Skip to content

← Psychology

Attention

Chapter 7 · The brain and the senses

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. A spotlight with a dimmer
  2. What you don’t see
  3. What catches attention
  4. Two things at once
  5. Does a phone distract you just by being there?

Start with a small test. It takes sixteen seconds and works properly only once, so give it everything you’ve got, and play it before you read on.

Try it

Count the bounces

Count, in your head, how often the white shapes touch the edge of the box. Ignore the black ones, and keep your eyes on the box until it stops.

White bounces, really
—
Did you see anything else?
—

Press Start and count, in your head, how often the white shapes touch the edge of the box. Ignore the black ones. It takes well under half a minute.

However your count came out, the count wasn’t really the test. While you counted, a red cross slid across the middle of the box. If you saw it, so did most of the people who took the test this one copies. But nearly three in ten of them never saw the cross, though it was the only red thing on the screen and the only cross, and it was there for five seconds. They weren’t careless. They were doing what they’d been asked to do.

That is the whole chapter in one experiment. Your eyes take in far more than your mind ever handles. Attention is how the mind picks out the little it will deal with, and what it doesn’t pick, you often don’t see at all, even when it is right in front of you.

A spotlight with a dimmer

The American psychologist William James put it well in 1890. “Every one knows what attention is,” he wrote. It is the mind taking hold, clearly and vividly, of one out of several things it could be thinking about at once, and it “implies withdrawal from some things in order to deal effectively with others.” Millions of things reach your senses, he went on, that never enter your experience, because they hold no interest for you. “My experience is what I agree to attend to.”

Psychologists still define attention much as James did: the mind’s selecting of some of what reaches it, so as to deal with it well, while the rest is left aside. A common picture is a spotlight. Whatever it falls on is bright and clear. Around it is a dim fringe you half notice, and beyond that, darkness.

The picture is useful because it carries attention’s main traits. It is selective: it picks a little out of a lot. It is limited: the beam is narrow, and widening it makes everything in it dimmer. It moves, from the teacher’s voice to the window to a friend’s whisper, often many times a minute. And it can be steered in two ways. Some things grab it, like a horn blaring behind you on the road, whether you want them to or not; James called this passive attention. Other times you aim it yourself, at a page of chemistry while the cricket is on in the next room, and that takes effort. That effort doesn’t hold for long. James thought that nobody can keep voluntary attention on one thing for more than a few seconds at a time: what feels like long concentration is the mind drifting and being brought back, over and over.

He seems to have been right about the drifting. Two Harvard psychologists once built a phone app that asked about 2,250 volunteers, at random moments of their day, what they were doing and what they were thinking about. Nearly half the time, 47%, their minds were on something other than what they were doing. Three quarters of those people were American, but nobody who has sat through a long class will be surprised.

What you don’t see

The cross test is a copy of a more famous one. In 1999 the psychologists Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris filmed two teams of three students, one in white shirts and one in black, passing basketballs to one another in front of some elevator doors. They showed the film to 228 students, almost all undergraduates, and asked them to count the passes made by one team. Some saw a version in which, about 45 seconds in, a woman with an open umbrella strolled through the game. Others saw a woman in a full gorilla costume do the same.

Afterward each student was asked, in four questions of growing directness, whether they had noticed anything unusual, ending with “did you see a gorilla walk across the screen?” Across all the versions, 46% failed to notice the visitor at all. The gorilla was missed more often than the umbrella, and in some versions only 8% of the students saw it. In one extra film the gorilla stopped in the middle, turned to the camera and thumped its chest, a full nine seconds on screen. Half of the twelve people who watched that one still missed it.

The name for this is inattentional blindness: failing to see something in plain view because your attention is busy elsewhere. It wasn’t new. The psychologist Ulric Neisser had shown the same thing with filmed ball games years earlier, and others had found it with shapes flashed on computer screens. What the gorilla did was make it impossible to wave away. Some of the students who missed it didn’t believe there had been a gorilla until the film was played again, and one exclaimed, “I missed that?!”

A close cousin is change blindness: missing a change that happens while you look away or blink. A year before the gorilla, Simons and Daniel Levin tried it in the street. A young man with a campus map stopped people on the path at Cornell University and asked the way to a building. As they talked, two men carrying a door barged between them, and for about a second the door hid him. Behind it, he grabbed the door and walked off, and one of the carriers stayed in his place, holding an identical map. The two men wore different clothes, differed in height by about five centimeters and had clearly different voices. Of 15 people, only 7 noticed that they were now giving directions to a stranger. Those who didn’t simply carried on explaining. The study was small, and the seven who noticed were all students of the experimenters’ own age, so the researchers tried again dressed as builders, on students only. This time 4 of 12 noticed.

Many versions of these tests have been run since, and the misses keep turning up, though how many people miss depends on how hard the task is and how the question is asked. What they mean is the important part. You feel as if you see the whole scene in detail, but you clearly see and remember only the part you’re attending to. The rest you mostly take on trust, as if it were still just as it was. Most of the time it is, which is why this works. It fails when something unexpected happens outside the beam.

What catches attention

So what decides where the beam goes? Psychologists group the answers in three places: in the thing itself, in the person, and in the surroundings.

Start with the thing. Some things pull attention by their nature, and James listed them: whatever is intense, large or sudden, a bang, a flash, a sharp pain, and things that are new, strange, bright or moving. Add contrast and change. A ticking clock goes unnoticed until it stops, and a single word in capitals jumps out of a page. Repetition helps too, which is why a microbus conductor calls the same stop five times.

Yet the gorilla was large, dark and moving, and still invisible to half the room. That’s because the person matters as much as the thing. In the basketball film, students counting the black team, whose shirts were the gorilla’s color, saw it 58% of the time; those counting the white team saw it 27% of the time. In the cross study, the more an unexpected shape resembled what people were watching for, the likelier they were to notice it. Your attention isn’t just pulled by the world. It is set, in advance, to look for certain kinds of thing, and things that don’t fit the setting slip past.

What sets it is you: your goals for the moment, your interests, what you expect and what you need. A hungry person picks out the smell of frying from down the street. A sleeping mother wakes to her baby’s small cry but not to louder sounds. Your own name is the classic case. At a crowded बिहे भोज (wedding feast) you can follow one conversation and lose the rest as a blur of noise, and then someone across the tent says your name and your head turns. Psychologists call this the cocktail party effect. In the laboratory, about a third of people hear their own name dropped into a recording they’re trying to ignore. Oddly, in one study those who heard it tended to score lower on a test of how much they can hold in mind, as if they were less good at keeping the ignored voice out.

Knowing the trick doesn’t free you from it. Later, Simons made a new film and showed it to people who already knew about videos like the gorilla one. They watched for a gorilla and duly found it. But two other things had been added: the curtain behind the players changed color, and one player walked off. Knowing to expect surprises didn’t help with these, and the people in the know were, if anything, a little worse at spotting them.

Last, the surroundings. Noise, crowding and clutter all compete for the beam. In one experiment, 24 kindergarten children were taught six short science lessons in a laboratory classroom, three with the walls bare and three with the walls covered in charts and artwork. With the decorations up, they spent 38.6% of the time off task, against 28.4% with bare walls, and scored 42% on the questions after the lessons, against 55%. It was one small study, of very young children in an unfamiliar room, so it is a hint rather than a rule. A phone is part of the surroundings too, and it gets its own section below.

One more thing decides where attention goes: habit. Some things capture attention because you have practiced them so much that they happen by themselves. Reading is the best example. Try this.

Try it

Name the ink

Do the Patches first, then the Words. Tap the color of the ink, as fast as you can.

Press Start0 / 12
Patches
—
Words
—
Words took longer by
—

Press Start, then tap the color of each patch as fast as you can. Twelve of them.

In 1935 an American psychologist, John Ridley Stroop, gave 100 students sheets of a hundred items. Naming the colors of a hundred colored squares took them, on average, 63 seconds. Naming the ink colors of a hundred color words, each printed in a different color from the one it named, took 110 seconds, 74% longer. In another of his experiments, reading the words aloud while ignoring their ink was barely slowed at all, by only 2.3 seconds. The word gets read whether you want it or not, and the color has to push past it.

The Stroop effect has been found again and again since, and it is used to study how people hold back an answer that comes too easily. Stroop’s students said the colors aloud. Here you tap a button instead, which is a different task, with only three colors and twelve items, so your times can’t be set beside his seconds. And your result is a single person on a single occasion, which proves very little either way. The finding is in the hundred students, and the many people tested since.

Two things at once

If attention is a narrow beam, what happens when you try to do two things at once? James asked this too. His answer was that a person can’t easily do more than one thing unless the others are habits, like walking while talking. When neither task is automatic, the mind doesn’t really do both. It switches between them, quickly, and each switch costs a little time and makes a mistake a little more likely. In experiments where people switch often between simple tasks, they are slower, and usually more error-prone, just after each switch. Being given time to prepare shrinks that cost but doesn’t remove it.

The case that matters most is driving. The psychologists David Strayer and William Johnston gave people a simple driving task on a computer screen and had them talk on a phone. Listening to the radio or to a recorded book did them no harm. But a real conversation, on a handheld phone or a hands-free one, doubled the number of traffic signals they failed to notice, and slowed their reactions to the ones they did. Hands-free didn’t help, because the trouble wasn’t the hand on the phone. It was the mind in the conversation. Later the same group tracked drivers’ eyes and found that people talking on the phone remembered fewer of the billboards they passed, even ones their eyes had rested on: inattentional blindness, at the wheel.

Later the team compared phone drivers with drunk ones, in a far more lifelike simulator, with the drinkers at the legal limit for alcohol in the United States. The two went wrong in different ways. Drunk drivers drove too close to the car in front and braked too hard. Drivers on the phone braked late, and had more crashes than when they weren’t talking. The researchers concluded that talking on a phone while driving can harm driving as much as being drunk. Talking to a passenger led to fewer driving errors than talking on the phone, and the reason seems to be that a passenger can see the road too. As the traffic got harder, passengers and drivers spoke more slowly and more simply, and talked about the traffic. The person on the other end of a phone can’t see it.

Are some people simply good at doing two things at once? In one study of 200 people in a driving simulator, 5 of them, 2.5%, did just as well at driving and a hard memory task together as at either alone. The researchers called them supertaskers. Everyone else got worse. A rare few may be able to do two hard things at once, but in that study, about 39 people in 40 couldn’t.

These were mostly simulator studies, of American students, and a simulator isn’t a road. But the pattern has held across many studies: when both tasks need you, at least one gets less of you.

Does a phone distract you just by being there?

This is where a strong headline met a messy record. A team led by Adrian Ward, at the University of Texas, asked 520 students to do two tests, one of how much they could hold in mind and one of reasoning. Some were told to leave their phones in another room, some kept them in a pocket or a bag, and some put them face down on the desk, silent. Those whose phones were in another room did best on the memory test, and those with phones on the desk worst, with the pocket in between. A second experiment, with 275 students, gave a similar answer, whether the phones were on or off. Most of the students, when asked, said their phone’s place had made no difference. The team named the effect “brain drain”, and it went round the world.

Then others tried it again. Two other researchers repeated the second experiment as closely as they could, after publishing their plan in advance, and found no difference at all between phones on the desk, in a pocket or in another room. Later a team in Singapore pooled 33 studies, with 4,368 people between them, and found no overall effect of a phone’s mere presence. One memory test did seem to suffer slightly, but its studies looked lopsided in the way that missing, unpublished results make them look, and once that was allowed for, the effect vanished. Another pooled review, of 22 studies, did find that phones harm thinking, but it counted studies where people used their phones together with ones where the phone just sat there, so it doesn’t settle the narrower question.

So the studies disagree, and nobody yet knows whether a silent phone lying on a desk does any harm by itself. A phone that makes a sound is another matter, though here too the evidence is one experiment. People doing a task that needed close attention did worse when their phone buzzed or chimed, even though they never picked it up, and the harm was about as large as the harm seen when people take a call or send a message. A notification is just the kind of sudden, personal signal that grabs attention. Two tips elsewhere on this site, on where to keep the phone and on alerts, say what they rest on.

Attention is the mind choosing what it will deal with, out of far more than it could ever take in. It is selective, limited, always moving, and grabbed by some things while you aim it at others. What decides where it goes is partly the thing itself, loud, sudden, new or moving; partly you, your goals, needs and expectations, your own name above all; and partly your surroundings. What falls outside it you often don’t see at all, which is why half a room can miss a gorilla, why a driver on the phone can miss a traffic signal, and why you feel you see everything when you see only a little. The rest you take on trust, and most of the time the world hasn’t changed behind your back.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.