← Making Decisions, in Practice
Asking for advice · 43 of 84
Ask what the adviser gains
Some evidence
Do this
- Ask: what does this person gain if I say yes?
- If you can’t tell, ask how they’re paid.
- Discount the advice even if they’ve told you openly.
- Get a second view from someone who gains nothing.
What the research says
In experiments, people didn’t discount advice from biased advisers enough, even when the bias was declared. Declaring it even led some advisers to give more biased advice. Some evidence. So “I’ll be honest with you, I do earn commission” doesn’t make the advice safe. Most advisers aren’t crooks. They only see from where they stand. See Check before you pay any education consultancy.
Try it today
Think of advice you’ve had this month. Write what that person stood to gain. Two minutes.
Where these facts come from
- Cain, D. M., Loewenstein, G. and Moore, D. A., The dirt on coming clean, Journal of Legal Studies, 2005 (abstract).
General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.
