Wait for a light, and press a key the moment it comes on: about a fifth of a second goes by. In that time a signal has gone from your eyes to the back of your brain, on to the strip of brain that moves your body, down your spinal cord and out along a nerve to the muscles of your finger. It feels like nothing at all.
How does a lump of tissue do that, and everything else a mind does? In short, the brain is made of cells that talk to each other, about 86 billion of them, with about as many other cells looking after them. Each nerve cell carries a small electric signal along itself and passes a chemical message across a gap to the next. Different parts do different jobs, though none works alone, and much of the map was drawn from people whose brains had been hurt. Hormones in the blood add slower messages. And the whole thing keeps changing with use.
This is the starting point of what psychologists call the biological approach: whatever a mind does, a body is doing it.
Cells that talk
For a long time nobody could tell whether the brain was one continuous net or made of separate cells. An Italian doctor, Camillo Golgi, found a silver stain, his “black reaction”, that picked out single nerve cells with all their branches. With it the Spanish anatomist Santiago Ramón y Cajal argued that each nerve cell was a unit on its own, touching the next but not joined to it. Golgi held to his net. The two shared a Nobel Prize, and Golgi used his prize lecture to argue against Cajal’s view. Cajal’s is the picture every textbook draws today.
A nerve cell, or neuron, has a body, many short branches called dendrites that take in signals, and one long fiber, the axon, that sends a signal on. Many axons are wrapped in a fatty coat, myelin, with small bare gaps along it, which makes the signal travel faster. At the axon’s far end are small knobs, the terminal buttons. Glial cells hold neurons in place, feed them and clean up after them. A careful count of adult men’s brains found about 86 billion neurons and about 85 billion other cells, not the hundred billion neurons and ten times as many glia still often quoted.
The signal along an axon is electric. A resting neuron is slightly negative inside, about 70 thousandths of a volt below the outside. When the signals arriving at its dendrites push it to about 55 thousandths, its threshold, the cell fires. For a moment it swings to about 30 thousandths positive, and the swing runs down the axon like a flame along a fuse. It is all or none: a neuron either fires completely or not at all, and the signal reaches the end of the axon as strong as it started.
At the end, the electricity stops. Between one neuron and the next is a very small space, the synaptic cleft, and the message crosses it as a chemical. The terminal buttons release neurotransmitters, which fit into receptors on the next cell like keys into locks. Some make the next cell more likely to fire, and some make it less likely, so a neuron is always adding up yeses and noes from the many cells that reach it. Then the gap is cleared for the next message: much of the chemical is taken back into the cell that released it, which is called reuptake.
Acetylcholine works in moving muscles and in memory, glutamate in learning and memory, GABA in sleep, and endorphins in pain. Dopamine is often called the pleasure chemical, but it works in movement, mood, reward and addiction, and the brain cells that make it are the ones lost in Parkinson’s disease. Serotonin is often called the happiness chemical, and its link to mood is argued over to this day (Chapter 32 tells that story). Every transmitter does different things in different places, and none is one feeling.
Many drugs work here. Agonists copy a transmitter and set off its receptors; antagonists sit in them and block them; others stop the clearing up, so a transmitter stays in the gap longer. Stimulants such as caffeine generally make neurons more active, depressants such as alcohol less. With repeated use the brain adjusts, so the same amount does less, which is tolerance, and some drugs bring addiction, with real suffering when they are stopped. That a chemical from outside can change a mood is one of the plainest signs that mind and body are one system.
All this takes time, and time can be measured. The Dutch physiologist Franciscus Donders measured how long people took to answer a signal, then made them choose: one answer for one signal, another for another. The second is slower, and the difference, he reasoned, is the time it takes the brain to choose. Try it on yourself.
When 1,469 adults were tested this way on computers, the average simple reaction came to about 231 thousandths of a second, or about 213 once the computers’ own delay was taken off. A choice always takes longer. Donders’ subtraction turned out to be too neat, as he half saw himself, since adding a choice can change the other steps as well, not just add one, but his idea that thinking takes time you can measure is how much of psychology’s work on the mind is still done.
What broken brains taught
The brain and spinal cord together are the central nervous system. Everything else, the nerves running out to the skin, the muscles and the organs, is the peripheral nervous system. Part of it, the somatic system, carries what you sense and the movements you choose. The other part, the autonomic system, runs the heart, the gut and the glands without being asked: one branch gets the body ready for action, the other calms it down again. The spinal cord, a soft cord about 45 centimeters long inside the backbone, has its nerve cells’ bodies in the middle, gray matter shaped like a butterfly, and the white fibers carrying signals up and down around them. It is the trunk line between brain and body, a relay station, but a very smart one, which can handle a reflex such as pulling your hand off a hot pan before the brain has heard about it. The anatomy, with the brain in 3D, is in Grade 9 Science. Which part does what was first learned from damage, by accident or by surgery.
On 13 September 1848 Phineas Gage, the foreman of a railway building gang in Vermont, in the United States, was packing a blasting charge into rock when it exploded. The iron rod he was packing it with, over a meter long and about 6 kilograms, went in under his left cheekbone and out through the top of his head. Soon afterwards he was sitting on the porch of an inn, telling people what had happened. His doctor, John Harlow, later wrote that the balance in him between reason and his “animal propensities” seemed to have been destroyed: he had become fitful, irreverent and impatient of advice, and his friends said he was “no longer Gage”.
That much is in the record. Most of the rest of the famous story isn’t. Gage is often described as a drunken, violent drifter for the rest of his life, but there is no good evidence for it. After a time showing himself and his rod at a museum in New York and working at a stable, he went to Chile and drove a stagecoach for years. Nobody recorded his days there, but an account of what seems to be the same route suggests a driver had to be ready by four in the morning for 13 hours and over 160 kilometers of poor road. That is hard to square with a man who couldn’t control himself. He died after epileptic fits nearly twelve years after the accident. There was no autopsy, so which parts were damaged can only be worked out from his skull, and the experts who have tried don’t agree. Gage is still the best-known case for the idea that the front of the brain helps people plan and hold themselves back, but notes about one man can’t carry that idea; later patients and studies do.
A clearer case came a century later, from surgery. Damage to the brain is called a lesion, and surgery that makes one on purpose is called lesioning. Henry Molaison, known for most of his life only as H.M., had seizures so bad that a surgeon removed the inner part of both temporal lobes, at the sides of the brain, including much of the hippocampus. His intelligence and his senses were untouched, but he forgot the day’s events nearly as fast as they happened. He could hold a three-digit number in mind for a quarter of an hour by repeating it to himself. Yet he learned to trace a shape while seeing his hand only in a mirror, getting better over three days with no memory of ever having done it. Studied for fifty years, his case showed that memory isn’t one thing and isn’t spread evenly through the brain. His brain, examined after his death, turned out to have more of the hippocampus left than first thought: even the best-studied cases get revised. Chapter 9 says more of what he taught about memory.
The third lesson came from surgery too. The two halves of the brain are joined by the corpus callosum, a band of about 200 million fibers. For a few patients with the worst epilepsy, surgeons cut it, and Roger Sperry and his students then tested what each half could do alone. Each half of the brain sees the opposite half of the world and moves the opposite side of the body, so a picture flashed to the left of the patient’s view reached only the right half of the brain. The patients couldn’t name it, because in most people speech comes from the left half. Yet the left hand, run by the right half, could draw it. The Nobel Prize story has more.
Put such cases together with scans of healthy brains, and a rough map appears.
Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0
The wrinkled outer layer, the cortex, is divided into four lobes on each side. The frontal lobe handles planning, judgment and self-control, and at its back is the strip that moves the body. In most people an area of the left frontal lobe, Broca’s area, is needed for producing speech. The parietal lobe, on top, takes in touch and keeps track of where things are, the body included. The temporal lobe, at the side, hears, and in most people the left one has an area, Wernicke’s area, needed for understanding speech. The occipital lobe, at the back, sees. Deeper inside, the thalamus passes on what every sense but smell sends in. The limbic system around it includes the hippocampus, needed for laying down new memories, the amygdala, which takes part in emotion and fear, and the hypothalamus, which keeps body temperature, appetite and blood pressure in check and controls the glands. Lower down, the brainstem keeps breathing and the heartbeat going, and a net of cells through it, the reticular formation, wakes the brain and lets it sleep. At the back, the cerebellum keeps balance and makes movements smooth, and helps with learned skills such as riding a bicycle.
How sure is this map? The broad outline is about as solid as anything in psychology. The finer you draw it, the less sure it gets, and “this area does that” means only that the area is needed, not that it works alone. Two popular ideas about the map don’t survive at all.
Two myths
The first is that people use only ten percent of their brains, an old story with no research behind it. It seems to have grown from the psychologist William James’s remark that people develop only a fraction of their mental powers, which the preface to a popular self-help book later turned into a percentage and pinned on him. Brain tissue costs a great deal of energy to run, and an animal carrying a mostly idle organ wouldn’t last. Losing far less than ninety percent of it, through a stroke or an injury, can be disastrous. And scans and recordings of brain cells find no quiet areas that are never used.
The second is that each person is “left-brained”, logical and verbal, or “right-brained”, creative and intuitive. It is often pinned on the split-brain studies, which found differences that show up clearly only when the bridge is cut. When a team scanned the brains of 1,011 people aged 7 to 29 while they rested, they found some networks that lean left, such as some for language, and some that lean right, such as some for attention. But a person whose language networks leaned left wasn’t more lopsided elsewhere: there were no left-brained or right-brained people, only left- and right-leaning parts in everyone. It is one large study, of resting brains, but it fits the split-brain work: two halves with different strengths, working as one.
Messages in the blood
Neurons are fast and private: a signal goes to the cells it touches in thousandths of a second. The endocrine system is slower and more public. Its glands release hormones into the blood, which carries them everywhere, so a hormone takes longer to act, lasts longer and reaches many organs at once. The two systems meet in the hypothalamus, which signals the pituitary gland beneath it. The pituitary is called the master gland, since its hormones control several other glands, but it mostly takes its orders from the hypothalamus.
Body and glands: BodyParts3D (CC BY 4.0)
The pineal gland, deep in the brain, releases melatonin, which helps set the body’s daily rhythms, sleep among them. The thyroid in the neck sets how fast the body burns energy, and too much of its hormone can leave a person agitated. The four small parathyroid glands behind it keep the blood’s calcium at the right level. The thyroid needs iodine, which is why salt in Nepal is iodized, as Grade 9 Science explains. The adrenal glands, on top of the kidneys, release adrenaline and noradrenaline when you are frightened or stressed, the racing heart of Chapter 13. The gonads, the ovaries and testes, release the sex hormones, which play a part in sexual desire and behavior. What each gland makes and where it acts is settled science; how much any of them shapes behavior from day to day is much less clear.
Take testosterone and aggression. When a team gathered every study they could find, the link between the testosterone a person normally has and how aggressive they are was very weak, close to nothing in women and small in men. A rise in testosterone went with slightly more aggression. And in studies that gave people extra testosterone to see what happened, which is the only way to show a cause, there was almost no effect at all. Large doses of the artificial hormones some bodybuilders take do seem to raise aggression, but that is not the hormone a body makes itself. Hormones nudge behavior; they rarely decide it.
A brain that changes, and pictures of it
The brain’s wiring isn’t fixed. Connections that are used get stronger, and new ones form, all through life. This plasticity is why people can recover after a stroke or a head injury, as other parts slowly take over some of the lost work.
The best-known evidence comes from London’s taxi drivers. To get a license they must learn about 25,000 streets in the middle of the city by heart, and many who try never qualify. Eleanor Maguire and her colleagues scanned 79 trainees before they began and 31 people of the same age and intelligence who weren’t training. At the start, the groups’ brains looked alike. Three or four years later, the 39 trainees who had qualified had more gray matter at the back of the hippocampus, the part tied to finding your way. Those who didn’t qualify, and those who never trained, had no such change. It is one careful study that followed the same people over time, about as good evidence as there is that learning changes an adult brain, though the authors leave open whether those who passed were better able to change from the start.
An MRI scan uses strong magnets to show the brain’s structure in fine detail. A functional MRI, or fMRI, shows where blood is flowing, and since busy brain cells draw more blood and oxygen, it shows roughly which parts are busy over time. An EEG records the brain’s electrical activity through the scalp, timed to the thousandth of a second.
None of these reads thoughts. An fMRI picture is built from as many as 130,000 tiny boxes of brain, and each one is tested for a change. Test that many, and some will seem to change by chance alone. The neuroscientist Craig Bennett showed how badly this can go. He bought a whole Atlantic salmon, put it, dead, in a scanner, showed it photographs of people in social situations, and asked it what each person was feeling. Analyzed without care, a few boxes in the salmon’s brain seemed to light up. With the correction for so many tests, nothing did. At the time somewhere between a quarter and two-fifths of published fMRI studies had skipped that correction; a few years later, about a tenth still did. Brain pictures are real evidence, but a colored blob in a news story is the end of a long chain of choices.
So the biological approach rests on a few ideas: that every thought and feeling is something the nervous system is doing, that its parts can be studied one at a time, and that the body’s chemistry and the genes behind it shape behavior, as Chapter 5 takes further. Its usual strengths are that its claims can be measured and tested, from a reaction time to a scan, and that it has real uses, from treating brain injuries to medicines for mental illness. Its usual weaknesses are that it can shrink a person to their chemistry, as if a feeling were nothing but a chemical, that it can make behavior sound fixed by biology, and that much of its evidence shows what goes together, not what causes what: a picture of a busy brain area doesn’t say what the person was thinking, or why. A brain isn’t a set of parts with one job each, but billions of cells passing signals through many parts at once, reshaped all the time by what its owner does and lives through.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
