When researchers asked the people of the Chitwan valley who had married between 1936 and 1945 how they chose their husband or wife, virtually none of them had chosen. Their parents and relatives had. Of the people there who married between 1986 and 1995, about half had some say in the choice. Something changed in the valley within a single lifetime, and a team of sociologists, one of them Dirgha Ghimire, set out to find what.
What they found comes later in this chapter. It belongs in a chapter on love because most of what psychologists know about love comes from a narrow slice of the world: young people in North America and Europe, many of them university students, choosing partners for themselves. That’s a fine thing to study, but it isn’t how a great many marriages in Nepal begin. So this chapter keeps two questions side by side: what the research found, and how far it reaches.
One thing first, though, because it is sometimes said that romantic love is a modern Western idea that films carried around the world. Two anthropologists went through the records of 166 cultures looking for signs of it, in stories, in folklore, in love potions. They found clear signs in 147, and in the other nineteen, they thought, the gap was more likely the record-keepers’ oversight than a lack of love. A !Kung woman of the Kalahari, Nisa, put it this way: “When two people come together their hearts are on fire …” Love is old and it is everywhere. What differs from place to place is what people are expected to do about it.
What love is made of
Ask people what they mean by love and their answers are long and tangled. In the 1980s the psychologist Robert Sternberg proposed that love has three parts. One is intimacy: feeling close, warm, understood. One is passion: the longing and attraction, the racing heart. The third he called decision and commitment: deciding that you love someone, and deciding to stay.
The point of the three is that they come in different mixtures. Intimacy alone, in his scheme, is liking, the feeling for a good friend. Passion alone is infatuation, the crush on someone you’ve hardly spoken to. Commitment alone is empty love, a marriage that holds together after the warmth has gone. The pairs make the kinds people write songs about.
Fatuous love, passion and commitment without intimacy, is the whirlwind romance that ends in a quick marriage between two people who don’t yet know each other. Consummate love has all three.
The triangle is a description, not a discovery about how love works inside us. It gives names to differences that people already notice, and it doesn’t say what causes them. What it has shown is staying power: when a team tried Sternberg’s questionnaire on more than seven thousand people in 25 countries, it measured much the same three things everywhere, and how strong each one was differed with how long a couple had been together, along the lines he had suggested.
A second way of describing love borrows from childhood. A baby left for a few minutes in a strange room shows how it is attached to its parent: some babies use the parent as a safe base, some keep their distance, and some cling and can’t be calmed. In 1987 two American psychologists printed a short questionnaire about love in an American newspaper. Readers picked which of three short paragraphs described their own romantic life best: one that sounded secure, one that kept others at a distance, and one that worried about being left. The three turned up in roughly the same shares as in studies of babies.
That started a large body of research on attachment in adults, and its record is mixed in useful ways. People don’t fall neatly into three boxes: the later studies find differences of degree, more like height than like blood groups. And a person’s style is only moderately steady from infancy to adulthood. A secure baby is somewhat more likely to be a secure adult, but life in between, including later relationships, moves people. The idea that your first months fix how you will love is not what the evidence shows.
Who we are drawn to
The first answer is plain and a little unromantic: we are drawn to the people we meet. A classic study of housing for students and their families at an American university, around 1950, found that people were far more likely to become friends with their next-door neighbors than with people a few doors down. That was about friendship, not love, but the lesson carries. Before anyone can be attracted to anyone, the two have to be in the same place, and who meets whom is set by where people live, study and work, and by which families mix. In Chitwan, among people who married between 2008 and 2012 and chose their spouse on their own, 42 percent married someone of another caste. Where parents or relatives took part in the choice, five percent did.
Once people meet, looks matter more than most of us like to admit. In the 1960s, at an American university, a team of psychologists held a dance for new students and told them a computer would match each one with an ideal partner. In fact the pairs were chosen at random. During the evening the students said how much they liked their partner. The researchers had measured their personalities and intelligence beforehand, and none of it predicted liking. By far the biggest thing was how attractive the partner was. The team had expected people to prefer partners who matched their own looks, and the dance didn’t show that either: almost everyone simply liked the attractive ones best.
But the dance was a first meeting, and a first meeting is where looks do best. The same pattern shows up with similarity. People say they want someone like themselves, and across more than three hundred studies, being alike in attitudes and personality really did go with attraction when strangers had never met or met only briefly. In couples already together, actual similarity hardly mattered. What still mattered was believing the other person was like you, which may come as much from liking someone as cause it.
The real surprise came when researchers tried to predict which pairs would click. Students in speed-dating evenings, each going on a string of very short dates, first answered questions on more than a hundred traits and wishes. From these the researchers could predict, to a modest degree, how much a person tended to like others in general, and how much a person tended to be liked. They could not predict who would like whom. Whatever made two particular people want to see each other again came from the meeting itself, and nothing on the forms caught it.
Closeness, at least, can be helped along. Arthur Aron and his colleagues paired students who were strangers and gave them 45 minutes of questions to take turns answering, starting light and growing more personal. Other pairs spent the 45 minutes on small talk. The pairs who opened up felt closer at the end. Matching the pairs by their opinions made no difference, and nor did telling them they would like each other. This was closeness between strangers in a lab, not love, but it fits what the rest of the research keeps finding: people grow close by telling each other true things, a little more each time, and being met kindly when they do.
Choosing, and families choosing
Back to Chitwan. The Chitwan Valley Family Study, a long-running survey of the valley’s people, asks about their lives, and among its questions was how much say each person had in choosing their spouse. Ghimire and his colleagues looked at what in a young person’s life, before marriage, went with having more say. Their answer was experiences outside the family, above all exposure to media and taking part in youth clubs, which they found had “strong positive effects” on taking part in the choice. And they found that the growth of those experiences over the decades could account for “a substantial fraction” of the rise.
The valley changed a great deal in those decades, and young people married later: the usual age at first marriage there went from about 16, for those married in the late 1950s and early 1960s, to about 21 for those married forty years on. A young person who had been to school, seen films and joined a youth club had seen other ways of living and had met people outside the family. Surveys like this show what goes together; they can’t run the experiment of handing some young people a cinema ticket and others none, so the claim is about strong links in what people did, not a law of cause.
What did the change lead to? Not, mostly, to the Western pattern. Among the people of Chitwan who married between 2008 and 2012, a little over half married someone of their own caste whom parents or relatives had helped choose. About a quarter chose a spouse of their own caste on their own, and about a fifth married across caste, most of them by their own choice. And the ideal held up across the region is what researchers call an “arranged love marriage”: choosing someone you care for, then marrying with your parents’ blessing and all the steps of an arranged wedding.
In a community in Dhading District, people in group discussions described the same three kinds of marriage in their own words. There was arranged marriage, in which parents find the spouse and the son or daughter may agree or not; love marriage, in which the young person finds someone, then asks for the family’s approval and has the same ceremony; and the rarer elopement, often across caste, which families usually came to accept, especially once children were born. Of the oldest generation, about four in five said their parents had chosen; of those married in the last fifteen years, a little over half. People named things arranged marriage gives, which the researchers found mattered more to women than to men: a family behind the marriage, and someone to step in when things go wrong. One woman put it sharply: “If you find a husband yourself, then whatever happens between the two of you cannot be shared … you can yell at your parents, ‘what kind of man did you get me?’”
Is one way better? A study in Chitwan in 2004 asked married people about their marriages. Those who had chosen their own spouse said they were somewhat more satisfied, did more things together and disagreed less; on how well they talked and how many problems they had, there was no difference. An earlier study in the valley, with fewer questions, had found no such difference. And people whose marriages had already ended weren’t in the sample, people who choose for themselves may differ in other ways, and most of the differences between one marriage and another weren’t explained by how the spouse was chosen. This research can’t tell you which way to marry, and it doesn’t try to. It does show that the question isn’t a simple choice between two boxes: in Chitwan and Dhading, many marriages now mix the young people’s choice with the family’s.
Attitudes differ too, though by degree. When students in eleven countries, among them India and Pakistan, were asked how much love mattered in marriage, it counted for most in Western countries and in those where people think more of themselves as individuals, and least in the poorer Eastern ones. The gap was bigger for starting a marriage than for keeping one going.
Jealousy, and when it turns to control
Jealousy is the fear of losing someone you love to someone else, and it often comes mixed with anger, hurt and a sense of helplessness. It is a feeling, and like any feeling it says something about what matters to you. The trouble starts with what a person does with it.
In Nepal’s national health survey of 2022, women who had ever had a husband or partner were asked about his behavior. About a quarter said he became jealous or angry if she talked to other men. About a fifth said he insisted on knowing where she was at all times. Smaller shares said he accused her of being unfaithful, stopped her from meeting her women friends or limited her contact with her own family. More than a third reported at least one of these. Among the youngest, aged 15 to 19, most of the shares were higher still: nearly two in five said he was jealous if she talked to other men. The survey’s own report says that controlling behavior can be an important warning sign of violence.
Jealousy that turns into checking a phone, deciding who a partner may talk to, or keeping someone from friends and family isn’t a measure of how much someone cares. It is a measure of control. Growing Up, in Practice has a page on the signs, and on where to turn: control isn’t care.
What makes it last
The most famous answer comes from John Gottman, who brought married couples into a lab in the United States, and filmed them talking about a disagreement. Years later he checked which couples had stayed together. In one study, couples who were most negative during a disagreement tended to divorce early, and couples who simply showed little warmth tended to divorce later. He named four habits of talk that went with trouble: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling, which means shutting down and refusing to engage. Contempt, treating your partner as beneath you, he counted the worst.
You may hear that Gottman can predict divorce with more than 90 percent accuracy. That figure needs care. It came from fitting a formula to couples whose outcomes were already known, and a formula fitted that way always looks better than it is. Critics pointed out that the couples weren’t chosen at random, that a formula built this way loses much of its accuracy when it is tried on new couples, and that advice was being given before the research could bear it. The habits he named are still worth knowing, but the famous number promises more than it can deliver.
The question has since been tried on a far larger scale. Samantha Joel and her colleagues brought together 43 sets of data from 29 labs and used computers to find which of many measures best predicted how happy people were in their relationship. Near the top came a person’s sense that the partner was committed, feeling appreciated, believing the partner was happy, and having little conflict. A person’s own answers predicted their happiness two to four times better than anything their partner reported. And the computers did poorly at one thing: predicting which couples would grow happier or less happy over time. However happy a couple is now, where they’ll be in a few years is mostly not written in what they say today.
Caryl Rusbult’s investment model looks at why people stay. Commitment, in her view, rests on three things: how satisfied you are, how good the alternatives look, and how much you have put in that you would lose by leaving, from years together to shared friends and a shared home. Across 52 studies with nearly twelve thousand people, those three explained nearly two-thirds of the differences in commitment, and commitment in turn predicted who stayed together. In this view, staying isn’t only a matter of being happy: a person with much invested and nowhere else to go may stay in a relationship that makes them unhappy.
The same ideas hold for couples of every kind. A study in the United States followed gay and lesbian couples living together and compared them with married heterosexual couples. In half the comparisons there was no difference at all, and the same things predicted how good and how lasting a relationship was. Some people fall in love with someone of their own sex, and the research finds their relationships working much as anyone else’s do. In Nepal the law has been moving toward recognizing such marriages. In 2007, in a case brought by Sunil Babu Pant, the Supreme Court ordered the government to make or change laws so that sexual and gender minorities could use their rights equally, without discrimination, and to set up a committee to study same-sex marriage. A couple in Lamjung registered their marriage in 2023 after an interim order of the court, and in June 2026 a full bench ruled in favor of same-sex couples seeking to register their marriages; its full written judgment had not yet been published when the ruling was reported.
What the research adds up to is less a recipe than a set of things to watch. Love is old, shared by people everywhere, and made of closeness, longing and the choice to stay, in changing amounts. Who we fall for depends a great deal on who we happen to meet, and the click between two particular people is still beyond any form to predict. Families in Nepal often take part in the choosing, more than in the countries where most of this research was done, and that is changing, without any study able to rank one way above the other. What keeps a relationship good is less mysterious: feeling appreciated, believing your partner is committed, fighting fairly and without contempt. And jealousy that turns into control is a warning, never a proof of love.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
