At 15, Sabina gets Rs. 2,000 a month in pocket money from her mother’s tea shop. By about the twentieth of each month it is gone, and if you asked her where, she could name a notebook, some phone data and a pair of earphones, and then she would run out of things to name. The rest went the way most money goes: a little at a time, on things nobody remembers buying.
That is the problem this chapter is about, and the answer to it is old and plain. Before the month begins, write down what will come in. Then decide where it will go: how much to put aside, how much the things you can’t do without will take, and how much is left for everything else. Then, as the month goes by, see whether it went where you said. That written plan is a budget (बजेट). It fits on one page, and the same page works for pocket money at 15, a first salary at 19 and a whole family’s month. The rest of this chapter is about why such a simple thing is harder than it sounds, and what it shows when it’s done.
Needs, wants, and the line between them
Every rupee that goes out goes on one of two kinds of thing. A need is something you must have to live, study or work: food, a roof, school fees, the bus fare to school, medicine. A want is something you would like and could manage without: a new phone while the old one works, momo with friends, a game, the shoes everyone else has. Wants aren’t bad. A life without any would be a grim one. The trouble starts only when a want is paid for with money that was meant for a need.
The line between the two moves, and it moves for good reasons. A jacket in winter is a need, and a jacket of one particular brand is a want. Phone data is a want for one student and a need for another whose classes are online. A motorbike is a need for someone who delivers goods across town, and a want for someone who lives beside their school. So nobody can hand you a list. The test is a question you ask about each thing: could I live, study and work without it?
How much of a family’s money its needs take depends, more than anything, on how much money there is. In 1857 a German statistician, Ernst Engel, went through the household accounts of 199 Belgian working families, published two years before. The families living on public help spent about 71 of every 100 francs on food. The families who were comfortable spent about 62. He put what he found in one line, which economists still call Engel’s law: the poorer a family, the greater the share of its spending that must go on food.
Nepal shows the same thing today. When the National Statistics Office’s survey teams recorded what families used in 2022/23, food came to about 52 of every 100 rupees’ worth, counting the rice and vegetables a family grows for itself as well as what it buys. For the poorest fifth of the people it was about 60. For the richest fifth, 43. A family with little money doesn’t spend it on food because it plans badly. It spends it on food because it has to eat, and there is less left over for anything else. That is worth remembering whenever someone says that poor families should simply budget better. Most of them budget hard. Their needs fill the page.
There is another way to see what a want costs, and it’s sharper than its price. At 19 Sabina takes home Rs. 21,499 a month for about 208 hours at work, a little over Rs. 100 an hour. A phone at Rs. 18,000 is not only Rs. 18,000. It is about 175 hours of her life, more than three weeks of work. Money spent on one thing is gone from every other thing it could have bought, and economists call the best of those other things its opportunity cost. Measured in hours, it is easy to feel. Some wants are worth three weeks. Plenty aren’t.
One more distinction matters on a family’s page. Most spending is used up: the rice is eaten, the bus ride is over. Nepal’s social studies course calls that consumption (उपभोग). Some spending is meant to bring in more later: school fees, a sewing machine for a tailor, a course that leads to better work, seeds for the next crop. That is investment (लगानी), even when it comes out of the household’s own month. A family that cuts its investment to pay for its consumption can make the month balance and the year worse.
Where the small money goes
The big spends look after themselves. Nobody forgets paying the rent or buying a phone, because those are decisions. The small spends aren’t decisions. They happen: a packet of chips after school, a cup of tea, a top-up, a bottle of water, a bus ride when walking would do. Each is too small to think about, and that is exactly why they add up unseen. Rs. 30 a day is nothing on any one day. It is Rs. 900 a month and about Rs. 11,000 a year.
The only way to see them is to write them down. Nepal Rastra Bank’s plan for teaching people about money lists filling in a financial diary among the first skills it wants everyone to have, beside making a household budget. A diary of this kind is just a page, or a note on a phone, where every rupee that goes out is written down the moment it goes, however small. Kept for a week, it shows where money really goes, and the answer surprises almost everyone. It doesn’t mean the chips have to stop. It means that from then on they are chosen.
The most famous money diaries were kept not by people trying to save but by researchers trying to understand. A team of four researchers, among them Stuart Rutherford and Daryl Collins, had interviewers visit 250 poor households in Bangladesh, India and South Africa every two weeks for a year, recording the money each one saved, lent, borrowed and paid back. They published what they found in 2009 as Portfolios of the Poor. Every household used savings and loans of some kind, and most used several at once. The money they pushed into these and pulled out again over the year was large beside what they earned: in India from three quarters of a household’s income to nearly twice it, even where the savings at the end of the year were small. These were households managing their money all the time. What made it hard, the researchers said, was a “triple whammy”: incomes that were small, incomes that came unevenly and without warning, and tools for saving and borrowing that didn’t suit them.
A plan made before spending
The word budget has a history worth a sentence or two. It comes from an old French word, bougette, a little leather bag. Its money sense goes back to Britain in 1733 and to Robert Walpole, the minister in charge of the country’s money, and the story is told two ways. Nepal’s Grade 10 Economics book has Walpole carry his papers to Parliament in a leather bag. The earliest written use that word historians have found is a pamphlet of that year, The Budget Opened, which mocked him as a quack doctor opening his bag to hand out his remedies. Either way, by the 1760s a government’s yearly plan for its money was called its budget. Nepal’s federal budget, read out in Parliament each year, is the same thing on the largest scale: what the state expects to collect and what it plans to spend, set down before the year begins. Economics, for the Curious has that one. A family’s is the same thing on a page.
The page has four parts, in this order.
First, what comes in during the month. For Sabina at 15 that is her Rs. 2,000. At 19 it is her net pay, the Rs. 21,499 that actually reaches her bank, never the bigger number at the top of the payslip. For a family it is every source added up: pay, the shop’s profit, what a son sends home, the rent from a room.
Second, what will be saved. It goes second, not last, for a reason the next part of this book spends a whole chapter on: money meant to be saved “out of whatever is left” has a way of finding there is nothing left. A rupee set aside on the day the money arrives is safe from the rest of the month.
Third, the needs. Some cost the same every month and are known in advance: rent, school fees, a bus pass, the phone plan. Those are fixed costs. Others change from month to month: food, gas, medicine, electricity. Those are variable costs, and the best guess for them is what they cost last month, which is one more reason to have written last month down.
Fourth, the wants. What is left after the first three is for wants, and it can be spent without guilt, because it was planned.
At 15, Sabina’s page might put Rs. 300 aside, Rs. 800 on notebooks, pens and the phone data she needs for class, and leave Rs. 900 for whatever she likes. At 19 the numbers are ten times bigger, and the needs now include money for the family’s food and rent, the bus to work, and lunch, but the order of the page is exactly the same. A budget changes its size as a life goes on. It doesn’t change its shape.
When the month is over, the page can turn out three ways, and Nepal’s school course gives each a name. If less went out than came in, the budget was a surplus budget (बचत बजेट): something was saved. If exactly as much went out as came in, it was balanced (सन्तुलित): nothing was saved, but nothing was borrowed either. If more went out than came in, it was a deficit budget (घाटा बजेट), and the difference had to come from somewhere, from savings put by earlier or from a loan. A deficit now and then, for a wedding or an illness, is what savings are for. A deficit every month is a household slowly borrowing its own future, which is the move Chapter 2 called moving money back, made without meaning to.
A rule of thumb often goes with all this. A 2005 American book by Elizabeth Warren and her daughter Amelia Warren Tyagi set out a rule now known as 50/30/20: no more than half of what you take home on needs, up to 30 in every 100 on wants, and at least 20 saved, with paying off debt counted as saving. It was written for families in a rich country, and it may fit many Nepali families badly. The survey’s shares aren’t shares of take-home pay, so the comparison is rough, but in Nepal food alone comes to about half of what the average household uses, before rent, fees or anything else, and about 60 in every 100 for the poorest. No rule replaces a family’s own page. What the 50/30/20 rule does get right is that saving comes with a number attached, decided in advance.
When the money comes when it comes
Sabina’s salary arrives on a known day, and that makes her page easy. Her mother’s doesn’t. Anshu’s tea shop has good weeks and slow ones, a rush at festival time and quiet days in the rains, and the shop’s profit, the family’s income from it, is never the same two months running. Chapter 3 showed that most of Nepal earns this way, by the day or by the season, and said that a budget is much harder to make when the month’s money isn’t known. It is harder, but it can be done, and the families who live on such income have worked out how.
The first trick is to plan on the slow month, not the good one. If the shop has never made less than Rs. 32,000 in a month, the family’s needs are planned on Rs. 32,000, and anything above it in a good month is not spent but kept for the slow one. A family that plans on its good months is in deficit every time a slow one comes, and it borrows at exactly the moment a lender can ask the most.
The second is to keep the shop’s money and the home’s money apart. The milk, sugar and gas the shop uses are paid for first, from the takings, because a shop that eats its own stock soon has nothing to sell. Only what is left, the profit, is the family’s income. A drawer that holds both is a drawer where nobody can tell how the shop is doing until it is too late.
The third is to know the year, not only the month. Some costs come every month and some come once a year, and the ones that come once a year are the ones that break a budget: the school fees and books at the start of the school year, the clothes, gifts and food of Dashain and Tihar, a wedding in the family, a repair to the roof before the monsoon. Divided by twelve and put aside a little each month, a big yearly cost becomes a small monthly one. Left to arrive on its own, it becomes a loan.
All of this is what Nepal’s optional Economics course of 2076 calls household economics (घरायसी अर्थशास्त्र), and the name fits. A household is a small economy. It has resources, and money is only one of them. It also has the time, energy and skills of everyone in it, the land and the animals, the help of neighbors and relatives. It has work to get done every day: cooking, cleaning, fetching water, looking after the young and the old, minding the shop or the fields. Someone has to manage all of it together: whether to buy a thing or make it, whether a son’s afternoon is better spent studying or in the shop, whether the extra this month goes to the roof or the savings. The course calls that person the household manager (घर परिवार व्यवस्थापक). The course asks what makes a good one, and a plain answer is someone who plans before spending, keeps a record, shares the work out fairly and decides with the others rather than for them.
Some of a household’s spending goes on the tools and comforts that make the work lighter, which the course calls household technology and amenities: a gas stove, a pressure cooker, a tap near the house. They cost money once and save time or money for years, which makes them investment as much as spending, and a family’s page is where such a choice gets weighed.
That is the budget’s real use. It shows a family, before the month starts, whether it can afford what it wants; it shows where cutting would hurt least if it can’t; it keeps the money for needs from being spent on wants by accident; it makes saving a decision rather than a leftover; and, written down, it lets everyone in the household see the same numbers. Nepal Rastra Bank, when it decides whom to teach about money, names women who decide how the household budget is used as one of the groups it wants to reach.
The aim isn’t a page that balances for its own sake. It is the life the money pays for: how well the family eats and lives, which the course calls its standard of living (जीवनस्तर), and how content its members are with it (सन्तुष्टि). Two families with the same income can live very differently, and a good part of the difference is the page.
So the plain thing to take from this chapter is that a budget is a plan for money made before it is spent, and that it has the same four parts at every size: what comes in, what is saved, the needs and the wants, in that order. Needs are what you can’t live, study or work without, and the line moves with time, place and how much money there is; the poorer the family, the more of its money they take. Small spends add up unseen, and writing every rupee down for a week shows them. A month can end in surplus, balanced or in deficit, and a deficit has to be paid for later. When income is uneven, the page is planned on the slow month, the business’s money is kept apart, and the yearly costs are put aside a little at a time.
Try this
- For seven days, write down every rupee you spend, however small, the moment you spend it. At the end of the week, mark each line N for a need or W for a want, and add up each. Which small spend surprised you most?
- Make your own page for next month: what comes in, what you will save, your needs, and what is left for wants. At the end of the month, compare it with what really happened.
- Choose something you want and divide its price by what an hour of work pays someone in your family. How many hours is it?
- Ask whoever runs your household which costs come only once a year, and roughly how much each is. Divide the total by twelve.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
