Skip to content

← Money

Enough

Chapter 35 · A Whole Life

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. Time, or one more thing
  2. The line that moves
  3. Luck
  4. A jar of coins
  5. The Ledger, whole

In 1978 three researchers went looking for people whose wishes had come true. They found 22 who had won big prizes in a lottery, and asked them how happy they were and how much pleasure they took in the small, ordinary things of a day. They asked the same of 22 people who hadn’t won, and set the answers beside those of 29 people who had been paralyzed in accidents. The winners were no happier than the people who hadn’t won. And they took less pleasure in the ordinary things, just as the researchers had expected: next to the day of the win, ordinary pleasures paled.

It is a small study, and part of why it is famous is that it sounds so unlikely. Bigger studies since have softened it. In Sweden, researchers surveyed a large group of lottery players between 5 and 22 years after a big win, and compared them with players much like them who hadn’t won. The winners were more satisfied with their lives, and the difference lasted more than a decade without fading. Their answers to how happy they were, and to questions about how they had felt over the past two weeks, had changed far less.

So both things are true, and the space between them is where this last chapter begins. Money changes how people judge their lives. It seems to change much less how the days feel. Which leaves the question this whole book has been circling without asking out loud: what is money for, and how would anyone know when they had enough?

The answer this book gives is plain, and a little dull. Money is for carrying a life through its lumps. It arrives mostly in the middle of a life and is needed every day from the first to the last, so it has to be moved: forward by saving, back by borrowing, sideways by insurance. Nearly everything else, the bank account, the EMI, the policy, the share, the pension, is one of those three moves made in a particular way, with its own price and its own risks.

Britain has a public body for money guidance, the Money and Pensions Service, and it describes what it calls financial wellbeing as feeling secure and in control, in three parts: making the most of your money from day to day, dealing with the unexpected, and being on track for a healthy financial future. Those are the same three jobs in other words. Day to day is the month’s budget. The unexpected is the fund for surprises and the insurance. The future is everything moved forward. The sentence doesn’t mention being rich. It doesn’t mention a car, a bigger house or doing better than anyone else.

Time, or one more thing

Once those jobs are done, money left over can buy two very different things. It can buy one more thing: a phone a year newer, a bigger wedding, a car. Or, if it stays unspent, it buys time, the choice of when to work, how much, and for whom.

Morgan Housel, an American who writes about money, thinks the second is the most useful thing money does, and the most overlooked. He tells it through his father, an emergency room doctor, which he calls one of the most stressful jobs in medicine. His parents saved a large share of what they earned, for years, while colleagues lived in bigger houses, drove nicer cars and sent their children to better schools. After about twenty years his father had had enough of the work, and because of those savings he could stop, on the day he chose. The colleagues, Housel says, were just as worn out, and couldn’t: they needed another ten years. Money you have and haven’t spent, he says, “becomes the most valuable thing in the world when it lets you gain control of your time.” He calls that as close as it gets to a universal law of money. It is his view, drawn from his family and his reading, not a measured result.

The research that does measure things points the same way, more cautiously. The World Happiness Report ranks countries every year by a single question, put by the polling company Gallup to about a thousand people in each country: imagine a ladder with steps from 0 at the bottom to 10 at the top, the top being the best possible life for you and the bottom the worst; on which step do you stand now? The report then tries to explain why countries differ, and six things account for more than three-quarters of the differences: income per person, healthy years of life, having someone to count on, generosity, freedom from corruption, and freedom to make life’s choices. The report says plainly that these go together and are not proof of what causes what. Still, only one of the six is money, and one is freedom.

A smaller study tested time against things directly. Researchers asked more than 6,000 people in the United States, Canada, Denmark and the Netherlands how they spent their money, and found that those who paid for services that saved them time were more satisfied with their lives. Then, in an experiment, working adults reported being happier after spending money on something that saved them time than after spending it on a thing.

In Nepal the same idea has a homelier shape. A fund for surprises means a broken phone doesn’t become a loan from a moneylender. Savings can mean turning down a job abroad with a bad contract, or waiting a season for a better one. A family with no debt decides for itself what a ceremony costs. None of this can be seen from the street. Housel’s line for it is that wealth is what you don’t see: the car not bought, the money still in the bank.

The line that moves

The best-known attempt to put a number on enough came in 2010, from Daniel Kahneman and Angus Deaton. They looked at more than 450,000 answers to a daily Gallup survey of Americans, and split happiness in two, the same split the lottery studies point to. One part was how people judged their lives when they stopped to think about them, the ladder question. The other was how their days felt: the joy, worry, sadness and anger of yesterday. The judgment rose steadily with income. The feelings of the day rose too, then stopped rising at about $75,000 a year. High income, they concluded, buys satisfaction with life but not happiness, and low income makes every misfortune, a divorce, an illness, being alone, hurt more.

Eleven years later Matthew Killingsworth, at the University of Pennsylvania, who had used a phone app to ask working Americans at random moments how they felt, published more than a million of those moments. He found the feelings kept rising past $80,000, as steeply above it as below. So the two best-known answers disagreed. Rather than leave it there, Kahneman and Killingsworth worked on it together, with a third researcher as referee, and found that both were right about different people. For the least happy 15 to 20 percent of people, feelings rise with income and then flatten, at about $100,000 a year. For everyone else they go on rising. The older questions, yes or no about yesterday, couldn’t tell a good day from a very good one, so they had mostly measured unhappiness. Killingsworth’s own summary: “Money is not the secret to happiness, but it can probably help a bit.”

Two things about these numbers matter more than the numbers. They are American incomes in dollars, far above what almost anyone in Nepal earns, and they say nothing about where Nepal’s lines bend. And in all three studies, the rise comes with each doubling of income, not each rupee. Put in rupees, with made-up incomes and only as an illustration, going from Rs. 20,000 a month to Rs. 40,000 would add about as much as going from Rs. 2 lakh to Rs. 4 lakh. The first rupees do the most, which is why poverty weighs so heavily, and why one more thing at the top adds so little.

The doubling has to be won again and again, partly because people get used to what they have. Psychologists call it hedonic adaptation: a new phone, a raise, a bigger room is a joy for a while and then simply the way things are. It isn’t total. Later work found that people settle back to different levels, that some changes in life move those levels for good, and that how satisfied people are with their lives and how their days feel can move separately, as the lottery winners’ did. But enough of it is real that the thing bought last year rarely feels like enough this year.

The other reason is comparison. A study of Americans that matched people’s answers with the average earnings where they lived found that people whose neighbors earned more reported being less happy, even when their own income was the same. Nepal’s word for spending to keep up, देखासिकी, is about the spending; this is about the feeling, and it needs no shop at all, only someone nearby with more. Housel calls getting the goalposts to stop moving the single most important thing in money, and the hardest, and says he and his wife struggle with it as much as anyone. Enough is simply the point where the goalposts stop. Nobody can set it for someone else, and nobody reaches it by earning more if it moves every time they do.

Luck

Housel once asked the economist Robert Shiller what he would most like to know about investing that can’t be known. Shiller’s answer: “The exact role of luck in successful outcomes.”

Across the world, much of what people earn is settled before they do anything at all. Branko Milanović, in a study of the world’s incomes, gave each of the world’s people just two things almost nobody chooses, the country they live in and how that country’s income is shared out among its people, and found that those two alone account for more than half of the differences in income across the world. Whether you call that luck or not, it isn’t earned.

Then come the smaller pieces. Sabina got her first job at 19 in an office with a payslip, and from that month a slice of her pay was saved for her by law, with her employer adding more. Pasang, who lays tiles and is paid by the job, has nobody saving for him and no cover if he falls. She didn’t work harder for that. She found that office and he found his trade. Good fortune and bad come by the same door, too. The flood that takes one field and spares the next, the illness, the market that falls just as someone must sell, the scam that happens to call on the worst day: risk and luck, Housel says, are two sides of one coin. Both are the simple fact that sometimes things happen that matter more than effort.

Seeing this is a reason to be careful. If part of anyone’s success was luck, then copying the winners copies their skill but can’t copy their luck. A plan that works only if nothing goes wrong is a plan that needs luck, which is why room for error, the fund for surprises and the cover against the rare disaster, matters even when things are going well.

It is also a reason to be kind. After his son was born, Housel wrote him a letter, and part of it reads: “not all success is due to hard work, and not all poverty is due to laziness. Keep this in mind when judging people, including yourself.” Every chapter of this book has tried to see each choice from where the person making it stands: grandmother’s gold, an uncle’s loan to go abroad, a neighbor’s ढुकुटी. Luck is the last reason why. Most people are doing the best they can with the hand they were given, and the hand was not theirs to choose.

A jar of coins

Sabina is 70 now, and like everything about her this is made up. Her granddaughter Diya, who is nine and made up too, has found a glass jar at the back of a shelf, heavy with old coins.

It is the jar Sabina started at 15, when her pocket money came from her mother Anshu’s tea shop and her month’s page first put something aside. The coins went in before she spent anything else, which was the first time she moved money forward, though she didn’t know the words then. Later she had a bank account, a payslip and a pension fund, and the jar was never needed. She kept it anyway.

They count it on the floor, in piles of ten. It comes to a little over a thousand rupees. Diya wants to know what it will buy, and the honest answer is: much less than when the coins went in. Each one is the same coin it was, the same size and the same metal. Prices have climbed the whole time, a few percent a year, and the coins sat still.

“So it was a waste?” Diya asks.

Sabina thinks about it. The coins bought nothing. But the habit they started did: the fund that turned a broken phone into an annoyance instead of a debt, the pension that arrives every month now that her own wage doesn’t, the years she could choose her work, and the evening she was able to say no to a loan she didn’t like the look of. The jar was the smallest part of all that, and the first.

Diya asks whether she is rich. Sabina says she has enough. Diya asks how much enough is, and Sabina says she couldn’t have told her at 15, or at 40, because the number kept moving. It stopped when she stopped moving it.

Then she tips the coins back into the jar and gives it to Diya, who puts it on her own shelf.

The Ledger, whole

The Ledger has been there since the second chapter, and this is its last look, on one year’s real figures for Nepal. The line of what is spent on a person barely moves from the early twenties to the end. The line of what people earn by their own work climbs late and falls early, and is above the other only from 27 to 46. Every move in this book lives somewhere on that picture: the twenty years in the middle carry money to both ends.

Try it

The Ledger, whole

Nepal, 2021/22: spent on each person and earned by their own work, on average, by age; each point is everyone of that age in one year.

0501001502000153045607590ageRs. thousand a yearearned by workspent oneach person
Spent on each person
Rs. 139,585
Earned by their own work
Rs. 19,853
Paid from elsewhere
Rs. 119,732

At 15, others carry the gap: family and the state.

Sabina’s life sits on those two lines like everyone else’s: the tea shop’s coins at the start, the payslip in the middle, the pension at the end, and a jar that is now on Diya’s shelf. How much of the middle to send forward, how much to borrow back, what to cover, and where to say enough is a different answer for every life, and nobody else’s answer is the right one for yours. This book has tried to explain how each of these things works and why it exists. What to do with any of it was always yours to decide.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.