Skip to content

← Money

A Piece of a Company

Chapter 22 · Owning a Share of Things

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. What you own
  2. How a dividend reaches you
  3. Borrowing makes each share riskier
  4. What a share is worth
  5. Try this

In March 1602 the Dutch government gave a new company the sole right to trade between the Netherlands and Asia for twenty-one years. It was called the United East India Company, the VOC from its Dutch initials, and it needed an enormous amount of money: ships, crews, guns, food for voyages that took years, and silver to buy pepper and cloves on the other side of the world. Its charter didn’t send it to a few rich men for that money. It said that notices were to be posted in the usual public places, telling the country’s inhabitants that for five months, from the first of April, anyone could join the company and pay in whatever sum they chose, in three parts over the next three years.

People did. The company raised about 6.4 million guilders, and the plan was simple. The money would send out fleets, the fleets would bring back spices, the spices would be sold, and after ten years the accounts would be closed and everyone could take their money out, with their share of whatever had been made.

It didn’t work out like that. The ships were slow to pay, the company spent heavily on forts and warships (the charter let it make treaties and wage war in Asia), and the first dividend, the owners’ share of the profit, came only in 1610. When it did come, most of it was offered not in money but in mace, a spice from the nutmeg tree, priced at the company’s own figures. Most owners refused the spice and waited for cash. And something else happened that nobody had planned. An owner who didn’t want to wait ten years could sell his part to someone who did, and trading in those parts began as soon as the subscription closed. In 1612 the company stopped promising to give the money back at all. It kept it for good, and the only way out for an owner was to sell to somebody else.

Those were shares, more or less as they are today: a company’s capital cut into pieces that anyone could buy, that paid out only when there was something to pay, and that changed hands at whatever the next buyer would give. Chapter 21 split the paper people keep their money in into two families, lending and owning. This chapter is the owning.

What you own

A company sells pieces of itself because some things need more money than any one person has, for longer than any lender would wait, with no promise of how it will turn out. A lender wants a fixed sum back on a fixed date, whatever happens. An owner agrees to share whatever happens, good or bad. For a voyage to Asia in 1602, or a hydropower dam in Nepal today, that is exactly the kind of money that is needed: money that will wait, and that won’t pull the business down if the first years go badly.

So what does an owner get? Three things, and the whole of this chapter grows out of them.

The first is a share of the profits, but only of the part the company decides to pay out. The rest stays in the business. The second is a vote: at the yearly meeting of owners, each ordinary share usually carries one, and the owners elect the board of directors who choose the managers. Owning one share in ten million means having one vote in ten million, which is to say almost none, but it’s still a vote. The third is the last place in the queue. If the company fails, its workers, lenders and the tax office are all paid before the owners get a rupee, and often there is nothing left by the time the queue reaches them.

The last place has a floor, though. A company is a person in law, as Economics, for the Curious explains in Chapter 9, and its debts are its own. If it fails, an owner loses what the shares cost and no more. Nobody comes for the owner’s house. That limit, limited liability, is what lets thousands of people who will never meet put money into the same enormous venture without each of them betting everything they own.

Most shares are of one kind: ordinary shares, साधारण सेयर, often called common shares. But a company can also sell preferred shares, which CDC calls पूर्वाधिकार or अग्राधिकार सेयर and Accounting, for the Curious meets in Chapter 19, and these are a bargain struck differently. Nepal’s Companies Act 2063 lets a company issue them, and it doesn’t fix the bargain. Instead, in section 65, it lists the questions every issue must answer: whether the holders are paid a dividend before the ordinary owners, and at what percentage; whether a dividend missed in a bad year piles up to be paid later, or is simply lost; whether they are paid back before the ordinary owners if the company is wound up; whether they vote, and on what; whether the shares can later turn into ordinary ones; and whether the company can pay their money back after a set time.

The usual answer makes a preferred share sit halfway between a loan and ownership. The holder gets a fixed dividend, paid before the ordinary owners see anything, and stands ahead of them in the queue if the company fails. In return, the holder usually gives up the vote, or most of it, and gives up the good years: however well the company does, the dividend stays at its fixed rate. Unlike interest on a loan, though, the dividend isn’t a debt. A company that skips it hasn’t broken a promise it can be taken to court for, which is why the question of whether missed dividends pile up matters so much to anyone thinking of buying one.

How a dividend reaches you

Suppose Sabina, who is made up, owns 100 ordinary shares in a company listed on the Nepal Stock Exchange. The year ends and the company has made a profit. Nothing reaches her yet.

First the board of directors proposes a dividend. In Nepal it is usually given as a percentage of each share’s face value, which for most companies is Rs. 100, so a “12% dividend” means Rs. 12 a share whatever the share now trades at; Grade 9 Math, Unit 3 works through the sums. The law keeps the board honest about where the money comes from. Under section 182 of the Companies Act, a dividend can be paid only out of profit, and only after the costs of starting up, the year’s wear on the company’s things and any losses carried from earlier years have been taken off. A company still digging out of old losses can’t pay its owners from new money until the hole is filled.

Then the owners meet. The annual general meeting approves the dividend, and the Act has a small twist here: the owners may vote for less than the board proposed, but not for more (section 77). The people closest to the company’s cash have the last word on how much of it can go.

Who gets it? Shares change hands every trading day, so the company has to draw a line. It closes its register of owners, which in Nepal is called book closure, दाखिल खारेज बन्द in the rules. Whoever is on the register then is paid. Someone who buys the next week buys a share without this year’s dividend in it, and you would expect the price to fall by about that much when trading starts again; the stock exchange’s rules even allow it different limits on how far that first price can move.

The company then has forty-five days from the decision to pay (section 182 again), and the money goes into an account kept for nothing else. Before it reaches Sabina’s bank account, five percent is taken off as tax, under section 88 of the Income Tax Act 2058. That tax is final: she pays nothing more on it, and doesn’t have to put it in a tax return. On her 100 shares the dividend is Rs. 1,200, the tax Rs. 60, and Rs. 1,140 arrives. A dividend nobody collects for five years goes into a fund set up to protect investors.

Sometimes, instead of money, the owners vote to take new shares. These are bonus shares, बोनस सेयर: the company turns profit it has kept into more shares and hands them out in proportion to what each owner holds. The Act allows it only by a special resolution of the general meeting, out of money that could have been paid as a dividend (section 179), and the Income Tax Act counts it as profit paid out, so the same five percent generally applies.

Bonus shares are greeted in Nepal like a gift, and it’s worth seeing what changes. Say a company has a lakh of shares and Sabina holds 100, one thousandth of it. A 20% bonus gives everyone one new share for every five they hold. Now the company has 1,20,000 shares and Sabina has 120. She still owns one thousandth. Nothing has come into the company and nothing has left it; the same business is simply cut into more pieces, the way a pizza cut into ten slices instead of eight isn’t any bigger. If each share sold for Rs. 300 before, you would expect each to be worth about Rs. 250 after, and her 120 shares to be worth what her 100 were. What a bonus does change is the money: profit that could have come to the owners as cash stays in the business instead, to earn more there, if it can.

How much a company pays, and how often, is a choice, and companies make it differently. Some pay much the same rupees every year, in good years and bad, because their owners like to count on it. Some pay a fixed share of each year’s profit, so the dividend swings with the profit. Some pay a small steady amount and add an extra in good years. And a company that is growing fast, with more good uses for money than it has money, may pay nothing at all for years, because every rupee kept can build something. A company with no dividend isn’t necessarily a bad one. Its owners are betting on what the kept profit will become.

Borrowing makes each share riskier

Where a company’s money comes from changes what its owners are holding. It can sell shares, or it can borrow, from a bank or by selling debentures (Chapter 25), and the two feel very different from the owners’ side.

Imagine a made-up dairy worth Rs. 1 crore: the cows, the cooling tank, the van, the stock of feed. In a bad year, when the rains fail and fodder is dear, it makes Rs. 4 lakh before paying any interest. In an ordinary year it makes Rs. 12 lakh, and in a good year Rs. 20 lakh. That swing, from 4% of what the business is worth to 20%, is its business risk, and it has nothing to do with how the dairy is paid for. It comes from the weather, the price of milk and the customers.

Now pay for the same dairy in two ways. In the first, owners put in the whole crore, as 1,00,000 shares of Rs. 100, and nothing is borrowed. Each share then earns Rs. 4 in a bad year, Rs. 12 in an ordinary one and Rs. 20 in a good one. In the second, owners put in only half, as 50,000 shares, and the other half is a loan at 10% a year. The lender must be paid Rs. 5 lakh in interest every year, good or bad, and only what is left belongs to the owners. In an ordinary year that leaves Rs. 7 lakh for 50,000 shares, Rs. 14 a share: better than without the loan, because the dairy earned 12% on the borrowed money and paid only 10% for it. In a good year it leaves Rs. 15 lakh, Rs. 30 a share. In a bad year the dairy makes Rs. 4 lakh and owes Rs. 5 lakh, and each share loses Rs. 2.

Try it

The same dairy, with and without a loan

All made up: a business worth Rs. 1 crore, shares of Rs. 100, the loan at 10% a year, tax left out.

Profit for each share, in rupees4−2A bad year1214An ordinary year2030A good yearnothing borrowedwith this loan
Borrowed:
Shares
50,000
Loan
Rs. 50 lakh
Interest a year
Rs. 5 lakh

With half borrowed, a share earns between −Rs. 2 and Rs. 30, a swing of Rs. 32, against Rs. 16 with nothing borrowed. The business is the same; only the interest is new.

The dairy hasn’t changed at all. Its cows give the same milk. But the owners’ slice has gone from swinging between Rs. 4 and Rs. 20 to swinging between a loss of Rs. 2 and a gain of Rs. 30, and borrowing three-quarters stretches it further still, from a loss of Rs. 14 to a gain of Rs. 50. The extra swing is financial risk, and it comes entirely from the fixed bill that has to be paid before the owners get anything. It is exactly what Chapter 24 will show a margin loan doing to a person who borrows to buy shares, done here by the company itself. And it has a darker edge than a bad year. Interest that can’t be paid isn’t skipped like a dividend; a lender can take the company to court, and enough bad years in a row can end it.

So a company sells shares in one year and borrows in another for reasons that make sense from inside it. Borrowing is attractive when the business is steady and expects to earn more on the money than the interest costs, and the owners keep all the extra without sharing their votes with anyone new. Selling shares is safer when the future is uncertain, because owners can be paid nothing in a bad year and nobody can take the company to court for it. A company with a lot of debt can be a fine company. Its shares are simply a bumpier ride.

What a share is worth

Here is the strange thing about a share: it has three different values, and people quote all three as if they were the same.

The first is its face value, the Rs. 100 printed on it, which says almost nothing; it is just the size the company chose to cut its capital into. The second is its book value: what the company owns, less everything it owes, divided by the number of shares. That is what each share would be entitled to if the company stopped, sold everything at the prices in its accounts and paid all its debts. The third is the price, what someone will actually pay for it today.

What ought it to be worth? Finance has a clean answer, and it is Chapter 10’s backward sum again. A share is worth everything it will ever pay its owner, with each future payment brought back to what it is worth today. Imagine a share that will pay Rs. 12 a year, every year, forever, and an investor who wants to earn 12% a year for taking the risk. Each future Rs. 12 is worth less today the further off it is, and added up, the whole endless line of them comes to exactly Rs. 100: Rs. 12 a year is 12% of Rs. 100. If instead the dividend is expected to grow by 4% a year, the investor is in effect being paid the 4% growth on top, so the yearly payment needs to cover only the other 8%: next year’s Rs. 12 divided by 8% makes the share worth Rs. 150. A growing dividend is worth much more than a flat one, and that is why a company that keeps its profit to grow can be worth more than one that pays it all out.

The catch is that every number in that sum is a guess. Nobody knows what a company will pay in twenty years, or how fast it will grow, and a small change in the guessed growth moves the answer a lot: at 6% growth instead of 4%, the same Rs. 12 is worth Rs. 200. So the sum doesn’t tell anyone the price. It tells them what they are assuming when they pay one.

The numbers people actually quote are shorter. Earnings per share is the year’s profit divided by the number of shares. Price to earnings, the P/E ratio, is the share’s price divided by that. Suppose a share costs Rs. 240 and its company earned Rs. 12 a share last year: its P/E is 20, which means buyers are paying for twenty years of last year’s profit, or, the other way up, that the share earns 5% of its price. A high P/E usually means buyers expect the profit to grow; a low one that they don’t, or that they are nervous. Price to book is the price divided by the book value: if the same company’s books show Rs. 120 a share, buyers are paying twice what the books say each share owns.

Each of these tells you something and hides something. One year’s profit can be unusually good or bad, so a P/E built on it can mislead. Book value counts a company’s things at what the accounts say, which for a bank, whose things are mostly loans and cash, is close to what they’re worth, and for a company whose value is in its people, its name or its ideas can be almost nothing. None of the three says whether a share is cheap, because cheap compared with what is always the question. They are a way of asking it, never an answer, and nothing in this chapter is advice to buy or sell any share.

Which leaves the plainest fact of all. A listed share’s price is whatever the last buyer agreed with the last seller, as Chapter 23 shows. It can sit far above every sum here, or far below, for years. The VOC’s first owners learned that their money could be got back only by selling to someone else at whatever that person would pay, and every shareholder since has been in the same position.

That is why owners read the company’s yearly report, which a listed company publishes before its annual meeting. A shareholder needs only four things from it at first: did it make a profit, what does it owe, did cash actually come in (profit on paper isn’t always money in the bank), and what did the auditor say, in the first paragraph of the auditor’s report, about whether the accounts can be trusted. Reading the whole report, line by line, is the subject of Chapter 20 of Accounting, for the Curious, which reads a bank’s.

What a reader should take from this is that a share is a piece of a business, with a share of what it pays out, a small vote and the last place in the queue, and that everything else about shares follows from those three. A dividend is decided by the board, approved by the owners, paid to whoever is on the register at book closure, and taxed at five percent on the way. A bonus share cuts the same business into more pieces. A company’s borrowing makes its owners’ slice swing harder in both directions. And a share’s worth depends on guesses about the future that nobody can check, which is why its price is in the end only what the next buyer will pay.

Try this

  • Find a company’s dividend announcement in the news. Work out what 100 shares would receive after the 5% tax, using the share’s face value of Rs. 100.
  • Find a bonus share announcement. Work out how many shares someone with 100 would hold afterwards, and what share of the company that is, before and after.
  • For any listed company, find its last year’s earnings per share and today’s price on the Nepal Stock Exchange’s site, and divide the price by the earnings. Then ask what the result would be if next year’s profit halved.
  • Open the yearly report of any listed company and read the first paragraph of the auditor’s report. What did the auditor say?

Found a mistake? Please tell us.