Skip to content

← Making Decisions, in Practice

Asking for advice · 44 of 84

Go by what they know, not how they sound

Moderate evidence

Do this

  1. Ask what this person really knows about this choice.
  2. Ask: “Have you done this, or seen many people do it?”
  3. Give weight for that, not for age, a title or a confident voice.
  4. Keep respect and weight apart: you can respect someone and still not follow them.

What the research says

Across 129 data sets, people moved their estimates by 32, 37 or 48 percent, depending on how good the adviser was made to seem. That helps only if the seeming is true. Moderate evidence: lab estimates, not life choices. See Ask “expert in what?”.

Try it today

List who you’d ask about one choice. Write beside each what they really know about it. Three minutes.

Where these facts come from

General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.

← All 84 small things