Grown-ups have been grumbling about teenagers for as long as anyone has written things down. Young people are moody, they say, reckless, glued to their friends and deaf to their parents. More than a century ago the American psychologist G. Stanley Hall wrote a book about adolescence and gave it a phrase that has never gone away: storm and stress. A whole age of life, in his telling, was a kind of weather.
The teenage years are a time of big change, in the body, in the brain, among friends and in how a person sees themselves, and some things really do get harder for a while. Arguments at home rise, moods swing more, and risks look more tempting than they will at thirty. But the storm isn’t the same for everyone, it is milder in some places than in others, and the brain behind it is not faulty. It is a brain doing what brains do at that age, and much of what gets said about it goes further than the evidence does.
A body on its own timetable
Puberty is the part everyone can see. Somewhere around 11 or 12 a small gland under the brain, the pituitary, starts sending stronger signals, and the body answers with growth hormone and the sex hormones. Over the next few years, until about 15 or 16, comes a growth spurt. The organs of reproduction mature, which psychologists call the primary sex characteristics, and the outward signs arrive: breasts and wider hips in girls, a deeper voice and facial hair in boys, hair under the arms and between the legs in both. Girls have their first period, and boys their first release of semen, often at night in a dream. Girls usually start a year or two before boys, which is why a Grade 7 class can look like two different ages sitting side by side.
Puberty overlaps the end of childhood and the start of adolescence, so no single day divides them. It is short, a few years, in three parts: an early one, when the sex characteristics begin, a middle, and a late one, when they mature. It can bring a spell of moodiness and wanting to be alone, once called the negative phase. It comes at different ages for different people, depending on their genes, how well they were fed, their health and their homes: two friends born in the same month can be years apart in their bodies, both perfectly normal. Young people also grow more aware of what is expected of them as a girl or a boy. Advice, encouragement and affection from parents and teachers, acting more as counselors than as bosses, can ease the hard parts.
The World Health Organization counts adolescence as the whole stretch from 10 to 19, a longer thing than puberty. Nepal’s Health books split it into an early, a middle and a late part, with girls entering each earlier than boys, and growth in height carrying on to about 17 or 18 in girls and 19 or 20 in boys. Nepal’s Education books, following the stages in the chapter on the first years, call the years from about 10–12 to 13–14 पूर्वकिशोरावस्था (pūrvakiśorāvasthā), pre-adolescence, and from then to 18 किशोरावस्था (kiśorāvasthā), adolescence. Feelings, friendships and the wish to decide things alone change with it. Puberty is the starter, not the whole race.
The starter has been firing earlier. A review of 30 studies found that the age at which girls’ breasts begin to develop fell by almost three months every ten years between 1977 and 2013. And starting well ahead of one’s classmates carries a small extra risk: a review of 101 studies found that early puberty went with slightly more worries, low moods and trouble with behavior, in boys and girls alike. The effect is small: it shows up across thousands of people, not as a fate for one.
A brain still being built
The brain changes too, and here the science is newer and shakier than the headlines.
What brain scans show most firmly is this. In four groups of young people scanned more than once between childhood and their late twenties, the gray matter of the outer layer, the cortex, was at its largest in childhood and shrank steadily through the teenage years, the shrinking slowing down in the twenties. The white matter, the long wires that join one area to another, kept growing until the middle or late teens and then leveled off. The usual explanation is the one in the chapter on the first years: connections that get used are kept and others are cut back, and in the front of the brain that cutting runs through the teenage years. The wires, meanwhile, get wrapped in more of the fatty coating that speeds up their signals.
A study that looked closely at children’s visual areas found that part of the shrinking seen on scans is the coating itself, which changes how the tissue looks to the scanner. The cortex wasn’t getting thinner so much as better insulated, a reminder that scans are measurements, not photographs (see the chapter on the brain).
You may have heard that the brain is finished at 25. No such date exists. Different parts and different measures settle at different ages, and some keep changing all through adult life. One neuroscientist who reviewed the evidence put it drily: if “mature” means every measure has stopped changing, the answer lies somewhere between the thirties and never.
So what does it mean for how teenagers act? One popular account says the parts of the brain that respond to rewards and thrills race ahead at puberty, while the parts in the front, the ones that plan and hold back (see the chapter on self-control), take years longer to catch up. For a while, the story goes, the accelerator is stronger than the brakes.
The best test of the idea came from the psychologist Laurence Steinberg and his colleagues, who asked about 5,000 people aged 10 to 30 in 11 countries, among them China, Kenya, Sweden, Jordan and India, where the group was from Delhi. Each filled in a questionnaire about how much they liked thrills and new experiences, played games that measured the pull of rewards, among them a driving game, and did tests of holding back.
Liking thrills, by the study’s combined measures, rose through the teens and peaked at about 19, then fell again, though the driving game on its own barely moves with age. Self-control kept rising until the mid-twenties, while the single test of it drawn here levels off by the late teens. That is the shape the popular account predicts, in most of the countries but not all: in four, Sweden among them, liking thrills didn’t peak in the teens, and in India and Jordan self-control showed no clear change with age. Where young people grow up shapes the pattern.
The averages also hide how much people differ. The average for liking thrills goes from 56 at age 10 to 62 at 19, a rise of six points out of a hundred. Within a single age, about two people in three lay within 28 points either side of their group’s average. Knowing a person’s age tells you very little about how much they like thrills. Plenty of 17-year-olds like thrills less than the average 25-year-old.
Other findings take more of the sneer out. When dozens of laboratory studies of risk were pooled, teenagers did take more risks than adults, but no more than children did. The gap with adults showed most in “hot” tasks, with rewards and losses right there. A review of how young people make decisions found that teenagers are capable of reasoning well when they have time and calm. They do worse in the heat of the moment, with friends around or in a situation that is new to them. And the old idea that teenagers think themselves invulnerable didn’t hold up: if anything, they overestimated the chances of dangers like lung cancer, and the feeling of being at risk fell with age. A related idea, that teenagers feel watched by an imaginary audience and believe their own story is unlike anyone else’s, found only partial support when it was put to the test. Feeling self-conscious was the one part that changed with school grade.
Friends
Friends start to count before the teens. Nepal’s Education books call the school years from about six to twelve or thirteen late childhood, or the group age, when children play and study in groups, start to put their friends’ rules ahead of the family’s, and learn the skills of games, reading, writing and arithmetic. Friends matter more still in the teenage years, and young people turn toward them and a little away from their parents. What gets exaggerated is the break. Most teenagers in the studies feel warmly toward their parents, and serious fighting is uncommon. Most of the arguing is about everyday things.
The famous evidence that friends change behavior comes from a driving game. Steinberg and a colleague had people play it alone or with two others of their own age. People took more risks with company, and the effect was larger in teenagers and people in their early twenties than in older adults. A later study put 40 people in a brain scanner while they played a similar game, with friends they had brought along watching from the next room. The 14 teenagers ran more yellow lights when watched, and the areas of their brains that respond to reward were more active. The areas linked with holding back were no different.
Those are small studies, and the picture is messier: 56 young teenagers aged 12 to 15 played a similar game beside someone their own age and beside a parent, and took no more risks with the peer. A recent review of 79 reports found that peers did sway young people, by a moderate amount on average, though it varied a great deal from study to study. What mattered most was not others simply being there but seeing what they did.
Why should friends count for so much? The neuroscientist Sarah-Jayne Blakemore has argued that for a teenager the risk that weighs heaviest is often a social one: being rejected by the group. Set against that, the chance of getting hurt or caught can seem the smaller danger, and taking a risk with friends can be a sensible choice by the measure that matters most at that age.
The pull of the group works in both directions. In one study, people asked how risky various situations were shifted their answers toward other people’s ratings, less so as they got older. Most leaned toward adults’ views, but the young teenagers leaned more toward other teenagers’. In another, 12- to 16-year-olds playing a sharing game gave more when other teenagers were watching, and more again when those watchers showed approval with “likes”. Friends who are generous or careful pass that on too.
Who am I?
Somewhere in these years most people start asking a question that small children don’t: who am I, apart from my family’s child and my teacher’s pupil? The psychologist Erik Erikson made it the work of the teenage years. Between about 12 and 18, he thought, a young person tries out roles and beliefs and builds a sense of self out of them. If that goes well, the person ends up with an identity of their own; if not, with confusion about who they are and where they are going.
Another psychologist, James Marcia, sorted young people by two things: whether they had explored the choices open to them, and whether they had committed to one. Someone who has done both has an achieved identity. Someone exploring without committing yet is in moratorium, a kind of holding pattern. Someone committed without exploring, often to a path handed down, is in foreclosure. And someone who has done neither is in diffusion.
When 124 studies were brought together, the shift with age was real but slow. Exploring without committing became more common up to about 19 and then fell away; achieved identities became more common through the late teens. But many people hadn’t reached an achieved identity even as young adults. Among those followed over time, about half stayed where they were, about a third moved forward, and about one in seven went back a step.
An identity has many parts: what you believe or don’t, the work you hope to do, the language and people you belong to, your place in your family, and who you are as a boy, a girl, or neither or both. For most people the sense of being a girl or a boy matches the body they were born with. For some it doesn’t, and some young people find in these years that they are attracted to people of their own sex. Nepal’s law has its own answer here. In 2007 the Supreme Court held that when people know their gender by their own feeling, it is not for others, society or the state to decide it for them; that this is natural, not a psychiatric problem; that the state should recognize people of a third gender; and it directed the government to make laws so that people of every gender identity and sexual orientation enjoy their rights without discrimination. Nepal’s Constitution lets a citizen by descent receive a citizenship certificate showing their gender identity, and names gender and sexual minorities among the groups the state must include.
Erikson pictured a young person working out a self of their own, apart from the family. That picture came out of the West, and Marcia’s word foreclosure makes taking on the family’s path sound like a failure. In many families in Nepal growing up is less about breaking away than about finding a place inside: helping at home, deciding with the family rather than alone, carrying its hopes. The few studies, nearly all from the United States, suggest that this does no harm. Among more than 800 American secondary students, those from Asian and Latin American families felt a stronger duty to help and respect their families, and that feeling went with warmer relationships at home and with friends and with wanting to do well at school. In a study of Mexican American teenagers, valuing family duty went with fewer worries and low moods over time, and helping at home was good for them, except when the helping came in answer to a parent in distress. We found no study of this in Nepal.
The storm itself looks different from here. The psychologist Jeffrey Arnett, going back over the evidence for Hall’s idea, found that the troubles Hall described, fights with parents, swings of mood and risk-taking, are more likely in the teenage years than at other ages, but not universal, and less common in traditional cultures. They may be rising as more of the world grows up the way Western teenagers do.
Arnett has also argued that in some countries a new stage of life has opened up, which he calls emerging adulthood, from about 18 to 25: years of trying out work, love and ideas before settling down. He is careful to say that it exists only where a society allows young people a long, independent time to explore.
Moods, worries and phones
There is a quieter reason to pay attention to these years. Most of the mental health conditions people ever have begin young. When 192 studies from around the world were brought together, they found that among people who have a mental disorder at some point in their lives, about a third had their first signs before 14, and nearly half before 18. That doesn’t mean half of teenagers become ill. It means that when these conditions come, they tend to come early.
The World Health Organization reckons that about one in seven young people aged 10 to 19 has a mental health condition. Anxiety and depression are the most common, and both are more common in the later teens than the earlier ones. Most of these conditions go unrecognized and untreated, and that is the part worth changing: the review of 192 studies points out that help early on improves how things turn out. What protects young people is ordinary and unglamorous: support at home, at school and around them, enough sleep (the body clock shifts later in these years, as the chapter on sleep explains), exercise, and ways of coping with hard feelings.
Then there are phones, and here the experts are fighting in public. The social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, in a bestselling book, argues that smartphones and social media are a main cause of a rise in anxiety and depression among teenagers. His case starts with the trends. In the United States, depression among teenagers began climbing in the early 2010s, around the time smartphones spread. In surveys of a million 15- and 16-year-olds, loneliness at school rose between 2012 and 2018 in 36 of 37 countries. He points to experiments as well, and reads most of them as showing harm.
His critics read the same evidence very differently. The psychologist Amy Orben and a colleague analyzed the data of more than 350,000 young people, three large surveys in all, and found that technology use explained at most 0.4% of the differences in how well young people felt, too small, they said, to justify changing policy. A later study by Orben and others found that the link was strongest at particular ages, earlier for girls than for boys, and that it ran both ways: young people who were less satisfied with life went on to use social media more. The psychologist Candice Odgers, reviewing Haidt’s book in the journal Nature, wrote that its central claim is not supported by the science. Most of the studies, she pointed out, are correlations, a mix of no link, small links and mixed ones, and young people who already have problems use social media more, which makes it hard to tell what is causing what. An analysis of 72 countries found no consistent link between wellbeing and the spread of social media there.
Both sides agree that many young people are struggling, and Odgers calls some of Haidt’s fixes reasonable, such as making companies build apps with their users’ ages in mind. They part on whether phones are the main reason, and on whether bans would help or backfire. That argument is not settled, and anyone who tells you it is has picked a side.
Nearly all of this research, on brains, friends, identity and phones alike, was done with teenagers in the United States, Britain and the rest of Europe. We found almost none from South Asia, and none from Nepal, on most of the questions in this chapter.
The teenage years are a time when body and brain change fast and friends, identity and the future suddenly matter a great deal. Most of what makes those years hard is a sign of growing, not of something broken, and teenagers are less reckless and more reasonable than the old jokes suggest. When a low mood or a worry won’t lift, though, it is worth taking seriously early. If it stops you sleeping, eating or seeing friends, tell someone you trust, and see a doctor at your health post or hospital.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
