Skip to content

← Accounting

Setting a Price

Chapter 23 · Looking Ahead

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. Costs that move and costs that stay
  2. The whole shop, in rupees
  3. The order below cost
  4. Mark-up and margin
  5. When the sales fall

In the rains nobody paints a house, and the mixing bench at Yasmin’s shop goes quiet. The corner opened at the start of the shop’s third year, and in an ordinary month it mixes about 200 tins; this wet month it looks like 120. Then Sangam, who is building a small hotel outside the town, asks for 100 tins of a cream the shop can mix, all at once, at Rs. 665 a tin.

The cost sheet says a mixed tin costs Rs. 680. Selling at Rs. 665 looks like losing Rs. 15 on every tin, Rs. 1,500 on the order. Yet Yasmin would be right to take it, and she would be Rs. 2,500 better off at the end of the month. The cost sheet isn’t wrong. It answers a different question, what a tin costs on average, and Sangam’s offer asks another: what would these hundred tins add? To answer it, the costs have to be sorted one more way.

Costs that move and costs that stay

Some of the corner’s costs grow with every tin. Each one takes a tin of white base at the cost sheet’s Rs. 560 and Rs. 70 of tinters, Rs. 630 of materials. It uses about Rs. 10 of stirring sticks, rags and labels, and twelve minutes of the helper’s time, which the cost sheet charges at Rs. 20. Mix ten more tins and these costs grow ten tins’ worth; mix none and they are nothing. These are variable costs, परिवर्तनशील लागत, and here they come to Rs. 660 a tin. The helper’s minutes take some judgment: she is paid the same each month, so to the shop as a whole her pay is fixed, but every twelve minutes she spends at the bench are taken from selling, and the corner counts them as its own, a tin at a time.

Other costs don’t care how many tins are mixed. The corner’s share of the rent, its light, the wear on the bench and scales, its share of the office, and the shade cards and bags that make up its selling costs: Rs. 4,000 a month, whether the bench is busy or idle. This is not the cost sheet’s Rs. 4,000 of overheads, which counted the sticks and labels and left out the office and the selling; the two only happen to match. The bags are a few rupees a tin and could as well be counted as variable; they are bought by the bundle and counted here with the shade cards. These are fixed costs, स्थिर लागत. This is the sorting by behavior, आचरण वा परिवर्तनशीलता, the last of Chapter 22’s five ways: does a cost change when the work changes?

Fixed doesn’t mean forever. The rent is fixed for the year the lease runs, and only while the bench is enough for the work; if the corner one day mixes so many tins that it needs a second bench and a second helper, its fixed costs jump to a new level and stay there. Accountants call that a stepped cost. Some costs are partly each. The delivery scooter costs something to keep even when it stands still, and more for every trip. Those are semi-variable costs, and a careful bookkeeper splits them into their fixed and variable parts. Economics, for the Curious, Chapter 10, has the theory behind all this, and the short run in which some things can’t be changed. What follows is the shop’s arithmetic.

An ordinary tin sells for Rs. 850 and costs Rs. 660 more to make than not making it would. The difference, Rs. 190, is the tin’s contribution: what it leaves over to pay the fixed costs, and once they are paid, to be profit. It is a contribution in the plain sense of the word, each tin putting its Rs. 190 into a pot that has to reach Rs. 4,000 before the month has made anything.

That pot fills a tin at a time. After 10 tins it holds Rs. 1,900; after 21, Rs. 3,990, just short; the twenty-second tin takes it past Rs. 4,000, and the month’s fixed costs are paid. Just over 21 tins is the break-even point, where the corner neither loses nor gains. Every tin before it reduces a loss. Every tin after it adds Rs. 190 of profit.

break-even=fixed costscontribution per unit=4,000190≈21 tins \text{break-even} = \frac{\text{fixed costs}}{\text{contribution per unit}} = \frac{4{,}000}{190} \approx 21 \text{ tins}

The same sum answers the questions a shopkeeper asks. At 200 tins the corner makes 200 × 190 − 4,000 = Rs. 34,000, exactly the month’s profit on the cost sheet. To make Rs. 20,000 in a month it needs (4,000 + 20,000) ÷ 190, about 127 tins. And in a normal month it sells about 179 tins more than it needs to break even. That cushion is the margin of safety, here nearly 90 percent of its sales: the corner could lose most of its customers before it lost money.

This also explains something the cost sheet does awkwardly. Its Rs. 680 was worked out from a normal month of 200 tins, with these fixed costs spread at Rs. 20 a tin. In a slow month of 120, the same Rs. 4,000 spread over fewer tins is about Rs. 33 each, and a tin’s full cost rises to about Rs. 693, though nothing about the tin has changed. Cost accounting calls this under-absorbed overhead. Seen through contribution it is simpler: the corner sold fewer tins, so less of the pot was filled. Its profit for the month is 120 × 190 − 4,000 = Rs. 18,800.

The whole shop, in rupees

The shop itself can’t count its break-even in tins. It sells hundreds of different things, brushes and putty and nails as well as paint, at different prices. So it counts in rupees of sales instead, and asks how much of each rupee is contribution.

The first year is the one whose accounts are set out in full, in Chapter 15, so its costs can be sorted. Most of the variable cost is simply the goods: the paint that went out cost what it cost. A few small lines follow the sales too. The discounts allowed and the bad debts grow with sales on credit, and on the other side the suppliers’ discounts and the paint company’s commission grow with what she buys and sells, so they reduce the variable cost. Everything else stays put whatever she sells: the rent, the helper’s monthly wages, the advertising, the depreciation. The scooter’s running costs and the petty cash, some of it porters carrying tins to customers, are partly each, and are counted as fixed here, which is a judgment, not a rule.

First year Rs.
Sales 2,811,200
Variable costs: goods sold 2,136,550, discounts allowed and bad and doubtful debts 21,850, less discounts received and commission 42,800 2,115,600
Contribution 695,600
Fixed costs: rent, wages, electricity, petty cash, advertising, scooter, depreciation, bank charges 490,600
Operating profit, before the bank’s interest 205,000
Interest on the bank loan 24,000
Net profit 181,000

The operating profit is the same Rs. 205,000 that Chapter 15 found under IFRS 18, and the net profit the same Rs. 181,000, because only the sorting is new. Of each rupee of sales, about 75 paisa went on costs that came with the sale, and about 25 paisa was contribution. Accountants call that share the contribution to sales ratio, here 24.7 percent. To cover Rs. 490,600 of fixed costs at 24.7 paisa a rupee, the shop had to sell about Rs. 1,983,000 in the year:

490,600695,600÷2,811,200≈Rs. 1,983,000 \frac{490{,}600}{695{,}600 \div 2{,}811{,}200} \approx \text{Rs. } 1{,}983{,}000

That is the operating break-even point: the sales at which the business covers all its costs of operating and has nothing left, before any interest is paid. The shop had to reach about 70 percent of what it actually sold before it earned anything, and its margin of safety was about Rs. 828,000, or 29.5 percent of its sales. Counting the bank’s interest too, it needed about Rs. 2,080,000, and the cushion was nearer a quarter.

Try it

The Books: Yasmin’s first year as a break-even chart

Move the sales and watch the gap between the two lines. Prices and the mix of goods are kept as they were. A made-up shop and made-up figures.

Rs. lakh001010202030304040Sales in the year, Rs. lakhfixedbreak-evensalescosts
Sales
Rs. 2,811,200
Costs
Rs. 2,606,200
Profit before interest
Rs. 205,000

The sales are past the break-even point. The fixed costs are paid, so about 25 paisa of every further rupee of sales is profit.

A break-even chart like this is a picture of the sums, and its straight lines carry the same assumptions. Prices stay the same however much is sold, and so do the variable costs per rupee and the mix of goods. The fixed costs stay fixed over the whole range. Real shops give discounts to big buyers, hire extra help in the festival season, and sell more of one thing and less of another. So the chart is honest only near the sales it was drawn from, and the break-even point is a good guide, not an exact line.

The order below cost

Now Sangam’s offer can be judged. A hundred tins at Rs. 665 brings in Rs. 66,500. What does the shop spend that it wouldn’t otherwise? The materials, sticks and labels, 100 × Rs. 640 at the cost sheet’s prices, are Rs. 64,000. The helper’s twenty hours at the bench come out of a slow month in which she is paid by the month anyway and has time to spare. The rent, the light and the office are the same with the order or without it. So the order adds Rs. 2,500 to the month. Even counting the helper’s minutes at the cost sheet’s Rs. 20 a tin, it adds Rs. 500.

The cost sheet’s Rs. 680 includes Rs. 20 of fixed costs, which will be paid this month whether Sangam buys or not. Leaving them in makes a profitable order look like a loss. Put simply: any price above the variable cost adds something, as long as the fixed costs really are fixed.

The words “as long as” carry a lot here. The order makes sense only because the bench has room; in the festival season every hour of mixing is wanted for tins that sell at Rs. 850, and a hundred tins at Rs. 665 would push out a hundred tins that each contribute Rs. 190. It makes sense only if it stays a one-off. A painter who hears that a hotel paid Rs. 665 will want the same, and if every tin sold at Rs. 665, the corner’s contribution of Rs. 5 a tin would pay only a quarter of its Rs. 4,000 in a normal month. And it makes sense only above Rs. 640, or Rs. 660 when the helper’s time is scarce. Below the variable cost, every tin loses money before the rent is even counted, which is the same line Economics Chapter 10 draws for a tea shop deciding whether to stay open.

The same reasoning settles other everyday choices. Should the shop mix a shade itself or buy it ready-mixed? Compare what a bought tin costs with the variable cost of mixing one, not with the full cost, if the bench and the rent would be there anyway. Should it close a line that looks like a loss? If the line’s sales cover its own variable costs and part of the fixed ones, closing it leaves the fixed costs to the rest of the shop and makes the shop worse off. A cost sheet that spreads the fixed costs over every unit is absorption costing; one that sets them against the period as a whole and counts each unit at its variable cost is marginal costing. For the mixing corner, which mixes only to order, the two give the same profit for the month; they differ only when tins are made and left in stock, carrying some of one month’s fixed costs into the next.

Mark-up and margin

None of this says what a tin should sell for. Contribution gives the floor, the lowest price worth taking for an extra order. The ordinary price has to do more: cover the fixed costs over the year, leave a profit, and still be a price painters will pay when the shop down the road is also mixing paint.

The simplest way to set it is to add a share to the cost. When a school asked for 300 tins of its own green, the shop priced them from the expected cost of Rs. 700 and added a fifth, Rs. 140, to quote Rs. 840. That added share, measured against the cost, is the mark-up. The same Rs. 140 measured against the price is the margin: 140 ÷ 840, or about 16.7 percent. One profit, two percentages, and they are easy to confuse. The ordinary mixed tin, Rs. 680 of cost sold at Rs. 850, has a mark-up of 25 percent and a margin of 20 percent.

The mix-up costs money. A shopkeeper who wants a margin of 25 percent and adds 25 percent to the cost gets only 20. To keep a quarter of the price, the price must be the cost divided by three quarters, 680 ÷ 0.75, about Rs. 907. The rule behind it is short: a mark-up of a quarter is a margin of a fifth, a mark-up of a fifth a margin of a sixth, because the margin divides the same profit by a bigger number.

On ready-made paint Yasmin has less say. Nepal’s Consumer Protection Act, 2075, requires a maker’s label to show the maximum retail price, including all taxes (section 6), and a seller to keep a price list where the public can clearly see it (sections 11 and 20). It lets the government fix maximum prices for goods it lists as essential (section 19), and forbids selling anything at more than its cost plus the profit prescribed for it (section 17), a profit the rules under the Act leave to be set goods by goods. The label’s price is called a maximum for a reason: on a tin of emulsion printed at Rs. 800, the room she has is below it, in discounts to painters who buy a lot. Her mixed tins carry no maker’s label, so their price is hers to set, within the same rule on profit.

When the sales fall

Fixed costs do one more thing, and it is the reason a business worries about them. Take the first year again and suppose the shop had sold 10 percent less, at the same prices. The contribution falls 10 percent too, by Rs. 69,560. But the rent, the wages and the rest don’t fall at all, so every rupee of that loss comes off the operating profit, which drops from Rs. 205,000 to Rs. 135,440. Ten percent less in sales has taken a third off the profit. Sell 10 percent more and the profit rises by the same third, to Rs. 274,560.

That is operating leverage: fixed costs act like a lever, and a small push on sales becomes a large swing in profit. The higher the fixed costs are against the contribution, the longer the lever. The mixing corner has a short one, with its fixed costs only Rs. 4,000 against Rs. 38,000 of contribution in a normal month: a tenth fewer tins takes about 11 percent off its profit. The shop as a whole has a longer one, and the uncertainty this creates in the operating profit, from how much is sold and how the costs are built, is called business risk.

Borrowing adds a second lever on top. The bank’s Rs. 24,000 of interest is due whatever the sales, so after the same 10 percent fall the net profit drops from Rs. 181,000 to Rs. 111,440, by 38 percent rather than 34. That extra swing, which comes from how a business is financed rather than how it trades, is financial risk. A business with high fixed costs and a large loan carries both, and each makes the other worse.

The airlines are the example every book reaches for, because the cost of a flight hardly changes with the number of people on it. The airlines’ own association reckons that roughly half of airline operating costs are fixed, and says this makes their profits swing. In 2019 the world’s airlines took in about $838 billion and made an operating profit of $43 billion. In 2020, with the pandemic, their revenue fell by more than half, to $384 billion, and the operating profit didn’t fall by half: it became a loss of $111 billion. Planes on the ground still had to be paid for.

So costs that stay are what turn a shop’s sales into a profit, or a loss, and how many of them there are decides how hard the profit swings. Sorting the costs into those that move with the work and those that don’t gives every unit a contribution, and from that comes nearly everything else: how many tins before a profit, how far sales can fall before a loss, which extra order is worth taking below the full cost, and why a business that also owes a bank feels a bad year twice. The price itself is set between two numbers: the variable cost below which no sale is worth making, and what customers will pay.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.