Skip to content

← Money

The Seller's Side

Chapter 8 · Going Out

In this chapter 6 sections
  1. Hurry
  2. The price you stop seeing
  3. Mystery boxes
  4. Who is talking, and who is looking
  5. Waiting
  6. Try this

In a study published in 2019, a team of researchers, most of them at Princeton University, sent a computer program shopping. It visited about 11,000 of the world’s most popular shopping websites and read some 53,000 product pages, and then it went back to the pages with countdowns and stock counts every few hours, recording what each said every time. On most pages nothing odd happened. On some, the program caught the pages lying.

A countdown said a special price would end in an hour. The hour ran out, and the price was still there, or the clock simply started again. The program found 393 countdowns, and 157 of them, on 140 websites, behaved like that. Another kind of message said “Only 3 left in stock.” On 17 websites the number was false: on 16 it went down on a timetable, whether or not anyone bought anything, and on the other it was a number picked at random each time the page opened. Messages about other shoppers, how many were looking at a thing or had just bought it, were made up on 20 sites, most often with a random number. And the researchers found 22 companies that sell these tools to shops ready-made, to be switched on like any other feature.

None of this means every countdown is false. Most sales really do end, and some things really do run out. But it says something plain about a shop, an app or a game: nothing on the screen is there by accident. Somebody chose every button, every color and every sentence, and was paid to choose the ones that sell. This chapter is about how they do it, and why it works.

A seller isn’t a villain for wanting to sell. Anshu wants people to buy tea at her shop, and she puts the biscuits where customers can see them. Everyone who sells does some of this, and much of it helps the buyer too: a clear picture, an honest review, a reminder that the rice is on offer this week.

The trouble is that a buyer and a seller want different things from the same moment. The buyer wants time to think: what does it really cost, is it cheaper elsewhere, do I need it at all? Those are the plain questions of a good price. The seller, at least the seller who designs the screen, does best when those questions don’t get asked. Nearly every trick in this chapter works by doing one of five things. It hurries you. It hides or blurs the price. It adds a gamble. It borrows someone else’s trust. Or it makes buying about being seen. Each has a defense, and the defenses are almost all the same one: time, and the real price in rupees.

The name for the dishonest kind is dark patterns. A British designer, Harry Brignull, gave it that name in 2010, when he started a website to collect examples of screens designed to trick the people using them.

Hurry

When the European Commission and the consumer offices of 25 European countries checked 399 online shops, in a check whose results came out in January 2023, they found tricks of this kind on 148 of them. Fake countdown timers were on 42.

Hurry works because thinking takes time. Comparing two shops takes a few minutes. Asking whether you want something at all takes a night’s sleep. A timer counting down from 59:59 says you don’t have a night, and a message saying “12 people are looking at this right now” adds that if you wait, someone else will take it. Neither needs to be true to work. A clock turns a purchase you haven’t made into something you are about to lose.

The trouble with fake urgency is that it can’t be seen from outside. A buyer can’t check the warehouse. What a buyer can check is whether the deadline matters to them. If the thing is worth buying, it’s usually still worth buying at a slightly higher price tomorrow; if it’s only worth buying because it’s cheap for the next hour, that is worth noticing. A real end-of-season sale doesn’t mind if you come back after lunch. A fake one counts on you not coming back at all.

Nepal’s law reaches part of this. The Consumer Protection Act counts false or misleading advertising, and selling by hiding the real price, quality or quantity of something, as unfair trade. Since the Electronic Commerce Act came into force on 15 April 2025, a business that sells online in Nepal, through a social media page included, has to list itself on the online register of the Department of Commerce, Supplies and Consumer Protection and name a person who handles complaints. The same Act forbids it to advertise misleadingly, and a buyer whose goods turn out to be different from what was described can send them back unused and take another thing or the full price back. By the deadline in July 2025, about 950 online sellers had listed themselves. Whether a fake countdown counts as misleading advertising is for the authorities to decide, but a seller who is registered can at least be found.

The price you stop seeing

At 16, Sabina wants a pair of earphones from a shopping app, Rs. 1,300. Delivery is Rs. 100, and a banner says delivery is free on orders over Rs. 1,500. Paying for delivery feels like a waste, so she looks for something to add and finds a phone cover for Rs. 300. Her order comes to Rs. 1,600 with free delivery, instead of Rs. 1,400 with delivery paid. She saved Rs. 100 and spent Rs. 200 more to save it. If she wanted the phone cover anyway, it was a fine trade. If she only bought it to get past the line, the line did exactly what it was put there to do.

Why does “free” pull so hard? In a study published in 2007, three researchers set up a booth in the students’ center of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology with two boxes of chocolates. One held a fancy truffle at 15 cents, the other a small plain chocolate at 1 cent, one per person. Of the students who took one, 73 in 100 chose the truffle, which was the better deal. Then the researchers cut both prices by one cent: 14 cents for the truffle and nothing for the plain one. The gap between them was exactly the same. This time 69 in 100 chose the free chocolate. Cutting a price from one cent to zero did far more than cutting it from 15 to 14, as if zero weren’t a price at all but a different kind of thing. A free delivery works the same magic on a much bigger order.

Free delivery at least shows its price. Some screens hide theirs. The Princeton crawl found shops that put things into a basket nobody asked for, and the European check found 70 shops hiding information, delivery costs among it, or making it hard to see. The defense is old and plain: look at the total on the last screen, line by line, before pressing pay.

The cleverest blur of all is to stop showing rupees. A game sells gems or coins, and then sells everything else for gems. The rupees are spent once, in one big lump, and after that every purchase is “only 400 gems”, which feels like nothing at all. The bundles can help it along. Say, in a game we’ve made up, 100 gems cost Rs. 120 and a bundle of 550 costs Rs. 600, which is cheaper for each gem. A skin you want costs 400 gems. Four small packs would cost Rs. 480. The big bundle costs Rs. 600 and leaves 150 gems over, not enough for anything, but enough to make the next bundle feel half paid for. It’s the unit price turned upside down: the bundle with the cheapest gem can leave you holding gems you don’t need.

A gem doesn’t look like money at all, which matters most when the player is a child. In December 2022 the maker of one of the world’s most played games agreed to pay $245 million back to its players, after the United States’ Federal Trade Commission said its game had tricked them into purchases: buttons laid out so that one press could buy something, even while the game was waking up or loading, and, until 2018, children able to buy its coins without a parent’s or card holder’s consent at all. The defense is to turn the gems back into rupees, every time, and the rupees into something real: at Rs. 100 an hour, a Rs. 600 bundle is six hours of somebody’s work.

Mystery boxes

A mystery box, in a game or in a shop, is a thing you buy without knowing what is inside. In a game it’s often called a loot box: pay, and it opens to give you a random item, usually a common one and once in a while a rare one. Shops sell the same thing as blind boxes, a toy hidden in a sealed packet so you don’t know which of the set you’ll get.

A box like that is a small gamble, and the arithmetic of a gamble is easy to do. Take a made-up box at Rs. 100. Seventy boxes in a hundred hold a sticker worth Rs. 20, twenty hold a keyring worth Rs. 80, eight hold earphones worth Rs. 300, and two hold a watch worth Rs. 1,500. Add up what a hundred boxes hold: 70 × 20, 20 × 80, 8 × 300 and 2 × 1,500 make Rs. 8,400. A hundred boxes cost Rs. 10,000. On average, each Rs. 100 box gives you Rs. 84 of goods, and the seller keeps the other Rs. 16. That average is called the expected value, and the seller sets it, by choosing the odds.

70 hold a sticker, worth Rs. 2020 hold a keyring, worth Rs. 808 hold earphones, worth Rs. 3002 hold a watch, worth Rs. 1,500Paid: Rs. 100 a box. Inside, on average: Rs. 84
Figure 8.1 A hundred made-up mystery boxes, one square each. Most hold the cheapest thing; the watch that makes the box exciting is in two of them.

The watch is what sells the box. Nobody films themselves opening a sticker. And the odds are often not shown at all, so the buyer can’t even do the sum. China made game makers publish them from May 2017. In April 2018 Belgium’s gaming regulator found that the paid loot boxes in three popular games were gambling under its law and had to be removed, and some game makers took them out of their Belgian games. Years later, though, most of the best-selling phone games in Belgium still sold them. The Netherlands’ regulator found the same that month about boxes whose prizes can be traded for money, and in 2019 it ordered the maker of a football game to pay a penalty. In March 2022 the country’s highest administrative court overturned that order, ruling that the game had to be judged as a whole, not its boxes on their own.

Do loot boxes lead to gambling? A 2018 survey of 7,422 adult gamers found that the people with more signs of problem gambling spent more on loot boxes. The survey can’t say which comes first, whether the boxes lead people into gambling or whether people already drawn to gambling buy more boxes, and the researchers said so. Both possibilities are a reason to know what the box is: a bet with the odds set by the seller.

Who is talking, and who is looking

On 3 October 2022 the American Securities and Exchange Commission announced that one of the world’s best-known celebrities would pay $1.26 million. It said she had been paid $250,000 for one post on social media promoting a crypto token, and that the post didn’t say she had been paid. She settled without admitting or denying that. The law, the commission said, was clear: anyone who promotes such an investment must say what they were paid, by whom and how much.

That is the whole problem with an influencer’s recommendation. An influencer can be honest, and many are, but a post looks the same whether the person loved the thing or was paid to say so. A friend’s advice is worth listening to because the friend has nothing to gain. A paid post borrows exactly that trust while having something to gain. The Federal Trade Commission’s guide for influencers, from November 2019, says what a fair post looks like: if a brand pays you, gives you the thing free or at a discount, employs you or is family, say so, in plain words like “ad” or “sponsored”, where people will see it, not buried at the end among the hashtags; in a video, say it in the video. And never call something great when you were paid and didn’t like it.

Nepal’s E-Commerce Act forbids an online seller to post reviews in the name of made-up customers, but neither it nor the Consumer Protection Act mentions paid posts by name. So the question to ask of any recommendation is the one Thinking Clearly asks of any message, in the feed or anywhere else: who is saying this, and what do they get if I believe it? A post that won’t answer the second half has answered it. The same book has the appeals that move people without a reason, in Persuasion, and why a feed shows what it shows, in The Feed.

Some spending isn’t moved by a seller at all, or not directly. It is moved by the people next door. In 1899 an American economist, Thorstein Veblen, wrote a book about the rich of his day called The Theory of the Leisure Class, and gave the world a phrase: conspicuous consumption, buying things less for their use than to show others what you can afford.

Veblen wrote mostly about the rich, but he saw the habit everywhere: no class, he wrote, not even the poorest, gives it up entirely. The Netherlands runs a lottery whose prizes go to the players of a whole postcode at once, and in 2011 a team of economists used it to see what happens to the neighbors of a winner. What the winners spent more on was almost all cars and other things that last. The neighbors who hadn’t played, and had won nothing, also bought more cars than other people who hadn’t played. Nobody gave them anything. They just lived next door to a new car.

Nepal has a word for it, देखासिकी (dekhasiki): doing something because you’ve seen someone else do it. Nepal’s social studies course for Grades 6 to 8 lists it beside फजुल खर्च, wasteful spending, among the things that stand in the way of a good society.

The odd thing about spending to be seen is how little anyone is looking. Morgan Housel, an American writer about money, once parked cars at a hotel in Los Angeles. He assumed that anyone who arrived in a costly sports car was rich. Getting to know some of them, he found that many weren’t that successful at all, and had spent most of their money on the car. A car’s price tells you what someone spent, not what they have. And when people see a driver in a fine car, he wrote, they rarely think about the driver at all. They think about how they would look in it. The admiration a purchase is meant to buy mostly goes to the thing, and the person who paid for it is hardly seen.

Waiting

Nearly everything in this chapter works best in the next few minutes: the clock, the stock about to run out, the line for free delivery, the gem bundle, the box that might hold the watch, the post that says buy now, the neighbor’s new phone. So the plainest defense is to let the minutes pass. Put the thing in the basket, close the app, and look again tomorrow. If you still want it, buy it. If you don’t, the screen has lost a sale it was built to make in a hurry.

Laws have built in the same idea for a long time. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission’s Cooling-Off Rule gives anyone who buys from a seller who came to their home, their workplace or their hostel three working days to change their mind, because a salesperson at the door is the oldest way to hurry someone. In the European Union, a buyer can cancel almost anything bought online within 14 days of its delivery, without giving a reason. Nepal’s Consumer Protection Act gives seven days to return unused goods with the bill, which works as a cooling-off too.

Waiting works for a simple reason: it gives back the time the seller tried to take. With time, the plain questions come back by themselves. What does it really cost, in rupees and in hours? Is it cheaper somewhere else? Would I buy it if there were no clock, no banner and no one watching?

So the plain thing to take from this chapter is that a shop, an app or a game is designed, and each part of the design is there because it sells. Most of the tricks do one of five things: they hurry you with clocks and stock counts, which are sometimes simply made up; they blur the price, with lines for free delivery, extra things in the basket and gems that stop you feeling rupees; they add a gamble, as a mystery box does, with odds the seller sets; they borrow trust from someone who may be paid; or they make buying about being seen, when hardly anyone is looking. The defense is nearly always the same: turn the price back into rupees, look at the total, ask who gains, and wait a day.

Try this

  • Find one countdown or “only a few left” message in an app or a shop’s website. Write down what it says, and look again the next day. Did the deadline end?
  • Next time you are near a free-delivery line, work out how much more you would spend to reach it and how much the delivery costs. Which is bigger?
  • If you play a game that sells coins or gems, find the price of each bundle and work out what one gem costs in rupees. Then work out what the last thing you wanted in the game cost in rupees.
  • Choose three posts that recommend something. For each, look for a word like “ad”, “sponsored” or “paid partnership”. Who gains if you buy?
  • The next time you want something you saw for the first time today, put it in the basket and wait a night. Did you still want it in the morning?

Found a mistake? Please tell us.