The best guide to all this is a man who wanted to see everything. Evliya Çelebi was born in Istanbul in 1611. When he was about twenty, he wrote, he dreamed that he met the Prophet. He meant to ask for şefaat, intercession on the Day of Judgment, but in his confusion he asked for seyahat, travel, and was given both. He then traveled for more than forty years, from Vienna to the Sudan, and wrote it all down in ten volumes. He describes a parade of Istanbul’s guilds in 1638, a thousand and one of them by his count, down to the circumcisers, who circumcised boys as they marched, to the noise of drums. Some of his journeys he probably never made, but where his descriptions of buildings can be checked they are often exact.

East of the Ottomans lay Iran, where the Safavids had made Shia Islam the faith of the state. The Ottomans were Sunni, and the two empires fought on and off through much of the 1500s; a peace in 1555 left Baghdad to the Ottomans. The Safavids’ greatest shah, Abbas, came to the throne in 1587 at about sixteen. He built an army that answered to him alone: slave soldiers, mostly Georgian and Circassian captives made Muslim, about twelve thousand musketeers and hundreds of cannon. He made the silk trade a royal monopoly and brought Armenian merchants to run it. In 1622, with help from four English ships, he took the island of Hormuz from the Portuguese. And he was so afraid of plots that he had his own sons killed or blinded.

In 1598 Abbas moved his capital to Isfahan and built a vast open square there, more than half a kilometer long and 160 meters wide, with a royal mosque at one end, the great bazaar at the other, and on one side a palace with a high covered terrace looking over the square, where polo was played.

Through a richly patterned vault and arch, a long rectangular square with lawns, trees and a pool, surrounded by low arcades, with a blue-domed mosque at the far end and a tall palace on the right.
Figure 22.2 The square in Isfahan, seen from the gate of the bazaar. The blue dome at the far end is the royal mosque, and the tall building on the right is the palace with its covered terrace. Photo: Amir Pashaei, CC BY-SA 4.0

Akbar and Aurangzeb

The Mughals came from Central Asia. Akbar’s grandfather Babur won north India at the battle of Panipat in 1526, with cannon and muskets. Akbar came to the throne in 1556 at thirteen and spent his life adding provinces: Gujarat, Bengal, Kashmir and more.

He bound his officers to him with ranks, from commander of ten to commander of ten thousand, each rank with its number of horsemen to keep and its pay. Most were paid not in coin but in assigned lands, the right to collect a district’s taxes, moved from place to place. In 1562 he married the daughter of the Rajput king of Amer, and her father, brother and nephew rose to the highest ranks, the nephew, Man Singh, to be one of his great generals. And in 1564 he abolished the jizya, the tax that Muslim rulers had long taken from non-Muslims. Abu’l Fazl, who wrote to praise him and is our main source, says statesmen objected, since it brought in a great deal of money, and Akbar did it anyway. Later his court called his policy sulh-i kul, peace with all.

His land tax was the most careful in the world. His minister Todar Mal had the fields measured and sorted by how often they were farmed. For each crop the officials took the average harvest of good, middling and poor land, and the state claimed a third of it, paid in cash. In about 1580 they added up the rates of the past ten years and fixed a tenth of the total as each year’s tax, so a farmer knew in advance what he owed.

A Mughal painting of men kneeling on a carpet in a courtyard at night under a full moon: two men in black robes and black caps on the left, beside men in white turbans.
Figure 22.3 Two Jesuits, in black, at a debate in Akbar’s house of worship, from a copy of Abu’l Fazl’s history painted about 1605. Akbar is not in this part of the painting. Photo: Akbarnama, Chester Beatty Library, Public domain

His great-grandson Aurangzeb is the most argued-over ruler in South Asia. He won the throne in 1658 in a war with his brothers, had his eldest brother, Dara Shikoh, executed, and kept their father, Shah Jahan, a prisoner in Agra Fort until he died. Then he ruled for 49 years. He took the sultanates of the Deccan and pushed the empire to its largest, over most of the subcontinent and perhaps 150 million people, and he spent his last years fighting in the south, much of it against the Marathas. In 1669 his officers pulled down the Vishwanath temple at Banaras, and in 1670 the Keshav Rai temple at Mathura. In 1675 he had the ninth Sikh Guru, Tegh Bahadur, executed in Delhi. The Guru’s son, Guru Gobind Singh, wrote that his father gave his head, but not his honor, for the sake of the tilak and the sacred thread, and Sikhs remember him as a martyr for freedom of faith; Persian histories written after Aurangzeb’s death call him a rebel who gathered followers and money, and historians weigh the two. In 1679 Aurangzeb brought back the jizya. A Mughal chronicle says that when crowds in Delhi blocked his way to Friday prayers to beg him to take it back, he had elephants driven through them. He died in 1707 at 88, and he was buried, as he had asked, in a plain grave in a Sufi shrine at Khuldabad, in the Deccan. A will said to be his, though the historian Jadunath Sarkar calls it only alleged, asks that his shroud be paid for with four rupees and two annas he had earned sewing caps.

A low grave covered by a white cloth scattered with red rose petals, with a small dark stone slab in the middle filled with earth, inside a plain white courtyard.
Figure 22.4 Aurangzeb’s grave at Khuldabad, in Maharashtra. The slab’s hollow is filled with earth, where herbs can grow. Photo: Colomen, CC BY-SA 3.0

What kind of ruler was he? For Sarkar, whose five volumes on him came out between 1912 and 1924, he was hardworking, honest and devout, and a disaster: by favoring Muslims and turning on Hindus he threw away Akbar’s peace with all, and hastened the empire’s break-up. That became the common view, in India especially. Audrey Truschke, an American historian, answered it in 2017. Judge him as a king of his own time, she says, not by today’s standards. He destroyed a few dozen temples, not the thousands that are claimed; he issued many orders protecting temples, gave land to Brahmans, and employed more Hindus in his government than any Mughal before him. Her critics, among them the writers Girish Shahane and Keshav Pingali, answer that even by the standards of his own time he undid the open ways of the Mughals before him, and that his own court papers tell of temples pulled down because idols were worshipped there. His court history does record an order of 1669 telling the governors to pull down the temples and schools of unbelievers, and gives spreading Islam as the reason for the jizya. The argument is not only between historians. In 2015 Delhi took his name off a road, and in Pakistan some see him as a bigot while others see him as one of the few truly righteous Muslim rulers. On one thing both sides draw on the same source. In his last letters to his sons, he wrote that he had not truly governed or protected his people, and that his life had passed in vain.

China, Russia and Japan

In 1600 the Ming had ruled China for more than two hundred years, and they were in trouble. Droughts and famines, quarrels between the court and its generals, and wars in the north all weakened them, and rebel armies grew. In 1644 a rebel leader, Li Zicheng, took Beijing, and the last Ming emperor hanged himself on a tree in an imperial garden beside the palace. A Ming general, Wu Sangui, held the pass in the Great Wall at Shanhaiguan. He let in the Manchus from the northeast, who had already named their own dynasty the Qing, and together they drove the rebels out. The Manchus then kept Beijing for themselves.

Conquering the rest of China took them almost forty years. The Manchus were few, and most of their banner armies were Chinese soldiers who had changed sides. In 1645 the regent Dorgon ordered every Chinese man to shave the front of his head and wear his hair in a long braid, the Manchu queue, within ten days. “Keep your hair and lose your head”, the saying went. Some cities resisted and were massacred, and nobody knows how many died in the whole change.

The emperor who settled it all was Kangxi, who came to the throne at seven in 1661 and reigned for 61 years, the longest of any Chinese emperor. He put down a great rebellion in the south, took Taiwan in 1683, and in 1689 agreed a border with Russia at Nerchinsk. Jesuits ran his observatory, for their astronomy. And in 1712 he froze the land tax, promising it would never be raised. His successors kept the promise. In 1720 a Qing army entered Lhasa.

Russia met the Qing because it had come so far east. In 1581 a Cossack leader called Yermak crossed the Urals with about 540 men and guns, and in 1582 took the capital of the khanate of Sibir. After that, small bands of Cossacks and traders moved along Siberia’s rivers, building wooden forts where the rivers met and making the forest peoples pay tribute in furs. They reached the Pacific in 1639, less than sixty years after Yermak set out. Smallpox went with them, and in the 1650s it killed up to eight in every ten among some Siberian peoples.

Japan went another way. After a century of civil war, Tokugawa Ieyasu won the battle of Sekigahara in 1600 and became shogun, the military ruler under the emperor, in 1603. The country was divided among about 270 lords, each with a domain measured in koku of rice, one koku being about what one man ate in a year. The Tokugawa held them in a clever grip. By 1642 every lord had to live every other year in Edo, today’s Tokyo, and when a lord went home his wife and heir stayed behind as hostages. The journeys and the two households ate up most of what a lord spent, leaving little to make war with.

The shoguns had already banned Christianity, and between 1633 and 1639 they forbade any Japanese to leave the country on pain of death and expelled the Portuguese. Japan is often called a closed country in these years, and that is only half true. Dutch and Chinese merchants still traded at Nagasaki, the Dutch on a small artificial island called Dejima. Korea, the Ryukyu kingdom and the Ainu of the north traded through three more gateways, each kept by a Japanese lord. The word for a closed country, sakoku, was only coined in 1801, and many historians prefer the shoguns’ own idea: not closing the country, but keeping the sea under control.

A painted folding screen of a wide bay among green hills, with sailing ships on the water and, at the bottom center, a small fan-shaped walled island covered with buildings.
Figure 22.5 Nagasaki Bay on a folding screen painted about 1836. The fan-shaped island at the bottom is Dejima, where the Dutch were allowed to live and trade. Photo: Kawahara Keiga; photograph by René Gerritsen, CC BY-SA 4.0

These were the states that about half the world lived in. They were not stuck or backward while Europe sailed the oceans. They counted their people and fields, kept their guns and their officers on a short lead, and held together lands bigger than any European kingdom for two or three centuries. Each also carried its own weak point: officers whose grants could turn into family property, wars that cost more than the taxes brought in, and rulers who could undo in a few years what their grandfathers had built. In 1600 the world’s great powers were still the land empires of Asia.

Meanwhile, in Nepal: the Valley’s kings struck coins copied from the Mughal emperors’, and in 1720, when the Qing army reached Lhasa, its silver flowed to the Valley’s mints; the Malla cities and their trade with Tibet are in The kingdoms of the Valley and Over the passes, and the day a Qing army came within reach of Kathmandu, in 1792, is in War with Tibet and China, all in Nepal’s History, for the Curious.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.