Skip to content

← Money

Earning

Chapter 3 · Coming In

In this chapter 5 sections
  1. Three ways money comes in
  2. Every month, or when it comes
  3. Why some work pays more
  4. School as a bet
  5. Try this

In 1995/96, when the government’s survey teams went from house to house across Nepal asking families where their money came from, six rupees in every ten turned out to come from the family’s own fields and animals. In 2022/23 their successors asked again, visiting homes for a whole year from July to June. This time the farm brought in less than one rupee in six.

The fields hadn’t gone anywhere. Other money had arrived beside them. Wages and salaries were now the biggest single source, about a third of everything. Money sent home by a family member living somewhere else had grown from something a quarter of households received to something more than three quarters did. A shop, a workshop or some other small business brought in a tenth. Put together, the picture is of a country where most families get their money from several places at once, and where the places have changed within one lifetime.

Wages and salaries33.1%The family’s own farm16.8%Money sent home16.5%Rent not paid on a home you own12.0%A shop or other business10.4%Other: allowances, pensions, interest9.8%Rent from a room, house or land1.4%
Figure 3.1 Where the income of Nepal’s households came from in 2022/23, as shares of the whole. Green is money earned by the family’s own work, blue is money sent home by a member living elsewhere (in Nepal or abroad, less what the family sent out), amber comes from what a family owns, and gray is everything else. The 12% for a home you own is not money that arrives: the survey counts the rent the family doesn’t have to pay.

That last bar is the odd one, and it says something about how statisticians think. A family that owns its house is better off than an identical family paying rent, by exactly the rent. So the survey counts it, as if the family paid the rent to itself. No rupee changes hands, yet leaving it out would make every owner look poorer than they are.

Where money comes from matters. A rupee of wages and a rupee of rent buy the same plate of momo, but they arrive differently and stop for different reasons. This chapter is about the lump of money that Chapter 2 said has to be carried through a life: where it comes from in the first place, why it comes so unevenly, and why some people’s work brings in so much more than others’.

Three ways money comes in

Nearly every rupee a person receives arrives in one of three ways. It is earned by work. It is earned by something the person owns. Or it is given.

Work comes first, and for most people it is nearly everything. A wage is pay for time: so much a day, or so much an hour. A salary is the same idea paid by the month, usually for a job that is expected to go on. Some work is paid by the piece or by the job, so much a sack carried or a wall built. In Nepali these are ज्याला (a day’s wage) and तलब (a salary), and the difference is more than a word. A salary arrives on a known day. A day’s wage arrives only on the days there is work.

Then there is work for yourself, which is how a farm, a tea shop or a tailoring business earns. Here the money that comes in is not the income. Sabina’s mother Anshu might take Rs. 4,000 at her tea shop on a good day, but she has paid for milk, sugar, tea leaves, gas and the rent of the shop out of that. What’s left after the costs is the shop’s profit, and that is the family’s income from it. The survey works it out the same way, revenue less costs, for every farm and every business. A busy shop can earn less than a quiet one if its costs are higher, which is why someone who works for themselves has to count what goes out as carefully as what comes in.

The second way is income from what you own. A room or a field can be rented out. Money in a bank earns interest, which Chapter 2 called the price of moving money forward. A share in a company may pay a dividend, a slice of its profits. This is money earning money, or a thing earning money, with no one having to turn up for work that day. For most households in Nepal it is a small part of the whole. Rent from a room, a house or land came to 1.4% of household income in 2022/23. Interest and dividends sit inside the “other” bar, beside pensions and allowances. The survey didn’t even try to count the interest people earn by lending to each other, because its questions couldn’t tell how much of what came back was interest and how much was the loan itself. Income from what you own needs something owned first, and that is what saving builds. It’s the reason Parts 4 and 7 of this book exist.

The third way is money that is given. Pocket money is given. So is the दक्षिणा (dakshina) that elders give with the tika at Dashain. A pension or the government’s allowance for the old is given too, though a pension is often the giver’s own pay, set aside years before and returned. And money sent home is given, though it was earned by someone’s hard work far away. In 2022/23 the average household that received it got about Rs. 1.45 lakh in the year. Money given is real income for the one who gets it. What makes it different is that the person receiving it can’t make more of it by trying harder.

Sabina, at 15, lives almost entirely on the third kind. Her pocket money comes from Anshu’s profit. Her Dashain money comes from her uncles and grandparents. Nepal Rastra Bank, in its plan for teaching people about money, puts students like her in a group of their own, dependents, which is a polite word for people whose money comes from someone else. That is how it should be at 15, and the law agrees. Nepal’s child labor law, as amended, calls everyone under 18 a child. Nobody under 14 may be employed as a worker at all. A child of 14 or more may be, but never in the risky work the law lists, never at night, and only for limited hours, set out in the box at the end. The Constitution says no child may be put to work in a factory, a mine or anything as dangerous. And the law on children says that parents and family must not make a child work in a way that harms their schooling, health or growing up. Helping in the family shop after school is not what these laws are aimed at. Being kept from school to work is.

The law and the country don’t yet match. In 2017/18, the last time it was measured, about 1.1 million of Nepal’s seven million children aged 5 to 17 were in what the survey counted as child labor, nearly nine in ten of them in farming. In the countryside it was about one child in five, in towns about one in eight.

Every month, or when it comes

Sabina’s mother earns from her shop, and her shop earns from customers, and customers don’t come evenly. Some weeks are good. Some, in the rains or after a festival has emptied people’s pockets, are not. Her income is what Nepal Rastra Bank calls irregular. The bank sorts the country’s earners into those with a regular income, mainly people on a salary in a company, an office or the government, and those without one: farmers, people running small businesses, daily wage workers, and people about to go abroad for work. The second group is most of Nepal.

The numbers make it plain. Of the people who did paid work for someone else in 2022/23, nearly two thirds were paid by the day. On average they found 72 days of such work in the whole year. Those days paid about Rs. 600 each in cash, and less than Rs. 55,000 in the year from that kind of work. Someone on a monthly salary earned, on average, about Rs. 2.9 lakh. Part of that gap is the pay for each day, but much of it is simply the days. A daily wage is only as good as the number of mornings someone needs you. For women the count was lower still: 43 days on average, against 91 for men.

Most of this work is informal, which here means it carries no social security, and so nothing to fall back on if it stops. Of about 3.8 million people working for wages in 2018, nearly 3.3 million had jobs of that kind.

Irregular income makes everything harder, and not because the people living on it are careless. The costs of living arrive every day. Rice, rent and school fees don’t wait for a good week. So a family with an uneven income has to keep some of each good week for the bad ones, which takes a discipline that a salaried person never needs. When a bad week comes before the money is put by, they borrow, and they borrow at exactly the moment when they have the least bargaining power. A lender asks how the loan will be repaid, and “when there is work” is not an answer that gets a good rate. Planning is harder too: it’s easy to make a monthly budget when the month’s money is known, and much harder when it isn’t.

Families have their own answer to this, and it’s a sensible one. They spread their income across sources that don’t all fail together. A household might have a field, a son working in Malaysia, a daughter on a daily wage in the nearest town and a mother selling vegetables at the weekly market. If the harvest is poor, the money from abroad still comes. If the money from abroad is late, there is still rice. The survey found that wealthier households spread their income across even more kinds of source, adding businesses and rent. What can look from outside like a muddle of small earnings is often a family protecting itself against any one of them stopping.

Adam Smith noticed something about uneven work in 1776, in The Wealth of Nations, the book that more or less began economics. Masons and bricklayers in Britain, he wrote, couldn’t work in frost or foul weather and were often without customers, so they were paid half as much again as an ordinary laborer, sometimes double, for each day they did work. Their trade was easy to learn. Their high day’s pay, he thought, was a payment for the idle days, and for the worry of not knowing when the next job would come. That is the way it ought to work: work that comes and goes should pay more for each day, to make up for the days without it. Nepal’s day laborers show it doesn’t always happen. When there are many more people looking for work than there is work to give, nobody has to pay extra for the uncertainty. That leads to the larger question of why any work pays what it does.

Why some work pays more

Adam Smith listed five reasons why one job pays more than another, and two and a half centuries later they still describe most of it.

The first is how pleasant the work is. Dirty, dangerous or disliked work has to pay more to find anyone willing to do it. Smith’s starkest example was the public executioner, the most hated job of his day, which was paid more for the work done than any ordinary trade. The reverse is true too. Work that people enjoy, or that brings respect, pays less than it otherwise would, because people line up to do it anyway.

The second is how long and costly the work is to learn. A doctor spends years training, unpaid, and pays for it. If being a doctor paid no more than a job anyone could start tomorrow, few would bother.

The third is the one already met: how steady the work is.

The fourth is trust. People who handle other people’s money, health or legal affairs are paid more, Smith said, because they have to be people others are willing to trust with them.

The fifth is the chance of success. In some careers a few do very well and many never earn much at all. Smith’s example was the law: for every young man who studied it and made a living, he reckoned, about twenty never did, and the one who succeeded was paid as if for all of them. He called it a lottery.

Behind all five is a simpler idea, which Economics, for the Curious takes further. Pay is high where what someone can do is wanted by many and offered by few. A heart surgeon is rare and needed. A plain day’s digging is something many people can offer. In Nepal the spread is wide. In 2022/23 people working as managers earned on average about Rs. 8.2 lakh a year in wages, and people in the simplest jobs, carrying, cleaning and laboring, about Rs. 49,000.

Some of the differences are less obvious. In 2018, a worker on a construction site earned about a third more than a similar worker doing farm work for wages, even though building work needs little training: building was booming and farming wasn’t. A worker in a formal job, one with social security, earned about a third more than a similar person doing the same kind of work informally. Place matters as much as skill. A day laborer in Bagmati Province found 82 days of work in 2022/23, one in Karnali only 38. And a cleaner in Qatar in 2018 earned at least about Rs. 28,000 a month, more than many school teachers in Nepal at the time.

And some of the difference is simply unfair. A man in Nepal in 2018 earned about 26% more a month than a woman with the same education, age and kind of job. Part of that is hours, since women had less time for paid work after the work at home that fell mostly to them. Counted by the hour, the gap was still about 16%. Smith’s five reasons explain a great deal about pay. They don’t explain that.

School as a bet

Every extra year of school or training is a bet. You pay now, in money and in time, for the chance of earning more later. Chapter 2 would call it moving money back: spending now what a later, better-paid you is expected to earn.

The cost has two parts. One is the bill. In 2022/23 the national survey’s tables put the average spent on education per head at about Rs. 34,800 a year at secondary level and about Rs. 77,000 at college or university, counting fees, books, uniforms, travel, tuition and snacks. At a private school the figure was more than four times that at a community one. The other part is bigger and easier to miss. It’s the pay you don’t earn while you are studying. A year at college is also a year not at work, and for a family that needs every earner, that is the real price.

What does the bet pay? The largest study of the question gathered 1,120 estimates from 139 countries. Across them, each extra year of schooling raised a person’s earnings, on average, by about 9%. The figure has stayed nearly the same for decades. For Nepal, a World Bank estimate published in 2011, from survey data of 2008, was about 8% a year. A later World Bank study of Nepal’s wage workers in 2018 found that a woman with a college degree earned about twice as much as a woman who hadn’t finished primary school, and a man with a degree about 71% more than a man who hadn’t. Education also seemed to help people find work at all: in 2022/23 only about 6% of people with a bachelor’s degree who wanted work couldn’t find it, and under 3% of those with a master’s, against about 15% of those who had finished only secondary school.

So, on average, the bet pays. The trouble is that you are not an average.

The averages hide three things. First, they mix together people who studied very different subjects and found very different work. A degree that leads to a job people need pays very differently from one that doesn’t. Second, some of the gain may not come from what was learned. People who stay longer in school may have been more able, or better connected, from the start, and some employers may pay for the certificate as proof that a person can stick at something, more than for what the certificate taught. Economists have argued for decades about how much of the gain is which. The tests they have run suggest that schooling itself does raise earnings, but nobody can say by how much it will raise yours. Third, the world changes while you study. The jobs a course was meant for may be fewer by the time it ends, or better paid abroad than at home.

None of that means the bet is bad. It means it’s a bet, and a sensible person weighs it the way a farmer weighs which crop to plant, without pretending to know the weather. The useful questions are plain ones. What will it cost, in rupees and in years? What are the people who did the same course a few years ago doing now, and what do they earn? How many who start it finish it? And what else could the same money and the same years do? A course whose graduates mostly can’t find work in it is a very different bet from one whose graduates are hired before they finish, even if the two look alike on paper.

The bet is also not only about money, and Smith saw that too. Some people choose the long, uncertain road because they love the work, or because it is respected, and are content to earn less than they might have. A choice like that isn’t a mistake in the sums. It is a different thing being bought.

The plain thing to take from all this is that money comes in three ways: by work, by what you own, and by being given. For most Nepali families it comes from several sources at once, and much of it unevenly, which makes every other money decision harder and makes spreading across sources a wise defense. Some work pays far more than other work, for reasons Smith listed, because of where it is done, and sometimes for no fair reason at all. And schooling is the biggest bet most people make with their earning life: it pays on average, but only on average. Earning is only half of it, though. The next chapter follows the first pay itself, from the amount an employer agrees to the smaller amount that reaches your hand.

Try this

  • Make a list of every source of money your household has, the way the survey asks: wages, a salary, the farm, a business, rent, money sent home, allowances, anything else. Which ones arrive every month, and which come when they come?
  • Ask someone who works for a daily wage, or a family member who once did, how many days of work they found last month. Multiply by the day’s pay and compare it with a monthly salary you know.
  • Pick a course or training you might take after school. Find out what it costs for the whole course and how many years it takes, then ask two people who finished it a few years ago what they do now.
  • If you ever help in a family shop or farm, keep a note of the hours for one week. The law’s limits for paid work, in the box below, are a fair measure of what still leaves time for school.

Found a mistake? Please tell us.