Skip to content

← Grade 12 Physics

Exam practice

Every question from the end of every unit, with hints and answers to open. After you check an answer, mark how you did, and come back to the ones you didn’t get.

7 questions

Unit 8 · Waves in Pipes and Strings

Answer these questions

15.
  • a.Define harmonics and overtones.
  • b.Differentiate between harmonics and overtones with respect to closed and open organ pipes.
  • c.A closed organ pipe has a fundamental frequency of 200 Hz. What is the length of the pipe? (Speed of sound = 340 m/s)
  • d.A string has linear density 0.01 kg/m and is under a tension of 144 N. What will be its fundamental frequency if its length is 0.6 m?
Answer
  • a.Harmonics are frequencies that are whole-number multiples of the fundamental frequency, nf1 nf_1 ; the fundamental is the first harmonic. Overtones are the frequencies a system actually produces above its fundamental; the first of them is the first overtone.
  • b.In an open pipe every harmonic is produced, so the first overtone is the second harmonic (2f1 2f_1 ), the second overtone the third harmonic (3f1 3f_1 ): the m m th overtone is (m+1)f1 (m + 1)f_1 . In a closed pipe only odd harmonics are produced, so the first overtone is the third harmonic (3f1 3f_1 ), the second overtone the fifth harmonic (5f1 5f_1 ): the m m th overtone is (2m+1)f1 (2m + 1)f_1 , and the second, fourth… harmonics don’t exist at all.
  • c.f1=v4l⇒l=v4f1=3404×200= f_1 = \dfrac{v}{4l} \Rightarrow l = \dfrac{v}{4f_1} = \dfrac{340}{4 \times 200} = 0.425 m.
  • d.v=Tμ=1440.01=120 v = \sqrt{\dfrac{T}{\mu}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{144}{0.01}} = 120 m/s, and f1=v2l=1202×0.6= f_1 = \dfrac{v}{2l} = \dfrac{120}{2 \times 0.6} = 100 Hz.
16.
  • a.Explain the formation of stationary waves in closed and open organ pipes.
  • b.How do boundary conditions affect the formation of nodes and antinodes?
  • c.How does changing the length of an organ pipe affect the pitch of the sound it produces? Explain using wave theory.
  • d.An open organ pipe is 85 cm long. Calculate its fundamental frequency. (Speed of sound = 340 m/s)
Answer
  • a.Air blown across the mouth of a pipe (or a tuning fork held over it) sends a longitudinal wave along the air column. It is reflected at the far end: at a closed end, where the air can’t move, and at an open end, where the air moves freely and the wave is sent back into the pipe. The wave going and the wave coming back have the same frequency and amplitude and travel in opposite directions, so they superpose into a stationary longitudinal wave. In a closed pipe it has a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, so l=(2n−1)λ/4 l = (2n - 1)\lambda/4 ; in an open pipe, antinodes at both ends, so l=nλ/2 l = n\lambda/2 . Only these wavelengths build up; the column resonates at their frequencies.
  • b.The ends decide what can happen there. At a closed end the air can’t move, so it must be a displacement node. At an open end the air moves freely (and the pressure stays at the outside air’s), so it must be an antinode. The stationary wave must fit both ends at once, which allows only certain wavelengths: an odd number of quarter-wavelengths between a node and an antinode (closed pipe), a whole number of half-wavelengths between two antinodes (open pipe) or between two nodes (a string).
  • c.The wavelengths that fit are fixed by the length: λ=4l,4l/3… \lambda = 4l, 4l/3 \dots (closed) or 2l,l… 2l, l \dots (open). With the speed of sound fixed, f=v/λ f = v/\lambda , so every frequency is proportional to 1/l 1/l : a longer pipe has longer waves and plays a lower pitch, a shorter pipe a higher one. That is why organ pipes for the low notes are long, and why lifting a finger on a flute, which shortens the air column, raises the note.
  • d.f1=v2l=3402×0.85= f_1 = \dfrac{v}{2l} = \dfrac{340}{2 \times 0.85} = 200 Hz.
17.
  • a.Derive the expressions for the fundamental frequency and overtones in: i. a closed organ pipe; ii. an open organ pipe.
  • b.A closed pipe resonates with a tuning fork of frequency 256 Hz in its first harmonic. What is the length of the pipe? (v=343 v = 343 m/s)
Answer

a. i. Closed pipe, length l l : a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end.

  • Fundamental: l=λ1/4 l = \lambda_1/4 , λ1=4l \lambda_1 = 4l , f1=v4l f_1 = \dfrac{v}{4l} .
  • First overtone: l=3λ2/4 l = 3\lambda_2/4 , λ2=4l3 \lambda_2 = \dfrac{4l}{3} , f2=3v4l=3f1 f_2 = \dfrac{3v}{4l} = 3f_1 .
  • Second overtone: l=5λ3/4 l = 5\lambda_3/4 , λ3=4l5 \lambda_3 = \dfrac{4l}{5} , f3=5v4l=5f1 f_3 = \dfrac{5v}{4l} = 5f_1 .
  • So f1:f2:f3=1:3:5 f_1 : f_2 : f_3 = 1 : 3 : 5 : only odd harmonics; the m m th overtone is (2m+1)f1 (2m + 1)f_1 .

ii. Open pipe, length l l : antinodes at both ends.

  • Fundamental: l=λ1/2 l = \lambda_1/2 , λ1=2l \lambda_1 = 2l , f1=v2l f_1 = \dfrac{v}{2l} .
  • First overtone: l=λ2 l = \lambda_2 , f2=vl=2f1 f_2 = \dfrac{v}{l} = 2f_1 .
  • Second overtone: l=3λ3/2 l = 3\lambda_3/2 , λ3=2l3 \lambda_3 = \dfrac{2l}{3} , f3=3v2l=3f1 f_3 = \dfrac{3v}{2l} = 3f_1 .
  • So f1:f2:f3=1:2:3 f_1 : f_2 : f_3 = 1 : 2 : 3 : all harmonics; the m m th overtone is (m+1)f1 (m + 1)f_1 .

b. l=v4f1=3434×256= l = \dfrac{v}{4f_1} = \dfrac{343}{4 \times 256} = 0.335 m.

18.
  • a.Why are only odd harmonics present in closed pipes, while all harmonics are present in open pipes?
  • b.Compare the harmonic content of a pipe open at both ends and one closed at one end, and explain how this affects the quality of sound.
  • c.An open pipe resonates in its second harmonic at 680 Hz. What is its length? (v=340 v = 340 m/s)
  • d.Calculate the frequency of the third harmonic of a closed pipe of length 0.4 m. (v=340 v = 340 m/s)
Answer
  • a.A closed pipe must have a node at one end and an antinode at the other. From a node to an antinode is λ/4 \lambda/4 , and each extra node–antinode pair adds λ/2 \lambda/2 , so the length can only be an odd number of quarter-wavelengths, l=(2n−1)λ/4 l = (2n - 1)\lambda/4 , giving f=(2n−1)v/4l f = (2n - 1)v/4l : odd multiples of f1 f_1 . An open pipe has antinodes at both ends; from antinode to antinode is any whole number of half-wavelengths, l=nλ/2 l = n\lambda/2 , giving f=nv/2l f = nv/2l : every multiple of f1 f_1 .
  • b.An open pipe sounds its fundamental together with all its harmonics, f1,2f1,3f1,… f_1, 2f_1, 3f_1, \dots A closed pipe sounds only f1,3f1,5f1,… f_1, 3f_1, 5f_1, \dots The quality (timbre) of a note depends on which overtones sound with the fundamental and how strongly. With the even harmonics missing, a closed pipe’s note is hollower and duller; an open pipe’s, with all of them, is fuller and richer.
  • c.In the second harmonic an open pipe holds one whole wavelength: l=λ2=vf2=340680= l = \lambda_2 = \dfrac{v}{f_2} = \dfrac{340}{680} = 0.5 m.

(Check: its fundamental is then 340/(2×0.5)=340 340/(2 \times 0.5) = 340 Hz, and 2×340=680 2 \times 340 = 680 Hz.)
d. f3=3v4l=3×3404×0.4=10201.6= f_3 = \dfrac{3v}{4l} = \dfrac{3 \times 340}{4 \times 0.4} = \dfrac{1020}{1.6} = 637.5 Hz.

19.
  • a.Explain the concept of end correction in resonance tubes.
  • b.Derive the expression for the effective length of a pipe including the end correction.
  • c.A resonance tube has an actual length of 0.75 m. If the end correction is 0.03 m, what is the effective length of the pipe?
Answer
  • a.The antinode at an open end doesn’t form exactly at the end, but a little outside it: the air just beyond the end keeps vibrating with the air inside before the wave spreads out. The distance from the open end to the antinode is the end correction, e e . A resonance tube is a closed pipe (closed at the bottom by water), so its column behaves as if it were l+e l + e long, not l l . Rayleigh found e=0.3d=0.6r e = 0.3d = 0.6r , so the wider the tube, the larger the correction.
  • b.The effective length is the distance between the true node and antinode positions (or the two antinodes) that fix the wave. For a closed pipe (one open end), leff=l+e l_{\text{eff}} = l + e , and in the fundamental λ4=l+e \dfrac{\lambda}{4} = l + e , f=v4(l+e) f = \dfrac{v}{4(l + e)} . For an open pipe (two open ends), leff=l+2e l_{\text{eff}} = l + 2e , and in the fundamental λ2=l+2e \dfrac{\lambda}{2} = l + 2e , f=v2(l+2e) f = \dfrac{v}{2(l + 2e)} . With e=0.3d e = 0.3d : l+0.3d l + 0.3d and l+0.6d l + 0.6d .
  • c.A resonance tube has one open end: leff=l+e=0.75+0.03= l_{\text{eff}} = l + e = 0.75 + 0.03 = 0.78 m.
20.
  • a.Mention the factors affecting the velocity of transverse waves along a stretched string.
  • b.Explain the laws of vibration of a stretched string.
  • c.How do length, tension and mass per unit length affect the fundamental frequency of transverse vibration of a string?
  • d.A string of length 1.2 m has a mass of 0.01 kg and a tension of 100 N. Find the velocity of the transverse wave.
Answer
  • a.v=T/μ v = \sqrt{T/\mu} : the speed depends on the tension T T (greater tension, faster waves) and the mass per unit length μ \mu (heavier string, slower waves), and through μ=πr2ρ \mu = \pi r^2\rho , on the string’s thickness and the density of its material. It does not depend on the string’s length or on the frequency.
  • b.From f=12lTμ f = \dfrac{1}{2l}\sqrt{\dfrac{T}{\mu}} :
  • Law of length: f∝1/l f \propto 1/l , T T and μ \mu constant.
  • Law of tension: f∝T f \propto \sqrt{T} , l l and μ \mu constant.
  • Law of mass: f∝1/μ f \propto 1/\sqrt{\mu} , l l and T T constant.
  • c.A longer string has a longer fundamental wavelength (2l 2l ) and so a lower frequency: twice the length, half the frequency. More tension makes the waves faster and the frequency higher: four times the tension, twice the frequency. More mass per unit length makes the waves slower and the frequency lower: four times μ \mu , half the frequency. (Example: shortening a sitar string on a fret, tightening its peg, or changing to a thinner string all raise the note.)
  • d.μ=ml=0.011.2=8.33×10−3 \mu = \dfrac{m}{l} = \dfrac{0.01}{1.2} = 8.33 \times 10^{-3} kg/m, and

v=Tμ=1008.33×10−3=1.2×104=109.5 m/s v = \sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}} = \sqrt{\frac{100}{8.33 \times 10^{-3}}} = \sqrt{1.2 \times 10^4} = \mathbf{109.5\ m/s}

21.
  • a.A string is vibrating in its third harmonic. Sketch the wave pattern and explain the number of nodes and antinodes formed.
  • b.Find the frequency of the fundamental mode of a stretched string 1 m long, under a tension of 150 N, with mass per unit length 0.005 kg/m.
  • c.A stretched string vibrates in its second overtone at 300 Hz. What is its fundamental frequency?
Answer
  • a.In the third harmonic the string vibrates in three loops, as in Figure 8.6 (c). Each loop is half a wavelength, so 3×λ/2=l 3 \times \lambda/2 = l , λ=2l/3 \lambda = 2l/3 . There are 4 nodes (the two fixed ends and two points dividing the string into thirds, at l/3 l/3 and 2l/3 2l/3 ) and 3 antinodes (the middle of each loop, at l/6 l/6 , l/2 l/2 and 5l/6 5l/6 ). Neighboring loops move in opposite directions.
  • b.v=Tμ=1500.005=30 000=173.2 v = \sqrt{\dfrac{T}{\mu}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{150}{0.005}} = \sqrt{30\,000} = 173.2 m/s, and f1=v2l=173.22×1= f_1 = \dfrac{v}{2l} = \dfrac{173.2}{2 \times 1} = 86.6 Hz.
  • c.A string makes every harmonic, so its second overtone is its third harmonic: 3f1=300 3f_1 = 300 Hz, f1= f_1 = 100 Hz.