Skip to content

← Working Together, in Practice

Meetings · 37 of 161

Ask one person to argue against the plan

Some evidence

Do this

  1. When a plan seems settled, say: “Dawa, your job is to tell us why this might fail.”
  2. Listen. Nobody defends the plan for two minutes.
  3. Fix what’s worth fixing.
  4. Next time, pick someone else, so it’s a role and not a person’s nature.
  5. Someone already really disagrees? Hear them first. A real doubt beats an act.

Why it helps

Janis suggested a “devil’s advocate” to guard against groups agreeing too easily, with a different person each meeting. Some evidence: there’s support for it in group problem solving, but critics note that people who honestly disagree are more effective than people arguing a side they don’t hold.

Try it today

In your next plan, ask a friend to find one hole in it. Three minutes.

Where these facts come from

General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.

← All 161 small things