← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words
Taxes and money between the levels
भाग ५: राज्यको संरचना र राज्यशक्तिको बाँडफाँड · Part 5, Structure of State and Distribution of State Power · Articles 59–60
On the radio, one day it is the federal budget, another day the Province’s, and later the municipality’s. Why three budgets? and of the Constitution say how money is shared among Nepal’s three levels: the Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels.
Each level’s own budget
is headed Exercise of Financial Powers (आर्थिक अधिकारको प्रयोग). It starts with what each level does with the money matters in its own hands.
The Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels each make laws, make annual budgets, take decisions, and prepare and carry out policies and plans on the financial matters within their own powers (). Which matters are in whose powers is set out in the lists of powers in Schedules 5 to 9 ().
The Federation may also make the policies, standards and laws needed on the matters in the concurrent list (साझा सूची) and in other areas of financial powers, so that they apply to the Provinces as well (). The concurrent lists are the ones the levels share: Schedule 7 for the Federation and the Provinces, Schedule 9 for all three levels ( and (5)).
Each of the three levels makes its own budget. When the Provinces and Local Levels present their budgets is as federal law sets out (). For the Federation, the Constitution fixes the day itself ().
Natural resources: sharing the benefits
says who is to share in what natural resources bring.
Sharing what natural resources bring
The Constitution
(४) संघ, प्रदेश र स्थानीय तहले प्राकृतिक स्रोतको प्रयोग वा विकासबाट प्राप्त लाभको समन्यायिक वितरणको व्यवस्था गर्नु पर्नेछ। त्यस्तो लाभको निश्चित अंश रोयल्टी, सेवा वा वस्तुको रूपमा परियोजना प्रभावित क्षेत्र र स्थानीय समुदायलाई कानून बमोजिम वितरण गर्नु पर्नेछ।
(4) The Federation, Province and Local Level shall provide for equitable distribution of benefits derived from the use of natural resources or development. Certain portions of such benefits shall be distributed, in accordance with law, in the form of royalty, services or goods to the project affected regions and local communities.
In plain words
The Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels must arrange for the benefits from the use or development of natural resources to be shared out equitably (समन्यायिक). A set part of those benefits must go to the areas the project affects and to the local communities, as royalty, services or goods, as a law sets out (कानून बमोजिम).
Nepali: प्राकृतिक स्रोतको प्रयोग वा विकास, the use or development of natural resources (the translation says “the use of natural resources or development”).
When natural resources are used, if the local community wants to invest, the three levels must give it priority to invest a share set by law, on the basis of the investment’s nature and size ().
Aid, loans and keeping the books in order
The power to take foreign aid and loans belongs to the Government of Nepal. Such aid or loans must be taken in a way that keeps the country’s macro-economic stability (समष्टिगत आर्थिक स्थायित्व) ().
The rules on managing budget deficits and on other fiscal discipline at all three levels are as federal law sets out (). A Provincial Government may not raise a loan or give a guarantee except as federal law provides ().
Who may tax what
is headed Distribution of Sources of Revenue (राजस्व स्रोतको बाँडफाँड). Its first clause is the core rule on taxes.
Each level taxes its own matters
The Constitution
(१) संघ, प्रदेश र स्थानीय तहले आफ्नो आर्थिक अधिकारक्षेत्र भित्रको विषयमा कर लगाउन र ती स्रोतहरूबाट राजस्व उठाउन सक्नेछन्।
तर साझा सूचीभित्रको विषयमा र कुनै पनि तहको सूचीमा नपरेका विषयमा कर लगाउने र राजस्व उठाउने व्यवस्था नेपाल सरकारले निर्धारण गरे बमोजिम हुनेछ।
(1) The Federation, Province and Local Level may impose taxes on matters falling within their respective competence and collect revenue from these sources.
Provided that provisions relating to the imposition of taxes and collection of revenue on matters enumerated in the Concurrent List and on matters that are not contained in the List of any level shall be as determined by the Government of Nepal.
In plain words
Each of the three levels may levy taxes on the matters within its own financial powers and collect revenue from those sources. But on the matters in the concurrent list, and on matters in no level’s list, how taxes are levied and revenue collected is as the Government of Nepal decides.
Nepali: आर्थिक अधिकारक्षेत्र, their own financial jurisdiction (the translation says “respective competence”).
The Constitution also says no tax may be levied and collected in a Province except as a law provides ().
A matter is in the concurrent list. Who decides how taxes on it are levied and revenue collected?
Pick an answer to see why.
Sharing the revenue
The Government of Nepal arranges for the revenue it collects to be shared out fairly (न्यायोचित) among the Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels ().
How much money the Provinces and Local Levels receive as fiscal transfers (वित्तीय हस्तान्तरण) is as the National Natural Resources and Fiscal Commission recommends (). That Commission is set up by , and among its duties is recommending the equalization grants to the Provinces and Local Governments ().
Grants: equalization, conditional and special
then turns to grants. The first are fiscal equalization grants:
Fiscal equalization grants
The Constitution
(४) नेपाल सरकारले प्रदेश र स्थानीय तहलाई खर्चको आवश्यकता र राजस्वको क्षमताको आधारमा वित्तीय समानीकरण अनुदान वितरण गर्नेछ।
(4) The Government of Nepal shall, on the basis of the need of expenditure and revenue capacity, distribute fiscal equalization grants to Province and Local Level.
In plain words
The Government of Nepal gives fiscal equalization grants (वित्तीय समानीकरण अनुदान) to the Provinces and Local Levels, based on how much each needs to spend and how much revenue it is able to raise.
Each Province, in turn, gives fiscal equalization grants to the Local Levels within it, as provincial law sets out, out of the grants it gets from the Government of Nepal and the revenue from its own sources, also based on each Local Level’s need to spend and its ability to raise revenue ().
The Government of Nepal also gives, from the Federal Consolidated Fund, conditional grants, complementary grants or special grants for other purposes. How these are shared out is as federal law sets out (). A Rural Municipality’s or Municipality’s grants from the Government of Nepal and the Provincial Government go into its Local Consolidated Fund ().
How the sharing must be done
When revenue is shared among the Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels, it must be done in a balanced and transparent way ().
lists what the federal Act on sharing revenue must take into account. It is quoted whole here.
What the sharing must take into account
The Constitution
(८) राजस्व बाँडफाँड सम्बन्धी संघीय ऐन बनाउँदा राष्ट्रिय नीति, राष्ट्रिय आवश्यकता, प्रदेश र स्थानीय तहको स्वायत्तता, प्रदेश र स्थानीय तहले जनतालाई पुर्याउनु पर्ने सेवा र उनीहरूलाई प्रदान गरिएको आर्थिक अधिकार, राजस्व उठाउन सक्ने क्षमता, राजस्वको सम्भाव्यता र उपयोग, विकास निर्माणमा गर्नुपर्ने सहयोग, क्षेत्रीय असन्तुलन, गरीबी र असमानताको न्यूनीकरण, वञ्चितीकरणको अन्त्य, आकस्मिक कार्य र अस्थायी आवश्यकता पूरा गर्न सहयोग गर्नु पर्ने विषयहरूमा ध्यान दिनु पर्नेछ।
(8) In making a federal Act on the distribution of revenues, regard shall be had to the matters of national policies; national requirements; autonomy of the Province and Local Levels; services to be rendered by the Province and Local Level to the people and financial powers granted to them; capacity to collect revenues; potentiality and use of revenues; assistance to be made in development and construction; reduction of regional imbalances; poverty and inequality; end of deprivation; and assistance to be made in the performance of contingent works and fulfilment of temporary needs.
In plain words
When the federal Act on sharing revenue is made, it must take into account: national policy; national needs; the autonomy of the Provinces and Local Levels; the services they have to provide to the people, and the financial powers given to them; their capacity to raise revenue; the potential and use of revenue; the help needed for development and construction; reducing regional imbalance, poverty and inequality; ending deprivation; and the help needed for emergency work and to meet temporary needs.
Nepali: क्षेत्रीय असन्तुलन, गरीबी र असमानताको न्यूनीकरण, reducing regional imbalance, poverty and inequality (the translation reads “reduction of regional imbalances; poverty and inequality”).
What it means in your day
- The taxes your family pays. The municipality, the Province and the Government of Nepal may each levy taxes on the matters in their own financial powers; on the concurrent matters, and on matters in no level’s list, the Government of Nepal decides how taxes are levied ().
- Three budgets. The federal budget on the day fixes, and the Provinces’ and Local Levels’ budgets at the time federal law sets ().
- A project near you that uses natural resources. The area a project affects and its local communities must get a set part of its benefits, as royalty, services or goods, as a law sets out (), and a local community that wants to invest must be given priority to invest a share set by law ().
- Your municipality’s money. Besides its own revenue, a municipality receives grants from the Government of Nepal and from its Province ( to (6)), and these go into its Local Consolidated Fund ().
This page explains what the Constitution says. It is not legal advice.
Getting help
If you think your rights, or someone else’s, have been violated:
- National Human Rights Commission (राष्ट्रिय मानव अधिकार आयोग), set up by , takes complaints of human rights violations (). Its hotline is +977-1-5010000, open 24 hours, holidays too, and it takes complaints online at nhrcnepal.org.
- Free legal aid. gives any indigent party the right to free legal aid. Under the Legal Aid Act, 2054, every district has a District Legal Aid Committee (जिल्ला कानूनी सहायता समिति), chaired by the district’s government attorney, for people whose yearly income is below the amount the rules set, and for victims of gender-based violence or armed conflict.
- The courts. gives the right to apply to the High Court () or the Supreme Court () to enforce the fundamental rights. A lawyer can explain how.
Where these facts come from
- नेपालको संविधान, Nepal Law Commission: the official Nepali text, as amended up to the Second Amendment, 2077 (PDF of Bhadra 2081): the heading of Part 5, and Articles 59–60 (PDF pages 32–34), quoted and read for every number
- The Constitution of Nepal, Nepal Law Commission’s English translation, as amended up to the Second Amendment (PDF, 2024): Articles 59–60 (pages 35–37), quoted; Articles 57, 119, 203, 229, 250 and 251, read
- कानूनी सहायता सम्बन्धी ऐन, २०५४ (Legal Aid Act), Nepal Law Commission: sections 2, 3 and 7, for Getting help
- National Human Rights Commission, Nepal: hotline and online complaints, for Getting help
