Skip to content

← Accounting

Budgets

Chapter 24 · Looking Ahead

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. A plan in numbers
  2. The festival season’s cash
  3. Against what happened
  4. Budgets and people

Before Dashain and Tihar, when people paint their houses, Yasmin’s racks fill with paint and Sujan’s bills arrive. The customers come later, and many of them, the builders especially, pay later still. In the first year the shop’s debts to Sujan swelled and shrank with the festivals, and the bank account coped. By the third year there is a mixing corner, a partner, a helper owed her festival allowance and bigger orders, and the question of whether the money will last through the month of Dashain is worth asking before that month begins. A budget asks it.

A budget, बजेट, is a plan written in numbers: what a business expects to sell, spend, receive and pay over a coming period, month by month. It isn’t a forecast in the weather’s sense, a guess at what will happen to you. It is partly a decision, what the owners mean to do, and partly an estimate of what that will take. Then, as the months pass, the plan is laid beside what actually happened, and the differences are read for what they say. That comparison, month after month, is budgetary control, and it is most of what a budget is for.

A plan in numbers

A budget does several jobs at once. It makes the owners think ahead, which is harder than it sounds in a busy shop. It fits the parts of a business together: there is no point planning to sell 280 mixed tins in a month if nobody has planned to buy the base for them. It tells everyone what is expected. It gives something to compare the results with, so that a month that went wrong can be noticed while it can still be put right. And a target can spur people on, or push them in directions nobody wanted.

In a larger business these plans fit together into a set. It starts with whatever limits the business most, which accountants call the limiting factor. For most businesses that is what customers will buy, so the sales budget comes first: how much of each thing will sell, in which month, at what price. From the sales follow the rest. A purchases budget says what must be bought, and when, so that the goods are on the racks in time; a business that makes things has a production budget too, for how much to make each month. A labor budget says how many hours of work the sales need. Budgets for trade receivables and trade payables say how much customers will owe at each month’s end and how much will be owed to suppliers. The cash budget gathers all the money that will come in and go out. At the end come a budgeted profit and loss account and a budgeted balance sheet, the year’s statements drawn in advance. Together they make up the master budget.

The limiting factor isn’t always sales. A factory may be able to sell more than its machines can make; a shop in the festival weeks may be held back by what the wholesaler can deliver, or by the hands at the counter. Then the budget is built outward from that limit instead. For Yasmin’s shop in its festival months, the thing that ran short was money.

A shop as small as Yasmin’s needs no thick binder. A spreadsheet does it well: put in the sales, the share sold on credit and the costs, and every line that depends on them follows, so the owners can try a slow month or a late customer in seconds. The same convenience is the spreadsheet’s danger. One wrong formula is copied down every row and across every month, and a neat printout looks just as trustworthy when it is wrong.

Budgeting has its costs too. It takes time, in a big company months of managers’ time each year. A plan fixed a year ahead can stop people doing the sensible thing when the year turns out differently. And a budget judged month by month can tempt people to favor this month’s figures over the business’s longer good, as the last part of this chapter shows.

The festival season’s cash

Late in भदौ of the shop’s third year, Yasmin and Gaurav sat down with the coming three months. Dashain moves between असोज and कात्तिक from year to year; that year it fell in असोज, with Tihar after it in कात्तिक. The mixing corner, opened in साउन, is part of the shop now.

They started with the sales: Rs. 400,000 in भदौ, which was nearly over, and for the three months ahead Rs. 650,000, Rs. 700,000 and, after the festivals, Rs. 380,000. About half of each month’s sales are for cash. The other half go on credit, mostly to builders and painters, and come in the month after. So the money from customers in any month is half of that month’s sales and half of the month before’s.

Then the goods. In the first year, each rupee of sales took about 76 paisa of goods, and the plan keeps that share. Paint arrives about a month before it sells, and Sujan is paid about a month after he delivers, so in each month the shop pays for roughly the goods that month will sell. Then the running costs, the same every month: the helper’s Rs. 20,000, the rent, the electricity, the scooter and the bank’s Rs. 2,000 of interest on its loan, Rs. 43,600 in all. And what the two partners take out for themselves.

Two payments come only once. The festival allowance is the law, not a kindness: section 37 of Nepal’s Labour Act, 2074, gives every worker each year a month’s basic pay as चाडपर्व खर्च, the festival allowance, paid at बडादशैं unless the worker asks for it at another main festival. The helper’s pay is all basic, so in असोज she is owed Rs. 20,000 more. And the shop has booked the same Rs. 18,000 of radio advertisements before Tihar that it bought in its first year. The partners also mean to take out more at Dashain, Rs. 40,000 instead of their usual Rs. 15,000.

The shop starts असोज with Rs. 60,000 in cash and the bank, and the partners have agreed never to let it fall below Rs. 40,000, enough for a week’s small bills and a surprise.

Cash and bank, Rs. असोज कात्तिक मङ्सिर
At the start 60,000 −30,600 53,800
Cash sales 325,000 350,000 190,000
Last month’s credit sales 200,000 325,000 350,000
Money in 525,000 675,000 540,000
Goods 494,000 532,000 288,800
Running costs 43,600 43,600 43,600
Festival pay 20,000
Radio ads 18,000
Partners’ drawings 40,000 15,000 15,000
Money out 615,600 590,600 347,400
At the end −30,600 53,800 246,400

The table says something the profit and loss account never would. Over the three months the shop does well: it begins with Rs. 60,000 and ends with nearly Rs. 250,000. But in असोज, the month of Dashain, it runs out. The goods for the festival have to be paid for, the allowance and the advertising fall due and the partners take their festival money, while half of the month’s takings won’t come in until कात्तिक. On paper the shop is Rs. 30,600 overdrawn by the end of असोज, Rs. 70,600 short of the floor the partners set.

Knowing that in भदौ changes everything. They could take out less at Dashain, ask Sujan to wait a few weeks longer for part of his bill, push the advertising into कात्तिक, or chase the builders who owe them. What they did was ask the bank, before the month began, for an overdraft of Rs. 75,000 for असोज, to be paid back in कात्तिक. A bank is far happier to lend to a shopkeeper who comes with a plan showing when the money will return than to one who comes in a panic in the middle of the festival. At 12 percent a year, as on the loan, a month’s interest on it is Rs. 750, and with the overdraft the plan ends असोज at Rs. 44,400 and कात्तिक, after repaying it, at Rs. 53,050.

Against what happened

The rain went on longer than usual that year, and the painting started late. By the end of असोज the shop had sold Rs. 610,000, not Rs. 650,000. Cash sales were Rs. 305,000, half of that. And of the Rs. 200,000 owed from भदौ, one builder still hadn’t paid his Rs. 10,000, so Rs. 190,000 came in. On the other side, the goods bill was exactly as planned, Rs. 494,000, because the paint had been ordered in भदौ for the sales the budget expected, and it arrived and was billed whether or not it sold. The electricity came to Rs. 2,400 instead of Rs. 2,100, since the corner’s lamps were on late into the festival evenings.

असोज, Rs. Budget Actual Worse by
Money in 525,000 495,000 30,000
Money out 615,600 615,900 300
At the end, before the overdraft −30,600 −60,900 30,300

Each difference is a variance. One that leaves the business better off than planned is favorable, and one that leaves it worse off is adverse. Here nearly all of it is in the money in, and the reasons are plain: Rs. 20,000 of cash sales that didn’t happen, and a Rs. 10,000 debt that should have been paid. With the overdraft the shop ended the month at Rs. 14,100, well under the floor. And on the racks sat about Rs. 30,400 more paint than planned, bought for sales that hadn’t come. That is where much of the missing cash went: a slow month leaves a shop’s money sitting on its racks. The variances don’t say what to do. They say where to look: the late builder needs a visit, and the order for कात्तिक should be smaller unless the rain was only a delay.

Comparing profit is trickier, and the mixing corner shows why. Its budget for कात्तिक was built on 280 tins, nine or ten on most days, near the most the bench can mix. Base now cost Rs. 580 a tin, Sujan’s newest price, so with the tinters, the sticks and labels and the helper’s twelve minutes, each tin’s variable cost was planned at Rs. 680 and its contribution at Rs. 170. The corner’s fixed costs were Rs. 4,000, as before. That budget promised a profit of Rs. 43,600.

The month came out at 240 tins. Some painters who bought a lot were given a little off, so the tins sold for Rs. 840 on average. Sujan raised his price again, and the base used cost Rs. 590 a tin. The lamps took the corner’s fixed costs to Rs. 4,300. The profit was Rs. 31,700, Rs. 11,900 below the plan.

Set the month beside the original budget, and the picture is muddled. Sales are Rs. 36,400 below it, which is bad. The variable costs are Rs. 24,800 below it, which looks good, as if the helper had been unusually careful with the base. But of course the costs were lower: forty fewer tins were mixed. A budget for one level of activity, kept unchanged whatever happens, is a fixed budget, and comparing a quiet month with it praises everyone for spending less when there was simply less to do.

The fairer comparison is a flexible budget: the same plan, worked out again for the number of tins actually mixed. The prices and costs a tin stay as planned and only the quantity changes, which is exactly what sorting the costs into fixed and variable allows.

Mixing corner, कात्तिक, Rs. Fixed budget, 280 tins Flexible budget, 240 tins Actual, 240 tins
Sales 238,000 204,000 201,600
Variable costs 190,400 163,200 165,600
Fixed costs 4,000 4,000 4,300
Profit 43,600 36,800 31,700

Now each part of the Rs. 11,900 has a name. Selling 40 tins fewer than planned, at Rs. 170 of contribution each, cost Rs. 6,800: the difference between the fixed budget and the flexible one, the sales volume variance. Everything else is the actual month against the flexible budget, the same 240 tins. The lower price cost Rs. 2,400, Rs. 10 on each tin sold. The dearer base cost another Rs. 2,400, Rs. 10 on each tin mixed. And the lamps cost Rs. 300. A statement that walks from one profit to the other in those steps is a reconciliation of the budgeted profit with the actual:

Rs.
Profit in the budget 43,600
Less: 40 fewer tins sold 6,800 adverse
Less: a lower selling price 2,400 adverse
Less: dearer white base 2,400 adverse
Less: higher fixed costs 300 adverse
Actual profit 31,700

Each line points to a different person and a different cause. The rain, which nobody controlled, is most of the volume. The discount was Yasmin’s choice at the counter. The base price was Sujan’s, and may mean it is time to ask another wholesaler. A business with many products and departments does the same with each, and a larger one splits the variances further, into how much material was used against how much it cost, or how many hours were worked against the rate paid for them, which is what standard costing does.

Some things the table can’t say. The discounts may have kept two painters who would otherwise have gone to the shop down the road, and they may bring a year’s work. The extra lamps may have kept the bench open when customers wanted it. A variance is a number. Whether it was a mistake is a judgment, and the reasons that don’t fit in the table, a customer kept, a supplier who can no longer be trusted, a helper worn out by the festival weeks, belong in it too.

Budgets and people

For a long time accountants treated budgets as arithmetic. Then a foundation for company controllers, the Controllership Foundation, asked the researcher Argyris to look at what budgets did to the people inside the companies that used them, and his report, in 1952, described something that was not arithmetic at all. People felt pressed between the budget and the rest of their job, between hitting the number and doing the work as the company’s own rules said it should be done. Pressure of that kind, he found, bred stress, quarrels and distrust, and those in turn bred the very behavior a business least wants: playing games with the figures, doing less, saying less. His remedy was participation, letting people help set their own budgets, and he drew a sharp line between real participation and the pretend kind, where people are asked their opinion and the figure is then handed down anyway.

That study started a whole field of research, and its findings are mixed, which is itself worth knowing. Hofstede found that targets motivate most when they are moderately hard, neither very easy nor very hard. Anthony Hopwood, a few years later, compared three ways that bosses used budgets to judge their staff. Where the boss judged people rigidly by whether they met the budget, whatever the reasons, the managers were more stressed, got on worse with their bosses and colleagues, and more often manipulated the accounting figures. Where the boss treated the budget as one sign among others of how the business was doing over the longer run, these things happened less. Another researcher later repeated the study elsewhere and found nearly the opposite: in his study a strict use of budgets brought no extra stress and went with better results, not worse. Researchers since have mostly concluded that the effect of a budget depends on the setting, the kind of work, how uncertain it is, and the people. Participation often helps, but not always, and not everywhere.

One game comes up again and again, in the studies of people and in the economists’ models alike. When people help set the budgets they will be judged by, they have reason to set them low: to forecast fewer sales than they expect, or more costs, so that the target is easy to beat. Accountants call this padding budgetary slack. A business can rarely squeeze it all out, and the economists’ models say it shouldn’t try: getting rid of every last bit would cost more than the slack itself. But it spoils the budget’s first job, which is to say honestly what the coming months hold.

One of the sharpest critics was Michael Jensen, an economist at Harvard Business School. In a paper he argued that the trouble lies in paying people bonuses for meeting budgets. Promise a bonus for hitting a target, and two things follow: people try to set targets they can be sure of reaching, and once a target is set, they will reach it even if the business suffers for it. Among his examples, managers at one heavy-equipment maker were so set on their quarterly targets that they shipped unfinished products from their plant in England to the Netherlands and finished them in a warehouse near the customer, so that the sale could be counted in the right quarter. They made the target. The company was worse off. Jensen’s cure was not to stop budgeting but to stop tying pay to whether a budget is met, and he said himself that the evidence on how much such gaming costs is not extensive. Some businesses have gone further. One Swedish bank says it has run without budgets since the early 1970s.

A government has budgets of a different kind. There the budget isn’t a plan the managers may depart from for good reason: an office may not spend beyond what its approved budget allows, and the government keeps a budget account of its own, बजेट हिसाब खाता, among its accounts. How the government’s books keep to it belongs later in this book; how the budget is made, and what it is for, is in Economics, for the Curious, Chapter 19. And one person’s budget, for a month’s pocket money or a first salary, is in Money, for the Curious, Chapter 6.

So a budget is a plan in numbers, made from the limit a business faces outward: the sales, the goods to buy, the cash. For Yasmin’s shop, the cash budget found the month the festival would empty the till, early enough for a bank to help. Laid beside what happened, the budget shows where the month went differently, and a flexible budget, worked out again for what was really sold, separates the rain from the discount and the price of base. The numbers say where to look. They don’t say who is to blame, and a budget used as a whip teaches people to bargain for easy targets and bend the figures. A business learns most from a budget that people helped to make, are judged by fairly, and can tell the truth in.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.