Skip to content

← Psychology

Motivation

Chapter 14 · Feeling and wanting

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. What gets you moving
  2. Maslow’s ladder
  3. Doing it for its own sake
  4. Does money make you happy?

Nepali has a short, honest way of saying why you aren’t doing your homework: पढ्न मन लागेन. My mind didn’t feel like studying. Nobody pretends the homework has changed. Something on the inside has, and it decides whether you sit down at the desk or wander off to see what’s on the phone.

Psychologists call that something motivation, and they mean it in the plain sense the word comes from: the Latin movere, to move. A motive is whatever gets you moving and points you somewhere. It explains why you eat, why you train for a race nobody pays you to run, and why, on some evenings, you do neither.

What gets you moving

A motive does three things. It starts you off. It aims you at a goal rather than at anything at all. And it keeps you at it, harder or longer the stronger it is, until the goal is reached or given up. What it never does is show itself. Nobody has ever seen a motive. You see a girl walking to the tap in the heat, and you say she’s thirsty, and you can predict that she’ll keep going until she finds water. A motive is an explanation for what people do, worked out from what they do.

The simplest motives run in a loop. Start with water. Your body needs a fairly steady amount of it, and when you’ve gone too long without, the need becomes a drive: a restless, uncomfortable push you feel as thirst. The drive sets you doing things that might get you water, which psychologists call goal-directed behavior. You find a glass, you drink, and the need is met. The push dies away and the body is back in balance, until it runs short again and the whole thing starts over.

Needthe body is short of waterDrivethirst: restless, uneasyGoal-directed behavioryou look for waterGoal reachedyou drink; the drive fadesIncentivea cold glasspulls
Figure 14.1 The motivation cycle, with thirst as the example. A need sets up a drive, the drive sets you looking, reaching the goal ends the drive, and in time the need comes back. A cold glass in front of you pulls from outside: that is an incentive.

Keeping the body in balance like this is called homeostasis, and it works much like a thermostat in a heater: drift too far from the setting and something switches on to bring you back. In the 1940s the American psychologist Clark Hull tried to build all of behavior on that idea. Deprivation creates a need, the need creates a drive, the drive drives you, and whatever action reduces the drive gets learned. A hungry rat learns its way through a maze because the food at the end ends the hunger.

The cycle has a second half that a thermostat lacks. You aren’t only pushed from inside; you’re pulled from outside. The smell of momos from a stall makes you hungry when you weren’t. An incentive is that pull: something out in the world, a smell, a prize, a word of praise, that makes you want to go after it.

Hunger shows both halves at work. When you haven’t eaten for a while, your stomach releases a hormone called ghrelin. In one small study, its level in the blood nearly doubled just before each meal and fell within an hour after it. Fat cells release another, leptin, which helps tell the brain you’ve had enough, and these signals are gathered in the hypothalamus, the small region at the base of the brain that keeps watch over the body. But hunger isn’t only chemistry. The time of day, the sight of food and the people you eat with all change how much you eat, which is why you can find room for sweets after a feast at which you were too full for another bite of rice.

Thirst, hunger, sleep, warmth, avoiding pain: these are the primary drives. Nobody has to learn them, and they come from what a body needs to stay alive. Secondary drives are learned. A fear of a place where you were once hurt can push you as hard as pain itself,. Money is the plainest case. It means nothing to a baby, just as a whistle meant nothing to an elephant until it was paired with banana, and yet for adults it has become one of the strongest pulls there is. Beside these sit the social motives every psychology book lists: the wish to achieve, to belong and to have a say over others. The need to belong may be the deepest of them. When two American psychologists went through the evidence in 1995, they found that people form bonds readily almost anywhere, fight hard to keep them, and do worse in health and happiness without them.

Hull’s neat loop leaves something out, though. If all we wanted were to bring our drives down to zero, we’d lie still once fed and warm. We don’t. We climb mountains, ride the swings at the Dashain fair and read books about psychology. People seem to look for a comfortable level of excitement, seeking more when bored and less when overwhelmed, and they differ a lot in where that level sits: some go looking for thrills that others can’t imagine wanting.

A rule called the Yerkes–Dodson law is often brought in here: a little arousal helps you perform, too much makes you worse, so a little nervousness before a test is useful and panic isn’t. Its origins are odd. In 1908 two American psychologists taught a breed of small pet mice, dancing mice, to choose a white box over a black one by giving them an electric shock whenever they chose wrong. When the boxes were hard to tell apart, the mice learned fastest with a fairly weak shock; when they were easy to tell apart, the strongest shocks the experimenters were willing to give worked best. That, with a handful of mice for each strength, is the whole of the original evidence. Later writers stretched it to cover reward, anxiety, stress and arousal of every kind, and often credited their versions to the two men, so it is now hard to say what the “law” claims at all.

Wants also clash, in three ways psychologists name: two things you’d love (two films on the one free evening), two you’d rather avoid (the dentist or the toothache), and one goal that pulls and pushes at once, like a part in the school play that comes with the terror of the stage.

Maslow’s ladder

In 1943 an American psychologist named Abraham Maslow published a paper called “A Theory of Human Motivation”. He thought too much of what was known about motives came from rats, and he wanted a theory of what moves people. His answer was that our needs come in an order.

Self-actualizationbecoming what you can becomeEsteemrespect from others and for yourselfLove and belongingfriends, family, a place among peopleSafetyshelter, order, no threatsThe bodyfood, water, air, sleepmore pressing
Figure 14.2 The five needs in the order Maslow gave them in 1943, the most pressing at the bottom. He never drew them as a pyramid, and he wrote that the order is “not nearly as rigid” as it sounds.

At the bottom are the needs of the body: food, water, air, sleep. Then safety: shelter, order, a world that doesn’t threaten you. Then love and belonging, the need for friends, family and a place among people. Then esteem, both respect from others and respect for yourself. At the top is what he called self-actualization, the wish to become what you are able to become. “A musician must make music, an artist must paint, a poet must write, if he is to be ultimately happy,” he wrote. “What a man can be, he must be.”

The order matters because, in his view, a need that isn’t met takes over. A person who is truly starving thinks of food, dreams of food, and imagines a perfect world as a place with plenty to eat. “It is quite true that man lives by bread alone,” Maslow wrote, “when there is no bread.” Once there is bread, and there is reliably bread, other needs rise up and take their turn. He didn’t mean that each must be fully met before the next can appear. He thought a new need emerges slowly, by degrees, and he listed exceptions: people for whom respect matters more than love, artists who create through any hardship, people who give up everything for an ideal.

Maslow was one of the founders of what came to be called humanistic psychology, beside Carl Rogers. Its starting points were that people are more than their drives and their past, that they make real choices, and that every person has a pull toward growth, so that psychology should study people at their best and not only at their worst. That gave the field a hopeful voice and a respect for the person in front of it, and Rogers built a way of counseling on it. Its weakness was the one its critics kept pointing to. Ideas like self-actualization are hard to measure, so they are hard to test, and Maslow’s own evidence was mostly his impression of people. For his picture of self-actualizing people he studied a small group of famous people he admired, which is a bit like learning what makes good food by tasting only your favorite dishes.

Then there is the pyramid. You have very likely seen it, five colored layers rising to a point. Maslow never drew it. Three researchers who searched his writings and his archive in Ohio found no trace of a pyramid in any of them. The earliest triangle they found was a set of steps in a 1957 book on business, and the earliest real pyramid was in a 1960 article for managers titled “How Money Motivates Men”, by a psychologist working for a consulting firm. Business schools took it up, and the shape stuck to Maslow’s name. It also made the theory look neater than he wrote it: a pyramid says you climb one step at a time and never go back, which he never said.

How well has the idea held up? Not very well as a ladder. A review of the research in 1976 found only partial support for any hierarchy of needs and called the theory “almost a nontestable theory”. A much larger study in 2011 used surveys from 123 countries and a list of needs much like Maslow’s. Meeting each need did go with people feeling better about their lives, in every region of the world, so the list itself holds up rather well. But the ladder didn’t. How much a need mattered to people’s well-being had little to do with whether the others were met. You can feel loved while you are still poor.

Two economists studying the world’s poorest families found something that sits oddly with a strict ladder, though they weren’t writing about Maslow. In Udaipur, a poor district of India, more than 99 in every 100 of the poorest households had spent money in the past year on a wedding, a funeral or a festival, and the typical one spent a tenth of its budget on festivals, while it could have spent up to 30% more on food. One way to read that, ours rather than theirs, is that belonging and standing don’t always wait for a full stomach.

Maslow’s list is still a useful reminder that people need more than food, and CDC’s course teaches it, though the AP course in the United States leaves it out of its exam. The pyramid is best read as a picture somebody else drew of a theory that was looser, and more interesting, than the picture.

Doing it for its own sake

Some things you do for what they bring. You sweep the courtyard because your mother asked, or for the pocket money, or to avoid a scolding. That is extrinsic motivation: the reason lies outside the activity. Other things you do because the doing is the point. Nobody pays a child to climb a guava tree. That is intrinsic motivation, and it raises a question that sounds simple and turned out to be one of the longest arguments in psychology. What happens when you pay someone for something they already love?

In 1971 the American psychologist Edward Deci gave college students puzzles to solve over three sessions. Some were paid a dollar for each puzzle they solved in the second session and nothing in the third; the others were never paid. In a break in the middle of each session the students were left alone with the puzzles still there, and were watched, without knowing it, to see what they did when nobody asked them to do anything. Those who had been paid and then stopped being paid spent less of their free minutes on the puzzles than they had at the start, a bigger drop than among those never paid. With only 24 students, the difference was small enough to be doubtful.

Two years later the psychologist Mark Lepper and his colleagues tried something similar with small children at a nursery school at Stanford University. They chose children who already loved drawing with markers. Some were promised a fancy certificate if they would draw; some got the same certificate without being told about it beforehand; some got nothing. Later the markers were put out in the classroom among the other things to play with, and the children were watched through a one-way mirror. Those who had drawn for the promised award spent less time with the markers than the children who had expected nothing. The certificate that came as a surprise did no such harm, and neither did surprise rewards in the few later experiments that tried them.

The idea that came out of this is that an expected reward can change your reason for doing something. If you were paid to draw, maybe you drew for the pay, and when the pay stops so does the reason. In 1999 Deci and two colleagues pooled 128 experiments and found that rewards which could be seen and touched, and which people knew were coming, did lower interest in activities people already enjoyed, more so in children than in college students. Praise for doing well did the opposite and raised interest.

That conclusion has been fought over for decades. Psychologists in the tradition of Skinner, for whom rewards are simply how behavior is shaped, pooled much the same studies and concluded that rewards in general do no harm. But when you read the two sides closely, they agree on more than they argue about. Praise helps. Rewards for jobs that are dull don’t spoil anything, since there was no love there to lose. The harm both find is in one corner: something real, promised beforehand, for doing a task that people already found interesting, given whether or not they did it well. What they still dispute is how big that corner is and how often real life falls into it. Most of the experiments were done on American children and college students in laboratories, which is a long way from a classroom in Kavre. If you want the practical side of this, there is a small habit built on what the studies agree on.

Deci and his colleague went on to build a broader account, self-determination theory. It says people have three needs of the mind, as basic in their way as the body’s: to feel they are choosing what they do, to feel they are getting good at it, and to feel connected to other people. Where all three are met, people tend to stay at things with energy of their own. Where they are thwarted, motivation drains away. Bandura, the psychologist of the Bobo doll, added a fourth ingredient that runs under all of these: what you believe about whether you can do it. Two students with the same ability may try very differently if one thinks the problem is within reach and the other is sure it isn’t.

Does money make you happy?

Money is the extrinsic reward of extrinsic rewards, and the old question about it has a good recent answer, because two scientists who disagreed sat down together to find it.

In 2010 the psychologist Daniel Kahneman and an economist colleague looked at more than 450,000 answers to a daily survey of Americans. They separated two things. One was how people judged their lives when asked to think about them, on a ladder from worst to best. The other was how their days actually felt: whether they had felt joy, stress, sadness or anger yesterday. The first kept rising with income. The second rose too, but then stopped, at around $75,000 a year. More money, they concluded, buys a better verdict on your life but, past a point, not better days.

Eleven years later another researcher, Matthew Killingsworth, published the opposite. He had collected 1.7 million moments from 33,391 working Americans, whose phones asked them at random times through the day how they felt right then. In his data happiness kept rising with income, past $75,000 and well beyond $200,000.

So Kahneman and Killingsworth joined forces, with a third psychologist as referee. Going back over Killingsworth’s data, they found that both had been partly right. For most people, happiness kept climbing with income. For the unhappiest group, the bottom 15 to 20 people in every hundred, it climbed until about $100,000 a year and then flattened. The 2010 study’s yes-or-no questions about yesterday could tell an unhappy day from a happy one, but not a happy day from a happier one, so the flattening it found was really that group’s.

The rise follows what mathematicians call a logarithm, and it means something easy to feel. What counts is the proportion, not the amount. Going from 20,000 to 40,000 rupees a month is about as big a step for happiness as going from 200,000 to 400,000. The same extra thousand rupees means far more to a porter than to a factory owner.

All of that is about working Americans, and it shows money and happiness going together rather than proving that one causes the other. Nepal has a finding of its own. Two economists used a national survey of more than 3,300 Nepali households, made in 1995 and 1996, in which someone in each household, usually its head, was asked whether its income, its food, its clothing, its housing, its schooling and its health care were adequate. More than two in three said their income was less than adequate. Whether a household felt it had enough depended on what it had, but also on what the households around it had: the better off the neighbors, the less adequate the same income seemed. The researchers had wondered whether poorer families in remote hill villages, with fewer neighbors in view, might care less about comparing. They didn’t. Even the poorest and most isolated households judged themselves against others, and people who had moved away from the district where they were born still measured themselves against the households back home.

So money matters, more than some comfortable sayings admit, and most of all to those who have little. But much of what it feels like to have enough depends on whom you are looking at.

Put together, motivation is less a single engine than a crowd of them. The body’s needs push you back toward balance, the world pulls you with incentives, and learned and social motives sit on top of the drives you were born with. People need more than bread, as Maslow saw, but their needs don’t wait in a fixed line. Doing something for its own sake keeps you going without anyone paying, and a reward promised for it can sometimes get in the way. And money raises happiness for most people, most of all for those with least, while how rich you feel depends a good deal on the people around you.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.