Break your arm playing football and everyone knows by evening. Your friends sign the plaster, your teacher lets you off writing, and an aunt comes round with advice. Nobody thinks less of you. Now imagine that for two months your मन has felt so heavy that you can hardly get out of bed. A great many people would tell nobody at all.
That difference has a name, stigma, and it is one of the main reasons why so many people with a mental illness never get the help that exists for them. This last chapter is about why people stay away, what is being done to change it, and the plain steps by which anyone in Nepal can reach help, for themselves or for a friend.
If something here is close to what you or someone near you is going through right now, here is where to turn. Everything in the chapter will keep.
Why people stay away
The word is Greek. A stigma was a mark cut or burned into the skin of a slave or a criminal, so that everyone could see at a glance who was to be shunned. Nobody burns marks into people now, but the idea is the same. A stigma is a label that makes others see a person as less, and treat them that way. It works much like the other labels that split people into us and them, which the chapter on us and them looked at. People who have lived with a mental illness often say something that surprises those who haven’t: that the stigma was worse than the illness itself.
Nepal has measured how many people stay away. The National Mental Health Survey set out to interview 15,088 people across all seven provinces between 2019 and 2020, adults and teenagers, with a standard psychiatric interview in Nepali. Of the adults it found to have a mental disorder, about 4 in 10 had talked to anyone about it, usually a husband or wife or someone else in the family. Fewer than 1 in 4, about 23 in 100, had sought any treatment at all. The people they went to most were ordinary doctors, faith healers and psychiatrists, and each of those was seen by fewer than one in ten: only about 6 or 7 in 100 had seen a psychiatrist. Fewer than one in a hundred had seen a counselor or a psychologist.
The survey also asked these adults what had held them back, and how much, and the answers weren’t mostly about shame. Three reasons came top. Wanting to sort it out on their own, thinking it would get better by itself, and not thinking they had a problem at all: nearly half said each of these had held them back a little or quite a lot, and between one in five and one in four said it had held them back a lot. About one in four said not knowing where to go had held them back a little or quite a lot, and one in five the cost. The worries about other people came lower down. About one in six had worried a little or quite a lot about being seen as weak, one in eight about what their family would think, and about one in ten about being seen as “crazy”, or had felt embarrassed or ashamed. For each of these worries, fewer than 3 in 100 said it had held them back a lot. A person could give several reasons, so these overlap.
A study in Chitwan, part of a larger program to bring mental health care into ordinary clinics, looked closer still. Researchers questioned nearly 2,000 adults, using short screening questionnaires for depression and for drinking problems. Of those whose answers pointed to depression, over 90% had seen nobody for it in the past year, not a doctor, a health worker or a traditional healer, and of those with signs of an alcohol problem, nearly 95%. When the researchers asked those who had had no care what stood in the way, each obstacle on the list was named, as holding them back at least a little, by about half of them or more. Money was the one most often called a big obstacle: about one person in four said not being able to afford care had held them back a lot. Next, for both groups, came the fear of being seen as crazy or weak, and for those who drank, not knowing where to go.
So staying away has many causes, and only some of them are stigma. Cost and distance are real. So is not knowing that what you feel has a name and a treatment. But stigma runs through the others. It is easier to tell yourself you can manage alone, or that nothing is really wrong, when admitting it would make you, in other people’s eyes, a different kind of person.
Karma, shame and changing minds
Every society builds its stigma out of its own beliefs, and in Nepal two of them matter most.
The first is karma, the idea that good and bad deeds shape what a person later meets in life. For many people it is a source of meaning and comfort, and it is part of the faith of millions. But when Brandon Kohrt, an American psychiatrist and anthropologist, and his colleagues asked Nepalis how they spoke of terrible events, they found it could also turn suffering into blame. An accident, a death in the family or an attack was often taken as the fruit of past deeds, कर्मको फल, the sufferer’s own from an earlier life or the family’s, परिवारको कर्म. The trouble then wasn’t only the pain. It was what the pain seemed to say about the person, and it cost them and their family their इज्जत, their standing. Some families, the researchers found, held back from seeking care for exactly this reason: seeking it would reveal the bad karma to everyone.
The second is a word, or rather two. The chapter on disorders showed how everyday Nepali divides the inner life between the मन, the heart-mind, and the दिमाग, the brain-mind that keeps behavior in check. Trouble in the मन is an acceptable reason to go for help. Trouble in the दिमाग is not, because its extreme is पागल, mad, a word whose shame can follow a family for years. So the same illness can be brought to a clinic or hidden at home depending on which word gets attached to it.
The fear of the दिमाग turned up in a place you might not expect: among health workers themselves. When Kohrt’s team trained health workers in Nepal to treat mental illness, a common fear among them was that a person whose brain-mind was damaged had lost control of their behavior and might be violent. A health worker who believes that will be reluctant to sit close to a patient, ask questions, or take them on at all. If the people who are meant to give care share the stigma, the clinic door can be open and still not let people in.
So how do you change a belief like that? Around the world, the approach with the most evidence behind it is a simple one: meeting people. In 2022 a large international commission on stigma, whose members included people who had lived with mental illness themselves, reviewed the studies and concluded that contact between people with and without that experience is, on the evidence, the most effective way to reduce stigma. It also said plainly what that evidence lacks: most of the studies with health workers were of low quality, few were proper trials, and most didn’t follow people for long.
Kohrt and colleagues at TPO Nepal tried that idea on health workers. They called it RESHAPE. People who had lived with a mental illness were trained, over three months, to tell their own story with photographs they took themselves: what life was like when they were ill, what treatment was like, and what life was like afterward. Then they stood up in front of health workers who were being trained to treat mental illness and told it. Health workers who already treated such patients well told their side too.
The first small study, in 2016 and 2017, followed 41 health workers trained this way. Before the training, 54% said they were willing to have contact with a person with a mental illness. Sixteen months later, 81% said so. Their skill in role-plays of a real consultation rose too, and in interviews many said their idea that such patients are violent had changed. But there was no comparison group, so nobody could say how much of the change came from the stories.
So the team ran a small trial with one. Thirty-four health facilities were split at random, and their 88 health workers, most of them health assistants and auxiliary health workers rather than doctors, were trained either the usual way or with RESHAPE. Sixteen months later, the RESHAPE group’s distance from people with mental illness had fallen further. And when they met real patients, they named the illness correctly far more often: 29 of 40 patients, against 10 of 29 for the group trained the usual way.
That is a striking difference, but it comes from a small study, built mainly to show whether a full trial could be done. A larger trial was set up to test it properly; we found no published results yet. What it does show is that the stigma isn’t fixed, and that people who have lived through an illness can do a great deal to change it.
Getting help
All of this is about other people’s minds. If you, or someone you care about, need help now, here is what to do.
Start by telling one person. A parent, an older brother or sister, an aunt, a teacher, a school counselor, a friend. You don’t need the right words, and you don’t need a name for what is wrong. In Nepali, the words your family already uses, मन भारी छ, my heart-mind is heavy, or निद्रा लाग्दैन, I can’t sleep, are a perfectly good start. Say what you have noticed in your days and your body. If the first person brushes it off, “it’s just a phase”, it says more about them than about you. Try someone else, and keep going until someone listens.
Then see a health worker, as close to home as you can. That may be a health post, a municipal clinic or a hospital. It is the right place to start because of a fact about Nepal’s care. For decades it was found almost only in a few hospitals. Nepal’s first psychiatric clinic was an outpatient room at Bir Hospital in Kathmandu, opened in 1961, and its only national mental hospital, at Lagankhel in Lalitpur, opened in 1984. In 2020 the government adopted a national strategy and action plan for mental health, which among other things sets out to counter myths about mental illness. By 2020 Nepal had about 200 psychiatrists, roughly one for every 150,000 people. So for most people the first step can’t be a specialist.
Instead, over the last decade, care has been brought to the places people already go. Thousands of Nepali health workers, from paramedics to nurses, have been trained through the World Health Organization’s Mental Health Gap Action Programme to recognize common mental illnesses, treat them and refer people on, and by 2025 dozens of health posts and municipal primary care centers offered mental health care. Not every health post has someone trained yet, so ask. Say it plainly: “I have been feeling very low for weeks.” The health worker can help, or send you on to a hospital where someone can. What happens after that, talking treatments, medicine, who the different specialists are, is the subject of the chapter on treatment, Chapter 33.
And there are the numbers in the box. 1166 is the National Suicide Prevention Helpline, run by the Mental Hospital in Lagankhel. It is open 24 hours, the service is free, and calls are free on Nepal Telecom. TPO Nepal answers on 1660 010 2005 every day from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., also free from Nepal Telecom. If someone may be in danger now, call the police on 100, or go to the nearest hospital.
The helpline isn’t only for the worst moments. Its counselors also answer people worried about other mental health problems, and explain what an illness is and what can be done. As the United Nations in Nepal described it in 2023, trained counselors and psychologists answer, listen and talk the trouble through. They may call back later to see how you are, invite you in for counseling, or help you see a doctor. You can call even if you aren’t sure it is serious enough.
Before you call, it is worth knowing the one limit on keeping what you say private. The government’s rules for the helpline say that what a caller tells it must be kept private, except when it shows that the caller’s life is in immediate danger. Then, to save that life, the service must get help from a health worker nearby, the caller’s family, a relative, a friend or the police. In practice, a counselor who is worried will first ask you not to be alone and to be with family or friends. That is not to get you into trouble. It is to keep you alive.
The first person to hear that someone is struggling is often not a parent or a doctor but a friend, and it may be you. You don’t have to be an expert, and you mustn’t try to be a doctor: a book can’t tell you what a friend has, and neither can you. What helps is simpler.
Tell them you have noticed, and that you are worried. Ask open questions, the kind that begin with how or what, and then listen without judging and without rushing to fix things. Tell them that talking to you was a real first step, and that the next one is to talk to someone who can help: a parent, a teacher, a health worker, the helpline. Offer to go with them. And be kind to yourself too, because hearing it can be heavy.
If a friend tells you they are thinking about suicide, the chapter on suicide says what to do. Above all, it is never a secret to keep.
Words matter here too. A joke that calls someone पागल is heard by everyone in the room, including the person who is quietly unwell and now knows what their friends would say. Saying “a person with schizophrenia” and not “a schizophrenic” sounds like a small thing. It is the difference between an illness someone has and a label that becomes all they are.
Getting better
Near its start, this book met two Nepali words, मन and दिमाग, and said that the way a language divides the inner life would matter, near the end, for who feels able to ask for help. Another idea has run under the chapters since: your mind doesn’t simply record the world. It makes its best guess, from thin signals, and it rebuilds the past each time you remember it. That can sound unsettling. It is also the most hopeful thing in the book, because a guess can change.
The brain’s wiring isn’t fixed: it goes on rewiring itself all through life, keeping the connections that are used. A fear that is faced, a step at a time and with support, tends to shrink, as the chapter on anxiety explained. When researchers follow everyone caught up in a war or a disaster, instead of meeting only those who come for treatment, recovery turns out to be the ordinary path: most people come through it. Up to four in ten people with post-traumatic stress get better within a year, even without treatment. With the right treatment and support, most people with depression can make a full recovery, and even of a severe illness like schizophrenia, at least one person in three recovers fully. The World Health Organization’s summary is short: effective prevention and treatment options exist. The trouble is mostly in reaching them.
Think of who stood at the front of those training rooms in Nepal, beside the trainers: people who had lived with a mental illness, telling health workers what their lives had been like before treatment and after. Getting better is rarely quick, and for some people it means learning to live well with an illness that comes and goes, not one that vanishes. But it is real, it happens in Nepal every day, and it usually starts with one person telling another.
So here is what to keep from this chapter, and from this part of the book. Stigma, a label that makes people see someone as less, keeps many people from care, alongside cost, distance and not knowing that help exists. In Nepal’s national survey fewer than one in four adults with a mental disorder had sought any treatment. Beliefs about karma, and the shame of the दिमाग and पागल, can turn illness into blame. Meeting people who have lived with a mental illness changes minds, even health workers’ minds, though the evidence from Nepal is still from small studies. And reaching help is a matter of plain steps: tell one person, see a health worker close to home, and keep the numbers in your phone.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
