Skip to content

← Accounting

Cash Is Not Profit

Chapter 17 · What the Year Came To

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. Where the money went
  2. Counting it straight
  3. Money to keep the shop going
  4. How long a rupee is away

Yasmin’s books say that her first year earned Rs. 181,000. Her bank statement and her till say that she has Rs. 63,200. Sujan, the wholesaler, is owed Rs. 118,000 of that year’s paint, her other suppliers Rs. 21,000, and on साउन 1 the helper is to be paid Rs. 20,000 for असार. If they all asked on the same morning, the shop couldn’t pay them.

Nothing in the books is wrong. Profit and cash are two different counts, and they part ways whenever money moves at a different time from the thing it pays for. Paint bought in असार and still on the racks has been paid for, but it isn’t a cost until it is sold. A builder who took paint on credit has made the shop a profit, but he hasn’t paid yet. A scooter is paid for within months and charged against profit a little at a time over five years. Every one of these leaves profit higher than cash, and in a shop’s first year, when the racks are filled from nothing, they add up to a lot. A business can be profitable and still run out of money, and it has happened to some very large ones.

So a business needs a third statement. The profit and loss account tells the story of what the year earned; the balance sheet is a photograph of the last evening. Neither says where the money went. The statement that follows the money itself is the statement of cash flows, नगद प्रवाह विवरण.

Where the money went

The statement of cash flows lists, for a period, every rupee that came into the business’s cash and bank and every rupee that left, sorted into three groups, and ends with the cash and bank balance on the last day. Operating activities, सञ्चालनसम्बन्धी क्रियाकलाप, are the business’s daily trade: selling, buying stock, paying rent and wages. Investing activities, लगानीसम्बन्धी क्रियाकलाप, are buying and selling the things kept for years, a scooter, racks, a building. Financing activities, वित्तीय क्रियाकलाप, are the money from the people who fund the business and what goes back to them: the owner’s capital and drawings, loans taken and repaid, and the interest paid on them.

The sorting is the point. A business whose cash rose because it borrowed is in a different state from one whose cash rose because its customers paid. The first can’t do that forever; the second can.

For a shop in its first year the story begins before the shop does, with nothing. The Rs. 500,000 that sat as cash on the morning it opened, Rs. 300,000 of Yasmin’s own and Rs. 200,000 from the bank, is itself part of the year’s cash story, under financing. What happened to the rest of it is the statement.

Try it

The Books: where Yasmin’s cash went

Each tap turns the next group of the year’s figures from profit into cash. A made-up shop and made-up figures, the end of Yasmin’s first year.

Profit for the year
Rs. 181,000
Cash worked out so far
–

Before the statement. The year earned Rs. 181,000; the bank and the till hold Rs. 63,200. Tap Next step to follow the profit to the cash.

The statement starts from the profit, Rs. 181,000, and corrects it, line by line, for everything that made profit and cash differ. This is the indirect method, अप्रत्यक्ष विधि. It can be drawn up from the trial balance, or from two balance sheets a year apart and the profit between them.

Two corrections come first. Depreciation, Rs. 31,000 for the scooter and the racks, was a cost in the profit and loss account, but no money left the shop when it was charged; the money left when they were bought. The same is true of the Rs. 4,800 provided for customers who may not pay. Both go back in. So does the Rs. 24,000 of interest on the bank loan, for a different reason: it will be shown among the financing lines, beside the loan it was paid on.

Then comes what the year tied up. The paint counted on the racks on असार 31 is in the books at Rs. 302,000. It was bought during the year, but none of it has been sold, so none of it was a cost in the profit. The money went out for it all the same (what is still owed for some of it comes back in below), and it comes off. So do the Rs. 96,000 that customers still owe: sales counted in the profit, money not yet in the till. And so do the Rs. 15,000 of rent paid ahead for साउन and the Rs. 9,000 of commission the paint company hasn’t sent.

The year also tied up other people’s money, and that goes the other way. Paint worth Rs. 139,000 came into the shop and was counted as bought without being paid for: the shop has, in effect, been lent it by Sujan and the others. The helper’s Rs. 20,000 for असार was a cost of the year but is paid only on साउन 1. And the school paid Rs. 40,000 for paint it hasn’t had. All three add to the cash.

After all that, the year’s trade brought in Rs. 17,800. That is cash from operating activities, and it is small: a shop that earned Rs. 181,000 of profit turned less than a tenth of it into money in hand, because the rest went onto the racks and into the customers’ hands. In a first year, when there was no stock at the start, that isn’t alarming. The shelves had to be filled once. If the same thing happened year after year, it would be.

Investing used Rs. 310,000. The racks took Rs. 70,000 in cash. The scooter was paid for in two parts: Rs. 100,000 by cheque on the day it came, and Rs. 140,000 to Kushal, the dealer, three months later. On the day it came, the part Kushal waited for moved no money, and the standard leaves a purchase on credit out of the statement until it is paid; only the payment appears, when it is made. Both payments fell inside the year. The profit felt only the year’s wear, Rs. 31,000 of it, but the cash paid the whole price.

Financing brought in Rs. 500,000 from Yasmin and the bank. Out went her drawings, Rs. 120,600, the cash she took home and a Rs. 600 tin of paint from the racks, whose money had gone to Sujan with the rest, and Rs. 24,000 of interest: Rs. 355,400 in all. Add the three groups: 17,800 − 310,000 + 355,400 = Rs. 63,200. That is exactly the Rs. 56,800 in the bank and the Rs. 6,400 in the till and the petty cash box on the balance sheet. The statement has to end on the counted cash; if it doesn’t, something has been missed.

Counting it straight

There is a second way to the same Rs. 17,800, which is to list the cash itself: what came in from whom, and what went out to whom. This is the direct method, प्रत्यक्ष विधि, and the international standard encourages it, because it gives information the indirect method doesn’t.

From customers, the year brought in Rs. 2,738,150. That is everything they were charged, the year’s sales and the school’s Rs. 40,000 paid ahead, less the goods sent back, the discounts given, the Rs. 96,000 still owed, and the Rs. 15,600 that Abinash will never pay. The paint company sent Rs. 27,000 of commission. Out went Rs. 2,292,750 to Sujan and the other suppliers for the shop’s paint, Rs. 195,000 of rent, Rs. 160,000 of wages, and Rs. 99,600 for electricity, the petty cash, advertising, the scooter’s fuel and repairs, and the bank’s charges. In less out: Rs. 17,800. Two routes, one answer, and a bookkeeper who gets two different answers knows she has made a mistake.

Where a payment goes is sometimes a choice, and the rules are changing. For years a company could put the interest it paid under operating activities or under financing, as long as it did the same every year. From 2027, under the international standard’s new rules, a business like Yasmin’s puts it under financing, which is where her statement has it. Had she put it under operating, her trade would show Rs. 6,200 going out instead of Rs. 17,800 coming in, and her financing Rs. 24,000 more. Neither figure is the truer. What matters is knowing which was used before comparing two businesses.

The statement wasn’t always about cash. A looser measure was once common, the working capital provided by operations: roughly, profit with depreciation added back. The financial press often called that figure “cash flow”. One of America’s biggest chains of shops, with 1,069 stores, showed why the loose measure wasn’t enough. In five years it opened 376 new stores, began selling more expensive goods such as refrigerators and air conditioners, and sold more of them on credit. It borrowed more and more to buy stock while it waited for its customers to pay. Its profit plus depreciation held fairly steady, and two years before the end its shares still sold for nearly twenty times its earnings. But when two researchers later went back through its statements, they found that for years its daily trade had used more cash than it brought in. When a recession came, unpaid debts and unsold goods piled up, and in October 1975 it became the second-biggest company in American history, up to then, to go bankrupt. A careful look at its cash, they wrote, would have shown the trouble as much as ten years before the collapse.

The international standard for the statement of cash flows, which replaced an older statement of changes in financial position, has applied for more than thirty years, and Nepal’s own standards follow it. The idea under it is the one Yasmin’s year shows: watch the cash from trade. Profit tells a business whether its trade is worth doing. Cash from operating activities tells it whether the trade is paying its own way.

Money to keep the shop going

Yasmin can’t sell paint she doesn’t have, and she can’t offer builders credit without waiting for them to pay. So her shop needs, all the time, a sum of money tied up in the trade itself: in paint, in customers’ debts, in a little cash in hand for the day’s bills. That sum is the shop’s working capital, कार्यशील पुँजी, the capital a business needs for its daily operations, for buying goods, paying salaries, rent and electricity, as against fixed capital, स्थिर पुँजी, put into things that last more than a year.

It is measured two ways. Gross working capital is all the current assets, everything that is cash or will turn into cash within the year: the paint, the customers’ debts, the rent paid ahead, the commission due, the bank and the till. On Yasmin’s balance sheet that is Rs. 480,400. Net working capital is what is left of them once the current liabilities, the bills that fall due within the year, are paid: 480,400 − 199,000 = Rs. 281,400. That figure depends on the bank loan not being due within the year; if it were, the Rs. 200,000 would join the current liabilities and the net working capital would drop to Rs. 81,400.

By the net figure the shop is comfortable. By the cash, it is tight. Both are true, because net working capital adds up things that turn into cash at different speeds. The Rs. 159,000 owed to suppliers and the helper falls due within weeks. The paint will take weeks or months to sell, and the debts will come in as customers pay. What decides whether the shop can pay its bills is not only how much it has, but when each part becomes money. Working capital matters for exactly that reason: a business that can pay its suppliers and its staff on time keeps their trust, its discounts and its stock, and one that can’t starts losing all three.

Some of it never goes away. However quiet the month, the racks must carry every common color in every size, and that much stock is the shop’s permanent working capital. On top of it comes a temporary part that swells and shrinks: before दशैं and तिहार, when houses are painted, the racks fill up and the debts to Sujan grow, and after the festivals both shrink again.

How much a business needs depends on the kind of business it is. A tea stall buys its milk and sugar each morning, turns them into tea within hours and is paid on the spot; its stock is a day’s worth, its customers owe it nothing, and it needs very little working capital. A paint shop is nearly the opposite. It must hold dozens of colors and sizes, some of which sell a tin a month; builders, its best customers, expect to pay later; and a big job empties a shelf that then has to be refilled at once. Besides the kind of trade, the amount depends on how long goods take to sell, how much credit customers are given and suppliers give, the seasons, and how fast the business is growing. That last one catches people out. A shop that doubles its sales needs about twice as much paint on its racks and twice as much owed by its customers, and it has to find the money for both before the extra sales have paid for themselves. Growing businesses, even very profitable ones, need more working capital, and the chain of shops that went bankrupt had been growing fast.

How long a rupee is away

There is a neat way to see all of this at once. Follow one rupee of Yasmin’s and count the days it spends away from her till.

It leaves when she buys a tin of paint. It sits on the rack until the tin is sold. If the buyer pays later, it waits in his hands until he pays. Then it is back. Against that, if Sujan let her pay later, the rupee didn’t leave her till on the day the tin arrived but some days after. So the time her money is away is the days on the shelf, plus the days waiting for the customer, less the days Sujan waits for her. Accountants call this the cash conversion cycle, or the working capital cycle. Each part comes from the year’s figures.

The paint on the racks is Rs. 302,000 at cost, and the cost of all the paint she sold in the year was Rs. 2,136,550, about Rs. 5,850 a day. So the racks hold 302,000 ÷ 2,136,550 × 365 = about 51.6 days of sales. Her books also split the year’s trade into cash and credit, figures not needed until now: Rs. 1,460,000 of her sales were on credit, and Rs. 2,190,000 of her purchases. Customers owe Rs. 96,000, so 96,000 ÷ 1,460,000 × 365 = about 24.0 days of credit sales are waiting to come in. She owes her suppliers Rs. 139,000, or 139,000 ÷ 2,190,000 × 365 = about 23.2 days of credit purchases. Her rupee is away 51.6 + 24.0 − 23.2 = about 52 days. A tin sold for cash skips the middle part.

These use the figures of the year’s last day. Cambridge’s A Level formula takes the stock as the average of the year’s start and end. Yasmin started with none, so the average would halve it and make her paint seem to sit for 26 days, when what is on her racks today is nearer two months of sales. For a first year, the figures on the last day tell the truer story.

Fifty-two days of a shop’s costs is a lot of money to have out of the till, and there are three places to look for less, one in each kind of current asset.

The first is stock. Paint that sells a tin a month ties up money for a month. Ordering it more often and in smaller lots, which a wholesaler close by makes possible, shortens its time on the rack. Each day’s worth of stock she can do without frees about Rs. 5,850, so ten days fewer on the racks would put nearly Rs. 60,000 back in the till. The limit is the customer who walks out because the color he wanted isn’t there.

The second is what customers owe. Credit wins sales, but every day a builder takes to pay is a day her rupee waits. Clear terms when the paint goes out, a reminder when the time is up, and a little off for paying early, the same bargain Sujan offers her, all shorten the wait. Abinash’s Rs. 15,600 is the reminder of what happens at the far end: some debts don’t come back at all.

The third is the cash itself. A till and a bank account need enough for the bills of the coming days and a little for surprises. More than that sits idle; it could be paying down what she owes, or, in a bigger business, waiting in marketable securities, short deposits and bills that earn something and can be turned back into cash quickly. Too little, and a late payment from one customer means a bill she can’t pay.

Paying her suppliers later shortens the cycle too, but it comes at a price. Sujan gives 5% off for payment within fifteen days, and every bill she pays late gives that up. A wholesaler who is made to wait also starts to wonder whether he will be paid, and a shop whose suppliers stop sending paint has no trade at all. The chain that failed found that too: in its last months, some suppliers were slow to send it goods.

None of this means the profit was false. Yasmin’s Rs. 181,000 is real: the paint on her racks and the debts in her customers’ hands are hers. But they are not yet money, and a supplier can be paid only in money.

What to take from this is short. Profit measures what a year earned; cash measures what came in and went out, and the two part whenever money moves at a different time from what it pays for, above all when stock is bought, sales are made on credit, and things are bought to last. The statement of cash flows follows the money in three groups, daily trade, investing and financing, and must end on the cash counted in the bank and the till. The money tied up in trade, the working capital, is what keeps a business going, and the number of days a rupee is away, on the shelf and in customers’ hands, less the days suppliers wait, says how much of it the business needs.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.