On the twenty-fourth of भदौ, Tenzing, a surveyor at a district survey office, is about to set off for a hill village where two families disagree about where one field ends and the next begins. He will be away for a week, and he needs Rs. 30,000 for the journey, his lodging and the porters who carry the instrument. The office spends lakhs of rupees a month, on salaries, fuel, paper and electricity. Yet if you could look at its bank account that morning, you would find nothing in it. Not a little: nothing. The balance is zero, and it will be zero again tonight, after Tenzing has been paid.
This chapter follows his Rs. 30,000, and every other rupee the office spends in one month, from the permission to spend it to the statement that reports it. The office, its people and its numbers are made up; the codes, the forms and the rules are the ones every federal office in Nepal uses. Chapter 30 followed money into the government’s hands. This is the other way, and it is where most of the care goes, because money going out is where it can go wrong.
Permission to spend
A shopkeeper spends her own money when she likes. A government office may spend only what it has been allowed to, on what it has been allowed to, and only after the allowing is done. Each year the budget is passed by Parliament as an Appropriation Act, and an office may spend from the day that act takes effect, by the approved budget and program (Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act, section 18(1)).
What the office is given is not one sum but many: so much for salaries, so much for fuel, so much for travel, so much for a new instrument. Each sum is a budget head, a five-digit code from the same chart of accounts that labels revenue. Revenue codes start with 1. Spending codes start with 2 for current spending, the costs of running the office this year, and with 31 for capital spending, things that will last: buildings, vehicles, furniture, machines. The rest of the 30000s are not spending at all but the government’s other assets and its debts. And as with revenue, money can go only to the end of a branch: 21111 is staff pay, 22111 water and electricity, 22212 fuel for the office, 22311 stationery and office supplies, 22612 travel, 31122 machinery and tools. The headings above them, 22000, 22600 and the rest, add themselves up.
Our survey office has six heads for 2083/84, with Rs. 85.8 lakh in all, of which Rs. 54 lakh is for pay and Rs. 18 lakh for one large instrument.
The heads are walls, not suggestions. An office chief must spend within the budget and the program (section 24(1), and the Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Regulation, rule 39(1)), and the office may not take on a liability the year’s budget doesn’t cover (rule 39(2)). If an office finds it has too much for fuel and too little for stationery, it can ask to move money from one head to another, a virement, रकमान्तर, but only within limits, and some heads are locked. Money may not be moved out of salaries and allowances, uniforms, food, water and electricity, communication or rent, and money for capital spending may not be moved into current spending (section 20(2)). The last rule is the important one. Without it, the money meant for a bridge would drift, a few lakh at a time, into the tea and the fuel bills, and the bridge would never be built.
The voucher
Every payment begins with paper: a bill, a contract, an approval from whoever is allowed to approve that kind of spending. On the ninth of भदौ the office buys paper, ink and field notebooks for Rs. 18,500. The accountant looks at the bill, checks that the purchase was approved and that the stationery head has the money, and writes a voucher, the गोस्वारा भौचर, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 203, the journal entry of government accounts.
It is double entry, exactly as Yasmin’s shop does it. The debit goes to the budget head, 22311, stationery: Rs. 18,500 has been spent on it. The credit goes to the account the money comes out of, the Treasury Single Account, the one account all of it is paid from. Debits equal credits, as they must, and every voucher carries the code, the amount, what it was for, and the signatures of the person who prepared it and the person who approved it.
Tenzing’s Rs. 30,000 is a different kind of payment, an advance, पेस्की. Nothing has been spent yet; he has only been trusted with money to spend. But on the government’s cash basis the advance is debited to its head, travel, the moment it is paid, and the office also writes his name against it in a ledger of its own, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 207, so that it knows he owes an account of it. When he comes back he has fifteen days to settle it, with his bills and his travel report (rule 48(2)). If he spent Rs. 27,000, he hands back Rs. 3,000, which goes back to the Treasury Single Account, and the spending on travel comes down to the Rs. 27,000 he really spent. If he spent more, and it was allowed, the office pays him the rest. Until then the advance is a loose end, and loose ends are what auditors look for.
The month’s pay is different again, because not all of it goes to the staff. The office owes them Rs. 450,000 in pay, but Rs. 36,000 of that is held back for their provident fund and Rs. 4,500 for tax. So the voucher debits the pay head, 21111, with the whole Rs. 450,000, credits the Treasury Single Account with the Rs. 409,500 that reaches the staff’s bank accounts, and credits the other Rs. 40,500 to two accounts of money held for someone else. Those are not spending and they are not the office’s: a second voucher, a miscellaneous one, विविध, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 203क, the form for money that isn’t spending under a budget head, pays them on, the provident fund’s share to the fund and the tax to the revenue account, and they come back to zero. The pay head shows what the staff cost, which is the whole Rs. 450,000, however much of it they took home.
The payment order
Here is where a government office parts company with a shop. Having written the voucher, the accountant does not write a cheque. The office has no chequebook. Instead it fills in a payment order, भुक्तानी आदेश, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 204: which voucher, which budget head, how much, who is to be paid, their PAN, their bank and their account number. The accounts chief and the office chief sign it, and it goes to the district’s treasury office, the कोष तथा लेखा नियन्त्रक कार्यालय, the कोलेनिका, the office that also collects every office’s statements. The form itself says it can be thought of as a cheque.
The treasury office does the paying. It checks the order against the office’s budget and against the money already released for it, and if all is in order it pays the person or firm named, straight into their bank account or by cheque (Regulation, rule 28(9)–(10)). The office’s chief has decided; the treasury office has checked; a bank has paid. Three different hands touch one payment, and no one in the survey office ever holds the money.
The law also gives the office a deadline, which matters a great deal to the people it buys from. Once the proper documents are in, a payment within the appropriated budget must be made within fifteen days (section 24(3)). A supplier who waits months to be paid by a government office has a law on his side.
Not everything is worth a payment order. An office keeps a small cash float, सानो नगदी कोष, for bus fares, a courier, a padlock, and records the small payments from it in a register; when the float runs low, one voucher puts the spending onto its heads and tops it up.
One account for everyone
The account every voucher credits is the Treasury Single Account, TSA, एकल कोष खाता, and it is the reason Tenzing’s office has nothing in its bank account.
Until 2009 or so, Nepal paid for things in the obvious way. Each spending unit, more than 4,000 of them, had accounts of its own in commercial banks; the treasury released money into them, and each office spent from its own. There were more than 14,000 such accounts. At any moment a great deal of the government’s money was sitting idle in thousands of places, nobody knew exactly how much was where, and every one of those accounts had to be checked against the books every month.
The change began in 2009/10, with help from the International Monetary Fund, as a pilot in two districts. It then spread district by district: by September 2012 sixty of the seventy-five were on it, covering 95% of the government’s spending, and more than 12,500 of the 14,000 accounts had been closed. In those districts each treasury office had just four accounts, for current spending, capital spending, revenue and deposits, fewer than 300 in all where there had been thousands, and the government was paying about Rs. 2 crore less in bank commission than in 2009/10. All seventy-five districts were on it a year ahead of plan. It has been called a stealth reform: a change that takes from thousands of offices their say over their own money is hard to push through, and this one went through, though during the pilot some treasury staff and offices did resist.
What changed is when the money moves. The government’s cash stays in one place, the consolidated fund, until the instant something is paid. An office’s account isn’t an account with money in it but a right to have payments made, up to its budget; that is why it is called a zero-balance account. The treasury office can see every office’s spending as it happens, so it can’t pay more than the budget allows even by mistake, and the government can see, on any morning, how much money it really has. In Palpa, teachers who used to wait weeks for their pay now got it the same day the treasury office issued the cheques.
One level of government works differently. The 753 local levels aren’t in the TSA: each pays from bank accounts of its own and keeps its books in an accounting system of its own, SuTRA, on the same codes and forms. Chapter 34 comes back to the computer systems.
The month’s books
Back in the survey office, by the end of भदौ the accountant has written seven vouchers: Tenzing’s advance, the stationery, Rs. 22,000 of fuel for the field vehicle, the Rs. 15,600 electricity bill, the pay and the deductions paid on, and the big one, Rs. 1,650,000 for a total station, the measuring instrument surveyors set up on a tripod to read angles and distances. Altogether Rs. 2,186,100 has been paid out on the office’s orders.
Each voucher is then copied into the bank cash book, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 209, the office’s day book, laid out in columns for cash, the bank, spending by budget head, advances and everything else. The Treasury Single Account stands in the bank columns, as if it were the office’s bank. It is the same idea as Yasmin’s cash book, with more columns: each voucher goes in on the same side it was written, and the book can be checked by adding up its debits and credits, leaving out the advances, which are already counted in the spending.
At the end of the month comes the entry that makes the zero-balance account visible. The treasury office reports what it paid on the office’s orders, Rs. 2,186,100, and that is what was released to the office: under the TSA, the money paid is the release, निकासा. So one more voucher debits the Treasury Single Account with Rs. 2,186,100 and credits the release, head by head. The TSA’s column in the office’s books goes back to where it started, nothing, and the release appears beside the spending it paid for.
From the vouchers the accountant also keeps a budget account for each head, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 208, a page per head with three parts: what the head was given for the year, what has been released, and what has been spent. It answers the question an office chief asks before approving anything: how much is left?
Then comes the report that leaves the office. Within seven days of the month’s end it must send its statement of expenditure, the खर्चको फाँटवारी, म.ले.प. फारम नं. 210, to the office above it, with a monthly list of the advances still to be settled, the मास्केवारी (म.ले.प. फारम नं. 211, a word that means a month’s summary), and the check of its books against the treasury office’s records (Regulation, rule 73(1)). Tenzing’s name will be on that list until he comes back with his bills. Here is our office’s for भदौ.
Its columns tell a story. The budget is what Parliament allowed. Spent before this month and spent this month add up to what has been spent so far. Part of that is only advances, money handed out but not yet accounted for: here, Tenzing’s Rs. 30,000, still on the hill. The next column takes it away, to show what has really been spent with bills to prove it. And the last is what is left, the budget less everything spent so far.
The bottom row is the one a ministry reads first. Two months into the year, this office has spent 32.1% of its budget. That sounds a lot, until you see why: nearly all of it is the one instrument, bought early so the surveyors could use it all season. Leave it out and the office has spent about 16% of the rest of its budget in a sixth of the year, just about on pace. The head-by-head columns show it at once: pay exactly on track, a sixth used; stationery ahead; machinery almost all gone, and rightly. A statement like this, from every office every month, added up by the treasury offices and by the Financial Comptroller General Office, is how the government knows, long before the year ends, which offices will spend their budgets and which will be left with money in असार.
That end of the year is where the rules grow strictest, because it is where the temptation is greatest. Budget that isn’t spent by the end of the year can’t be carried into the next: it lapses, or is frozen, फ्रिज, in the offices’ word. So, apart from advances for travel and those a contract provides for, the Regulation allows no advance that can’t be settled within the year without a higher official’s approval, and it forbids giving advances or moving money into other funds at the year’s end only to keep a budget from being frozen (rule 50(3)–(4)). Payments close at least seven days before the year ends, and a payment the treasury office made by the end of असार that hasn’t reached the payee within fifteen days is taken off the year’s spending again (rule 30). The statements, month after month, are what let anyone see the rush coming.
The survey office’s month ends with its account where it began, at nothing, and a page that says exactly what happened in between. That is what money going out of a government looks like when it is done properly: no office holds the money it spends, every rupee is spent under a head someone allowed, each payment is decided in one office and made by another, and every month the whole of it is reported, head by head, to people who will add it up with everyone else’s. None of this tells you whether the boundary between the two fields was measured well. But it tells you, to the rupee, what measuring it cost, who was trusted with the money, and whether he has accounted for it yet.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
