Skip to content

← Speaking Up, in Practice

Debate and contests · 54 of 120

Answer their strongest point, not the silly one

Expert guidance

Do this

  1. Ask: “If this one point fell, would their case fall?” That’s your target.
  2. Test it. Would it really lead to what they say? Could it cause worse things? Does it contradict something they said? Did they give an example?
  3. No example? Ask for one, or give one that shows the opposite.
  4. Start: “Before my first argument, I’d like to respond to what the other team said.”

Why this way

Hong Kong’s debating notes say not every argument is worth rebutting. Aim for the ones central to the other side’s case. They list these four tests, and suggest that opening line. Expert guidance. Skip plainly silly points. A clever but irrelevant one gets a quick reply.

Try it today

Take any opinion in today’s news, and test it four ways, in one line each. Five minutes.

Where these facts come from

General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.

← All 120 small things