Skip to content

← Psychology

Treatment

Chapter 33 · When minds are in trouble

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. Talking treatments, and what happens in them
  2. What all good help has in common
  3. Medicine, and why a doctor decides
  4. Care closer to home
  5. Healers, specialists, and the first step

Picture a woman in a village in eastern Nepal who has felt heavy for months. She sleeps badly, she has stopped visiting her neighbors, and the work that used to fill her days feels like carrying stones uphill. Her family has an idea of what to do, the health post has another, and the धामी (dhami) down the road a third. Which of them, if any, will help?

This chapter is about what people actually do when a mind is in trouble, and whether it works. The short answer is hopeful. For the common troubles of the mind, depression and anxiety above all, there are treatments that have been tested in hundreds of trials, and the first of them is talking. Medicine helps some people, and a doctor decides when. And Nepal has tested, carefully, how to bring that help to places with no specialist for miles.

If you are looking for help now rather than reading about it, start here. The chapter will keep.

Figure 33.1 Where to get help in Nepal. The same box is at the end of this chapter.

Talking treatments, and what happens in them

The World Health Organization’s advice on depression is plain: psychological treatments are the first treatments. For anxiety disorders it calls them essential, and for post-traumatic stress disorder the first choice. Most of it is talking with a trained person, alone or in a group, for a set number of meetings, and doing things between them. It is less like a chat with a wise friend and more like lessons with a coach: the talking is how the work is planned, and much of the work happens outside the room.

There are many kinds, and a few have been tested far more than the rest. The best known is cognitive behavioral therapy, CBT for short. Its idea is that the way we read what happens to us, and what we then do, can keep a trouble going long after its cause has gone. A person who is depressed may read a friend’s unanswered message as proof that nobody cares, stay home, and so have fewer chances to find out otherwise. In CBT, the person and the therapist catch those readings, look at the evidence for them, and try out other ways of acting to see what happens. It is a test, not a pep talk: the point is to find out, not to be told to cheer up.

Chapter 31 showed how a fear can last because it is never tested. The treatment that follows from that is exposure, which the World Health Organization describes simply as people learning to face their fears. Someone afraid of crowded buses, say, would list with the therapist the frightening situations from mildest to worst, standing at a bus stop, riding one stop with a friend, riding alone at a quiet hour, and climb that ladder a rung at a time, staying in each situation without the escapes and safety habits that chapter described, until it becomes clear that the disaster they dreaded doesn’t come. For a terrible memory, trauma-focused therapy helps the person recall and tell what happened in a safe setting, so the memory loses some of its power to ambush them. Facing a fear in small steps is the everyday version.

For depression there are other well-tested methods, and WHO names four: CBT, behavioral activation, interpersonal therapy and problem-solving therapy. Behavioral activation starts from something people with depression know well: you wait to feel like doing things, and the feeling doesn’t come. So it turns the order around. The person plans small activities that once brought some pleasure or a sense of getting something done, a walk to the temple, cooking a favorite dish, an hour in the field, and does them whether or not they feel like it, and the mood often follows the doing. Interpersonal therapy works on the relationships around a low mood, and problem-solving therapy breaks worries that feel too big to touch into parts that can be worked on.

How well do they work? CBT for depression has been tested more than any other talking treatment: one review in 2023 gathered 409 trials with more than 52,000 patients. Compared with ordinary care or a waiting list, its effect was moderate to large, and it lasted at follow-up six months to a year later. It helped children and teenagers too, though by less. But CBT was hardly better than other proper talking treatments, and that puzzle leads to the next question.

What all good help has in common

If talking treatments built on quite different ideas turn out to work about equally well, perhaps what helps is not what makes them different but what they share. Researchers have argued about this since the 1930s. They call the shared parts the common factors.

The man who did most to put the relationship at the center was Carl Rogers, whose ideas about personality are in Chapter 21. In a talk he gave in 1946 he listed the conditions he thought a counselor must meet. The counselor had to treat the client as responsible for their own life, create “a warm and permissive atmosphere” in which any feeling could be said, however contradictory, and convey “deep understanding” and acceptance, which, he added, “involves neither approval nor disapproval”. And the counselor had to hold back from what most of us do when a friend is upset: questioning, probing, blaming, interpreting, advising, persuading, even reassuring.

Research has kept returning to his themes. A review in 2015 by the psychologist Bruce Wampold, the best-known champion of the common factors, put the evidence together. The bond between a client and a therapist, and their agreement on what they are working toward and how, is called the therapeutic alliance, and it is linked to how well treatment goes in about 200 studies with more than 14,000 patients. Empathy, warmth and genuineness each showed links of their own. Therapists differ too: some get better results than others with the same kind of patients, and the better ones tend to form good alliances with a wide range of people. Meanwhile, studies that took one supposedly key ingredient out of a treatment, to see whether it still worked, mostly found that it did.

Wampold’s explanation is that a talking treatment works in three ways at once. There is a real human relationship. There is an explanation of the trouble that makes sense to the person, with a plan that follows from it, which builds the expectation of getting better. And there are the specific tasks that get the person to do healthier things, such as facing a feared bus. On this view the tasks matter, but they work best inside a relationship the person trusts.

Not everyone agrees, and it would be unfair to tell only one side. In 2019 the psychologist Pim Cuijpers and his colleagues pointed out that the research on how therapies work has so far all been correlation. A good alliance may help people improve, or people who are already improving may simply get on better with their therapist. Nobody yet knows, they concluded, whether therapies work through common factors, specific ones, or both.

That matters in Nepal. If good help depends partly on warmth, understanding and a sensible plan, then people who are not psychologists can learn to give some of it, and Nepal set out to test that.

Medicine, and why a doctor decides

Medicines are the other main kind of treatment. Some illnesses, such as bipolar disorder, are treated with medicines of their own, which this chapter leaves aside. For depression and anxiety the official advice is careful.

For adults with depression, the trials that Chapter 32 left to this one are many. A review in 2018 gathered 522 trials with more than 116,000 adults and found that every one of the 21 medicines it compared did better than a dummy pill in short-term treatment. WHO says that for mild depression medicines are not needed, and that for moderate and severe depression they can be combined with talking treatment. England’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, NICE, says doctors should not routinely offer them first for less severe depression, unless that is what the person, well informed, prefers. For anxiety disorders, WHO says some of the same medicines can also help adults.

For young people the advice is stricter. WHO says these medicines should not be used to treat depression in children, and that in teenagers they are not the first treatment and should be used with extra caution. The NHS in Britain says much the same for everyone under 18, though they are sometimes used alongside another treatment. When they are, it is a doctor’s decision, made with the young person and the family.

Why must it be a doctor? Because the choice depends on things a person can’t judge alone: how severe the illness is, what else is going on in the body and which side effects to watch for. NICE asks doctors to reach a shared decision with each person, taking their preferences into account, and says people have a right to decline treatment. And stopping matters as much as starting. NICE advises anyone who wants to stop such a medicine to talk first with the person who prescribed it, because it usually needs to be reduced in stages over time; most people, it adds, stop successfully that way.

So nothing in this chapter is a reason to start, stop or change a medicine. Anyone who takes medicine for their mind and has a question about it should take that question to their doctor. The rule for everyone else is simple: mind medicine only from a doctor, never from a friend’s packet or on your own from a pharmacy.

Care closer to home

The treatments in this chapter were mostly worked out in rich countries, with plenty of psychologists. Nepal has very few. Its mental health care began in general hospitals, with the first psychiatric outpatient clinic in 1962, and its one mental hospital, now in Lagankhel, opened in 1984. A review written in 2021 counted about 200 psychiatrists in 2020, up from about 40 in 2008, and about 30 clinical psychologists with the highest training. Services are mostly in the big cities, far from a village in the hills.

The answer that Nepal’s researchers and charities have tested is called task-sharing: training people closer to home to do part of the work, with specialists teaching and supervising them instead of seeing every patient themselves. WHO built its mhGAP program, a guide for doctors and health workers who are not mental health specialists, on the same idea, and Nepal’s government based its own plan of 2017 for mental health care in the community on it. Charities brought mental health care to Nepal’s communities long before: the United Mission to Nepal from the 1980s, and others for victims of torture, war and the refugee camps in the 1990s. The trials below were run by one of them, TPO Nepal, with researchers abroad.

One test was in Chitwan. Health workers at ordinary health posts and primary hospitals were trained to recognize depression and alcohol problems and to treat them, with medicine where it was called for. Two small trials then asked whether adding a local counselor helped. The counselors were people from the district with at least a high school education, trained for about six months. For depression, they gave six to eight weekly sessions of a behavioral activation program. Adults with depression who had the counselor as well improved more over a year, in their mood and in their daily lives, than those who had the health post’s care alone. For drinking problems, the extra counseling made no clear difference to the drinking. The trials were small, 120 people in the depression trial, and their authors said so.

Another test was of a group treatment called Problem Management Plus, made by WHO for communities hit by adversity. In 2018 and 2019 it was tried in 72 wards of Morang district in eastern Nepal, a place of yearly floods, with 611 adults, most of them women. Groups met for five weekly sessions of about two and a half hours to learn four things: to slow their breathing when stress rose, to break a problem into steps, to get going again on things that mattered to them, and to lean on the people around them. The groups were led by people from the community who had finished higher secondary school but had no training in mental health. They got twenty days of training and were supervised every week by psychologists, and their basic helping skills, such as listening and showing empathy, were rated before they led a group.

The results were real and modest. Right after the groups, people’s distress had fallen more than in the comparison wards, where families got a meeting about mental health and a referral to the health post. Three months later the difference had shrunk to a small one. But about 30 in 100 of the group members had at least halved their depression symptoms, against about 17 in 100 in the comparison wards, and fewer of them still had problems of the मन, the heart-mind, as Nepali puts it. There was no difference in symptoms of trauma or in how well people managed their daily lives.

These studies show both sides of the idea. For it: help reaches people who would otherwise get none, from someone who speaks their language and knows their life. Against it: a lay counselor can’t do everything a specialist can, and the gains depend on training and supervision that are easy to cut. When researchers asked patients and their families in Chitwan, most were satisfied with the care at their health post. Their complaints were practical: trained health workers were often transferred away, the same person wasn’t there at the next visit, medicines ran out, and there was no private room for a confidential talk. Task-sharing works when it is done properly, and the hard part is doing it properly for years, not months.

Healers, specialists, and the first step

For many people in Nepal, the first stop is not a health post at all. The review of 2021 says that for most people the first point of contact is a traditional or faith healer, such as a धामी or a झाँक्री (jhankri). Researchers who went and asked why found good reasons, and some worrying ones.

In 2019 a team that included a psychiatrist from Nepal spent three months in villages of southeastern Nepal and interviewed 124 people: 40 traditional healers, most of them धामी-झाँक्री, 79 people from the communities and five doctors. Most of the people they interviewed, 78 of the 124, believed that an illness could have both a supernatural cause and a medical one, and 64 had used both kinds of care. People valued healers for reasons that any clinic could learn from. A healer lived nearby and came quickly, at any hour. Many people said that most healers didn’t treat anyone differently for their caste or for being poor, and they took an offering, भेटी, in place of a fixed fee. One healer rang a patient afterward to ask whether he was getting better. People spoke of what good treatment left them with in words such as मनको शान्ति, peace in the heart-mind. As one farmer put it, only fishes from the same lake can help each other.

The same people were clear about bad practice. They distrusted healers who had grown greedy or arrogant, who trusted nothing but their own powers, or who started handing out medicines. Older studies record far worse: some healers threatened, beat or burned patients. A review of 86 studies of Nepal’s healers in 2021 concluded that the good people felt from them seemed greatest for mild and moderate distress, and that the research was too varied to say more.

The interviews also showed what happens when the two worlds don’t talk. Patients who felt a doctor had mocked their beliefs were far more often unhappy with their care, and some simply hid their healer visits: “That’s why we never say anything about dhami-jhankri in front of doctors.” One psychiatrist, though, allowed some patients a single visit to a healer alongside their treatment. Most of the people interviewed wanted the two to work together more, and the researchers suggested training for healers, referral both ways and an open conversation. You don’t have to choose between your faith and a doctor; the two can go together. What matters is that a serious illness doesn’t wait for months while one kind of help is tried after another, and that no one is hurt in the name of healing.

So who is who, if you go looking for help? A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who has trained further in mental illness; psychiatrists can prescribe medicine, and many also talk with their patients. A clinical psychologist has studied psychology at university to a master’s degree or beyond and been trained to assess and treat mental illness with talking therapies; psychologists don’t prescribe. A counselor helps people talk through their problems and find their own way forward, usually without giving advice; in Nepal a psychosocial counselor, मनोसामाजिक परामर्शदाता, is typically someone trained over several months by a charity to help with distress, often after disaster, violence or loss, paying attention to the family and community around the person as well as the mind. A community psychosocial worker has shorter training, to offer basic emotional support, spot people who need more and help them reach it. Counseling usually means help with the problems of living, and psychotherapy a longer, planned treatment of an illness, though the line is blurred. Titles in this field aren’t always protected, so it is fair to ask anyone what training they have and who supervises them.

There is no need to wait for the worst: trouble getting in the way of your days is reason enough. In practice, the first step is usually near home. A doctor or health worker at the nearest health post or hospital can listen, check that nothing else in the body is causing the trouble, and treat it or refer it up the chain, to a district or provincial hospital or a medical college’s psychiatry unit. Some schools have a counselor. The helplines in the box below are there for anyone who would rather start with a phone call, and this list of where to go says more. If you are offered counseling, give it a fair try: go more than once, and if you don’t get on with one person, say so and ask for another. That isn’t rude: a good working bond goes with better results.

So treatment is not one thing. It is talking that is really practice, done in a relationship the person trusts; medicine, chosen and watched over by a doctor, when the illness calls for it; and, in Nepal, increasingly, trained people from the community who bring some of that help to the village, with specialists behind them. None of it works for everyone, and most of it takes weeks rather than days. But the common troubles of the mind can be treated, as Chapter 30 and the chapters after it said, and the hardest step is usually the first one: telling someone.

Figure 33.2 Where to get help in Nepal.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.