Skip to content

← Psychology

Stress

Chapter 29 · When minds are in trouble

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. The alarm and how it works
  2. Stressors, and good stress and bad
  3. When the alarm doesn’t stop
  4. Stress in Nepal
  5. What helps, and what a very large trial found

You step off the sidewalk without looking, a horn blares, and you’re back on the curb before you know why. Your heart is thumping, your hands feel strange, and for a minute you can hear every sound in the street. Nothing hit you. Your body simply did, in less than a second, what bodies are built to do when danger comes close.

That reaction is stress, in its simplest form: the body’s alarm. Nepali calls it तनाव, tension. The alarm saved you on the curb. The trouble starts when it rings for weeks, over things no sprint can escape, like money, a sick parent or an exam that won’t go away. This chapter is about both: what the alarm is for, and what it costs when it doesn’t switch off.

If stress is weighing on you right now, here is where to turn. Everything in the chapter will keep.

Figure 29.1 Where to get help in Nepal. The same box is at the end of this chapter.

The alarm and how it works

The alarm has two arms, one fast and one slow, and a brake.

It starts in the brain. A small pair of knots of cells deep inside it, the amygdala, keeps watch on what your eyes and ears report. When something looks like danger, it signals the hypothalamus, which works like a control room for the parts of the body you don’t run on purpose, such as your heartbeat and breathing.

The fast arm runs along nerves. Within moments the adrenal glands, which sit on top of your kidneys, pour adrenaline into the blood. Your heart beats faster and harder, pushing blood to the muscles. The small airways in your lungs open wide. Sugar and fat are let out of storage, so the muscles have fuel. Your senses sharpen. All of this is ready in seconds, which is why you were on the curb before you had a thought.

The slow arm runs on hormones. The hypothalamus sends a chemical message to the pituitary gland just below it, which sends another down to the adrenal glands, and they release cortisol. Cortisol keeps the body revved up and on alert for as long as the brain still thinks there is danger, and falls once the threat has passed.

When the danger has passed, a second set of nerves, the calming ones, acts as the brake. The heart slows, breathing settles and digestion starts again. Cortisol has a brake of its own: as it rises in the blood, it tells the hypothalamus and the pituitary to send fewer of their messages, so once the brain stops signaling danger, cortisol falls back.

Danger, or a hard momentThe brain sounds the alarmamygdala, then hypothalamusFast, by nervesadrenal glands releaseadrenalineIn secondsheart beats fasterairways open widesugar into the bloodsenses sharpenSlower, by hormonespituitary, then adrenalglands: cortisolLasts longerthe body stayson alert whilethe danger seemsto lastDanger over: the brakecalming nerves settle the body;cortisol turns down its own supplyIf the alarm never switches off, the wear adds up.
Figure 29.2 The body’s alarm. The fast arm works in seconds, the slow arm keeps it going, and the brake settles everything once the danger is over.

None of this is a fault. It is a very good design for a world of sudden, short dangers: a dog in the lane, a falling rock, a horn in the street. The American physiologist Walter Cannon described it in 1915 as preparing the body for “fighting or flight”, and the phrase stuck. Later work added a third common answer, freezing, which many animals use to go unseen.

Stressors, and good stress and bad

The scientist who made “stress” a word for what happens in the body was Hans Selye, a doctor working in Montreal from the 1930s. Selye noticed that rats exposed to quite different troubles, cold, drugs or an injury, showed the same pattern of changes in their bodies. Whatever the trouble, the body’s answer was much the same. He called it the general adaptation syndrome and described three stages: the alarm, a stage of resistance in which the body copes for a while, and, if the trouble goes on long enough, exhaustion.

That gives two words worth keeping apart. A stressor is the thing that happens: an earthquake, an argument at home, a long walk to school in the rain, an exam. Stress is what it sets off in you. Big stressors are obvious. Small ones, piling up day after day, can matter as much.

Selye later split stress into two kinds, and his words are still the ones taught. Distress is the harmful kind, the strain that wears you down. Eustress, from the Greek eu, good, is the kind that sharpens you: the fizz before a match, the push of a deadline that gets the work done, the nerves before you sing on stage. The racing heart is the same in both. What differs, on this view, is how you see what is happening: as a challenge you can meet, or as a threat too big for you. And stress that goes on and on, with no end in sight, tends to be the wearing kind.

That fits the way emotions work: much depends on how you read what is happening. The same exam can be a threat for one student and a chance to show off for another, and the body follows the reading.

Not everyone likes the two words. Some biologists argue that the body’s reaction is neither good nor bad in itself, and that whether a stress does you good depends on so many other things that the labels explain little. They would simply say “stress”. The idea behind the words still holds, though: stress isn’t always bad.

When the alarm doesn’t stop

The design has one weakness. It was built for dangers that end. Once a danger is over, the brake can do its work. But many of the things that worry people don’t end: a debt, a quarrel that never gets settled, a family member far away, a home that isn’t safe. Then the alarm keeps ringing, and the body pays for it.

In 1993 two scientists, Bruce McEwen and Eliot Stellar, gave this cost a name, allostatic load. The idea is that the body is always adjusting, raising and lowering the heart rate, blood sugar and hormones to meet each demand. That adjusting is healthy. But when the demands come again and again, or the alarm never switches off, the wear adds up: what they called the hidden cost of chronic stress.

Some of that cost is fairly well understood. Research suggests that long stress helps raise blood pressure, and repeated surges of adrenaline are thought to wear on the blood vessels, which over many years adds to the risk of heart disease and strokes. It builds slowly, and blood pressure is easy to have measured and can be lowered. Cortisol that stays high increases appetite and helps the body store fat. Long stress can also make sleep, concentration and mood worse, and it can bring on or worsen anxiety and depression, which can be treated.

One of the best-known experiments on it was done with colds. A team led by a psychologist at Carnegie Mellon University in the United States asked 394 healthy volunteers how much stress they were under, then gave them nose drops containing a cold virus and kept them in quarantine to see who fell ill. The more stress people reported, the more likely they were to catch the infection and come down with a real cold: from about 27% of the least stressed to about 47% of the most. Smoking, drinking, sleep and diet didn’t explain the difference. Stress seemed to lower the body’s resistance itself.

Stress in Nepal

If you had to guess which children in Nepal carry the heaviest load of stress in their bodies, you might guess the boys who live on the streets. A study of 107 Nepali children aged 10 to 14 suggests the guess is wrong.

Two anthropologists, Carol Worthman of Emory University in the United States and Catherine Panter-Brick of Durham University in Britain, compared four groups of children: homeless street boys, children from families in poor squatter settlements in the city, children from middle-class families in the city, and children from families in a remote village. They took many measures of physical and psychosocial stress, among them how well they had grown, the cortisol in their saliva, their antibodies to a common virus, a sign of inflammation in the blood, and how fit their hearts were and how their heart and blood pressure responded to a test. Put together, these gave each child a score for allostatic load, the body’s wear from stress.

The groups differed a great deal, and the load was highest not in the street boys but in the village children, though the picture differed from one part of the score to another.

It is one study, of 107 children, and a score made of body measures is not the same as how a child feels. But the authors drew a plain lesson from it. Being homeless, or having moved away from home, shouldn’t simply be assumed to be the greatest risk to a child: it has to be weighed against what the other children live with, such as rural poverty. A label like “street child” can hide more than it tells, and a village childhood that looks safe from outside can be hard on the body.

Nepal has also lived through larger stressors in living memory.

During the Maoist war, armed groups recruited children. In 2007, after the fighting, researchers compared 141 former child soldiers with 141 children of the same age, sex, schooling and ethnic group who had never been recruited. Every one of the 282 children had been through at least one traumatic event. Even allowing for what each had lived through, the former soldiers had more symptoms of depression and of post-traumatic stress, the lasting after-effects a terrible event can leave. In anxiety and in managing daily life, the study found no clear difference. A second study of 142 former child soldiers looked at what made a difference. Torture, the death of a relative in the war, physical abuse at home and a family losing wealth in the war went with doing worse. Going to school went with doing better.

On 25 April 2015 the earthquake killed nearly 9,000 people and destroyed more than 600,000 homes. About a year later, questionnaires given to teenagers in two districts found many with the signs of trauma and of low mood. Trauma scores were higher in the harder-hit district; low mood was about as common in both. Those were one-time checklists, not diagnoses, and they can’t say how many got better afterward. The same study asked the teenagers how they coped. They talked to others, prayed, helped others and hoped for the best.

The third great stressor is quieter. Millions of Nepalis work abroad, and many families live apart for years. Health researchers have called for more support for the teenagers left behind, since being separated from a parent can add to stress and loneliness, but in Nepal it has been little studied.

Here is the part that is easy to miss when you read about war and earthquakes: most people come through them.

The World Health Organization says that almost all people caught up in an emergency feel distress, and that the distress usually gets better with time, though some people go on to develop a mental health condition and need care. For a long time psychologists thought that coping well after a disaster was rare, or even a sign of something wrong. The American psychologist George Bonanno pointed out that this belief came from studying the people who sought treatment. When researchers followed everyone, they found that many people had only small, short-lived troubles after a loss or a terrible event, and went on having good days.

A review in 2018 brought together 54 studies that followed people over time after such events. The commonest path, on average about two people in three, was resilience: they stayed steady, with no lasting rise in symptoms. About one in five had a hard time at first and then recovered. About one in ten stayed unwell, and a smaller share became unwell only later. These studies were of many kinds of people and events, and whether the same shares hold in Nepal hasn’t been measured in the studies we found. But across the studies the same paths turned up in fairly steady shares: being shaken is normal, and so is getting better.

None of this makes the suffering small. The one person in ten is still a person, and so is the one who struggles for a year before things lift. It means that a hard time is not a life sentence, and that needing help for a while is one of the ordinary ways through.

What helps, and what a very large trial found

Stress management is the name for the things that keep the alarm in proportion. The World Health Organization’s advice is plain: keep a daily routine, sleep at regular times, stay in touch with people you trust and talk to them, eat regular meals, move your body, walking included, and cut back on news and social media if they make things worse. It has a short guide, Doing What Matters in Times of Stress, with skills that take a few minutes a day, and it can be read in Nepali. Small steps like these are in the Your Mind tips: slow breathing, a walk, and knowing your own signs of stress, so you notice the alarm before it has been ringing for weeks.

What about mindfulness, training your attention to notice your breath and your thoughts without being swept along by them? Reviews of earlier studies had suggested that teaching it in schools showed promise, so it was tested on a large scale. The MYRIAD trial in the United Kingdom took 85 schools and gave about half of them a course of 10 mindfulness lessons, while the others carried on with their usual lessons on feelings and getting along. Researchers followed 8,376 pupils aged 11 to 14 for a year. At the end there was no evidence that the mindfulness schools did better on the risk of depression, on behavior and getting along, or on wellbeing. No harm from the course was seen, but it did no better than what schools already did.

That doesn’t show that mindfulness never helps anyone. It shows that ten lessons for a whole class, in British schools, did no better than ordinary teaching, and the researchers themselves say the next question is what works, for whom and how. It is also a good example of why big, careful trials matter: an idea can feel right, spread widely, and still not do what everyone hoped.

Stress is part of a full life. The alarm that gets you onto the curb, through the exam and up on stage is working as it should, and a hard time after a disaster is the normal reaction of a healthy mind. Most people come through.

But stress that doesn’t lift is a reason to act, not to wait. If worry or strain stops you sleeping, eating, studying or seeing friends, or goes on for weeks, tell someone you trust, and see a doctor at your health post or hospital. That isn’t weakness. It’s what the brake is for, given a little help.

So the body’s alarm has a fast arm and a slow one and a brake, and it is built for short dangers. Stressors are the events; stress is the body’s answer. Some stress sharpens us and some wears us down, and the difference lies less in the body than in whether it ends and whether we can meet it. In Nepal the heaviest load on the body was found where few would look, in a remote village. Almost everyone is shaken by war or disaster, and in the studies so far most people recover. And most of what helps is ordinary: sleep, routine, moving, and other people.

Figure 29.3 Where to get help in Nepal.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.