Skip to content

← Psychology

Obedience

Chapter 23 · Other people

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. What happened in the room
  2. What changed the number
  3. The second telling
  4. What it says about real cruelty
  5. Respect, and when to say no

In the summer of 1961 a notice in a New Haven newspaper offered four dollars for one hour of your time. It wanted five hundred men between twenty and fifty for “a study of memory”, and it said who was welcome: factory workers, barbers, clerks, salespeople, construction workers, businessmen. No experience was needed. The study was at Yale University, and the man running it was a young psychologist called Stanley Milgram.

An old newspaper advertisement headed Public Announcement, in large type: We will pay you $4.00 for one hour of your time. Persons needed for a study of memory. Below is a list of jobs and a coupon to fill in and mail.
Figure 23.1 The advertisement that brought in Milgram’s first volunteers. Photo: New Haven Register, 1961, Public domain

The study was not about memory. Milgram wanted to know how far an ordinary person would go in hurting someone, simply because a man in charge told him to. What he found became the most famous experiment in psychology. It has also been told in two quite different ways, and both are worth hearing.

What happened in the room

A man who answered the advertisement arrived at a laboratory and met two people. One was the experimenter, a stern man in a gray technician’s coat. The other seemed to be a second volunteer, a mild, likable man in his late forties. Both were playing parts: the experimenter was a biology teacher, and the “volunteer” an accountant.

The experimenter explained that the study was about the effect of punishment on learning. One of them would be the teacher and the other the learner. They drew slips of paper to decide. The draw was rigged, since both slips said “Teacher”, so the real volunteer always became the teacher. He watched the learner being strapped into a chair in the next room, with an electrode on his wrist and paste put on “to avoid blisters and burns”. The experimenter told them that the shocks could be extremely painful but would cause no permanent damage.

The teacher sat in front of a large machine with thirty switches in a row. They ran from 15 volts to 450, in steps of 15, and groups of them were labeled from Slight Shock through Strong, Very Strong and Intense to Danger: Severe Shock. The last two switches were marked only XXX. To show that the machine was real, the teacher was given a real 45-volt shock himself.

Then the lesson began. The teacher read out pairs of words, and the learner, through the wall, had to pick the right match by pressing one of four switches. Each time he got one wrong, the teacher was to give him a shock, one switch higher than the last, and say the voltage aloud. The learner, who was getting no shocks at all, made wrong answers on a fixed plan. In the first version, at 300 volts he pounded on the wall. After 315 he pounded again. After that there was silence, and the experimenter told the teacher to treat no answer as a wrong one and carry on.

Whenever the teacher hesitated, the experimenter used the same few sentences, in order. “Please continue.” “The experiment requires that you continue.” “It is absolutely essential that you continue.” And last, “You have no other choice, you must go on.” If the teacher still refused after the fourth, the session ended.

Milgram asked people to guess what would happen. Psychology students at Yale guessed that about one man in a hundred would go to the end. Psychiatrists guessed one in a thousand.

Of the first forty men, every one went to at least 300 volts. Fourteen stopped somewhere between 300 and 375. The other twenty-six, nearly two in three, went on to the last switch on the board and kept pressing it until the experimenter called a halt.

They didn’t do it calmly. Milgram saw men sweat, tremble, stutter, bite their lips, groan and dig their nails into their own flesh. Fourteen of the forty broke into nervous laughter, and three had uncontrollable fits of it. One observer watched a businessman come in “smiling and confident” and within twenty minutes become “a twitching, stuttering wreck”, who pulled at his ear and said, “Oh God, let’s stop it.” And yet he went on to the end. Afterward each man met the learner, unharmed, for what Milgram called a friendly reconciliation.

What changed the number

That one result is what most people remember. But Milgram didn’t stop at it. He ran the experiment again and again, in many versions, each time changing one thing, with new people. The number who went to the end moved a long way.

First study: learner out of sight, pounds the wall26 of 40His cries heard through the wall25 of 40In the same room, a few feet away16 of 40Teacher holds the learner’s hand on the plate12 of 40Orders given by telephone9 of 40A plain office in another town, not Yale19 of 40Two other “teachers” refuse4 of 40Another man presses the switch37 of 40Teacher chooses the level himself1 of 400%25%50%75%100%
Figure 23.2 Out of 40 men in each version, how many went on to the last switch. The amber bar is the first study. From the tables in Milgram’s book.

The closer the learner was, the more people stopped. When the teacher could hear the learner’s cries through the wall, a little fewer than two in three went to the end. In the same room, a few feet away, it was 16 of 40. When the teacher had to hold the learner’s hand down on a metal plate to give the shock, it was 12.

The closer the authority was, the more people obeyed. When the experimenter left the room and gave his orders by telephone, only 9 of 40 went to the end. Some of those who carried on quietly used the lowest shock on the board, while assuring the experimenter on the phone that they were raising it as told. In one version a second man, apparently just another volunteer, took over the orders when the experimenter was called away. Most refused him. In another, two experimenters began to argue in front of the teacher, one saying go on and the other stop. Nobody went on to the end. Nearly all stopped the moment the two disagreed.

The place mattered less than you might expect. He moved the whole thing to a plain rented office in a nearby industrial town, under a company name invented for the purpose, with no tie to Yale. Nearly half still went to the end.

Two versions show the two directions most clearly. In one, the real volunteer sat beside two other “teachers”, both actors, and both refused to go on. With others refusing, only 4 of 40 went to the end. In the other, another “volunteer” pressed the switch, while the real one did the rest of the job beside him. Then 37 of 40 stayed to the end. Being a step away from the harm made it easy to bear.

And when the teacher was told to choose the shock himself, as low or as high as he liked, almost nobody went high. Most never went past the point where the learner first showed discomfort. One man in forty went to the top. Whatever made people climb to 450 volts, it wasn’t that they wanted to.

Milgram’s explanation was that people who join a system run by someone in charge come to see themselves as acting for that person, not for themselves. He called this the agentic state, from agent, someone who carries out another’s wishes. Responsibility seems to pass upward, to the man in the gray coat.

The second telling

That is the story the way Milgram told it. The second telling begins with whether he should have done it at all.

Soon after his first paper came out, a psychologist called Diana Baumrind wrote that he had failed the people he studied. A volunteer, she argued, trusts the researcher, and agreeing to take part doesn’t end the researcher’s duty to protect him. Milgram’s own description showed men in distress that, in her view, should have stopped the study, and she didn’t think what was learned was worth it. Milgram replied with his volunteers’ own answers to a questionnaire, which, he said, showed that most were glad they had taken part.

The rules psychologists follow today make the point for her. Deceiving people in a study is allowed only when the study is valuable enough and there is no honest way to do it. It is never allowed about research that can be expected to cause physical pain or severe emotional distress. People must be told of a trick as soon as possible, and they must be free to stop at any time. Milgram’s experiment was built around a man being told that he had no choice.

Then came the archives. Milgram’s papers and the recordings of his sessions are kept at Yale and were later opened to researchers, and several people have spent years going through them, among them Gina Perry, an Australian psychologist. They found that the story had rough edges. The sessions weren’t all run as evenly as the published accounts suggest. And most of the men hadn’t been told the whole truth in the laboratory: Milgram held back a full explanation until most of the sessions had been run, so that word wouldn’t spread, and sent a written report afterward.

Perry and three colleagues later brought out a report by Milgram’s research assistant, Taketo Murata, that had never been published. Milgram had sent every volunteer a questionnaire afterward, and one question asked how far they had believed the learner was really being shocked. Murata compared those who said they had fully believed it with everyone else. In 18 of the 23 versions he looked at, those who fully believed gave lower shocks.

The difference wasn’t big, and the questionnaire came months later, when a man who had gone to the end had every reason to say he hadn’t really believed it. Milgram thought some of the doubt was real and some a way of saving face. Which version a man was in mattered far more than what he believed. Still, the figures in Milgram’s own book, counted across all his versions, tell a quieter story than the famous one. Of the people who said they fully believed it, a little over one in three went to the end, and overall more people refused than obeyed.

Others have since tested whether people still obey. More than forty years later a psychologist in California repeated the version in which the learner’s cries were heard, but stopped at 150 volts, where the learner first demands to be let out. In Milgram’s own studies most of those who went past that point went all the way, so it seemed a fair place to stop. He screened out anyone likely to be badly upset, told each person at least three times that they could leave and keep the money, and gave them only a 15-volt sample shock. Of 40 people, 28 were ready to go on past 150, not very different from Milgram’s 33. A team in Poland, a few years later, used the same approach with ten buttons on a box and found obedience about as high as Milgram’s: by the team’s own account to the press, nine in ten pressed the last button. Neither repeat had the whole of Milgram’s experiment, so both are estimates. But they suggest people today aren’t much braver than those men in New Haven.

What it says about real cruelty

Milgram opened his first paper by naming the Nazi death camps, and in his book he tied his work to Adolf Eichmann, the official who organized the transport of millions of people to their deaths. Writing about Eichmann’s trial, the philosopher Hannah Arendt described him not as a monster but as a diligent, efficient official, and called this “the banality of evil”, meaning that great wrongs can be done by ordinary people doing their jobs. Milgram thought his laboratory showed her right. Ordinary people, he wrote, simply doing their jobs, could become agents in a terrible destructive process. The volunteers who did their part while someone else pressed the switch seemed a small model of how such a system works.

Two psychologists, from Australia and Scotland, tell it differently. They point out that the famous result is only one of Milgram’s many versions, which ranged from nobody going to the end to nearly everybody. When they and others looked again at the sessions, the teachers kept going when the experimenter appealed to the importance of the science, and usually stopped at the bare order, “You have no other choice”. People weren’t simply obeying, they argue. They went on when they believed in what the experimenter was doing, and stopped when they didn’t. They call this engaged followership. Their evidence is a reading of Milgram’s data, some of it not yet published, and a later, gentler test that used unkind words, not shocks. Historians, they add, have found that men like Eichmann weren’t only following orders either: they understood what they did, took pride in it, and worked out much of it for themselves.

The two readings agree on more than they seem to. Both say that ordinary people can be brought to do terrible things. They disagree about why: whether people hand over their conscience to whoever is in charge, or give their effort to a cause they have come to believe in. That matters, because it changes where you look for the danger: in the habit of obeying, or in what people are persuaded to believe.

No laboratory can show how a genocide happens. Milgram’s men were strangers to each other, told that the shocks did no lasting harm, and held there by nothing but a man’s words. What the experiments do show, in the versions with real differences between them, is what makes obeying easier: an authority close at hand, a victim far away, someone else’s hand on the switch, and no one beside you saying no.

Respect, and when to say no

In Nepal, respect for parents, elders and teachers is a real and good part of life. Children are expected to listen, and the elders, for the most part, have earned it. Nothing in Milgram’s experiments says that this respect is a mistake. Most of the time, doing what a trusted adult asks is sensible, since they usually know more than you.

Nepal’s own law puts it in a careful way. The Children Act, 2075, says that a child has a duty to follow the advice and guidance of parents, guardians, family, teachers and social workers, given with the child’s best interest in mind, and to respect everyone (section 77). The same Act says that every child has the right to be protected from every kind of physical or mental violence, contempt and abuse, by parents, family, guardians, teachers and anyone else (section 7(5)). Respect is owed to guidance given for your good. It isn’t owed to harm.

The experiments suggest what makes saying no easier. Nobody had to be rude to stop. One man who stopped said, “I’d like to continue, but I can’t do that to a man,” and told the experimenter to take back his check. And one person refusing made it much easier for the next. If an adult, at home or at school, hurts you or asks you to do something that hurts someone else, you are allowed to refuse, and to tell another adult you trust. The Child Helpline, 1098, is free to call. There is more on what to do in two short tips, if an adult hurts or scares you and if teachers beat students.

So the lesson isn’t to stop respecting people. The men in New Haven weren’t chosen for being cruel, and many of them were plainly miserable at what they were doing. Why they went on is still argued. What made stopping easier isn’t: the victim close, the authority far, and someone else already saying no. That holds in either telling, and it is worth knowing before the day it matters.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.