← Checking What You Hear, in Practice
Health claims · 44 of 73
Ask “compared with what?”
Expert guidance
Do this
- Hear “better”, “faster”, “stronger”? Ask “compared with what?”
- Ask what would have happened with no treatment, or with the usual one.
- Look for a fair test: two similar groups, treated differently, with the results compared.
- None was done? Then nobody knows yet, including the person selling it.
Why it works
Unless a treatment is compared with something else, the Informed Health Choices guide says, you can’t know what would have happened without it. It says to ask “compared to what?” whenever you meet a word like “better”. That goes for tablets, herbs, diets and exercises alike, old or new, and for treatments called too special to test. Expert guidance, from researchers who teach this in schools.
Try it today
Find one health claim with “better” or “faster” in it. Can you find what it’s compared with? Three minutes.
For example
A shampoo ad says “90% less hair fall”. Sarita asks, “Less than what, on how many people, for how long?” The ad doesn’t say.
Where these facts come from
- Oxman, A. D. and others, Informed Health Choices Key Concepts, Informed Health Choices Group, 2022.
- That’s a Claim!, Centre for Informed Health Choices and others.
General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.
