← Working Together, in Practice
Meetings · 37 of 161
Ask one person to argue against the plan
Some evidence
Do this
- When a plan seems settled, say: “Dawa, your job is to tell us why this might fail.”
- Listen. Nobody defends the plan for two minutes.
- Fix what’s worth fixing.
- Next time, pick someone else, so it’s a role and not a person’s nature.
- Someone already really disagrees? Hear them first. A real doubt beats an act.
Why it helps
Janis suggested a “devil’s advocate” to guard against groups agreeing too easily, with a different person each meeting. Some evidence: there’s support for it in group problem solving, but critics note that people who honestly disagree are more effective than people arguing a side they don’t hold.
Try it today
In your next plan, ask a friend to find one hole in it. Three minutes.
Where these facts come from
- Groupthink, Wikipedia.
General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.
