The Nepali word for a balance sheet, वासलात, has a second, plainer meaning. It came into Nepali from an Arabic word, वासिलात, and besides an organization’s yearly statement of its income and spending, the dictionary gives it a meaning from office work: the paper an official draws up when he hands over his post. On it he lists everything in his charge as the books show it on that day: the balance, what is still owed, the cash, the goods in store. It is drawn up to be handed to his successor.
A shop’s balance sheet is much the same paper. It is written on one day, the last of the year, and it answers two questions about that day only: what the business has, and whose it is. The profit and loss account told the story of a whole year, from the first of साउन to the last of असार. The balance sheet is a photograph of the evening when the story stops. And it is a particular kind of thing: not an account but a statement, विवरण, with no debit or credit written on it, drawn up after the profit and loss account and dated as on a single day.
The English name has an older picture inside it. Balance comes, through Old French, from the Latin bilanx, having two scale pans. A balance sheet is a pair of pans, and its two sides always weigh the same. Why they must, and why that proves less than it seems to, is most of what there is to understand about it.
Yasmin’s shop on असार 31
By the evening of असार 31 Yasmin’s books have been through a long day. The stock has been counted, the loose ends adjusted, and every income and expense account emptied into the trading and profit and loss accounts, which closed with a net profit of Rs. 181,000 carried to her capital account. Sales, rent, wages, electricity: all stand at zero, ready for the new year.
One account of that kind is still open. All year, the cash and paint Yasmin took home for her household went to a drawings account, Rs. 120,600 of it, so that her capital account showed only what she put in. Drawings aren’t an expense of the shop, so they never went near the profit. They are her capital taken back, and at the year’s end they are closed into the capital account where they belong:
| Date | Particulars | L.F. | Debit Rs. | Credit Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| असार 31 | Capital a/c Dr. | 120,600 | ||
| To Drawings a/c | 120,600 | |||
| (Being drawings for the year transferred to capital account) |
Now look at what is left in the ledger. Every page still open is one of three kinds. It is something the shop has: the scooter, the racks, the paint counted on the shelves, the customers’ debts, the bank and the till. Or it is something the shop owes to someone outside: the bank’s loan, the suppliers, the helper’s wages for असार, the school’s money for paint it hasn’t had yet. Or it is Yasmin’s capital. A balance sheet is simply those pages copied out, sorted and added up.
Her capital is the first line. She put in Rs. 300,000 on the day the shop opened. The year’s work added Rs. 181,000, and she took Rs. 120,600 home, so her share now stands at 300,000 + 181,000 − 120,600 = Rs. 360,400. Below it come the liabilities, sorted by when they must be paid. Nothing in her books has said when the bank wants its Rs. 200,000 back, so we take it that none of it is due within the coming year, which makes it a long-term liability, दीर्घकालीन दायित्व. A loan repaid in installments would put the coming year’s installment among the current liabilities instead. Everything else the shop owes falls due within the year, and these are its current liabilities, चालु दायित्व: Rs. 118,000 to Sujan and Rs. 21,000 to her other suppliers, Rs. 20,000 of wages for असार that the helper will be paid on साउन 1, and the school’s Rs. 40,000, which the shop owes in paint, not cash. Together they come to Rs. 199,000.
On the other side are the assets, sorted the same way. The fixed assets, स्थिर सम्पत्ति, the things kept to use for more than a year, are shown at what they cost less the depreciation charged so far: the scooter at 240,000 − 24,000 = Rs. 216,000 and the racks at 70,000 − 7,000 = Rs. 63,000. Then come the current assets, चालु सम्पत्ति, which will turn into cash or be used up within the year. The paint on the racks, at Rs. 302,000. What customers owe, Rs. 96,000, less the Rs. 4,800 provided for those who may not pay, so Rs. 91,200, the amount she can honestly expect. The Rs. 15,000 of rent paid for साउन, and the Rs. 9,000 of commission the paint company owes her. And last, the money itself: Rs. 56,800 in the bank and Rs. 6,400 in the till and the petty cash box.
Add up each side and both come to Rs. 759,400.
That figure is worth a moment. On the morning the shop opened, its balance sheet was three lines long: Rs. 500,000 of cash on one side, and on the other Yasmin’s Rs. 300,000 and the bank’s Rs. 200,000. A year later the cash has become paint, racks, a scooter and promises, the bank’s share is unchanged, the suppliers and the school have joined it, and Yasmin’s own share has grown by Rs. 60,400. It is the same equation that was written on the first day, assets = capital + liabilities, filled in with a year of business:
759,400 = 360,400 + 200,000 + 199,000
Sorting the lines
Putting a balance sheet’s lines in order has a name, marshalling, सम्पत्ति र दायित्वको क्रमबद्धता, and there are two ways to do it. Yasmin’s sheet is in the order of permanence, स्थायित्व: it starts with what lasts longest, the capital on one side and the fixed assets on the other, and ends with what moves fastest, current liabilities and cash. The other way, the order of liquidity, तरलता, turns it upside down, starting with cash and what is due soonest and ending with the fixed assets and the capital. Neither is more correct. They put first what the reader most wants to see first.
The groups have a reason behind them. Splitting the shop’s things into those it keeps and those that come and go shows at a glance what it works with and what it lives on: the racks and the scooter will be there next year, while the paint, the debts and the cash will have turned over many times. Splitting the debts by when they fall due shows what has to be paid soon and what can wait. A lender reads those two splits first, setting what will come in over the next few months against what must go out. That reading belongs to later chapters, which take a balance sheet apart in numbers. Here it is enough that the sorting makes the reading possible.
Assets are often divided into four groups, not two. Fixed assets are either tangible, things you can see and touch, like land, buildings, machines and furniture, or intangible, like goodwill, a trademark or a patent. Besides fixed and current assets there are investments, money placed somewhere else to earn, counted as current if it is for less than a year and among the fixed assets if longer. And there are what accountants call fictitious assets, मूल्यहीन सम्पत्ति: amounts that sit among the assets only because they were spent and not yet written off, such as the costs of starting a company or a loss carried forward, which would fetch nothing if the business closed. Companies that follow the international standards don’t show such amounts as assets at all. The costs of starting a business are counted as expenses when they are spent. Yasmin has neither investments nor anything fictitious, so her sheet has two groups on each side.
The side each thing goes on is a matter of habit, not rule. The horizontal form Nepal’s school books teach, तेर्सो ढाँचा, puts capital and liabilities on the left and assets on the right, the opposite of their sides in the ledger, where an asset’s balance is a debit, on the left. Since a balance sheet is a statement, not an account, nobody minds. There is also the vertical form, ठाडो ढाँचा, with everything down the page, capital and liabilities first and the assets beneath them. Companies that publish under the international standards turn that round, assets first. Set out that way, Yasmin’s sheet reads:
| Yasmin’s shop: statement of financial position as on असार 31 | Rs. | Rs. |
|---|---|---|
| Non-current assets | ||
| Delivery scooter, cost 240,000 less depreciation 24,000 | 216,000 | |
| Racks, cost 70,000 less depreciation 7,000 | 63,000 | 279,000 |
| Current assets | ||
| Inventory (closing stock) | 302,000 | |
| Trade receivables, 96,000 less provision 4,800 | 91,200 | |
| Prepaid rent and commission receivable | 24,000 | |
| Cash and bank | 63,200 | 480,400 |
| Total assets | 759,400 | |
| Capital | ||
| Opening capital | 300,000 | |
| Add: net profit for the year | 181,000 | |
| Less: drawings | (120,600) | 360,400 |
| Non-current liabilities | ||
| Bank loan, 12% | 200,000 | |
| Current liabilities | ||
| Trade payables | 139,000 | |
| Wages owed | 20,000 | |
| Income received in advance | 40,000 | 199,000 |
| Total capital and liabilities | 759,400 |
The names are the international ones: a statement of financial position, non-current for fixed, inventory for stock, receivables and payables for debtors and creditors. The new international standard that sets out how a company presents its accounts, IFRS 18, says plainly that a company may still call it a balance sheet. Its rule for sorting is the one Yasmin’s sheet follows. An asset is current if it is cash, or is held to be sold or used up in the business’s ordinary round of buying and selling, or will turn into cash within twelve months. A liability is current if it falls due within twelve months, or if the business has no right to put off paying it for that long. Everything else is non-current. The same standard lets a business list everything in order of liquidity instead when that is more useful, and gives banks as the example: a bank has no clear round of buying and selling, and for it the plain question is how soon each thing turns into money.
Next year the statement will grow a second column. The usual form gives this year’s figures beside last year’s, and the international standard asks the same of every company, so that a reader sees not only where the business stands but which way it is moving. A business that sells only its work, a tutor or a tailor, has the same statement with fewer lines. With no goods bought to sell there is no stock, but there are still tools, money owed by customers, bills to pay and the owner’s share, and the two sides still agree.
Why it can’t fail to balance
Here is the thing that puzzles almost everyone who first draws up a balance sheet and watches the two totals come out the same. Nobody made them agree. Yasmin didn’t adjust anything to make the left side match the right. It just did.
There are two ways to see why, and they are the same fact. The first is the ledger’s. The adjusted trial balance agreed, every debit against every credit, Rs. 3,878,050 a side. Closing the income and expense accounts into profit and loss, and that into capital, moved amounts from one page to another, and every move took the same amount off both sides, so they still agree. What is left after the closing is the balance sheet’s pages and nothing else, so their debits and credits must still agree, and a balance sheet is those debits listed on one side and those credits on the other.
The second is the equation’s. Yasmin’s share can be found two ways. One is the story in her capital account: Rs. 300,000 put in, Rs. 181,000 earned, Rs. 120,600 taken out, so Rs. 360,400. The other is a count of what is there: everything the shop has, Rs. 759,400, less everything it owes to others, Rs. 399,000, which leaves Rs. 360,400. The two answers come from different places, one from a year of sales and expenses and the other from a count of stock, debts and cash on the last evening, yet they agree to the rupee. That agreement is the double entry doing its work. Every rupee that came into the shop was written down once for what it became and once for whose it was, so the story and the count can’t drift apart.
The shop’s new year starts from this sheet. On साउन 1 the balances are carried into the new year’s books by an opening entry, प्रारम्भिक भौचर: every asset debited, every liability credited, and the capital written in as whatever makes the two sides equal. Pacioli’s merchants did the same work without a journal entry. When the old ledger was closed, he wrote, each account’s remainder went straight into the new ledger, not through the journal, and both sides of the old account were totaled “so that the eye can see at a glance that it is all even”.
What balancing doesn’t prove
The two totals agree because the capital is always the difference between the other two. That is also the catch. A balance sheet will balance whether its figures are right or wrong, because any mistake in what the shop has, or in what it owes, is carried straight into the owner’s share.
Suppose Yasmin’s helper had counted Rs. 10,000 too much paint on the evening of असार 31. The closing stock would be Rs. 10,000 higher, so would the profit, and so would her capital. Both sides would rise by Rs. 10,000, and the sheet would balance as neatly as before. A customer who will never pay, left on the books, balances too. So does a debt to a supplier that nobody wrote down, which is missing from both the liabilities and the purchases, and so from the profit. The agreement of the totals checks that the books are internally consistent. Whether each line is true has to be checked against the world: the paint on the shelves, the customers, the bank’s own statement.
One of the plainest proofs came from an Italian dairy company, Parmalat. Its balance sheet, checked by auditors and published, showed close to four billion euros of cash and securities in an account at Bank of America in New York, in the name of one of its subsidiaries. In December 2003 it came out that the account didn’t exist. The letter confirming it, which the auditors had relied on, was a forgery. The United States’ securities regulator said the company’s assets had been overstated by at least €3.95 billion. The balance sheet had balanced every year. Parmalat collapsed, and its founder was convicted in Italy of market manipulation, a conviction the country’s highest court upheld in 2011. A balance sheet that agrees tells you that the bookkeeping was done. It can’t tell you that the bank account is there.
Three plainer limits come with every honest balance sheet too. Its figures are mostly costs, not prices: the scooter’s Rs. 216,000 is the part of its cost not yet charged, not what a dealer would pay, and a building bought forty years ago sits at forty-year-old prices. It leaves out whatever money can’t measure: a helper who has learned the trade, the bus stop at the door, Yasmin’s own skill. And it is one day’s photograph. On साउन 1 the helper is paid, and by the next evening the bank balance has fallen by Rs. 20,000 and the wages owed have gone. Before दशैं the racks will be fuller and the debts to Sujan bigger. A business can even choose how its last day looks. If Yasmin held back a payment to a supplier until साउन 1, her bank balance would look healthier on the sheet, though she would owe just as much more to the supplier. Accountants call tidying the last day that way window dressing, and the people who read balance sheets for a living learn to ask what happened on the day after.
What, then, does Yasmin’s sheet tell her? That of the Rs. 759,400 her shop is using, a little over half, Rs. 399,000, is other people’s money: the bank’s, her suppliers’, even her helper’s month and the school’s paint. That her own share is Rs. 360,400, up by Rs. 60,400 on the year. And something more awkward. Her profit for the year was Rs. 181,000, yet the bank and the till together hold only Rs. 63,200, and Sujan alone is owed Rs. 118,000. The profit is real, but most of it is sitting on her racks as paint and in her customers’ pockets as debts. Where the money went, and why a shop that made a profit can still be short of cash, is the next question her books will have to answer.
What to take from all this is short. A balance sheet lists, on one day, everything a business has on one side and, on the other, whose it is: what it owes to outsiders, now and later, and what is left for the owner. It always balances, because the owner’s share is by its nature whatever is left, and because the same double entry that made the year’s profit also made every figure on the sheet. That makes balancing a check on the bookkeeping, not on the truth of each figure. It is the start of reading a business, never the end.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
