Skip to content

← Accounting

Money In

Chapter 30 · The Government's Books

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. Where the money comes from
  2. A number for every rupee
  3. Into the bank
  4. The shop’s side
  5. VAT in a shop’s books

Sneha needs a passport. Before anyone at the district administration office in Bhaktapur, where she applies, looks at her photo or her citizenship certificate, she goes to a bank counter and fills in a small slip. She writes her name, the office she is paying, the amount, a few thousand rupees, and one number that says what she is paying for: 14227. The cashier takes her money, keeps one copy of the slip and gives her the other, which she carries back to the office as her proof of payment.

Those five digits are the whole of this chapter in small. They say what her money is: a passport fee, not a fine, a tax or a grant. And because every government office in Nepal uses the same list of numbers, her fee can be added, that same evening, to every other passport fee paid that day anywhere in the country, then to every other fee, and then to all the government’s revenue, without anyone opening an envelope. A government takes in money from millions of people in thousands of places. What makes that money countable is that each rupee arrives already labeled.

Where the money comes from

Most of what a government takes in is tax. Nepal’s federal government raised about Rs. 1,241 billion in the year ending in असार 2083, and much the greater part of it was tax: value added tax, VAT, on things people buy; income tax on what people and companies earn; customs duty on goods brought across the border; excise duty on things such as alcohol, tobacco and cars. What a tax is, who pays which, and whether it is fair is a story told in Economics, for the Curious, Chapter 18. This chapter is about the bookkeeping: what happens to the money after it is paid.

The rest is not tax. A government charges fees for what it does, passports, driving licenses, the registration of a piece of land. It collects fines. It earns royalties when someone uses the country’s water, forests or minerals, dividends from the companies it owns, interest on money it has lent. Foreign governments and agencies give it grants. And now and then an office gets back money that was paid out wrongly and found by the auditors. Each kind has its own place in the books.

The people who keep the accounts sort revenue another way too, by how it is known. Some revenue comes from a list. A land-revenue office knows who owns each plot and what each owes; an income tax office has a register of taxpayers. That is लगती revenue, from लगत, the register of who owes what, and the office can check at the end of the year who has paid and who hasn’t. Other revenue turns up without warning: nobody knows in advance who will apply for a passport this week. That is हसबली revenue, paid when the service is asked for. The first kind can be chased. The second can only be counted.

A number for every rupee

The list that number comes from is the government’s chart of accounts, the same idea as the list of accounts Yasmin keeps for her shop, but drawn up once for all 761 governments in Nepal. The Financial Comptroller General Office keeps it and the Auditor General approves it, and it is built on the International Monetary Fund’s manual for government accounts, so that Nepal’s figures can be set beside other countries’.

A revenue code has five digits and starts with 1. The second digit says what kind of money it is: 11 is tax, 13 is grants, 14 is the rest of a government’s own income, fees, fines, royalties and the like, and 15 is money coming back, such as a sum the auditors found paid out wrongly. Each digit after that narrows it down, like an address that goes from a country to a district to a street to a house. 11000 is all taxes. 11400 is taxes on goods and services. 11410 is value added tax, and 11411, one branch under it, is a government’s share of the VAT that is divided among the federal government, the provinces and the local levels.

The rule that makes the tree work is simple. Money can only be put in at the end of a branch. A code that ends in zeros is a heading, and the chart says plainly against such headings that no money may be put there. Nobody can pay into 11400, taxes on goods and services in general; they must say which tax. Only a code whose last digit is 1 to 9 can take money: 11111, the tax on the income of a person or a sole trader; 11511, customs duty on imports; 14227, passport fees. Then the headings add themselves up. The total of 11410 is whatever has been paid into the codes under it, and the total of 11000 is all of those together.

So the question “how much VAT came in last month?” never needs anyone to look through receipts. It is the sum of what was put under one branch. The same question can be asked of a province’s share, or of every district office in the Tarai, because the slip also carries the office’s own code: nine digits for a federal office, ten for a province’s, the last digit naming the province.

The codes are not fixed for ever. The chart has been revised and amended several times, and a new tax gets a new code: when a green tax was brought in, it was given 11515, a new branch under foreign trade. An office uses the list in force on the day the money arrives.

Into the bank

Sneha didn’t hand her money to the office. She paid it into a bank, and the slip she filled in is called a revenue deposit voucher, राजस्व दाखिला भौचर. It is the most important piece of paper in this chapter, so here is one filled in.

Figure 30.1 A revenue deposit voucher as it might look, with most of the fields Nepal Rastra Bank’s rules for government transactions list. Sneha, her payment and the slip’s number are made up; the codes of the bank, the account and the office are described, not invented. The two copies carry the same printed number.

The account it names is not the district office’s. It belongs to the Financial Comptroller General Office, and it is a strange kind of bank account: money can be paid into it at any branch of any bank allowed to take government revenue, but no office can take anything out. The Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Regulation calls it a non-operating account (rule 58). An office that collects revenue never holds it. All it ever has is the slip saying that the money went in.

From there the money moves fast. The Financial Procedures and Fiscal Accountability Act says revenue paid into a bank must reach the consolidated fund the same day (section 27(2)); a bank more than three days late can be fined ten percent of what it still owes, or reported to have its license to handle government money taken away (section 27(4)). The consolidated fund is the account into which, the Constitution says, all of the federal government’s revenue goes (Article 116), held at Nepal Rastra Bank, which is the government’s banker. Each bank sends its collections there, and every day it reports to the Comptroller General’s office and to Nepal Rastra Bank what it took, under which code, for which office.

A slip of paper alone would not be enough for that. The voucher is entered in a computer system that all the banks and offices share, the Revenue Management Information System, RMIS, and the rules say a deposit doesn’t count until it is there. When Sneha’s slip is entered, her fee is in the national figures, under 14227 and under the district office’s code, before she is back at its counter. The bank keeps one copy of the slip and she keeps the other. Both carry the same eight-digit number, so neither can be swapped or used twice. And a voucher has a shelf life: it must be used for the service, or the money asked back, within a year, and after that the money simply stays in the fund.

The office still keeps books of its own. Someone who comes to the counter with a small amount in cash may pay the office directly; the office gives a printed receipt, enters it in its daily revenue book, and must bank the cash that day, or the next day if it can’t (section 27(1) of the Act). At the end of the day the office makes one voucher, its गोस्वारा भौचर, for the revenue entered, and posts it to a ledger with a page for each code, so it can say at any time how much it has taken under each.

That ledger is kept by double entry, like Yasmin’s. When money comes in, the bank side goes up, and so does the revenue under its code; nothing goes out. The government counts revenue on the cash basis, when it is received, not when it is owed, which makes revenue easy to count and hard to argue about. It also means a fine that someone hasn’t paid yet is nowhere in the accounts, which is why the लगती register of who owes what matters so much.

And then the office checks its books against the bank’s, exactly as Chapter 10 did for Yasmin’s shop. Every month the bank sends a statement of everything paid in under that office’s code. The office lays it beside its own ledger and explains every difference: a slip the bank entered under the wrong office, a deposit the bank shows that the office hasn’t entered yet, cash taken late in the day and banked the next morning. Then it sends statements of its revenue, office by office, up the line, to its ministry and to the district’s treasury office, the Treasury Controller Office, कोष तथा लेखा नियन्त्रक कार्यालय, कोलेनिका for short, each month and again when the year closes. All of it is checked, first by the office’s own chief, then by internal auditors from the treasury office, and finally by the Auditor General, who also prescribes every form on which the accounts are kept. The forms are known by that office’s initials, म.ले.प., and a number, the same in every office in the country.

The shop’s side

Now turn the counter round. A great deal of the government’s revenue is not paid by people like Sneha buying a service. It is collected for the government by businesses, a few rupees on every sale, and a business that does that needs two things of its own.

The first is a PAN, a permanent account number, the nine-digit number every taxpayer has, which Chapter 6 found printed on every proper bill (getting one as a person is in Money, for the Curious, Chapter 5). A business gets its own, separate from its owner’s. To apply it takes the papers that show the business exists: the certificate of a firm’s or company’s registration, a company’s memorandum and rules, the partners’ or directors’ citizenship certificates and photographs. Once it has one, the number goes on every bill it issues and on its dealings with banks, so that the tax office can follow its money.

The second is registration for VAT, which comes with a certificate to hang where the business trades and a registration number (VAT Act, section 10). Yasmin’s shop has never registered, and none of her bills has had VAT on it. She doesn’t have to. The VAT rules let a business that sells goods stay out of VAT while its sales over the past twelve months are no more than Rs. 50 lakh, as long as it puts up a notice saying so; her first year’s sales were about Rs. 28 lakh. But a business may also register by choice, and many small ones do, for a reason that says a lot about how VAT works. Suppose the contractors who buy from Yasmin, Pasang among them, are registered themselves. They can take off the VAT they pay on their materials from the VAT they owe, but only with a proper tax invoice from a registered seller. An unregistered shop’s bill is no use to them, and a registered shop up the road would get their orders. So suppose Yasmin registers.

How that taking-off works is VAT’s whole idea. The tax is collected at every step on the way from raw materials to a family’s wall, but each business pays only on what it added. Follow one carton of white paint.

Figure 30.2 One carton of paint on its way to a family, with VAT at 13% at every step. Each business charges VAT on its whole price, takes off the VAT it paid when it bought, and pays the government the rest. The chain is made up, worked by a script so that the sums agree.

The paint factory imports raw materials worth Rs. 3,000 and pays Rs. 390 of VAT on them at the border, before they leave customs. It makes the paint and sells the carton to a wholesaler for Rs. 6,000 plus 13%, Rs. 780. Of that 780, the factory has already paid 390 at the border, so it pays the government only the other 390. The wholesaler sells the carton to Yasmin for Rs. 7,000 plus Rs. 910 of VAT, takes off the 780 it paid the factory, and pays in 130. Yasmin sells it to a family for Rs. 8,500 plus Rs. 1,105, takes off the 910 she paid, and pays in 195.

Add up what reached the government: 390, 390, 130 and 195 make Rs. 1,105, which is exactly 13% of the Rs. 8,500 the family paid before tax. Each business paid 13% of the value it added: the factory turned Rs. 3,000 of materials into a Rs. 6,000 carton, the wholesaler added Rs. 1,000 by stocking and delivering it, Yasmin Rs. 1,500 by having it on the shelf when the family wanted it. Only the family, at the end of the chain, has no one to pass the tax on to. VAT is a tax on what people finally spend, collected in slices on the way. The VAT Act sets the rate (section 7) and lets a registered business take off what it paid when it bought (section 17); that taking-off, कर कट्टी, is called a tax credit.

The slicing is what makes VAT hard to dodge. If Yasmin hid her sale, the government would lose only her Rs. 195; the 910 paid before her was already in. And a registered buyer can take nothing off without the seller’s tax invoice, so every step in the chain checks the one before. That is why her contractors would ask for one.

VAT in a shop’s books

Registering would change Yasmin’s books more than her prices. The VAT she collects is not hers, so it is not her income; the VAT she pays is not her cost, since she gets it back. The international standard for counting revenue says the same thing about any sales tax: a business’s revenue is what it earns for itself, not amounts it collects on behalf of someone else. So VAT gets an account of its own, a VAT account.

Say that in her first registered month, साउन, she buys Rs. 160,000 of stock on credit. The stock goes up by 160,000 and so does what she owes the supplier, and she also owes the supplier Rs. 20,800 of VAT, which is debited to the VAT account: it is money the government will let her take off. She sells Rs. 200,000 of goods for cash; her sales go up by 200,000, her cash by 226,000, and the other 26,000 is credited to the VAT account: money she holds for the government. At the end of the month the VAT account shows a credit of 5,200, what she owes. Her profit is exactly what it would be without VAT. Only her cash and what she owes are bigger.

The VAT Act wants that account settled every month. Within twenty-five days of the month’s end she files a return with the tax office, even in a month with no sales at all, and pays what she owes (sections 18 and 19). For साउन she pays Rs. 5,200, by a revenue voucher at a bank, the same slip that Sneha used, with her VAT number in the box for it. In a district with no tax office, she can pay and hand in the return at the treasury office instead, by the fifteenth (section 18(1a)). Her money then follows Sneha’s, a bank and RMIS, but with one turn. VAT belongs to all three levels of government, so it doesn’t go into the federal consolidated fund. It is paid under codes of its own, in a group starting 333 that the chart keeps for money to be shared (hers, VAT on goods sold by wholesalers and shops, is 33313), and goes into a pool, the divisible fund, which the law shares out, 70% to the federal government and 15% each to the provinces and the local levels (Intergovernmental Fiscal Arrangement Act, section 6). Only then does each government count its share as revenue, under 11411.

A month can also go the other way. In भदौ she stocks up for the festivals, buying Rs. 300,000 of goods, VAT 39,000, while selling only Rs. 180,000, VAT 23,400. She has paid Rs. 15,600 more VAT than she collected. The government doesn’t hand it back at once: the extra is carried forward and taken off next month’s (section 24). In असोज, with Rs. 340,000 of festival sales, she owes 44,200 less the 18,200 she paid on that month’s purchases, less the 15,600 carried from भदौ, and pays Rs. 10,400. A business whose credit keeps piling up for four months in a row can ask for a refund, and one whose exports are more than 40% of a month’s sales can ask sooner, since its sales abroad carry no VAT to take its credit off.

Nepal’s VAT began on मङ्सिर १, २०५४, replacing a sales tax and three smaller taxes on hotels, contracts and entertainment. It started at 10% and was raised to 13% some seven years later, and 13% is the rate in 2083. A few things now have a lower rate, which the chapters on tax in the Economics and Money books follow, and some, such as basic farm produce, medicines and books, have none at all.

Sneha’s passport fee and Yasmin’s VAT end in the same place by the same road: a slip at a bank, a five-digit code, an account no office can draw on, and a fund that belongs to everyone. The government’s accounts are built so that money can come in at ten thousand counters and still be counted as one, and so that the people who handle it never get to hold it. The codes say what each rupee is, the bank says it arrived, the office’s own books check the bank’s, and the auditors check them all. For a business, the same system reaches into the shop: VAT passes through its books without touching its profit, collected a little at a time by everyone who adds something, and paid by the one who finally buys.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.