On the morning of साउन 1, a year to the day after the shop opened, the paint has been counted and the loose ends tied, and Yasmin wants one number: what did the year make? The books give her two answers, and both are right. The paint she sold fetched Rs. 674,650 more than it had cost her. Yet she is nowhere near Rs. 674,650 better off, because the shop also paid rent, wages, electricity and a bank, and none of that was the cost of a single tin. Take those off too and what is left is Rs. 181,000.
The first figure is the gross profit and the second the net profit. Gross comes through Old French from the Late Latin grossus, thick, and in English it meant large, the whole of something before anything is taken away. Net came into English from Old French, where it meant elegant, and from the Old Italian netto, remaining after deductions; both go back to the Latin nitidus, clean. Profit itself is from the Latin proficere, to make progress. The two profits are worked out in two accounts, one after the other, and each answers its own question about the shop.
Emptying the accounts
All year, Yasmin’s books have kept her income and her expenses in accounts of their own: sales, purchases, rent, wages, commission received and the rest. They are pieces of her capital, kept apart so that she can see where her share of the shop grew and where it shrank. At the year’s end they have done that job. Each is emptied into one place, the profit is worked out there, and the profit goes back into the capital account it was taken from.
That is an old routine. Pacioli’s guide of 1494 tells the merchant to keep an account called Profit and Loss, which he says goes by different names in different cities: pro e danno, favor and damage; avanzi e desavanzi, increase and deficit. In his day a merchant kept a separate account for each line of goods, so many loaves of sugar, say. When a line was finished he balanced its account, and the difference, a gain if it showed more on the credit side than on the debit, a loss if less, went into Profit and Loss. All the merchandise accounts were closed that way one by one, “so that your Ledger always shows the accounts in balance”, and then Profit and Loss itself was closed into the capital account, which Pacioli calls the last account in every ledger, “the receptacle of all other accounts”. That way, he wrote, “you will see at a glance whether you are gaining or losing, and how much.”
The modern routine has the same shape in two steps. First the accounts of buying and selling go into a trading account, व्यापार खाता, which gives the gross profit. Then the gross profit and every other income and expense go into a profit and loss account, नाफानोक्सान खाता, which gives the net profit. Together they are the first of the final accounts, अन्तिम खाता, under the Nepal Accounting Standard’s heading of the income statement, आयव्यय विवरण. The journal entries that do the emptying are the closing entries, अन्तिम भौचर, made at the end of the accounting period, before the two accounts are drawn up, so that every income and expense account is left with nothing in it and starts the new year at zero.
What the goods cost and what they fetched
The trading account takes the sales and the costs that belong to the goods themselves. These are the direct costs, प्रत्यक्ष खर्च: what the goods cost to buy, and whatever it cost to bring them in or make them, carriage and freight on purchases, customs and excise duty, wages in a workshop, fuel and power in a factory. Yasmin’s trading account is short, because she makes nothing. Even the truck that brings Sujan’s paint each week adds no line of its own: Sujan charges for it on his bills, so the carriage is already inside her purchases. The account has four things in it.
The first is the sales, less the paint brought back. After Chapter 14’s adjustment took out the school’s Rs. 40,000 for paint it will get in साउन, the sales account holds Rs. 2,820,000. Customers returned Rs. 8,800 of paint, so the year’s net sales are Rs. 2,811,200. They go on the credit side, where income has always gone.
The second is the purchases, less what she sent back to her suppliers: Rs. 2,448,000 less Rs. 9,450, or Rs. 2,438,550. They go on the debit side. Above them, in every trading account, is a line for the opening stock, the goods on the shelf when the year began. Yasmin’s first year began with bare racks, so her line is empty. Next year it will hold the Rs. 302,000 she counted this year.
The third is that count. The purchases account says what came in, not what went out. Rs. 302,000 of paint, at cost or less, is still on the racks, unsold, so its cost belongs to next year’s sales. It goes on the credit side, which takes it off the year’s cost of goods. Chapter 14’s closing stock entry, closing stock debited and trading account credited, put it there. The goods she sold cost
which in general is opening stock plus purchases less purchases returns plus direct expenses less closing stock.
The fourth is the difference. The credit side is Rs. 674,650 bigger than the debit side. That difference is the gross profit, कुल नाफा, written on the debit side as gross profit carried down, c/d, so that both sides come to the same total, exactly as a ledger page is balanced. It is what the paint fetched over what it cost, before anything else. Had the debit side been the bigger, the shop would have sold its goods for less than they cost, and the difference, a gross loss, would go on the credit side. It does happen: picture a firm whose trading account sets Rs. 203,450 of costs against Rs. 185,000 of sales.
The closing entries that empty these accounts into the trading account come in two steps here. The returns are set off first, each against the account it reduces, and then what is left is carried across. Nepal’s school books, whose example has no returns, carry each balance across as it stands; with returns, either way gives the same profit.
| Date | Particulars | L.F. | Debit Rs. | Credit Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| असार 31 | Purchases returns a/c Dr. | 9,450 | ||
| To Purchases a/c | 9,450 | |||
| (Being purchases returns set off against purchases) | ||||
| असार 31 | Sales a/c Dr. | 8,800 | ||
| To Sales returns a/c | 8,800 | |||
| (Being sales returns set off against sales) | ||||
| असार 31 | Trading a/c Dr. | 2,438,550 | ||
| To Purchases a/c | 2,438,550 | |||
| (Being net purchases transferred to trading account) | ||||
| असार 31 | Sales a/c Dr. | 2,811,200 | ||
| To Trading a/c | 2,811,200 | |||
| (Being net sales transferred to trading account) | ||||
| असार 31 | Trading a/c Dr. | 674,650 | ||
| To Profit and loss a/c | 674,650 | |||
| (Being gross profit transferred to profit and loss account) |
Each one is the ordinary rule run backwards. The purchases account has a debit balance, so it is credited by the same amount, which leaves it at zero, and the trading account is debited. The sales account has a credit balance, so it is debited. The last entry carries the gross profit across to the next account. With the closing stock already credited, the trading account is now balanced and closed, its two sides Rs. 3,113,200 each.
What it took to sell them
The profit and loss account takes over where the trading account stops. Its credit side starts with the gross profit brought down, b/d, and adds every other income the shop earned. Yasmin has two: Rs. 6,800 of discounts her suppliers gave her for paying early, and the paint company’s commission, the Rs. 27,000 it paid plus the Rs. 9,000 it owes for the last quarter, Rs. 36,000 in all. Other such income includes interest, rent and dividends received, a profit on selling a fixed asset, and bad debts recovered.
Its debit side takes the indirect expenses, अप्रत्यक्ष खर्च, the costs of running the business that belong to no particular tin. They fall into four groups: administrative expenses (salaries, rent, stationery, telephone, insurance, the audit fee), selling and distribution expenses (advertising, carriage on sales, commission to salesmen, bad debts), financial expenses (interest, bank charges), and the rest (depreciation, repairs, a loss on selling an asset). Yasmin’s year puts Rs. 536,450 on that side:
| Expense | Rs. |
|---|---|
| Rent, for the year’s twelve months | 180,000 |
| Wages, the helper’s, कात्तिक to असार | 180,000 |
| Electricity | 21,600 |
| Petty cash expenses: porters, postage, tea, cleaning | 21,000 |
| Advertising on FM radio | 18,000 |
| Scooter running costs | 36,400 |
| Discount allowed | 1,450 |
| Bad debts: Abinash | 15,600 |
| Estimated bad debts: the provision | 4,800 |
| Depreciation: scooter 24,000, racks 7,000 | 31,000 |
| Bank charges | 2,600 |
| Interest on the bank loan | 24,000 |
| Total | 536,450 |
Two of those lines could have gone the other way, and the reason they don’t is the whole difference between the two accounts. The rule is about whose pay it is. Wages for making the goods or bringing them in, a factory hand’s pay or a porter’s for unloading them, go in the trading account; the salaries of office and sales staff go in the profit and loss account. Yasmin’s helper makes nothing. She serves customers and keeps the petty cash box, so her pay is a cost of selling, like the seller’s salary, बिक्रेताको तलब, one of the selling expenses. The porters in the petty cash book carried tins out to customers’ building sites, not in from Sujan’s warehouse, so that is carriage on the goods sold, a selling expense too. The test is always the same question: was it part of what it cost to get the goods onto the shelf? If so, it belongs to the trading account. If it was spent selling them, collecting for them or keeping the shop open, it belongs here.
The credit side comes to Rs. 717,450, and the debit side to Rs. 536,450. The difference, Rs. 181,000, is the net profit, खुद नाफा, carried down on the debit side to make the two sides equal. It is the year’s whole result, and the closing entries finish the job:
| Date | Particulars | L.F. | Debit Rs. | Credit Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| असार 31 | Discount received a/c Dr. | 6,800 | ||
| Commission received a/c Dr. | 36,000 | |||
| To Profit and loss a/c | 42,800 | |||
| (Being other income transferred to profit and loss account) | ||||
| असार 31 | Profit and loss a/c Dr. | 536,450 | ||
| To Rent a/c | 180,000 | |||
| To Wages a/c | 180,000 | |||
| To the ten other expense accounts | 176,450 | |||
| (Being expenses transferred to profit and loss account) | ||||
| असार 31 | Profit and loss a/c Dr. | 181,000 | ||
| To Capital a/c | 181,000 | |||
| (Being net profit transferred to capital account) |
The last line is Pacioli’s receptacle. Profit was never a separate pile of money. It is the amount by which the owner’s share has grown, and the closing entry writes that growth into the capital account at last. Yasmin started with Rs. 300,000 of her own in the shop, and her year’s work added Rs. 181,000 to it. What she took home during the year comes off separately, and the share she ends with belongs to the next chapter. A loss works the same way in reverse: the debit side is the bigger, the net loss goes on the credit side, and the entry debits the capital account, so the owner’s share shrinks.
Not every business needs both accounts. A tailor, a barber or a tutor sells work, not goods, and has no stock bought to sell, so there is no trading account and no gross profit, only income less expenses. The Cambridge IGCSE syllabus asks its students for the income statements of both kinds, trading businesses and service businesses, and to explain the difference.
What each says about a shop
The two profits measure different things, and a shopkeeper reads them differently. Gross profit comes from the trading account, from direct income and expenses only, and tells how the buying and selling went. Net profit comes from the profit and loss account, with the indirect income and expenses added, and tells what was left after everything.
They mean most as shares of the sales. Of every Rs. 100 Yasmin took for paint, Rs. 76 paid for the paint itself, and Rs. 24 was gross profit. Out of that Rs. 24, about Rs. 7.90 kept the shop open, about Rs. 9.10 went on selling and collecting, the helper’s pay among it, and about Rs. 2.05 on the racks and scooter wearing out and on the bank. The commission and discounts brought back about Rs. 1.50. What was left, of each Rs. 100 of sales, was about Rs. 6.40. Accountants call these two shares the gross margin and the net margin, here 24.0 and 6.4 percent, and the IGCSE syllabus asks students to understand why the difference between them says something about how efficiently a business is run.
Each answers to its own kind of decision. The gross margin moves with prices and buying. If Sujan raises his prices and she can’t pass the rise on, or she cuts her own to win customers from the shop down the road, or tins go missing from the racks, the gross margin falls. It doesn’t move when the rent goes up, or when she hires a second helper. Those land between the two profits, and only the net margin shows them. A shop whose gross margin holds steady while its net margin shrinks has a problem in its running costs. One whose gross margin is falling has a problem with what it pays or what it charges, and no saving on electricity will fix that.
The gap between the two also shows how little room a shop has. Suppose Yasmin had sold exactly the same paint all year at prices five percent lower. Her sales would have been Rs. 2,670,640, her gross profit Rs. 534,090, and with the same expenses her net profit Rs. 40,440. A five percent cut in prices would have taken more than three quarters of her net profit, because her expenses don’t care what she charges. A little off for every customer adds up to most of a year. The stock count matters for the same reason: the closing stock goes straight into the gross profit, so every rupee it is overcounted is a rupee of profit that isn’t there.
The net profit says one more thing about a shop run by its owner. Yasmin paid her helper Rs. 20,000 a month, and nobody paid Yasmin. She worked every day of the year and put in Rs. 300,000 of her own money besides. Her Rs. 181,000 is her pay for all of it, the work and the money together, and it is less than twelve months of her helper’s wages would have been. A first year is often like that. Whether the shop is worth running is a question the net profit can raise, but the year’s accounts alone can’t answer it.
The same sums, set out other ways
The trading and profit and loss account is written in two columns with “To” and “By”. The same figures can also be set out as an income statement, आय विवरण, written down the page instead of in two columns, with no debit or credit sides. It is a statement, not an account, though it is drawn up from the accounts, and it comes in two forms. The single-step form adds up all the income, adds up all the expenses and takes one from the other. The multi-step form goes in stages: net sales, less the cost of goods sold, gives the gross profit; less the operating expenses, by group; then the other income and the other expenses, among them the interest on loans, down to the profit before and after tax. Yasmin’s multi-step statement would read sales of Rs. 2,811,200, less the cost of goods sold, Rs. 2,136,550, a gross profit of Rs. 674,650, and so on down to Rs. 181,000. The numbers are the same. The order is the trading account’s, then the profit and loss account’s.
Companies that follow the international standards call it the statement of profit or loss. For years beginning on or after 1 January 2027 its shape is set by IFRS 18, which replaces the older IAS 1. IFRS 18 lets a company show its operating expenses by their nature, what was used up (materials, staff, depreciation), or by their function, what they were used for (the cost of sales, selling, administration), or a mix where that is clearer, and it points out that for a retailer the cost of sales may be what drives the profit. It puts every income and expense in a category: operating, investing, financing, income taxes, discontinued operations. A company following it must show a subtotal called operating profit, then profit before financing and income taxes, then profit for the year. Interest on a loan taken only to raise money, like Yasmin’s bank loan, falls in the financing category, below the operating profit. Set out that way, her shop would show an operating profit of Rs. 205,000, and Rs. 181,000 after the bank’s interest. However they are arranged, the closing figure is the same, because the same entries made it.
Every income and expense account starts the new year at zero. The shop’s sales for its second year will begin from nothing on साउन 1, and so will its rent. Only the accounts of what the shop has and owes, and Yasmin’s capital with the year’s profit in it, carry on. That is the point of the two accounts. The trading account says whether the goods were bought and sold well: Rs. 674,650 over their cost, 24 rupees in every hundred. The profit and loss account says what the whole year added to the owner’s share once the shop had been paid for: Rs. 181,000, about 6 rupees in every hundred. A shopkeeper needs both, because a business can sell well and still be eaten by its costs, and a shop with low costs can still be selling too cheaply.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
