Skip to content

← Accounting

Loose Ends at Year's End

Chapter 14 · What the Year Came To

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. The shelf on the last evening
  2. Costs and income that cross the line
  3. Customers who won’t pay
  4. Before and after

In November 1963 a company in the United States called Allied Crude Vegetable Oil collapsed, and its lenders went to look at what they had lent against. Allied dealt in soybean oil, and banks and brokers had lent it millions of dollars on the strength of the oil in its tanks in New Jersey, each lot certified by receipts from a warehouse company that was meant to keep watch over it. The oil wasn’t there. Allied’s men had pumped oil from one tank to another so that the same oil was counted twice. Some tanks were full of water with a thin layer of oil on top. In the end Allied simply forged receipts of its own. The lenders held receipts for about 1.8 billion pounds of oil, some 800,000 tonnes, and found barely 100 million pounds, about 45,000 tonnes: a shortfall worth about $130 million. A big stockbroker that had lent against the receipts went under, and Allied’s owner pleaded guilty to fraud and went to prison.

It is an extreme case, but it rests on a plain fact about every set of books. They know what was bought and what was sold. They don’t know what is still on the shelf. That has to be counted, and the count changes the profit.

That count is one of a handful of loose ends that every business ties up on the last day of its year. Yasmin’s shop has a few: paint on the racks, rent paid ahead, wages she hasn’t paid yet, money a school paid early, and a customer who will never pay. The books record when money moved. A year’s profit must carry that year’s own costs and income, and no other year’s. So before the year’s accounts are drawn up, each loose end gets one more journal entry, an adjustment, समायोजन, that moves an amount into the year it belongs to. Every adjustment has two sides, like any entry, so the books still balance afterwards. Only the profit moves.

The shelf on the last evening

Since her first week, everything Yasmin bought to sell has gone to the purchases account, and everything she sold to sales, at the selling price. Neither account says what the goods sold had cost, or what is left. Her journal promised to work that out at the year’s end, and this is where it does.

Her first week shows how. She bought Rs. 230,000 of goods and sold some of them. If at the end of that week she had counted the shelf and found Rs. 178,000 of goods there at cost, then the goods that had gone must have cost 230,000 − 178,000 = Rs. 52,000. That is exactly the cost of goods sold worked out one sale at a time for that week, and her profit comes out the same. The count does the work that writing down each sale’s cost would have done, all at once.

Over a whole year the sum has a few more terms. The goods that were sold cost:

opening stock + purchases − purchases returns − closing stock

Yasmin’s first year started with an empty shop, so her opening stock is nothing. Next year it won’t be. The stock counted on this year’s last evening is next year’s opening stock, which is how each year’s count carries into the next one’s sums.

So on the evening of असार 31 the shop is shut and Yasmin and her helper go along the racks with a notebook, counting every tin, brush and roller and writing each down at what it cost. It comes to Rs. 307,400.

That isn’t quite the figure that goes into the books, though. Thirty tins of one shade of emulsion, a pale green, have sat there since कात्तिक. Three of them are the tins Pasang sent back. They cost Rs. 630 each, and nobody wants them at Rs. 800. A painter offers Rs. 480 each if she delivers them, and delivery costs her about Rs. 30 a tin. So what they will fetch her is Rs. 450 a tin, less than they cost.

The rule is that stock goes in at its cost or at what it will fetch, whichever is lower. Nepal’s school books say the lower of cost and market price. The international standard, IAS 2, says the lower of cost and net realizable value, which it defines as the expected selling price less the costs still needed to make the sale. That is why the delivery comes off. And it means each item, or group of like items, is valued on its own: the green tins can’t be held up at cost because the enamel on the next rack would sell at a handsome profit. That profit isn’t earned until the enamel is sold. The loss on the green tins is already plain. It is prudence again, anticipating losses and never gains.

The green tins come down from 30 × 630 = Rs. 18,900 to 30 × 450 = Rs. 13,500, so Rs. 5,400 comes off. The stock goes into the books at 307,400 − 5,400 = Rs. 302,000. If the price of the green tins rises next year while they are still on the shelf, the write-down is reversed, but never above their cost.

Date Particulars L.F. Debit Rs. Credit Rs.
असार 31 Closing stock a/c Dr. 302,000
To Trading a/c 302,000
(Being goods on hand counted at cost, the green emulsion at what it will fetch)

Closing stock, अन्तिम मौज्दात, is something the shop has, an asset, so it is debited. The credit goes to the trading account, the account in which the year’s gross profit is worked out, where it comes off the cost of the goods. That account is the next chapter’s.

The count matters more than its one line suggests. Every rupee of stock counted is a rupee off the cost of goods sold, and so a rupee more profit. If the count were Rs. 10,000 too high, this year’s profit would be Rs. 10,000 too high, and so would the shop’s assets and Yasmin’s capital. Next year the same Rs. 10,000 would come back as opening stock, and next year’s profit would be that much too low. A careless count moves profit from one year to another. A dishonest one invents stock that isn’t there, and with it assets and profit that aren’t there either.

Costs and income that cross the line

Most of the other loose ends are money that moved in one year for something that belongs to the next, or the other way round. They come in four kinds, and they are easiest to see as two pairs.

On जेठ 1 Yasmin’s landlord asked for three months’ rent ahead, Rs. 45,000 for जेठ, असार and साउन. With the ten months before at Rs. 15,000, her rent account shows Rs. 195,000. But the shop’s year has used only twelve months of rent, Rs. 180,000. The last Rs. 15,000 buys साउन, in next year. Until then it is something the shop has, the right to a month in the building, as surely as a tin of paint is. That is a prepaid expense, अग्रिम भुक्तान खर्च.

The helper is the opposite case. Yasmin took her on for the festival season in कात्तिक and kept her, and she has been paid Rs. 20,000 on the first of each month for the month before. So her wages for असार, earned in this year, will be paid on साउन 1, in next year. The wages account shows only eight months. The ninth is this year’s cost, and until it is paid, a debt. That is an outstanding expense, तिर्न बाँकी खर्च.

Date Particulars L.F. Debit Rs. Credit Rs.
असार 31 Prepaid rent a/c Dr. 15,000
To Rent a/c 15,000
(Being rent for साउन paid in advance)
असार 31 Wages a/c Dr. 20,000
To Outstanding wages a/c 20,000
(Being wages for असार not yet paid)

The first entry takes the rent down to the year’s Rs. 180,000 and puts Rs. 15,000 among the shop’s assets. The second takes the wages up to Rs. 180,000 and puts Rs. 20,000 among what it owes. One adds Rs. 15,000 to the profit, the other takes Rs. 20,000 off.

Income has the same pair, the other way round. On असार 25 a school paid the shop Rs. 40,000 for paint for its new classrooms, to be delivered in साउन. It went into sales with the day’s takings. But nothing has been handed over, so nothing has been earned, and if the paint never came the school would want its money back. Until साउन it is something the shop owes. That is income received in advance, अग्रिम आय: “Sales a/c Dr. 40,000 / To Income received in advance a/c 40,000”. The school’s tins are still on the rack, so they are in the count, at cost.

Last, a paint company pays Yasmin a commission on its paint she sells, Rs. 9,000 a quarter, in the month after each quarter ends. Three quarters have come in. The fourth, for वैशाख to असार, comes in साउन, but she earned it this year. That is accrued income, आर्जित आम्दानी: “Commission receivable a/c Dr. 9,000 / To Commission received a/c 9,000”. It is something owed to the shop, an asset, and this year’s income.

The rule behind all four is the matching that runs through this book. A year carries what it used and what it earned, whenever the money moves. The list of adjustments has two more: closing stock, and depreciation, which takes the year’s share of the scooter, Rs. 24,000, and of the racks, Rs. 7,000, as an expense that moves no money.

Customers who won’t pay

Abinash took twelve tins of enamel in कात्तिक, for Rs. 15,600, and paid with a cheque that came back. Since then Yasmin has phoned, gone round, written, and finally learned that he has closed his business and moved away. The Rs. 15,600 still sits on his page in the ledger as something the shop has. It isn’t any more. It is a bad debt, खराब ऋण (an irrecoverable debt, in the Cambridge syllabus), and it is written off:

Date Particulars L.F. Debit Rs. Credit Rs.
असार 31 Bad debts a/c Dr. 15,600
To Abinash a/c 15,600
(Being the amount due from Abinash written off as irrecoverable)

The bad debts account is an expense, a loss of this year, closed to profit and loss with the others. If Abinash turns up one day and pays, the money is received in the usual way and credited to an account of income called bad debts recovered, खराब ऋण असुल. The old write-off stays where it is.

The other customers who buy on credit owe the shop Rs. 96,000 between them. Most will pay. A few may not. She can’t yet say which, so she can’t write anyone off, but prudence says the Rs. 96,000 probably won’t all come in. So she makes a provision for doubtful debts, शङ्कास्पद ऋणका लागि व्यवस्था, an estimate of how much of it won’t. Small shops often use a flat percentage from experience. Five percent of Rs. 96,000 is Rs. 4,800:

Date Particulars L.F. Debit Rs. Credit Rs.
असार 31 Estimated bad debts a/c Dr. 4,800
To Provision for doubtful debts a/c 4,800
(Being a provision of 5% made on debtors of Rs. 96,000)

In this entry the charge goes to an account of its own, estimated bad debts, which is closed to the year’s profit and loss with the other expenses. Some books debit the profit and loss account directly, others the bad debts account. All three end in the same place, a cost of this year. No customer’s page is touched, because nobody has been found out. The provision is a credit balance of its own, and when the balance sheet is drawn up it is taken off what the customers owe: debtors Rs. 96,000, less the provision of Rs. 4,800, Rs. 91,200. That is the amount she can honestly expect.

Next year the provision isn’t made again from the start. Only the change is charged. If customers then owe Rs. 120,000, five percent is Rs. 6,000, so another Rs. 1,200 comes off that year’s profit. If they owe less, the provision shrinks, and the part no longer needed comes back as income. Debts that do go bad are written off against it, and the year-end figure is set again. Bigger businesses don’t use one flat rate. They sort what they are owed by how long it has been overdue, a month, three months, a year, and set a higher rate on each older group, from their own record of who paid in the end. The international standard for this, IFRS 9, calls the amount a loss allowance and gives that grid of rates by days overdue as a way to work it out.

For tax, a provision is still only a guess. Nepal’s Income Tax Act lets a business write a debt off as bad only once it has taken every proper step to collect it and is reasonably satisfied it can’t be recovered; Yasmin’s calls and visits to Abinash are the sort of steps it means. Only banks and cooperatives may also deduct a fund kept against bad loans, up to five percent of what they are owed. For other businesses the Act names no such deduction, and provisions made for the accounts can’t be deducted until the loss really happens. So, as we read it, a shop like Yasmin’s gets a debt off its tax only when the debt is written off, not when it is provided for.

The word provision trips people up, because accountants use it in two ways. Here it means an amount taken off an asset’s figure in the books, as a provision for depreciation is. The international standards keep the word for a debt whose amount or date isn’t yet certain, such as a guarantee to repair what was sold, and call the amount off debtors an allowance. Either way it is a charge against profit, a cost of earning it. A reserve, सञ्चिति, is different. It is profit kept back, set aside from what the owners could take out, after the profit has been worked out. A provision makes the profit smaller. A reserve only decides what happens to profit already made. Reserves come in two kinds: revenue reserves, set aside out of ordinary profit, either general ones with no particular purpose or specific ones for a named purpose, and capital reserves, from gains such as profit on selling a fixed asset. A sole trader like Yasmin seldom keeps reserves. Companies do, and they come later in this book.

One provision sits on the line between the two meanings. A company owes tax on its year’s profit, but the amount isn’t settled until its return is filed and assessed, months later. So at the year’s end it charges its best estimate against the profit and shows it as a debt, a provision for tax, करका लागि व्यवस्था. Yasmin doesn’t need one. Her shop isn’t taxed on its own: she is taxed as a person on what it earns, so the tax is hers, not the shop’s.

Before and after

Put all the adjustments together and the books need one more check before the final accounts are drawn up. It is called the adjusted trial balance, समायोजित सन्तुलन परीक्षण. It starts from the ordinary trial balance, the year’s balances as the books left them. Beside it go columns for the adjustments, each entered on its two sides, and beside those, the balances as they now stand. In Yasmin’s, most of the figures are the rest of her year’s trade, the hundreds of sales, purchases and payments this book hasn’t shown one by one. Closing stock goes below the other rows, in both the debit and the credit column, because it has two homes in the final accounts: off the cost of goods in the trading account, and among the assets in the balance sheet.

Try it

Yasmin’s year-end adjustments

Each tap makes one adjustment, and the rows it changes light up. Yasmin’s first year, all made up.

Totals
agree
Profit, this step
noneup Rs. 302,000up Rs. 15,000down Rs. 20,000down Rs. 40,000up Rs. 9,000down Rs. 31,000down Rs. 15,600down Rs. 4,800

Before the adjustments. The books as they stand. They agree, but some figures belong to another year.

Each adjustment adds the same amount to both columns, or moves an amount within one column, so the totals agree after every step. That is the check: a column that doesn’t agree means an adjustment went in on one side only. Some adjustments raise the year’s profit and some lower it. Together they move it by a great deal, mostly because of the stock on the shelf, which turns a year’s buying into the cost of what was sold.

None of this touches the cash. The rent was paid when it was paid and the helper’s wages go out on साउन 1. What changes is which year each amount is counted in. The year’s profit is now the profit of that year’s own work, the figure the next chapter works out.

That is what the loose ends are for. Money moves when it moves, but a year should carry only its own costs and income: the stock still on the shelf comes off the year’s purchases, the rent paid for next month and the money taken for paint not yet handed over move forward, the wages and commission earned this year come back, and what customers owe is set at what they will really pay. Each adjustment is an ordinary journal entry with two sides, so the books balance as they did. What the adjustments change is the answer to the question the books exist for: how did this year go?

Found a mistake? Please tell us.