Skip to content

← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words

The Constitutional Council and appointments

भाग ३२: विविध · Part 32, Miscellaneous · Articles 284–285 and 291–294

On the news on a phone, a reporter says a committee of Parliament has held a hearing on someone named to head a commission. Where do those steps come from? Part 32 of the Constitution sets them out: who recommends people for the highest posts, the hearing in Parliament before they are appointed, and how the bodies they lead answer to Parliament.

The Constitutional Council

sets up a council whose work is to recommend people for some of the highest posts.

Who sits on the Council

The Constitution

(१) यस संविधान बमोजिम प्रधान न्यायाधीश र संवैधानिक निकायका प्रमुख र पदाधिकारीहरूको नियुक्तिको सिफारिस गर्न देहाय बमोजिमका अध्यक्ष र सदस्य रहेको एक संवैधानिक परिषद रहनेछः—

(क) प्रधानमन्त्री —अध्यक्ष

(ख) प्रधान न्यायाधीश —सदस्य

(ग) प्रतिनिधि सभाको सभामुख —सदस्य

(घ) राष्ट्रिय सभाको अध्यक्ष —सदस्य

(ङ) प्रतिनिधि सभाको विपक्षी दलको नेता —सदस्य

(च) प्रतिनिधि सभाको उपसभामुख —सदस्य

(1) There shall be a Constitutional Council for making recommendations for appointment of the Chief Justice and Chiefs and officials of the Constitutional Bodies in accordance with this Constitution, which shall consist of the following as the Chairperson and members:-

(a) The Prime Minister - Chairperson

(b) The Chief Justice - Member

(c) The Speaker of the House of Representatives - Member

(d) The Chairperson of the National Assembly - Member

(e) Leader of Opposition Party in the House of Representatives - Member

(f) Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives - Member

In plain words

There is a Constitutional Council (संवैधानिक परिषद) to recommend who is appointed, under the Constitution, as Chief Justice and as the heads and officials of the Constitutional Bodies. The Prime Minister chairs it. Its five members are the Chief Justice, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Chairperson of the National Assembly, the leader of the opposition party in the House of Representatives, and the Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives.

The Constitutional Bodies are the thirteen listed in : the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority, the Auditor General, the Public Service Commission, the Election Commission, the National Human Rights Commission, the National Natural Resources and Fiscal Commission, the National Women Commission, the National Dalit Commission, the National Inclusion Commission, the Indigenous Nationalities Commission, the Madhesi Commission, the Tharu Commission and the Muslim Commission.

When the office of Chief Justice is vacant and the Council recommends a new Chief Justice, the Government of Nepal’s Minister for Law and Justice sits on the Council as a member too (). The Nepali begins the clause with “when the office of the Chief Justice falls vacant” (प्रधान न्यायाधीशको पद रिक्त भएको अवस्थामा), words the translation leaves out.

The Council must make its recommendation a month before the office of the Chief Justice, or of a head or official of a Constitutional Body, falls vacant (). If the office falls vacant because the holder dies or resigns, the Council may make its recommendation so that the office is filled within one month of the day it fell vacant (the proviso to ).

The Council’s other functions, duties and powers, and the procedure for appointing the Chief Justice and the heads and officials of the Constitutional Bodies, are as a federal law sets out (). The Chief Secretary of the Government of Nepal works as the Council’s secretary ().

Government services

The Government of Nepal may set up the federal civil service (संघीय निजामती सेवा), and other federal government services as needed, to run the country’s administration. How they are set up and run, and their conditions of service, are as a federal Act sets out ().

When posts in all federal government services, including the federal civil service, are filled through competitive examinations (प्रतियोगितात्मक परीक्षा), this is done on the basis of the open and proportional inclusive principle, as a federal law sets out (). The Nepali speaks of filling posts through competitive examinations (प्रतियोगितात्मक परीक्षाद्वारा पदपूर्ति गर्दा) and says “including” (लगायत) the civil service and “as a federal law sets out” (संघीय कानून बमोजिम); the translation says positions “shall be fulfilled through competitive examinations”, says “as well as”, and leaves the federal law out.

A Province’s Council of Ministers, a Rural Municipal Executive and a Municipal Executive may each set up and run government services, as a law sets out and as they need to run their administration ().

Holding a foreign residence permit

applies to every office the Constitution fills by election, nomination or appointment.

No office with a foreign residence permit

The Constitution

(१) यस संविधानमा अन्यत्र जुनसुकै कुरा लेखिएको भए तापनि विदेशको स्थायी आवासीय अनुमतिपत्र लिएको नेपालको नागरिक यस संविधान बमोजिम निर्वाचन, मनोनयन वा नियुक्ति हुने पदमा निर्वाचित, मनोनीत वा नियुक्तिको लागि योग्य हुने छैन।

तर त्यस्तो विदेशको स्थायी आवासीय अनुमतिपत्र त्यागेको व्यक्तिलाई कम्तीमा तीन महीनाको अवधि व्यतित भए पछि त्यस्तो पदमा निर्वाचित, मनोनीत वा नियुक्त गर्न बाधा पर्ने छैन।

(1) Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in this Constitution, a citizen of Nepal who has obtained a foreign permanent residence permit shall not be eligible for election, nomination or appointment to an office to be elected, nominated or appointed in accordance with this Constitution.

Provided that nothing shall prevent electing, nominating or appointing a person who has renounced such foreign permanent residence permit to such office after the expiry of a period of at least three months.

In plain words

Whatever else the Constitution says, a citizen of Nepal who has taken a foreign permanent residence permit (विदेशको स्थायी आवासीय अनुमतिपत्र) is not eligible to be elected, nominated or appointed to any office the Constitution fills that way. Someone who has given up such a permit may be elected, nominated or appointed once at least three months have passed.

Other matters about citizens of Nepal who have taken a foreign permanent residence permit are as a federal law sets out ().

A citizen of Nepal gives up a foreign permanent residence permit. How long before they can be appointed to an office under the Constitution?

Pick an answer to see why.

Hearings in Parliament

Before anyone is appointed to these offices, a parliamentary hearing (संसदीय सुनुवाई) is held, as a federal law sets out: the Chief Justice, the Justices of the Supreme Court, the members of the Judicial Council, and the heads or officials of the Constitutional Bodies, appointed on the Constitutional Council’s recommendation under the Constitution; and ambassadors (). The Nepali says the hearing comes before the appointment (नियुक्ति हुनु अघि), which the translation doesn’t say.

For these hearings, a joint committee of fifteen members, drawn from both Houses of the Federal Parliament, is formed as a federal law sets out (). A member of that committee may not appear and plead cases (बहस पैरबी) in the Supreme Court for that term of the Federal Parliament (); the translation says “practice law”.

Answering to Parliament

says to whom the Constitutional Bodies answer.

Answerable to Parliament

The Constitution

संवैधानिक निकायका प्रमुख र पदाधिकारी संघीय संसदप्रति उत्तरदायी र जवाफदेही रहनु पर्नेछ। प्रतिनिधि सभाका समितिले राष्ट्रिय मानव अधिकार आयोग बाहेकका अन्य संवैधानिक निकायको प्रतिवेदन लगायतका काम कारबाहीको अनुगमन र मूल्याङ्कन गरी आवश्यक निर्देशन वा राय सल्लाह दिन सक्नेछ।

The chiefs and officials of the Constitutional Bodies shall be accountable and responsible to the Federal Parliament. The committees of the House of Representatives may monitor and evaluate the functioning, including reports, of the Constitutional Bodies, other than the National Human Rights Commission, and give necessary direction or advice.

In plain words

The heads and officials of the Constitutional Bodies must be accountable and answerable to the Federal Parliament. The committees of the House of Representatives may monitor and evaluate the work of the Constitutional Bodies, including their reports, and give the direction or advice needed. The National Human Rights Commission is the one body they leave out.

Yearly reports

Every Constitutional Body sends the President a yearly report on its work, and the President has the Prime Minister put it before the Federal Parliament (). What the report must contain is as a federal law sets out (). Whatever clause (1) says, a Constitutional Body may also prepare a separate report on its work in each Province and send it to that Province’s Chief of Province ().

What it means in your day

  • A new Chief Justice or commission head. When the news says the Constitutional Council has recommended a name, that is at work; the hearing that follows in a committee of Parliament is .
  • A government job. When posts in the federal civil service and other federal government services are filled through competitive examinations, it is on the open and proportional inclusive principle, as a federal law sets out ().
  • Coming home to stand for office. A citizen who has taken a foreign permanent residence permit can’t be elected, nominated or appointed to an office under the Constitution until at least three months after giving it up ().
  • A commission’s report in the news. The yearly reports of the Constitutional Bodies go to the President and then to Parliament ().
Getting help

If you think your rights, or someone else’s, have been violated:

  • National Human Rights Commission (राष्ट्रिय मानव अधिकार आयोग), set up by , takes complaints of human rights violations (). Its hotline is +977-1-5010000, open 24 hours, holidays too, and it takes complaints online at nhrcnepal.org.
  • Free legal aid. gives any indigent party the right to free legal aid. Under the Legal Aid Act, 2054, every district has a District Legal Aid Committee (जिल्ला कानूनी सहायता समिति), chaired by the district’s government attorney, for people whose yearly income is below the amount the rules set, and for victims of gender-based violence or armed conflict.
  • The courts. gives the right to apply to the High Court () or the Supreme Court () to enforce the fundamental rights. A lawyer can explain how.
Where these facts come from

← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words