← Making Decisions, in Practice
Asking for advice · 39 of 84
Ask people one at a time, before you say which way you lean
Some evidence
Do this
- Write one plain question, the same for everyone.
- Ask people who don’t know each other, or haven’t talked about this.
- Don’t say what you’re leaning toward.
- If they disagree, that’s useful. Find out why.
What the research says
In one experiment, opinions that fed off each other made people more confident, though their judgments were less accurate. People trusted agreement too much, and underrated opinions that clashed. Some evidence: one study, on guessing calories. Agreement from friends who all heard the same story isn’t three opinions, but one. See Don’t count how often you’ve heard it.
Try it today
Write your question without a hint of your own view. Two minutes.
Where these facts come from
- Yaniv, I., Choshen-Hillel, S. and Milyavsky, M., Spurious consensus and opinion revision, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2009 (abstract).
General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.
