On 25 June 2002 WorldCom, a large American telephone company, told the world that its accounts for the past five quarters were wrong. Its own internal auditors had found that $3.852 billion of ordinary running costs had been written into the books as if they were things the company had bought to keep. The costs were what WorldCom paid other telephone companies to carry its calls over their lines, as everyday a cost for a telephone company as rent is for a shop. Moved out of the costs and in among the company’s equipment, they stopped counting against its profit. For 2001 WorldCom had reported a profit before tax of $2.393 billion. With the costs put back where they belonged, the year was a loss of about $662 million.
Nobody had invented any money. Every dollar of it had really been spent. The trick was only in which kind of spending it was called. And that is a question every set of books has to answer many times a year, in Yasmin’s paint shop as much as in a telephone company: when money goes out, is it gone, or has it bought something that is still there?
Two kinds of money out
Early in मङ्सिर, with the Tihar rush over and builders asking for paint to be brought to their sites, Yasmin buys a delivery scooter for Rs. 240,000. The same month she fills its tank, again and again, for about Rs. 3,500. Both are money out of the shop. But at the end of the year the fuel is gone, burnt on the road to building sites, and the scooter is standing at the door, ready for next year’s deliveries.
That is the whole difference, and accountants give it two names. Spending that buys or improves something the business will use for more than a year is capital expenditure, पुँजीगत खर्च. Spending that keeps the business running from day to day, used up within the year, is revenue expenditure, आयगत खर्च. The scooter is capital expenditure. The fuel, the month’s rent, the helper’s wages, the electricity and the paint bought to be sold again are revenue expenditure.
The two go to different places in the books, and that is why the difference matters. Revenue expenditure is a cost of this year. It goes into an expense account, and at the year’s end it is taken away from the year’s income to find the profit. Capital expenditure is not a cost of this year, or not all of it. It goes into an asset account, the scooter account, and it appears among the things the shop owns. Only a share of it is counted as a cost each year, for as many years as the scooter lasts; how big a share is the next chapter’s question.
The reason is the matching rule, the one that makes a year’s profit mean something. The scooter will carry paint to customers for years, and help earn the money of every one of them. To charge its whole price against the year it was bought, and nothing against the years after, would make the first year look much worse than it was and every later year look better.
What a fixed asset is, and what it costs
The things that capital expenditure buys are fixed assets, स्थिर सम्पत्ति: things a business keeps to use, year after year, not to sell. They come in several kinds. There is land, which doesn’t wear out. There are buildings, machines and equipment, vehicles, and furniture and fittings. There are things that can’t be touched at all, a patent, a copyright, a trademark, the right to use a piece of software. And there are buildings and works still under construction, not yet finished but already the business’s. The international standard for the solid ones calls them property, plant and equipment, and asks only two things of them: they are held for use in the business, and they are expected to be used for more than one year.
They also have some things in common. They are bought to be used for a long time, not sold. They usually cost a lot. Everything but land wears out, and loses value as it is used. They need looking after, a repair here and a service there. And each has a useful life, a stretch of years it can be expected to work, after which it is worn out or out of date.
What goes into the asset account is not just the price on the dealer’s bill. It is everything it cost to get the thing to the shop and ready to work. Carriage, wages for putting it in, insurance on the way, customs duty, installation, trial runs and registration fees are all added to the asset’s own account. The international standard says the same in its own words: the purchase price, with import duties and taxes that can’t be claimed back, less any trade discount, and every cost directly needed to bring it to where it will be used and make it work.
Yasmin’s shop shows how it goes. In her second week, on साउन 10, she buys steel racks for her paint tins. The supplier’s bill is Rs. 62,000. A truck brings them for Rs. 3,000, and a carpenter takes two days to bolt them to the walls, for Rs. 5,000. Without the truck and the carpenter the racks would be no use to her, so the books treat all three as the price of the racks:
| Date | Particulars | L.F. | Debit Rs. | Credit Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| साउन 10 | Racks a/c Dr. | 70,000 | ||
| To Cash a/c | 70,000 | |||
| (Being steel racks bought, carried and fitted, as per the bills) |
The truck that brought the racks is part of the racks’ cost. The truck that brings Sujan’s paint every week is not, since that paint is for sale: it is carriage on purchases, a revenue expense. Same truck, same driver, different job.
The scooter, too, is debited to an account of its own, not to purchases, since it isn’t for sale. Its Rs. 240,000 is everything Yasmin paid to get it on the road, the dealer’s price with the registration and number plate he arranged. She pays Rs. 100,000 by cheque, from the bank account the festival weeks had filled, and the dealer, Kushal, agrees to wait three months for the rest. An asset bought on credit is one of the entries that go in the journal proper:
| Date | Particulars | L.F. | Debit Rs. | Credit Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| मङ्सिर 10 | Delivery scooter a/c Dr. | 240,000 | ||
| To Bank a/c | 100,000 | |||
| To Kushal a/c | 140,000 | |||
| (Being a scooter bought from Kushal, the rest due in three months) |
Not everything spent around a new asset belongs to it, though. The standard is clear that the costs of opening a new branch, of launching a new product, of general office work, belong to the year, even when they come at the same time as a big purchase. And once the thing is in place and working, adding to its cost stops.
The scooter’s year
Over the rest of the year the scooter costs Yasmin money again and again, and each payment has to be sorted.
| What | When | Rs. | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel, about Rs. 3,500 a month | मङ्सिर to असार | 28,000 | revenue |
| Insurance to the year’s end | मङ्सिर | 2,800 | revenue |
| Two services | फागुन, जेठ | 3,000 | revenue |
| A new rear tyre, the old one cut on a building site | असार | 2,600 | revenue |
| 36,400 |
All of it is revenue expenditure, even the tyre, which will outlast the year. The test isn’t only how long a thing lasts. It is what the spending does. Fuel, insurance, servicing and a damaged tyre replaced all keep the scooter doing what it did on the day it was bought. None of them makes it a better scooter. Spending that keeps an asset working is revenue expenditure; spending that adds to it, makes it bigger, lets it do more, or makes it last longer than it would have is capital expenditure. Had Yasmin paid to have a steel carrier box fitted to the back, so that the scooter took eight tins instead of four, that would have been added to the scooter’s account.
The classic pair comes from a factory: painting a factory building is a revenue expense, an addition to a machine is capital. The wages to install a new machine are capital, the repairs to an old one are revenue. Interest on a loan the business has taken is revenue expenditure too, the cost of borrowing for this year.
Some cases sit on the line, and here the rules can’t do all the work for you. Replacing the scooter’s engine, after many years, might count as capital, a new part that will give years of use. A new roof on an old building is a familiar argument. And very small things get the simplest sensible treatment: a Rs. 300 measuring tape may last three years, but nobody opens an asset account for it.
Getting it wrong
It is easy to see what goes wrong when the two kinds are mixed up, and this is the part of the subject that matters most.
Suppose Yasmin wrote the scooter into an expense account, as if it were fuel. The books would still balance. But this year’s profit would come out lower by nearly the whole Rs. 240,000, less only the share of the scooter that the year ought to carry anyway. The shop’s list of what it owns would leave the scooter out entirely, though it stands at the door. And next year, and the year after, the profit would come out a little higher than it should, since the scooter’s share of cost would never be charged against those years at all. The years would all be wrong, the first by a lot and the others by a little, in the opposite direction.
Now suppose the other mistake. Yasmin, pleased with her scooter, writes everything she spends on it into the scooter account: the fuel, the insurance, the services and the tyre, Rs. 36,400 in all. This year’s profit now comes out higher by nearly the whole Rs. 36,400, because those costs have left the costs, and only a small slice of them comes back as the scooter’s yearly share. And the scooter is in the books at Rs. 276,400, worth more on paper than she paid for it, with a heap of burnt fuel counted as part of it.
That is an error of principle, the kind a trial balance can’t catch, since every debit has its credit. It is also the mistake WorldCom made on purpose.
In the boom years WorldCom had signed long leases on other companies’ lines, expecting far more traffic than ever came. Much of the capacity sat unused, and the bills for it kept arriving. For more than a year, on the orders of its chief financial officer, Scott Sullivan, accountants at the company’s offices in Mississippi made large journal entries, in round sums of hundreds of millions of dollars, that took these line costs out of the expense accounts and put them into asset accounts, among them the account for construction still in progress, with no bills or papers behind them. Sullivan later argued that the costs were for capacity bought ahead of need, and should wait, like the scooter’s cost, until that capacity earned money. That was the matching rule, turned upside down. The investigators the company’s board appointed called the accounting wrong, and “not even a close call”: a payment for using someone else’s lines this quarter buys nothing that lasts. In the first three months of 2002 alone the move turned a loss of about $557 million into a reported profit of $240 million.
It was found by people inside who kept asking. Cynthia Cooper ran WorldCom’s internal audit department, the people the company itself paid to check its own workings. In the spring of 2002 her team started a new audit of capital spending. Sullivan asked them to put it off; they carried on. One of them, going through the accounts, noticed the huge round-sum entries, which were easy to spot because nothing ordinary looks like them. In the middle of June Cooper and a colleague went from office to office asking what the entries were for. The accountant who had made one didn’t know, and her bosses had no papers to show. Within days the matter was before the board’s audit committee, and five days after that the company told the world. Less than a month later WorldCom was in bankruptcy, and tens of thousands of people lost their jobs. The digging went on for months, and in the end the investigators counted more than $9 billion of false entries of all kinds. How the fraud was hidden for so long, and what happened to the people behind it, belongs to a later chapter.
What made the trick attractive is plain from Yasmin’s scooter. A cost moved into an asset account doesn’t disappear; it reappears among the things a business owns, and only a slice of it comes back as a cost each year. So the profit rises at once, and the balance sheet looks richer. Investors reading such accounts see a company that is both profitable and investing in its future. WorldCom looked exactly that.
Money in, gains and losses
The same line runs through money coming in. A revenue receipt, आयगत प्राप्ति, comes from the business’s ordinary work: sales, a commission, interest on a deposit, a discount received for paying a bill early. It is income, and it goes into the year’s profit. A capital receipt, पुँजीगत प्राप्ति, comes from somewhere else: money the owner puts in, a loan, the money from selling a fixed asset. On the morning the shop opened, Rs. 500,000 came in, Rs. 300,000 of Yasmin’s savings and Rs. 200,000 from the bank. Not a rupee of it was income. Had the books counted the bank loan as income, the shop would have made a profit of Rs. 200,000 before it sold a tin.
Selling a fixed asset brings in a capital receipt, and it can also bring a gain or a loss. Suppose that some years from now Yasmin sells her old scooter. The money she gets is a capital receipt. Whether she gains or loses on it depends on what the scooter is worth in her books by then, its cost less the share already counted as cost over the years: if she sells it for more than that, the difference is a gain, a capital profit, पुँजीगत नाफा, and if for less, a loss, a capital loss, पुँजीगत नोक्सान. A revenue profit, by contrast, comes from the shop’s trading, from selling paint for more than it cost. A revenue loss comes from the trade too, such as goods damaged on the way or sold below cost. The international standard puts a gain or loss on selling a fixed asset into the year’s profit, but never counts a gain as sales: it isn’t what the business is for, and a reader should be able to see that this year’s profit came partly from selling off an old scooter. The traditional profit and loss account gives it a line of its own, “Profit on sale of fixed assets”.
Businesses, especially companies, keep part of their profit back, in what are called reserves, जगेडा. A reserve built from capital profits, a capital reserve, is usually kept in the business rather than paid out to the owners, since it didn’t come from the trade the business lives on. A revenue reserve is built from ordinary trading profit and can be paid out in a later year if the owners choose. Reserves, and what is done with them, come back at the year’s end and again with companies.
Last, there is a kind of spending that seems to sit between the two. Before Tihar, in असोज, Yasmin paid Rs. 18,000 for advertisements on the local FM radio. The customers they brought in may keep coming for years. Older accounting books call such a large cost with long-lasting benefit deferred revenue expenditure, स्थगित आयगत खर्च, and spread it over a few years, Rs. 6,000 a year for three years, say. Nepal’s school books still teach it, with the costs of starting a company and of research as its other examples. The international standards, which Nepal’s own follow, are stricter. Advertising, the costs of starting up a business, training staff and research are all counted as costs of the year they are spent in, because nobody can show what exactly they bought or how long it will last. So in accounts that follow the standards, Yasmin’s Rs. 18,000 is all this year’s cost. The old term is still worth knowing, because older accounts are full of it, and because the urge behind it, to make a good year look better by pushing a cost into the future, is the same urge that drove WorldCom.
Nepal’s government divides its spending the same way. Its budget has current spending, चालु खर्च, on salaries, fuel and the running of offices, and capital spending, पुँजीगत खर्च, on roads, bridges, buildings and machines, and in the government’s list of accounts every heading of current spending has a code beginning with 2 and every heading of capital spending one beginning with 31. How those accounts are kept is a story for the government’s books, later on.
The idea in this chapter is a small one with a long reach. Every rupee a business spends is either used up now or buys something that will go on working, and the books keep the two apart. Spending used up in the year is revenue expenditure, a cost taken from this year’s income. Spending that buys or improves a fixed asset is capital expenditure, recorded at everything it took to get the asset working, and counted as a cost only a share at a time, over the years that use it. Repairs keep a thing as it was and are revenue; improvements make it more and are capital. Money in is sorted the same way, so that a loan is never income. Mixing them up leaves the books balanced and the profit wrong, in one direction or the other, and in the hands of someone who means it, that is enough to fool a whole market.
Found a mistake? Please tell us.
