Skip to content

← Checking What You Hear, in Practice

Health claims · 43 of 73

Treat a cure story as a story

Official advice

Do this

  1. Hear “it cured my aunt”? Be kind, and be glad for her.
  2. Then ask: what else was she doing? Would she have got better anyway?
  3. How many took it and didn’t get better? Those people don’t make videos.
  4. Ask whether anyone has tested it on many people, with a fair comparison.

Why it works

The US Food and Drug Administration calls testimonials “the weakest form of scientific validity”: they’re hard to check, and can be hearsay or made up. Honest stories can mislead too. The Informed Health Choices guide says not to assume that personal experience alone is enough, or that a treatment is good because many people use it. It doesn’t show that the story’s wrong, only that it can’t settle the matter. Official advice.

Try it today

Next time someone recommends a remedy, ask gently, “Did it help everyone who tried it?” One minute.

Where these facts come from

General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.

← All 73 small things