On the last day of कात्तिक, after the festival rush, Yasmin adds up the bank column of her cash book. It says the shop has Rs. 163,050 in the bank. That evening she opens the bank’s statement of her account for the month, and it says Rs. 207,900. The two figures are Rs. 44,850 apart, nearly three months’ rent.
The natural thought is that someone has made a mistake. Usually nobody has. Yasmin’s cash book is right about everything Yasmin knows, and the bank’s statement is right about everything the bank knows. They don’t know the same things yet. A month’s difference between the two is mostly a list of things that one side has heard about and the other hasn’t, and the work of finding them, and showing that they account for every rupee of the gap, is called reconciling the bank account. The result is a bank reconciliation statement, a बैङ्क हिसाब मिलान विवरण.
Two records of one account
The shop’s bank account is written down twice. Yasmin keeps it in the bank column of her cash book, as an asset: money paid in on the left, money paid out on the right, a debit balance meaning money the shop has. The bank keeps it in its own books, where the same money is something the bank owes the shop, so it sits the other way round, deposits as credits and withdrawals as debits. Every so often the bank sends the customer a copy of its side. In the past this was a pass book, a little booklet the bank wrote up whenever the customer brought it in. Today it is usually a statement, printed, emailed or opened on a phone, and the pass book is fading out. A statement reads like the running balance form of a ledger page: date, details, a debit column for money taken out, a credit column for money put in, and the balance after every line.
So a debit on the statement is money leaving the shop’s account, and a credit is money arriving. That looks backwards from Yasmin’s side of the counter, and it is meant to: it is the bank’s own record, seen from the bank. When the two records are put side by side, a deposit should appear on the left of her cash book and in the credit column of the statement, and a cheque she wrote should appear on the right of her cash book and in the statement’s debit column.
They don’t always appear on the same day, and that is the whole story. Each side writes a transaction down when it learns of it. Yasmin writes a cheque in her cash book the moment she hands it over; the bank writes it only when the cheque comes back to it for payment. The bank writes its monthly charges the moment it takes them; Yasmin writes them only when she reads them on the statement. The reasons for a gap come in three kinds: differences of timing, transactions one side hasn’t recorded at all, and plain mistakes, by either side.
The journey of a cheque
Most of the timing differences come from cheques, so it helps to know what one is. A cheque is a written order from someone with a bank account to their bank: pay this person this much from my account. It has three parties. The drawer writes and signs it, the drawee is the bank that must pay, and the payee is the person or firm it is made out to. The bank must pay as soon as the cheque is presented, and because a cheque can be passed from hand to hand, it counts as a kind of bill of exchange, the paper Chapter 7 described, with a bank as the one ordered to pay.
How it can be paid depends on how it is written. A bearer cheque can be paid to whoever brings it to the bank. An order cheque can be paid only to the payee it names, so it is a little safer. A crossed cheque has two parallel lines drawn across its corner, and it can’t be cashed over the counter at all: it can only be paid into a bank account, so if it is stolen, the money still has to land in someone’s named account. A payee can also pass a cheque on to someone else by signing its back, which is called endorsing it, or दरपिठ.
A cheque is not money until the bank pays it, and a bank can refuse. The usual reasons are not enough money in the drawer’s account, a signature that doesn’t match the one the bank holds, the amount in words and in figures disagreeing, a cheque past the time it is good for, a court’s order to stop payment, or news that the drawer has died or gone bankrupt. A cheque refused is said to be dishonored, or in plainer words, it bounces.
Not so long ago, a cheque paid in at one bank and drawn on another made a slow trip. Cheques were cleared by hand, and the paper itself had to travel from bank to bank before the money could move. Today Nepal’s banks clear cheques electronically through Nepal Clearing House Limited, a company set up in 2008 under the guidance of the central bank, Nepal Rastra Bank. The paper stays where it was paid in. The bank takes a picture of it and sends the picture, and the paying bank decides from the picture whether to pay or not. A cheque presented before the regular cut-off, three in the afternoon when this was written, is settled that same day, and the payee’s account is credited the same day the drawer’s is debited. One presented later usually waits for the next working day.
So the delays that matter to a shopkeeper today are mostly human. A supplier keeps a cheque in his drawer for a week before paying it in. A cheque handed to the bank late in the afternoon waits until tomorrow. And many payments now skip paper altogether. A customer can pay from a phone, or by scanning a QR code at the counter, or by a transfer from their own bank. A card can draw money from any machine, and a business can tell its bank to pay a bill every month without being asked again. Banks offer other modern tools too: banking at any branch of the same bank, debit and credit cards, internet banking and mobile banking. Each of them leaves a line on the statement, and some of them leave it there before the shopkeeper hears anything.
Ticking off
Here is Yasmin’s कात्तिक. Her cash book’s bank column carries on from where Chapter 9 left it, Rs. 167,800 on the tenth. Since then she has written in the cheque that refilled the petty cash box on the fifteenth, a cheque to Nishma for her bill on the eighteenth, the cash paid in on the twentieth, Abinash’s cheque paid in on the twenty-sixth, a cheque to Sujan on the twenty-eighth and Rabina’s cheque paid in on the thirtieth. They bring it to Rs. 163,050. Her statement covers the whole month. The way to begin is the way accountants have always begun: go through the two records line by line and tick everything that appears in both.
The opening balances agree, at Rs. 186,000, because last month’s differences were all cleared up. Then eight lines match: the cash paid in on the third and the twentieth, Salim’s transfer, the cheques for the rent, for Sujan’s असोज bill, for Nishma, and the two cheques cashed for the petty cash box. They match even though some appear on different dates. The rent cheque Yasmin wrote on the sixth reached the bank on the seventh, and Sujan’s cheque of the eighth on the twelfth, because he held it for four days. Those lines explain nothing. Everything that explains the gap is in what is left.
What is left falls into two piles, and the whole method rests on telling them apart.
The first pile is things the bank knew first. Three lines are on the statement and nowhere in the cash book. On the twenty-second, Pasang paid the Rs. 13,600 he owed straight into the shop’s account by transfer, and didn’t tell anyone. On the twenty-fifth, the bank paid the shop’s electricity bill, Rs. 1,800, as Yasmin had told it to do every month: an instruction called a standing order. On the thirtieth it took Rs. 200 in service charges. And one line in the cash book belongs in this pile too. On the twenty-sixth Yasmin paid in a cheque from Abinash for Rs. 15,600. His bank said no, and the cheque came back to her with a note giving the reason. In Nepal’s clearing a bank credits a cheque only once the paying bank has paid it, so this one never reached the statement at all. (Where a bank credits a cheque before it is paid, as many textbook examples have it, the statement shows the money going in and then coming back out, and the sums below come out the same.) Yasmin’s cash book still counts it as money in the bank.
These are all real events that have already happened, so Yasmin’s cash book is out of date until she writes them in. Pasang’s transfer goes on the cash book’s left side, in the bank column, and his page in the ledger is credited: he no longer owes anything. The electricity and the bank charges go on the right side, and their expense accounts are debited. The returned cheque goes on the right side too, undoing the deposit, and Abinash’s page is debited again with the Rs. 15,600 he still owes, to be chased. Once those four lines are in, the cash book’s bank balance is Rs. 159,050, and that is now the true figure for what the shop has in the bank.
The second pile is things Yasmin knew first. Two cheques in her cash book are still on their way. She wrote Sujan a cheque for Rs. 77,850 on the twenty-eighth, for his कात्तिक 3 bill less the dented tins she sent back, and he hasn’t yet paid it in. Accountants call that an unpresented cheque. And on the thirtieth Rabina paid her Rs. 29,000 by cheque, which Yasmin took to the bank after the day’s cut-off, so the bank will credit it on the first of मङ्सिर. That is a deposit not yet credited, sometimes called a deposit in transit.
Nothing needs writing in the books for these. They are already right in the cash book, and in a few days they will be right on the bank’s side too, all by themselves. They are only listed, in the reconciliation statement, to show how the bank’s figure follows from the cash book’s. Start with the updated cash book’s Rs. 159,050. Add back Sujan’s Rs. 77,850, because the bank hasn’t taken it out yet. Take off Rabina’s Rs. 29,000, because the bank hasn’t put it in yet. That gives Rs. 207,900, exactly the statement’s balance. The whole Rs. 44,850 is explained.
This order, first bringing the cash book up to date and then listing what is still on its way, is how the Cambridge IGCSE course teaches it, and it has one great advantage: it gives the right figure for the balance sheet, Rs. 159,050, rather than either of the two figures Yasmin started with. Nepal’s school books teach a shorter way, which puts everything into one statement, starting from either balance and adding or taking off every difference in turn:
| Bank reconciliation statement, कात्तिक 30 | Rs. | Rs. |
|---|---|---|
| Balance as per cash book | 163,050 | |
| Add: cheque issued but not yet presented for payment (Sujan) | 77,850 | |
| Add: paid straight into the bank by a customer (Pasang) | 13,600 | 91,450 |
| Less: cheque deposited but not yet credited (Rabina) | 29,000 | |
| Less: cheque deposited and returned unpaid (Abinash) | 15,600 | |
| Less: electricity paid by the bank on a standing order | 1,800 | |
| Less: bank charges | 200 | 46,600 |
| Balance as per bank statement | 207,900 |
The two ways always agree, because they move the same amounts; one just does it in two stages. The statement can also be worked from the other end, starting with the bank’s balance and ending at the cash book’s. Then every amount that was added is taken off and every amount taken off is added. From Rs. 207,900, take off Sujan’s cheque and Pasang’s transfer, add back Rabina’s cheque, the returned cheque, the electricity and the charges, and you arrive at Rs. 163,050.
The one rule worth carrying in your head is to ask, for each item, which side is ahead. If the cash book has written something the bank hasn’t yet, such as a cheque that has gone out but not been presented, the bank’s figure is behind and must be moved the same way. If the bank has written something the cash book hasn’t, such as a transfer or a charge, then it is the cash book that is behind.
The same steps work when the shop has drawn more than it had. Then the cash book’s bank column ends on its credit side, and the statement shows a debit balance: the shop owes the bank, the overdraft Chapter 9 described. The reconciliation starts from a minus figure, but every item moves it the same way as before.
Mistakes get sorted the same way, by whose they are. If Yasmin wrote a cheque for Rs. 29,000 into her cash book as Rs. 92,000, the statement will show the true figure and she corrects her own book, with an entry that says what it puts right. If the bank charged another customer’s cheque to her account, she doesn’t touch her books at all. She lists it in the reconciliation as the bank’s error and asks the bank to put it right, and next month’s statement should show the correction.
Why bother
All this might seem like a lot of work to arrive at a number the bank has already printed. But the reconciliation isn’t really about finding the balance. It is a check of two independent records against each other, kept by two different people who never compare notes otherwise. It is the same idea as Chapter 6’s statement of account from a supplier, made routine.
Done every month, it catches things while they are still small and fresh. A cheque from a customer that bounced, which Yasmin might otherwise have counted as paid until the year’s end. A payment she forgot to write down. A charge the bank shouldn’t have made. A supplier who still hasn’t paid in a cheque after two months, which is worth a phone call: perhaps it was lost, and a lost cheque can be stopped. And it makes stealing harder. Cash and cheques that pass through a bank leave a record the shop’s own staff can’t change, so someone who takes money and hides it in the cash book is found out when the cash book is held up against the bank’s version. Catching mistakes, fraud and deceit in banking transactions is one of the reasons for doing it, and the statement is an important tool for preventing financial fraud. Who should do the checking, and why it shouldn’t be the person who writes the cheques, is a question for a later chapter.
How often to reconcile depends on how much money moves. It used to be done monthly, and now it is often done fortnightly, weekly or even daily: companies that move money online reconcile every day. However often it is done, the lines that match take little thought. The lines that don’t are where the work is, and where the mistakes turn up.
So Yasmin’s cash book and her bank’s statement are two honest records of one account, kept from opposite sides of the counter and written up at different moments. Most of the gap between them is timing. To reconcile them, she ticks off everything that appears in both and sorts what is left. Things the bank knew first, like a transfer in, a standing order, a charge or a cheque that bounced, go into her cash book, which gives the true balance. Things she knew first, like a cheque not yet presented or a deposit not yet credited, are only listed, and they take the true balance to the bank’s figure. When the two meet to the rupee, both records have been checked, and the balance she will report is the right one.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
