Skip to content

← Psychology

Depression

Chapter 32 · When minds are in trouble

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. What it is like
  2. Where it comes from
  3. The chemical imbalance story
  4. Who it reaches, and who gets help

When someone you love dies, the sadness can be enormous. You cry without warning, the house feels wrong, and for weeks food tastes of nothing. And yet, as the months pass, there are moments of something else: a laugh at a cousin’s joke, the pleasure of a good meal, a morning when you forget for an hour. Sadness, even deep sadness, moves. It comes in waves, and between them life gets back in.

Depression is different. It isn’t simply sadness that lasts longer. The World Health Organization’s words for its mood are sad, irritable or empty, and for some people the emptiness is the heart of it: no energy for anything, and nothing, not even what they used to love, giving any pleasure back. In Nepal’s school books the word is अवसाद. This chapter is about what depression is, who it reaches, what is known of where it comes from, why the most famous explanation of it is in dispute, and why so many people who have it never get help, though it can be treated.

If a low mood is weighing on you right now, here is where to turn. Everything in the chapter will keep.

Figure 32.1 Where to get help in Nepal. The same box is at the end of this chapter.

What it is like

The World Health Organization puts the heart of it in one line: depression involves a low mood, or a loss of pleasure and interest in things, that lasts for a long time, not for an afternoon or a bad week. It is different, WHO says, from the ordinary ups and downs of feelings about everyday life.

What people describe goes beyond mood. The things that used to give pleasure, friends, music, a favorite food, stop giving anything back, and an ordinary day can take far more effort than it should. For some, WHO’s guide for doctors notes, the low mood is felt less as sadness than as an absence of feeling, an “emptiness”. In a teenager, the same guide says, a low mood may show less as sadness than as irritability, a short temper that is new.

Not everyone has all of these, and nobody can tell from a list whether a person has depression. A doctor looks for a pattern: how many of these things there are, how strong, for how long, and how much they get in the way of school, work, family and friends, against what is usual for that person. Reading a description like this, almost anyone will recognize a piece of themselves, because every piece is ordinary on its own. That is why a book can’t diagnose you or a friend.

Because the feelings are so ordinary in small doses, the line between a hard time and depression needs care. WHO’s guide says that some low mood is a normal reaction to a serious loss, such as a divorce or losing a job, and is common. Grief, the NHS says, is a natural response to losing someone, while depression is an illness; grieving people can have some of the same feelings, but those usually ease with time. What tends to set depression apart is how much of life it covers and how long it stays. In grief the pain is about the person who died. In depression it spreads to everything.

How people speak of it differs from place to place. In Nepal, suffering is often spoken of through the मन, the heart-mind, or the body, and WHO’s guide asks doctors everywhere to listen for pain in the heart or heat in the body as ways depression may be described. A team working in Chitwan found that the English “feeling down” made no sense in Nepali, and had to rewrite a standard questionnaire’s question around being frustrated and losing hope.

Two things depression is not. It is not ordinary sadness, however deep. And it is not weakness. The NHS is blunt about it: some people think depression is trivial and not a genuine health condition, and “they’re wrong”. It is a real illness with real symptoms, and not something a person can snap out of by pulling themselves together. Telling someone with depression to cheer up is like telling someone with a broken leg to walk it off.

Where it comes from

There is no single cause. WHO describes depression as coming from a complex interaction of social, psychological and biological factors, and the NHS says plainly that it can happen for many reasons, often several at once, and sometimes for no obvious reason at all.

The clearest link is with what happens to people. Those who have gone through hard events, the death of someone close, losing a job, abuse, a terrible experience, are more likely to become depressed. Loneliness raises the risk too. And the trouble can feed itself, in what people describe as a downward spiral: a person feels low, stops seeing friends, perhaps starts drinking more, and each of those makes the low mood worse. WHO makes the same point the other way round: depression can lead to more stress and more trouble at home, school or work, which then deepen the depression.

Genes play a part as well. Depression runs in families: in studies of families, a person with depression was markedly more likely than others to have a parent, brother or sister who had it too. Twin studies put its heritability, the share of the differences between people that goes with differences in their genes, at about 37%. That is a figure about groups, not about anyone’s chances, and it can’t be read as “37% of your depression is genetic”. The rest, the larger part, went with things particular to each person, their own experiences, along with the errors any measurement has, and the review concluded that depression comes from neither genes nor surroundings alone, but from both.

Which genes? Not one, and not a few. The famous early idea of a single gene that made people vulnerable to stress didn’t hold up in large samples. When the biggest search so far compared the DNA of nearly 700,000 people who had had depression with more than 4 million who hadn’t, in 29 countries, it found nearly 700 links to it, at more than 600 places in the DNA, each with a tiny effect. Added together, in people of European ancestry, they accounted for at most about 6% of the differences in who became depressed. Having relatives with depression makes it more likely, then, but it is no sentence. A family history of depression, the NHS says, doesn’t always mean a person will develop it.

The body matters in other ways. People with a long or serious illness, heart disease, cancer, pain that won’t go away, are more likely to become depressed, partly because of how hard it is to live with such a condition. Alcohol and drugs can bring it on or make it worse. More than one woman in ten becomes depressed while pregnant or soon after giving birth, a time of great change in the body and in life. And many of the things that raise the risk of depression, such as sitting still most of the day or drinking heavily, also raise the risk of heart disease and diabetes.

So the honest answer is: genes, life events and the body, together. A person may carry some inherited risk, meet a loss or a long strain, and be ill or isolated when it comes, and no one part explains it alone. Scientists can say a good deal about what raises the odds. Nobody can yet say exactly what happens inside the brain when a person becomes depressed.

The chemical imbalance story

You may have heard a much simpler answer: depression is a chemical imbalance in the brain, a shortage of serotonin. Serotonin is one of the brain’s chemical messengers. The idea that low serotonin causes depression was first suggested in the 1960s and became famous from the 1990s, when a new kind of antidepressant medicine, said to raise serotonin, came into wide use. It caught on. Surveys in Australia and the United States found that 80% or more of the public believed it had been proven.

In 2022 a team of researchers in Britain and elsewhere set out to check. They gathered the main reviews of the evidence: serotonin and its breakdown products measured in blood and spinal fluid, brain scans of serotonin receptors, experiments that briefly lower serotonin by taking away tryptophan, the building block the body makes it from, and the genes that handle serotonin. Their review of 17 such studies found no consistent evidence that depression is linked to, or caused by, lower serotonin. Lowering serotonin didn’t reliably bring on low mood in healthy volunteers. The largest genetic studies found nothing. They concluded that it was time to accept the serotonin theory had not been shown to be true.

The paper was widely reported, and the reply was quick. A group of 35 psychiatrists and scientists wrote that the review had left out important evidence and misread some of what it included. Lowering serotonin, they pointed out, does bring on low mood in people prone to depression and in some who have recovered on antidepressants, and a blood measure of tryptophan is lower in people with depression, most clearly in those not taking medicine. Brain scans, they argued, suggest that the serotonin system is disturbed in depression, even if not simply “low”. The review’s authors answered in turn, defending their methods and saying that their critics’ evidence was weak, small or affected by earlier medicine.

So where does that leave the story? On one point nearly everyone agrees. Several of the experts who answered the review said they knew of few or no psychiatrists who believe depression is simply a shortage of one chemical, and Britain’s Royal College of Psychiatrists had already written, in 2019, that the original idea that antidepressants “correct a chemical imbalance in the brain” is an over-simplification. A condition as varied as depression is unlikely to come down to one messenger. What is still argued is whether the serotonin system plays some part, perhaps in some people or some kinds of depression, and how anyone could measure that in a living brain. The review showed that the simple story was never proven. It didn’t prove that serotonin has nothing to do with depression. That is why the honest word is disputed, not settled either way.

One more thing often gets tangled in this. Whether a medicine helps is a separate question from what causes an illness. As one psychiatrist put it, paracetamol helps a headache, but nobody thinks headaches come from too little paracetamol. Whether antidepressants help, and whom, is decided by trials that test the medicines themselves, which belong to the next chapter. Nothing in this argument is a reason for anyone to change a medicine on their own. Anyone who takes medicine for depression and wonders about it should talk to their doctor before changing or stopping it.

Who it reaches, and who gets help

Depression is common. WHO estimates that in 2023 about 4 people in 100 around the world had it, more than 300 million in all, and about 5 adults in 100. Anyone can become depressed. It is about one and a half times as common in women as in men. It is fairly rare in young children, and becomes much commoner after puberty, when, WHO’s guide says, girls become about twice as likely as boys to have it. WHO reckons that about one in a hundred children aged 10 to 14 has depression at any one time, and about three in a hundred aged 15 to 19.

And much of it is never recognized. Depression often comes on slowly, the NHS says, so it can be hard to see that something is wrong. Many people try to cope without realizing they are unwell, and it can take a friend or a relative to say so. In surveys run with WHO in 21 countries, only a little over half of the people found to have depression felt they needed treatment at all. Fewer still got care that met even minimal standards: about one in five in rich countries, and about one in 27 in poorer ones.

Nepal measured this for itself between 2019 and 2020. The National Mental Health Survey set out to interview 15,088 people across all seven provinces, 9,200 adults and 5,888 teenagers aged 13 to 17, chosen at random, and trained interviewers asked them, face to face, the questions of a standard psychiatric interview translated into Nepali. Of the adults, about 97 in 100 answered in full.

Among adults, it found that about 3 in 100 had had depression at some time in their lives, and about 1 in 100 had it at the time they were asked. Among the teenagers, it found depression in fewer than 1 in 100. Of all the adults found to have any mental disorder, only about 4 in 10 had talked to anyone about it, and fewer than 1 in 4 had sought any treatment. The people they went to most were ordinary doctors, faith healers and psychiatrists, each seen by fewer than one in ten. Why so many stay away is the subject of a later chapter.

What can numbers like these show, and what can’t they? They are the first count of their kind for the whole country, from a large sample chosen to stand for it, and they show that depression is here, among adults and teenagers alike. But they look low beside the world’s, and the survey’s own authors give reasons to read them as an undercount. The questions were asked only in Nepali, and in Province 2, now Madhesh, where many people speak other languages first, the survey found the fewest problems of all, a figure the authors believe was grossly underreported. It left out people without homes and people in prison, and children under 13. And an interview can only count what people are willing to say to a stranger, about feelings that carry shame. Almost every one of those limits points the same way: toward people missed, not people counted twice. Even so, nobody can yet say how much depression Nepal really has, only that the survey found at least this much. Nor can a survey like this say what caused anyone’s illness. It is a snapshot, taken once.

The most hopeful fact about depression comes last, and it is also the plainest. Depression can be treated. WHO says there are effective treatments for mild, moderate and severe depression, and that talking treatments come first. With the right treatment and support, the NHS says, most people with depression can make a full recovery. What those treatments are, how they were tested and who gives them in Nepal is the subject of the next chapter, Treatment.

Help works best when it comes early. If a low mood, or a loss of interest in things you used to enjoy, goes on for weeks, or stops you sleeping, eating, studying or seeing friends, tell someone you trust, and see a doctor at your health post or hospital. If you or someone you know has thoughts of not wanting to live, the numbers in the box below are there for exactly that. Asking for help with depression is no more a weakness than asking for help with a fever.

So depression is not sadness turned up, and it is not a failing. It is a lasting low that drains pleasure, energy and hope, and it reaches hundreds of millions of people, more often women, more often after the teenage years begin. It comes from genes, life events and the body together, not from one cause. The famous story of a chemical shortage was never proven, and how far serotonin is involved is still argued, which is a question about causes, not a reason to change any medicine. Most people with depression, in Nepal and everywhere, never get care. And it can be treated: with the right treatment and support, most people recover.

Figure 32.2 Where to get help in Nepal.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.