When Andrew Carnegie was learning the iron trade in Pittsburgh, he was “greatly surprised to find that the cost of each of the various processes was unknown.” He asked the leading ironmasters of the city, and none of them knew either. “It was a lump business,” he wrote, “and until stock was taken and the books balanced at the end of the year, the manufacturers were in total ignorance of results.” “I felt as if we were moles burrowing in the dark, and this to me was intolerable.”
What he did about it was to weigh things. Scales went in at points all through the mills, and clerks wrote down what went into each furnace and what came out, until he knew what every department, and every man at the furnaces, was doing. Every manager was against it, and it took years. The old way, as he saw it, had been careless. Owners who “would not trust a clerk with five dollars” without a check on him were handing over tons of material every day without weighing what came back as finished iron.
The books of the earlier chapters are the ones Carnegie found wanting. They record every sale and purchase, and once a year they say what the whole business earned and owns. That is financial accounting, वित्तीय लेखाविधि, and beside it stand two other kinds. Management accounting, व्यवस्थापन लेखाविधि, gives the owners figures for their decisions, and it is what the rest of this part of the book is about. Cost accounting, लागत लेखाविधि, finds what each thing costs, in total and for one unit, so that a price can be set and the cost kept in check. Financial accounting looks back over the year, at the business from the outside. Cost accounting looks inside it. It takes clerks and time, as Carnegie found, and much of it rests on rules for sharing costs that someone has to choose.
Three kinds of cost
At the start of the shop’s third year, Yasmin and Gaurav opened a corner for mixing paint. Gaurav, her partner since the year before, is a house painter, and knew how long painters spend hunting for the shade a customer wants. So the shop bought white tinting base in 4-liter tins, which is never sold plain, a rack of tinters, a bench and a set of small scales, and now mixes any color on the shade card while the painter waits. It sells the mixed tins at Rs. 850 each. Is that a good price? The shop’s books can’t say, because they record the base, the tinters, the helper’s wages and the rent each in its own account for the whole shop, and no account says what one mixed tin took.
Cost accounting starts by sorting those costs, by element first. There are materials, सामग्री: the base and the tinters. There is labor, श्रम: the time someone spends mixing. And there is everything else, called expenses, and among them the overheads, उपरिव्यय: the rent of the corner, the light, the wear on the scales.
Then by whether a cost can be traced to the thing made. A direct cost, प्रत्यक्ष लागत, belongs to one product so plainly that it can be measured for each unit: the tin of base in this tin of green, the 70 rupees of tinter stirred into it, the twelve minutes the helper spent on it. An indirect cost, अप्रत्यक्ष लागत, serves many products at once and can only be shared out among them: no one can say how much of the month’s rent is in one tin of green. Every overhead is indirect.
Costs can be sorted other ways too, five in all, each answering its own question. By product and process, according to which product or stage of work a cost belongs to. By element, materials, labor and expenses. By function, according to where in the business a cost arises: in making the product, in running the office, or in selling it. By control, according to whether a manager can change it: the helper’s minutes, yes; the rent agreed with the landlord for the year, no. And by behavior, according to whether a cost grows with the number of tins mixed or stays the same however many are mixed, which is the subject of Chapter 23.
How the costing is done depends on what is being made. A painter who paints a whole school keeps one account for that contract, contract costing, and a printer keeps one for each order of wedding cards, job costing. A paint factory adds up the cost of each stage its materials pass through, process costing. A brick kiln divides its cost by the bricks, unit costing; a bakery costs its cakes by the batch; a bus company counts the cost of carrying one passenger one kilometer, service costing. A bicycle maker, with many different parts and products, uses several methods at once, which is called multiple costing. Yasmin’s mixing is the simplest kind, unit costing: one product, made over and over, the cost of a month divided by its tins.
The tins on the rack
Materials are usually the biggest cost, and the easiest to lose, so a business that takes cost seriously puts a procedure around them. Someone who needs materials fills in a requisition. Someone else, with the authority to spend, sends a purchase order to a supplier, often after calling for tenders. The goods are counted and inspected against the order when they arrive, and only then is the bill paid. A chain of shops can buy for all of them from one office, centralized purchasing, for better prices but slower service, or each shop can buy for itself, decentralized purchasing, quicker and dearer. Once bought, the materials are in the care of a storekeeper, who receives them, keeps them safe, hands them out only against a requisition, and keeps the records. Each kind of material gets a code, so that the white base in 4-liter tins is always WB4 and never confused with the 1-liter tins.
Two records follow every material. On the rack hangs the storekeeper’s bin card, which counts tins only: in, out and left. In the office is the store ledger, भण्डार खाता, which counts the same tins in rupees. The ledger has a question to answer that the bin card doesn’t: when tins bought at different prices sit on the same rack, what does a tin taken from it cost?
In भदौ the shop began with 40 tins of white base left from साउन’s order, bought at Rs. 540 each. On भदौ 3 Sujan, the wholesaler, delivered 120 more at Rs. 560, because the price had gone up. A hundred went to the bench by the 15th, another 90 arrived on the 17th at Rs. 580, and a hundred more were used by the end of the month. Fifty tins were left. In all, Rs. 141,000 of base came onto the rack, and the question is how to divide it between the 200 tins mixed and the 50 still there.
One way is to suppose the oldest tins go out first. Here it is more than a supposition, because the helper takes tins from the front of the rack and new ones go in at the back, and the method is called first in, first out, प्रथम आगमन प्रथम निकासी. The first hundred issued are the 40 at Rs. 540 and 60 of the 560s, Rs. 55,200. The second hundred are the other 60 at Rs. 560 and 40 of the 580s, Rs. 56,800. The 50 left are all from the last delivery, at Rs. 580: Rs. 29,000.
The other way is to stop telling the tins apart. After each delivery the ledger works out the average price of everything on the rack, weighted by how many tins came at each price. The 40 at Rs. 540 and the 120 at Rs. 560 make 160 tins worth Rs. 88,800, an average of Rs. 555; after a hundred go out and 90 come in at Rs. 580, the 150 on the rack are worth Rs. 85,500, an average of Rs. 570. This is the weighted average method, भारित औसत. It charges the bench Rs. 112,500 and leaves Rs. 28,500 on the rack.
Neither is truer. The tins are identical and the total is fixed: whatever one method gives the bench, it takes from the rack. But they don’t come out the same when prices are moving. With prices rising, first in, first out charges the work with the older, cheaper prices and leaves the newest on the rack, so it shows a slightly higher profit and a stock closer to what replacing it would cost. The average smooths the rise. With prices falling, everything goes the other way.
Two more are often taught. The simple average takes the three prices without asking how many tins came at each, (540 + 560 + 580) ÷ 3 = Rs. 560, which goes wrong as soon as the deliveries differ in size. And last in, first out, LIFO, charges the newest tins first, so that the bench pays the latest prices and the rack keeps the oldest; here it would charge Rs. 113,800 and leave just Rs. 27,200. The international standard on stock, IAS 2, has not allowed LIFO since it was revised in 2003: the method doesn’t show how goods actually flow, and it leaves a balance sheet showing prices that may be years old. It was often chosen for the tax it saved when prices were rising, which the Board that writes the standards did not think reason enough. Nepal’s Income Tax Act, in section 15, allows a business whose stock can’t be told apart to choose first in, first out or the weighted average, and nothing else. Yasmin uses first in, first out, because it is how her rack actually works.
There is one more choice. The ledger can be worked out after every issue, as above, which is the perpetual system, or only once at the end of the period, which is the periodic system: then the month’s Rs. 141,000 over its 250 tins gives Rs. 564 a tin for the whole month, the bench Rs. 112,800 and the rack Rs. 28,200. The perpetual ledger takes more work but says, on any day, what is on the rack and what it is worth.
The ledger also tells the storekeeper when to order. If the bench can use up to 10 tins on a busy day and Sujan can take up to 4 days to deliver, an order must go when the rack is down to 40 tins, the reorder level, पुनः आदेश तह; above it lie a maximum level, beyond which tins only tie up money and space, below it a minimum the rack should never reach, and between them an average level, what the rack holds on an ordinary day. How many to order is a balance between two costs. Every order costs something to place and bring, say Rs. 600 for the van, so fewer, larger orders are cheaper; but every tin kept costs something to hold, say Rs. 50 a year in the money tied up, the space and the risk of damage, so smaller orders are cheaper. The quantity at which the two costs together are least is the economic order quantity, मितव्ययी आदेश परिमाण, and it has a formula: the square root of twice the year’s use times the cost of an order, divided by the cost of holding one tin for a year. For 2,400 tins a year, √(2 × 2,400 × 600 ÷ 50) = 240 tins, ten orders a year, one about every five weeks. Then the orders cost Rs. 6,000 and the holding Rs. 6,000, which is no coincidence: the formula finds where they are equal.
The helper’s minutes and the rent
Labor is counted as carefully as tins, at least in a factory. A worker is taken on against a labor requisition and has a record of their own; their hours are recorded on a time card, or now often by a fingerprint machine at the gate, and a job card shows how many of those hours went on which job. The payroll turns them into wages. Wages themselves are paid by time or by output: a time rate pays for hours, whatever is done in them, and a piece rate pays for each piece finished, whatever the hours.
Yasmin’s helper is paid by time, Rs. 20,000 a month for about 200 hours, which is Rs. 100 an hour. Partners’ salaries and interest are not costs of the business but shares of its profit, so the labor in a tin is the helper’s. A tin takes her twelve minutes to weigh, stir and label, so 200 tins took 40 hours, or Rs. 4,000 of her pay. The rest of her month went to selling and fetching, and is not a cost of mixing at all. If she were paid by the piece instead, at Rs. 20 a tin, she would earn the same Rs. 4,000 for 200 tins, but only Rs. 2,400 in a slow month of 120, and the shop’s labor cost would rise and fall with its work. That difference is what Chapter 23 is built on.
The overheads are the hardest part, because none of them belongs to a tin. They are sorted the same ways as other costs, by element, function, behavior and control, and then shared out. Cost accountants deal with them in three steps, allocation, apportionment and absorption, बाँडफाँड, संविभाजन and अवशोषण. First, any overhead that belongs wholly to one part of the business is allocated to it: the stirring sticks, rags and labels, Rs. 2,000 a month, belong to the mixing corner and to nothing else. Next, an overhead shared by the whole shop is apportioned among its parts by a fair measure. Rent is usually shared by floor area, and the corner takes a tenth of the shop’s floor, so it takes a tenth of the Rs. 15,000 rent, Rs. 1,500. Its light comes to Rs. 300. The bench and the scales cost Rs. 24,000 and should last ten years, so their wear is Rs. 200 a month. The corner’s overheads come to Rs. 4,000.
Last, the overheads are absorbed into the tins, at a rate fixed in advance from a normal month: Rs. 4,000 over 200 tins is Rs. 20 a tin. It is fixed in advance because a price must be set before the month’s costs are known. But months are not all normal. In a slow month of 120 tins the rent, the light and the wear don’t shrink, and with the sticks and labels at Rs. 1,200 the overheads come to Rs. 3,200, while the tins absorb only 120 × 20 = Rs. 2,400. The other Rs. 800 is under-absorbed, a cost that went into no tin; in a busy month the tins absorb more than was spent, and the overheads are over-absorbed.
One tin, added up
Now every cost of the month can go on one sheet, the cost sheet, laid out as a ladder, each rung a named cost. Here is the mixing corner’s month of भदौ, 200 tins, with the base priced first in, first out.
| Rs. | One tin, Rs. | |
|---|---|---|
| White base (from the store ledger) | 112,000 | 560 |
| Tinters | 14,000 | 70 |
| Direct materials | 126,000 | 630 |
| Direct labor (40 hours) | 4,000 | 20 |
| Prime cost | 130,000 | 650 |
| Mixing corner’s overheads | 4,000 | 20 |
| Works cost | 134,000 | 670 |
| Office and administration | 1,000 | 5 |
| Cost of production | 135,000 | 675 |
| Selling and distribution | 1,000 | 5 |
| Cost of sales | 136,000 | 680 |
| Profit | 34,000 | 170 |
| Sales | 170,000 | 850 |
The direct costs together make the prime cost, मुख्य लागत. With the factory’s overheads they make the works or factory cost, कारखाना लागत, and the corner’s share of the office’s costs (its slice of the phone, the paper, the accountant’s time) makes the cost of production, उत्पादन लागत. Tins mixed and not yet sold would be taken off here, and those left from before added, to give the बिक्री योग्य वस्तुको लागत, the cost of the goods to be sold; Yasmin mixes only to order, so there are none. Shade cards and the bags the tins go out in are selling and distribution, and with them the sheet reaches the cost of sales, the whole cost of every tin sold. It is Rs. 680 a tin, against Rs. 850, so each mixed tin earns Rs. 170 after every cost of its own. A tin of ready-made emulsion, bought at Rs. 630 and sold at Rs. 800, leaves the same Rs. 170 before any of the shop’s costs are counted at all. Mixing, it turns out, pays its way.
A paint factory’s books carry the same ladder, only longer, in a manufacturing account, which Cambridge’s course teaches: prime cost, factory overheads and the work half-finished at either end of the year, ending in the cost of the goods made. The ladder also shows something the financial books need. On the ladder as Nepal’s school books draw it, unsold tins come off at the cost of production, Rs. 675, office costs and all. In the year’s financial accounts the same tins would be valued at works cost, Rs. 670: IAS 2 counts the materials, the labor and the production overheads, but leaves out office costs that do nothing to make or bring the stock and all selling costs, and the Income Tax Act’s section 15 counts the same three. Each ladder is right for its own book.
A cost sheet can look forward as well as back. When a school asked the shop to quote for 300 tins of its own green, Yasmin built one from the expected costs, not the past month’s: the base at Sujan’s newest price, Rs. 580, and everything else as before, which comes to Rs. 700 a tin. With a fifth added for profit, the quotation was Rs. 840 a tin, Rs. 252,000 for the order. These two are the historical and the quotation cost sheet.
At the end of the year one more statement is needed. The cost accounts and the financial accounts measure the same year, but they don’t arrive at the same profit, and the cost reconciliation statement, लागत हिसाब मिलान विवरण, lists why. Overheads under- or over-absorbed are one reason. Some items appear only in the financial books: the interest on the shop’s bank loan, or the commission the paint company pays on its paint, belong to the business but not to any tin. Stock may be valued one way in the cost books and another in the financial ones. Each difference is added to or taken from one profit until it equals the other.
A cost sheet takes the shop’s costs, which the books record whole, and divides them again into what each thing took. Materials are traced through a store ledger and priced by a method the law allows. Labor is traced by the clock, and overheads are shared by rules fixed in advance. Built up rung by rung, they give the cost of one tin, which is what a price must cover and what an owner can try to bring down. Carnegie’s moles had a whole year’s profit but no idea which part of the work had made it.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
