On the first of जेठ, २०८३, in May 2026, the Auditor General sent the President a report of 1,113 pages. It was the sixty-third of its kind, and it covered the audits of government offices across Nepal for the year that had ended in असार, 2081/82. Most of it is about other people’s mistakes, office by office. But near the front, before any of that, is a page addressed to the Secretary of the Ministry of Finance, and it gives an opinion on the federal government’s own accounts for the year. The opinion is qualified: the accounts are fair, it says, except for the matters it lists.
That is the word Chapter 27 used for a shop whose auditor found something big enough to matter that couldn’t be put right. And one of the matters listed is the one Chapter 10 started from. The government’s accounts said its cash and bank balance at the year’s end was Rs. 28.3 billion below zero. Nepal Rastra Bank, which keeps the government’s accounts, said it was Rs. 69.9 billion below zero. The government’s books showed Rs. 41.6 billion more than the bank did, and nobody had prepared the statement that explains the difference. Yasmin would have been told off for less.
So even the government’s books get checked, and found wanting. This chapter is about who does the checking: who keeps the public purse, who looks inside it, and what happens to the rupees nobody can account for. It is easiest to follow one rupee past everyone who watches it, inside the government and out.
The keepers
At the top of the government’s own money sits the Ministry of Finance, अर्थ मन्त्रालय. It makes economic policy, prepares the budget, raises loans and runs the government’s finances. Every year, on the fifteenth of जेठ, the Finance Minister must put the next year’s estimates of revenue and spending before Parliament (Constitution, Article 119), and with them, the Constitution adds, how much each ministry was given the year before and whether it hit its targets. The budget is a promise, and a promise has to be checked against what happened.
The checking starts with the Ministry’s own office for the accounts, the Financial Comptroller General Office, महालेखा नियन्त्रक कार्यालय, which Chapter 29 met as the old Accountant General’s office. It runs the federal consolidated fund, designs the forms and codes every office uses for the Auditor General to approve, keeps the record of money owed to the government, pays pensions, and at the end of the year puts together the federal government’s consolidated financial statement, the one the Auditor General qualified, and another that adds in the accounts of all 761 governments.
Its history has a small surprise in it. When it began, in २००८, it did almost everything the Auditor General does now as well: it kept the government’s accounts and it checked them, and it answered to no ministry. It was placed under the Ministry of Finance in २०१६, the year Nepal got its first Auditor General, and its work changed a great deal after an audit law of २०१८. Today the office that keeps the books is not the office that judges them. That is Chapter 26’s rule, that the person who takes the cash shouldn’t also count it, applied to a whole government.
The Comptroller General can’t be in every district, so it has an office in each one: the कोष तथा लेखा नियन्त्रक कार्यालय, the district treasury comptroller’s office, कोलेनिका for short, which Chapter 31 met paying the survey office’s bills. There has been one in every district since २०३८, and today there are 81, the 77 districts’ and four more payment centers in Kathmandu. A कोलेनिका releases the budget, pays on offices’ orders, keeps the district’s accounts of government money, records public buildings and land, advises offices on the rules, and audits them from inside.
The provinces and local levels have keepers of their own, because the Constitution gave each its own consolidated fund. Each province has a Ministry of Economic Affairs and Planning, which does for the province what the Ministry of Finance does for the federation, and a Provincial Financial Comptroller Office, प्रदेश लेखा नियन्त्रक कार्यालय. That office belongs to the province, not to the federal Comptroller General, though it does the same work: it runs the province’s fund, keeps its accounts, audits its offices from inside, and puts together one statement of the province and all its local levels, which it sends both to the Comptroller General and to the Auditor General. And each गाउँपालिका and नगरपालिका keeps its accounts in its own finance section, the same way, with the same codes and forms.
Someone in each office answers for all of it. The law calls that person the accounting officer, लेखा उत्तरदायी अधिकृत: the secretary at the head of a ministry, the person responsible for its budget, its accounts, its internal and final audits, for settling what the audit finds and for recovering what is owed (Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act, 2076, section 2(फ)). When the audit finds a problem, it is this name, not a clerk’s, that goes up the line.
The keepers also check themselves, which is what internal audit means. The Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act has every federal office’s transactions audited from inside by the Comptroller General or the कोलेनिका it names (section 33). The internal auditor looks at the office every three months, and within a month sends the office chief a report with suggestions. Nobody may be put on an office’s internal audit who keeps its accounts. And the accounting officer must have what the internal audit found settled before the final audit arrives, so that the outsiders find less. The provinces and local levels must have internal audits too, with an audit committee to see that the problems found are fixed (section 34).
That is a lot of checking. But every one of these offices belongs to the government it checks. The final word belongs to someone outside.
The outsider
The Constitution creates the Auditor General, महालेखा परीक्षक, in two articles. Article 240 says who it is: one person, appointed by the President on the recommendation of the Constitutional Council, for six years, and never again after that. The Auditor General must be at least 45, trained in accounting or commerce, long experienced in audit or the senior civil service, and not a member of any political party when appointed. The post can be lost only by resigning, by turning 65, by death, by impeachment in Parliament, or by removal for illness that makes the work impossible. The pay and conditions can’t be cut while the Auditor General is in office, except in an emergency declared for a grave economic crisis, and afterwards the Auditor General may take no other government job, apart from a political post or an inquiry. Every one of those lines is there for the same reason as the independence Chapter 27 asked of a company’s auditor, who can’t easily be dismissed for finding something awkward. An auditor who can be punished by the people being audited isn’t an outsider.
Article 241 says what the Auditor General does. Every government office is audited by the Auditor General, from the President’s office, the courts and Parliament to every province and local level, every constitutional body, the Army and the police. The Auditor General may see any of their accounting papers at any time, and the head of any office must hand over whatever is asked for (Article 241(3)). Their accounts are kept in the form the Auditor General prescribes (Article 241(4)), which is why the forms of Chapters 30 to 32 carry the Auditor General’s initials. And a company more than half owned by the federal or a provincial government chooses its auditor only after consulting the Auditor General (Article 241(2)).
The same article says how the accounts are to be judged, and it asks for more than a company’s auditor does. Five tests: नियमितता, regularity, whether the money was spent by the rules and the budget; मितव्ययिता, economy, whether it cost no more than it needed to; कार्यदक्षता, efficiency, whether it got as much as it could from what was spent; प्रभावकारिता, effectiveness, whether the spending did what it was meant to; and औचित्य, propriety, whether it was sensible and fair at all. The last is the boldest. The Audit Act, 2075, lets the Auditor General question spending that kept within the money released but was made in an unreasonable way, or harmed the nation’s wealth (section 9). A road can be built by every rule and still be the wrong road.
That Act fills in the rest. It lists the bodies the Auditor General audits, adding companies wholly owned by a government and anything a federal law names (section 3), and it lets the Auditor General choose how: every transaction, or a sample picked at intervals, or a percentage, just as Anisha sampled Yasmin’s vouchers (section 4). In the audit for 2081/82 the Auditor General’s office looked at 5,526 offices, local levels, committees and companies, which between them handled about Rs. 9,484.5 billion. It can’t look at all of them closely. It sorts them by risk, audits the risky ones in detail and the others from a distance, by having them upload their statements and internal audit reports into its computer system.
At an ordinary office the auditor’s work looks a lot like Anisha’s, with government forms. Take the survey office of Chapters 31 and 32, made up, as before. The auditor lays its monthly statements of expenditure beside the vouchers and the treasury office’s record of payments, and checks that each head stayed inside its budget. The cash in the small float is counted. The bank balance is checked against the bank’s statement. The bank cash book is checked line by line. In the advance ledger, Tenzing’s Rs. 30,000 should have been settled with his bills once he was back, and if it is still open past its time, that is a finding. The total station must be in the asset ledger, with its serial number, and then, if possible, on its tripod in the office. Every check that fails becomes a line in a report.
The road a finding travels
What happens to that line is set out in law, and it has deadlines at every turn.
First the office gets a preliminary report, प्रारम्भिक प्रतिवेदन, listing what the auditor found. It has 35 days to settle each finding, by producing the missing paper, putting the record right or paying the money back, and to send the evidence to the Auditor General (Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act, section 37). It can ask for more time, and get up to a month. If it still hasn’t settled, the Auditor General tells the accounting officer, who now has the job; if the accounting officer doesn’t finish it in time, the Auditor General tells the minister, and the amount goes into the annual report.
This year’s report shows how much that stage matters. The preliminary reports found about Rs. 95.3 billion of problems. Before the annual report went to print, offices had settled about Rs. 7.2 billion of it, leaving Rs. 88.1 billion.
Then the annual report. The Constitution says every constitutional body sends one to the President, who has it laid before the Federal Parliament through the Prime Minister (Article 294). The Audit Act says what it must contain: what the Auditor General did in the year, a summary of the main findings, how far earlier reports have been acted on, and what should be improved (section 19), and that it must be made public. Each province gets a report of its own, sent to the Province Head and laid before the Provincial Assembly by the Chief Minister. Each local level gets its own audit report, which it must lay before its village or municipal assembly for discussion (section 20).
In Parliament the report goes to the House of Representatives’ Public Accounts Committee, सार्वजनिक लेखा समिति. When it discusses what the report found, the accounting officer must come, take part, answer and say what is being done (Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act, section 41). The committee writes its own report with its own suggestions; when the House adopts it, the accounting officer and the Auditor General must carry it out, and anything the committee’s report says to remove from the record of unsettled findings, the Auditor General removes within thirty days. A provincial assembly’s accounts committee does the same for its province.
Notice what the road does. Every step sends a finding to someone more senior, more public, and harder to ignore: from the clerk to the office chief, to the secretary, to the minister, to the President, to a committee of elected members, to anyone who downloads the report. An office that settles its findings in the first 35 days never gets there. That is the point.
What बेरुजु are
The unsettled findings have a name of their own. A बेरुजु, the law says, is a transaction which the audit finds was done without the procedure the law requires, or for which the accounts that should have been kept weren’t, or which was done irregularly or improperly (Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act, section 2(त)). A बेरुजु is an entry the audit hasn’t accepted, a rupee that hasn’t yet been accounted for in the way the law asks.
That isn’t the same as a stolen rupee, and the Auditor General’s own sorting shows why. The law divides बेरुजु into three kinds: amounts to be recovered, amounts to be regularized, and advances. The Auditor General’s office splits them further.
About 37 percent was money to be recovered, असुल गर्नुपर्ने: money embezzled or misused, money lost by someone’s fault, and other amounts that should be paid back. This is the kind that can mean real wrongdoing, though not every rupee of it does, and the report’s summary tables don’t say how much is which. About 57 percent was to be regularized, नियमित गर्नुपर्ने, and the largest part of that, 41 percent of all the बेरुजु, was simply papers not produced: a payment the office made but couldn’t show the auditor the bill, the contract, the approval or the measurement for. The money may have been spent exactly as it should; the office just couldn’t prove it. About 16 percent was irregular, done against the rules, a purchase without the proper tender, say, but without any rupee being shown to be lost. And about 6 percent was advances not settled in time, Tenzing’s Rs. 30,000 multiplied by thousands of people who came back from the field and never handed in their bills.
Each kind is settled in its own way. The law puts the first duty on the person whose transaction it was, and an official being transferred can’t be released from an office until its internal audit has been done (section 39). A paper not produced is settled by producing it. An irregular transaction can be regularized by the accounting officer, but only with evidence that no government cash or goods were lost (section 40). Money to be recovered has to be recovered: if the person responsible doesn’t pay, the accounting officer must investigate, find who is to blame and recover it from them, and a loss caused knowingly or by carelessness is recovered from the person responsible, with departmental action besides (section 39). The office and its ministry keep a running record of every बेरुजु against them, the लगत, until each is settled (section 38). It is the same idea as the storekeeper’s handover in Chapter 32: what can’t be accounted for stays against a name until it is cleared.
Some बेरुजु can’t be settled in the ordinary way. For those, the government can set up a बेरुजु settlement committee, chaired by a member the Public Accounts Committee chooses, with a deputy of the Auditor General, officers of the Ministry of Finance and the Comptroller General, and the chief of the Kumari Chok office as its secretary (section 42). It can regularize a बेरुजु or write it off, मिनाहा, if the ministry shows that no government cash or goods were lost. What it may never write off is embezzlement, misuse, or money found to be recoverable (section 43).
The pile
Settling takes time, and findings arrive every year. So the Auditor General keeps a running total, the अद्यावधिक बेरुजु, everything found over the years and not yet settled. At the start of the year it stood at about Rs. 733.2 billion. During the year offices settled Rs. 63.1 billion of old findings, a few billion were adjusted away, and the year’s audit added Rs. 88.1 billion. Settling less than is added means the pile grows, and it did, by nearly 3 percent, to about Rs. 755.2 billion. That is about half of everything that came into the federal consolidated fund in the whole year.
Put that way it sounds alarming. Two other numbers put it in proportion. The Rs. 88.1 billion of new बेरुजु is 1.84 percent of the Rs. 4,795.5 billion it was found in; the companies, whose boards settle their own findings, aren’t counted in it. And it isn’t spread evenly. Ten ministries held more than 97 percent of the federal offices’ बेरुजु, and 894 of the 3,050 federal offices audited had no बेरुजु worth mentioning. Of the 721 local levels audited, 681 had बेरुजु under 5 percent of what they handled, 39 between 5 and 15 percent, and one above 15. And about half of the 187,914 findings had no rupee figure on them at all: they were about policy, plans, internal control and how services were delivered. During the year, about Rs. 14.6 billion was actually paid back.
An audit can’t promise more than that, and the report says so of itself. It works from samples, with limited time and people, and depends on the records it is shown, so it gives reasonable assurance, not certainty. Investigating a suspected crime is not the Auditor General’s job. That belongs to the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority, the CIAA, and the courts, and why public money goes astray, and what has worked against it, is the subject of Government and Law, for the Curious, Chapter 17, Corruption and Accountability.
What the system does promise is that nothing goes quietly. A rupee of public money is kept by one office, released by another, paid by a bank, checked every three months by internal auditors, checked again by an outsider the government can’t dismiss, and if it still can’t be accounted for, it is written in a public report with an office’s name beside it, for elected members to ask about. The Auditor General’s report each जेठ is the government doing what Yasmin did on the day her auditor signed, showing its books to someone with no reason to believe them, except that the someone is the whole country.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
