Skip to content

← Geography

What Geography Is

Chapter 1 · What Geography Is

In this chapter 4 sections
  1. Why up there
  2. What geography asks
  3. Close up and far away
  4. How places are linked

Bandipur sits on a ridge about a thousand meters up, halfway between Kathmandu and Pokhara. On some mornings the valleys below it fill with cloud, and from the town you look down on a white sea with dark hilltops standing out of it. Above it, far to the north, runs a long wall of snow: Ganesh Himal, Himalchuli, Manaslu, the Annapurnas.

Snow peaks in the pink light of early morning above a valley filled with white cloud, with the dark edge of a ridge and its houses in the foreground.
Figure 1.1 The view north from Bandipur, with the valley under cloud. Photo: Rajivkilanashrestha, CC BY-SA 4.0

Under that cloud, about three kilometers away as the crow flies and 600 meters lower, lies Dumre, a bazaar on the Prithvi Highway where the buses stop. Bandipur is old: brick town houses on both sides of a long street paved with slate. Dumre is young. It began in the 1970s as a row of shops thrown up in a hurry beside the new road.

So why is the old town up there, on a narrow ridge you have to climb to reach, and the new one down by the river? It’s a small question about two small towns. Ask it about any town, or any field, forest, factory or flood, and you’re doing geography.

Why up there

Long before there was a bazaar, Magar farmers lived on these hills, and their old terraces cover almost every piece of land around the town. Then, near the end of the 1700s, merchant families began arriving from Bhaktapur, in the Kathmandu Valley. They were Newars, and they came to trade. Two family records kept in Bandipur put the first of them at least seven generations back, which the historian who read them took to mean between 1775 and 1800.

What drew them? Partly the ground itself. The top of the ridge flattens out into a saddle just wide enough for one street with a row of houses on each side, and that’s where they built, with bricks and roof tiles made from the local clay. Up there a cool breeze blows from the north, and it keeps mosquitoes away even in the monsoon, so Bandipur had no malaria. The warm country to the south did. Geographers call this a place’s site: the ground it stands on, with its slope, its water, its soil and its air.

The bigger draw was trade. Bandipur lay about halfway along a walking route that followed the Marsyangdi and joined Tibet in the north with India in the south. Tibetan salt came down it to be traded for rice. Wool, herbs, musk and horses came south, and cotton, spices, copper and glassware went north. Porters carried most of it on their backs, and the stone steps of the trail were worn smooth by their feet. Every load that passed needed somewhere to rest, eat, trade and buy a new डोको, the carrying basket. Geographers call this a place’s situation: where it sits among other places, and what links it to them. Bandipur’s site made it a pleasant place to live. Its situation made it rich.

Then the links moved. In the 1960s the government redrew the districts, and the new boundaries left Bandipur at one edge of Tanahun, so in 1968 the district’s offices moved to Damauli, a day’s walk west, where two rivers meet. Around the same time a road from Kathmandu to Pokhara was being planned, to be built and paid for by China. When the plans were drawn, the road ran along the river valley, about 600 meters below the town. A committee from Bandipur went to Kathmandu to ask for the road to come up through the bazaar, and the surveyors called it uneconomical and unfeasible. The highway was finished in 1973 or 1974, by different accounts. Traders followed the buses down the hill, and Dumre grew where the path from Bandipur met the road. By 1980 nearly all of Bandipur’s trade was local: a few shops selling cloth, kerosene, mustard oil, tobacco and medicine to the villages around.

The ridge hadn’t changed at all. The site was as good as ever. What changed was the situation, because the line linking the town to the rest of the world had moved down the hill by a few kilometers.

There’s a twist. The old bazaar kept its look through the quiet years, and its look and its view are what bring people now. By 2024 it had about 90 hotels and restaurants, and the road up from Dumre carries visitors instead of salt. It’s still a story about links, only a new kind.

What geography asks

The word is more than two thousand years old. Eratosthenes, a librarian at Alexandria in the third century BCE, probably coined it: geographia, from the Greek for earth and writing, a description of the Earth. The Nepali word, भूगोल, comes from Sanskrit and puts together भू, the earth, and गोल, round. The round Earth.

Geography today does more than describe. Nepal’s school books define it as the study of how nature and people depend on each other, and that’s a fair summary. Its subject is the Earth’s surface, where rock, water, air and living things meet, and the people who live among them, use them and change them. Most of what geographers ask comes down to four questions. Where is it? What is it like there? How does the answer change if you look closer, or farther away? And how is it linked to other places?

“Where” sounds like the dullest of the four, but the answers often start there. The example geography books love best comes from London in 1854. On 31 August, cholera broke out in Soho, and in the next two days 197 people died. A doctor named John Snow suspected the water. He took the list of deaths from the registrar and walked from house to house, and he found that nearly all of them had happened close to one street pump, in Broad Street. Of the ten deaths in houses nearer to another pump, five were in families who sent to Broad Street because they liked its water better, and three were of children who went to school near it.

The places where people didn’t die told him as much. A workhouse on Poland Street was surrounded on three sides by houses where people had died, yet only five of its 535 inmates died of cholera. It had its own well. A brewery near the pump had more than seventy workmen, and none of them was badly ill. They had a well of their own too, and the owner believed they drank no water at all, because they were given beer. On the evening of 7 September Snow told the parish board what he’d found, and the next day the handle was taken off the pump.

An old black-and-white street map of Soho in London, with short black bars stacked along the streets, thickest around Broad Street.
Figure 1.2 John Snow’s map of the outbreak, from his book of 1855. Each black bar is a death, stacked at its house, and the pumps are marked along the streets. Photo: John Snow, Public domain

By then the outbreak was already dying down, partly because so many people had fled, and Snow said so himself. The famous map came afterward, for his book, to show what he had found. But the finding was a geographer’s finding, all the same: put the deaths where they happened, and the cause is standing in the middle of them. (That same year, south of the Thames, Snow made a second case from two water companies whose pipes ran down the same streets; that one is told in Without an experiment, in Thinking Clearly, for the Curious.)

The second question, what a place is like, asks about everything at once. Bandipur’s saddle, its clay, its breeze and its view are part of the answer, and so are the people who live there, the language they speak at home, the work they do and the way they build. A place is all of that together, which is why the same valley can be a good place to grow rice and a bad place to build a school.

Close up and far away

The third question is about scale. Change how much you look at, and the question changes, and so does the answer.

Close up, Bandipur is where it is because of a saddle and a breeze. Step back, and it’s where it is because it lay halfway along a trail. Step back again, and a new question appears: why was there a trail at all? Why would anybody carry salt over the Himalaya on their back? Because the lands on either side are so different. North of the mountains the ground is high, dry and cold, with a growing season too short for much farming. It had salt, wool and horses, and it needed grain. South of them it’s warm and wet, and rice grows well. A difference between two places is what trade lives on, and the greater the difference, the further people will walk.

To see how sharp that difference is, step back as far as Nepal itself and cut it through, like a cake, from the Indian plain to Tibet.

Try it

The Section

Nepal cut through from the Indian plain to Tibet, along three lines. The ground is real, measured from space: at each point, the highest ground within 2 km of the line, the skyline you would see. Choose a line, then see the land at its true shape.

03,0006,0009,000mNepal: 166 km← IndiaTibet →BirgunjHetaudaKathmanduLangtang Lirung0 km50100150200
Line:
Heights:
Across Nepal
166 km
Lowest
89 m
Highest
7,120 m

Past low hills and a higher ridge, across the flat floor of the Kathmandu Valley at about 1,300 m, then up to Langtang. Heights are drawn 10 times taller than they are.

Along the Koshi line, the ground in Nepal starts near Biratnagar at less than 100 meters above the sea and reaches about 8,000 meters on the shoulders of Makalu, which stands right on the border with Tibet. That’s a rise of 8 kilometers across 173 kilometers of country. The Kathmandu line does much the same, past low hills and a higher ridge, across the flat floor of the Kathmandu Valley, and up to Langtang. The Karnali line, in the far west, bends through Surkhet, Jumla and Simikot to follow the country the long way, so it crosses 299 kilometers of Nepal. It climbs more gently and runs much farther before it reaches its highest ground.

The drawing hides something, though. To make the hills visible, it draws every height about ten times taller than it is, fifteen times on the Karnali line, which is what almost every drawing of a section does. Switch it to the true shape, and the whole of Nepal, the Himalaya included, becomes a faint ramp along the bottom, rising on average about one meter for every twenty. Both drawings are true. They answer different questions, and that’s the other meaning of scale: every map and every drawing of the land is squeezed or stretched by some amount, and it’s worth knowing by how much.

How places are linked

The fourth question is about links: roads, rivers, trails, wires, winds, money and people moving between places. Bandipur rose on one link and fell when it moved. Rivers link places too. When heavy rain falls on the hills, the rivers carry it down to the plains, and people there can be flooded by rain they never saw.

With questions this wide, geography splits into parts. Physical geography studies the Earth itself: the shapes of the land, weather and climate, rivers and seas, soils, plants and animals. Human geography studies people: where they live and why, how many there are, how they earn a living, how they are governed, what they believe and build. A third part is the tools: maps, surveying, pictures of the Earth taken from satellites, and computer systems that lay one map on top of another, so that a flood map, a road map and a map of schools can be read together. Regional geography takes one region and puts all of these together for it. Because it reaches into both the natural sciences and the study of people, geography is often called a bridge between them.

That makes it one of the most useful things a person can know, mostly without noticing. Where should a school go, so that no child walks more than an hour, and no flood reaches its floor? Which hillside will hold a road, and which will slide? Why does land cost so much more in one ward than in the next? Why did a bazaar on a ridge empty when a road was built below it? Each is a question about where things are, what places are like, how far you look, and what joins one place to another.

There’s no need to go to Bandipur to start. Look out of the nearest window. The ground you see was made somehow, and the water in it is on its way somewhere. Somebody chose to build there, for reasons that had to do with the ground and with the paths that led to it, and some of those reasons may no longer hold. Why is your town here, and not a kilometer away? The answer begins with the ground itself, which had to be made before anyone could stand on it.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.