Skip to content

← Grade 12 Physics

Exam practice

Every question from the end of every unit, with hints and answers to open. After you check an answer, mark how you did, and come back to the ones you didn’t get.

9 questions

Unit 5 · Second Law of Thermodynamics

Answer these questions

12.
  • a.State and explain the second law of thermodynamics, using the Kelvin–Planck and Clausius statements.
  • b.Compare and contrast the first and second laws of thermodynamics in terms of the direction of heat flow and the efficiency of energy conversion.
Answer

a. Kelvin–Planck statement: it is impossible to make an engine, working in a cycle, that takes heat from a single reservoir and turns all of it into work. Every heat engine must give out part of the heat it takes in to a colder sink, so none can be 100% efficient.
Clausius statement: heat cannot flow by itself from a colder body to a hotter body; for that, external work must be done, as in a refrigerator.
The two are equivalent: a perfect engine (breaking Kelvin–Planck) could drive a refrigerator so that the pair moves heat from cold to hot with no outside work (breaking Clausius), and a perfect refrigerator joined to an ordinary engine would make a perfect engine.
b.

First law Second law
Direction of heat flow not stated: heat could flow either way, as long as energy is conserved heat flows by itself only from hot to cold; the reverse needs work
Efficiency of turning heat into work not limited: allows 100% always less than 100%; at most 1−T2/T1 1 - T_2/T_1
About the quantity of energy (conservation) the direction of processes, irreversibility, entropy
13.
  • a.What are the essential parts of a heat engine?
  • b.Draw a block diagram of a heat engine. Explain how its efficiency can be found.
  • c.A heat engine absorbs 1200 J of heat from the source and rejects 700 J to the sink. Calculate i. the work done, ii. the efficiency of the engine.
  • d.Why can the efficiency of a heat engine never be 100%?
Answer
  • a.A source (a hot reservoir at T1 T_1 , from which heat is taken without changing its temperature), a sink (a cold reservoir at T2 T_2 , to which heat is given without changing its temperature) and a working substance (the gas or steam that takes in heat, does work by expanding, and gives out the rest of the heat), in a cylinder or turbine where it does the work.
  • b.The block diagram is Figure 5.3: Q1 Q_1 from the source into the engine, W W out as work, Q2 Q_2 into the sink. In a cycle the working substance’s internal energy doesn’t change, so W=Q1−Q2 W = Q_1 - Q_2 , and the efficiency is the work done over the heat taken in:

η=WQ1=Q1−Q2Q1=1−Q2Q1 \eta = \frac{W}{Q_1} = \frac{Q_1 - Q_2}{Q_1} = 1 - \frac{Q_2}{Q_1}
Measure (or calculate) the heat taken in and the heat given out, or the work done, and use this.

  • c.i. W=Q1−Q2=1200−700= W = Q_1 - Q_2 = 1200 - 700 = 500 J. ii. η=WQ1=5001200=0.417= \eta = \dfrac{W}{Q_1} = \dfrac{500}{1200} = 0.417 = 41.7%.
  • d.100% would need Q2=0 Q_2 = 0 : all the heat turned into work with none given to a sink. The Kelvin–Planck statement says that is impossible for an engine working in a cycle. Even the ideal Carnot engine has η=1−T2/T1 \eta = 1 - T_2/T_1 , which would be 1 only with a sink at 0 K, and absolute zero can’t be reached. Real engines also lose energy to friction and heat leaks.
14.
  • a.Describe the Carnot cycle and explain its representation on a P–V diagram.
  • b.Derive the efficiency of a Carnot engine, and explain the significance of the source and sink temperatures.
  • c.The efficiency of a Carnot engine is 60%. If the sink is at 300 K, what is the temperature of the source?
Answer
  • a.The Carnot cycle is the ideal, reversible cycle of an ideal gas in a cylinder with insulating walls and a conducting base, moved between a source at T1 T_1 , an insulating stand and a sink at T2 T_2 (Figure 5.7): AB, isothermal expansion on the source at T1 T_1 , taking in heat Q1 Q_1 ; BC, adiabatic expansion on the stand, the gas cooling to T2 T_2 ; CD, isothermal compression on the sink at T2 T_2 , giving out heat Q2 Q_2 ; DA, adiabatic compression on the stand, back to T1 T_1 . On the P–V diagram the isotherms are the gentler curves, the adiabats the steeper ones; the loop is traced clockwise and its area is the net work done in each cycle.
  • b.For n n moles: Q1=W1=nRT1ln⁡(V2/V1) Q_1 = W_1 = nRT_1\ln(V_2/V_1) ; Q2=nRT2ln⁡(V3/V4) Q_2 = nRT_2\ln(V_3/V_4) ; the two adiabatic works, ±nR(T1−T2)/(γ−1) \pm nR(T_1 - T_2)/(\gamma - 1) , cancel. From TVγ−1= TV^{\gamma - 1} = constant on BC and DA, T1V2γ−1=T2V3γ−1 T_1V_2^{\gamma-1} = T_2V_3^{\gamma-1} and T1V1γ−1=T2V4γ−1 T_1V_1^{\gamma-1} = T_2V_4^{\gamma-1} ; dividing, V2/V1=V3/V4 V_2/V_1 = V_3/V_4 . So W=Q1−Q2=nR(T1−T2)ln⁡(V2/V1) W = Q_1 - Q_2 = nR(T_1 - T_2)\ln(V_2/V_1) and

η=WQ1=nR(T1−T2)ln⁡(V2/V1)nRT1ln⁡(V2/V1)=1−T2T1 \eta = \frac{W}{Q_1} = \frac{nR(T_1 - T_2)\ln(V_2/V_1)}{nRT_1\ln(V_2/V_1)} = 1 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}
Significance: the efficiency depends only on the two temperatures (in kelvin), not on the working substance. A hotter source or a colder sink gives a higher efficiency; it could be 100% only with T2=0 T_2 = 0 K, which is impossible. No engine between the same two temperatures can do better.
c. 0.6=1−300T1⇒300T1=0.4⇒T1= 0.6 = 1 - \dfrac{300}{T_1} \Rightarrow \dfrac{300}{T_1} = 0.4 \Rightarrow T_1 = 750 K.

15.
  • a.Differentiate between the Otto and Diesel cycles. Show both on P–V diagrams.
  • b.A diesel engine takes in 5000 J of heat and does 1200 J of work. Calculate the heat it rejects and its efficiency.
Answer

a. The P–V diagrams are Figure 5.11 and Figure 5.13.

Otto cycle (petrol engine) Diesel cycle (diesel engine)
compresses an air–petrol mixture compresses air only
lit by a spark fuel lights itself in the hot air
heat added at constant volume (vertical line CD) heat added at constant pressure (horizontal line CD)
compression ratio 8–12 compression ratio 14–25
η=1−1/rγ−1 \eta = 1 - 1/r^{\gamma-1} η=1−1rγ−1⋅ρcγ−1γ(ρc−1) \eta = 1 - \dfrac{1}{r^{\gamma-1}}\cdot\dfrac{\rho_c^{\gamma}-1}{\gamma(\rho_c-1)} , lower at the same r r , higher in practice because r r is higher

Both have adiabatic compression BC and expansion DE, and heat given out at constant volume EB.
b. Q2=Q1−W=5000−1200= Q_2 = Q_1 - W = 5000 - 1200 = 3800 J; η=12005000=0.24= \eta = \dfrac{1200}{5000} = 0.24 = 24%.

16.
  • a.Describe the working of a refrigerator as a reversed heat engine. Define its coefficient of performance (COP).
  • b.A refrigerator removes 400 J of heat from its cold compartment and needs 100 J of work. What is its COP?
Answer

a. A heat engine takes heat from a hot body, gives work out and gives the rest of the heat to a cold body. A refrigerator does the reverse: work W W (from the electric motor) is done on its working substance, which takes heat Q2 Q_2 from the cold inside and gives out Q1=Q2+W Q_1 = Q_2 + W to the warmer room (Figure 5.8). The refrigerant boils in the evaporator inside, taking in heat; the compressor squeezes the vapor, making it hotter than the room; it gives out heat and condenses in the coils at the back; through the expansion valve its pressure and temperature drop, and it returns to the evaporator (Figure 5.9).
The coefficient of performance is the heat taken from the cold body per unit of work: β=Q2W=Q2Q1−Q2 \beta = \dfrac{Q_2}{W} = \dfrac{Q_2}{Q_1 - Q_2} ; for an ideal refrigerator β=T2T1−T2 \beta = \dfrac{T_2}{T_1 - T_2} .
b. β=Q2W=400100= \beta = \dfrac{Q_2}{W} = \dfrac{400}{100} = 4.

17.
  • a.What is entropy? How does it relate to disorder?
  • b.Why is the entropy of the universe said to be always increasing? Give examples.
Answer
  • a.Entropy S S is a state variable that measures the disorder of the particles of a system, or how spread out its energy is. A small change in it is the heat given reversibly divided by the absolute temperature: dS=dQ/T dS = dQ/T , in J/K. The more disordered a system, the more ways its particles can be arranged, and the higher its entropy (Boltzmann: S=kBln⁡W S = k_B\ln W ): a gas has more entropy than its liquid, and a liquid more than its solid.
  • b.Almost every natural process is irreversible, and in every irreversible process the total entropy of the system and its surroundings increases; in a reversible process it would stay the same, and it never decreases. The universe is an isolated system, so its entropy keeps rising. Examples: heat flowing from a hot cup of tea to the room (1000 J from 400 K to 300 K raises the total entropy by 0.83 J/K); ice melting in a warm room; ink or incense smoke spreading out; friction turning a vehicle’s motion into heat in its brakes; fuel burning. None of these undoes itself. The entropy of one part can fall (water freezing in a freezer), but only if the entropy elsewhere rises by more.
18.
  • a.Explain why no heat engine can be more efficient than a Carnot engine working between the same two temperatures.
  • b.Describe the practical limitations of real engines compared with the ideal Carnot engine.
  • c.A Carnot engine works between a source at 500 K and a sink at 300 K. Calculate its efficiency.
Answer
  • a.Suppose an engine X were more efficient than a Carnot engine R between the same reservoirs. R is reversible, so it can be run backwards as a refrigerator, driven by X. X can supply all the work R needs while taking less heat from the hot reservoir than R gives back to it. Together, the two machines then do no net work, yet move heat from the cold reservoir to the hot one: heat flowing from cold to hot by itself, which the Clausius statement forbids. So no engine can beat Carnot’s (Carnot’s theorem).
  • b.A real engine can’t be reversible: its pistons and bearings have friction; heat leaks through its walls; its processes are fast, not infinitely slow, so the gas isn’t in equilibrium; heat must flow across a real temperature difference to get in and out in a reasonable time, so the working substance never reaches the source’s or the sink’s temperature; fuel doesn’t burn completely; and real cycles (Otto, Diesel) aren’t Carnot cycles, and throw out exhaust that is still hot. A Carnot engine would also run infinitely slowly, giving no power. So real engines reach well under the Carnot efficiency.
  • c.η=1−T2T1=1−300500=0.4= \eta = 1 - \dfrac{T_2}{T_1} = 1 - \dfrac{300}{500} = 0.4 = 40%.
19.

A heat engine has an efficiency of 25%. How much heat does it reject if it absorbs 600 J of heat from the source?

Answer

W=ηQ1=0.25×600=150 W = \eta Q_1 = 0.25 \times 600 = 150 J, so Q2=Q1−W=600−150= Q_2 = Q_1 - W = 600 - 150 = 450 J.

20.

A Carnot engine rejects heat at 400 K and absorbs heat at 800 K. If it does 300 J of work per cycle, calculate a. its efficiency, b. the heat it absorbs per cycle.

Answer
  • a.η=1−400800=0.5= \eta = 1 - \dfrac{400}{800} = 0.5 = 50%.
  • b.Q1=Wη=3000.5= Q_1 = \dfrac{W}{\eta} = \dfrac{300}{0.5} = 600 J (of which 300 J is rejected to the sink).