← Making Decisions, in Practice
Asking for advice · 42 of 84
No one to ask? Guess again, as if you were wrong
Moderate evidence
Do this
- Make your first guess at a number.
- Assume it’s wrong. Ask why it might be.
- Make a new guess from a different angle.
- Take the middle of the two.
What the research says
The average of two guesses from one person tends to be more accurate than one guess: this “crowd within” held up when it was repeated in a pre-registered study. A second guess that uses different knowledge helps most. Moderate evidence. A real second person brings knowledge you don’t have, so ask someone if you can.
Try it today
Guess the cost of something you’re planning. Then guess again as if you’d been wrong. Two minutes.
Where these facts come from
- Herzog, S. M. and Hertwig, R., The wisdom of many in one mind, Psychological Science, 2009 (abstract).
- Vul, E. and Pashler, H., Measuring the crowd within, Psychological Science, 2008 (abstract).
- Steegen, S. and others, Measuring the crowd within again: a pre-registered replication study, Frontiers in Psychology, 2014 (abstract).
General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.
