Exam practice
Every question from the end of every unit, with hints and answers to open. After you check an answer, mark how you did, and come back to the ones you didn’t get.
26 questions
Unit 20 · Theories of Evolution
Printable PDFs
- Study notes 4 pages
- Worksheet 4 pages Answer key
B. Answer the following questions
What is the primary concept of Lamarckism regarding environmental influence?
Answer
A change in the environment gives an organism new needs; new needs lead to new habits, so some organs are used more and others less. The organs used more develop, those not used weaken, and these changes, acquired in response to the environment, are inherited by the next generation. So, for Lamarck, the environment shapes organisms through their needs and habits.
What theory did Charles Darwin propound to explain organic evolution?
Answer
The theory of natural selection (Darwinism), published in On the Origin of Species (1859): organisms produce more young than can survive; they vary, and the best-fitted variants survive and reproduce, passing on their characters, so that species change over generations and new species arise.
Describe the concept of “use and disuse of organs” in Lamarckism with an example.
Answer
Lamarck held that an organ that is used constantly becomes stronger and larger, while an organ that is not used becomes weaker and smaller and finally disappears; these changes are passed on to the young.
Example (use): the giraffe’s ancestors stretched their necks to reach high leaves; their necks grew longer, and their young were born with longer necks, until the long-necked giraffe evolved. Example (disuse): the snake’s ancestors stopped using their legs while creeping through narrow places; the legs weakened and disappeared over generations.
What criticism did Weismann’s experiment provide against Lamarckism?
Answer
Weismann cut off the tails of mice for five generations; of the 901 young born, none was born without a tail or with a shorter tail. This showed that a change in the body acquired during life (here, a lost tail) is not inherited, against Lamarck’s inheritance of acquired characters. Weismann explained it by his theory of the continuity of germplasm: only changes in the germ cells, not in the somatic cells, pass to the next generation.
Explain the postulates of Lamarckism and provide examples for each postulate.
Answer
- a.Tendency to increase in size: living things and their organs tend to grow larger through an internal vital force. Example: Lamarck pointed to the rise of life from small, simple organisms to large, complex ones.
- b.Direct influence of the environment: a change in the environment creates new needs, which bring new habits and changes in the organs. Example: the ancestors of ducks took to the water and needed to swim.
- c.Use and disuse of organs: organs used more develop; organs not used degenerate. Examples: the giraffe’s neck lengthened by stretching (use); the snake’s legs disappeared through disuse; the human appendix shrank as our diet changed.
- d.Inheritance of acquired characters: changes acquired in life are passed on, and add up into a new species. Example: the webs between the duck’s toes, stretched by paddling, were inherited by its young; over generations, webbed feet became a character of ducks.
Name the type of struggle that occurs between individuals of the same species.
Answer
Intraspecific struggle, for example sal seedlings competing for light in a forest gap, or dogs fighting over food.
Explain the concept of “enormous fertility” in Darwinism with an example.
Answer
Every species produces far more young than can survive; if all survived and bred, its numbers would increase in a geometric ratio and soon overfill the Earth. Examples: an oyster can lay up to about 100 million eggs in a year; a Paramecium divides two or three times a day; even the slow-breeding elephant, Darwin calculated, would leave nearly 19 million descendants from one pair in about 750 years. Yet the numbers of each species stay roughly the same, so most young must die before breeding. This leads to the struggle for existence.
What is the main cause of the decline in light-colored peppered moths during the industrial revolution?
Answer
Soot from factories killed the pale lichens on tree trunks and blackened the bark. The light-colored moths, resting on the dark bark by day, became easy for birds to see and were eaten more, while the black moths were hidden. So predation by birds (natural selection) reduced the light moths and favored the black ones.
Which process describes the random change in gene frequencies in a population?
Answer
Genetic drift (the Sewall Wright effect).
How does natural selection lead to the origin of new species?
Answer
Individuals of a population vary, and many variations are inherited. Those with variations that suit their surroundings survive and reproduce more, so those variations become commoner in each generation. Where a population is isolated (by a mountain, river or sea) in different surroundings from the rest of its species, selection fits it to those surroundings; mutation and drift add other differences. Over many generations the differences build up until the isolated population can no longer interbreed with the original one: it has become a new species. Darwin’s Galápagos finches, each fitted to a different food on different islands, arose in this way.
Describe the three types of struggles for existence as observed by Darwin.
Answer
- a.Intraspecific struggle: between individuals of the same species, which need the same food, space, shelter and mates; the most intense kind. Example: tree seedlings of one species competing for light; male deer fighting for mates.
- b.Interspecific struggle: between individuals of different species, as predator and prey or as competitors for the same food. Example: tigers and leopards both hunting deer in Chitwan; elephants raiding farmers’ crops near the national parks.
- c.Environmental struggle: against the physical conditions of life, such as floods, droughts, extreme heat or cold, landslides and storms.
What prevents different species from interbreeding despite living in the same area?
Answer
Reproductive isolating mechanisms. Premating mechanisms prevent mating or fertilization: different habitats, different breeding seasons or times, different courtship behavior, sex organs or flower parts that don’t fit, and sperm that can’t fertilize the eggs. Postmating mechanisms act after fertilization: the hybrid dies (hybrid inviability), is sterile (hybrid sterility, like the mule), or its own young are weak (hybrid breakdown).
Explain Lamarck’s concept of the use and disuse of organs and how it contributes to evolutionary changes within a species.
Answer
Lamarck held that when the environment changes, an animal’s needs change, and it uses some organs more and others less. Organs used more grow stronger and larger; organs used less weaken and shrink, and may disappear. These changes, acquired during the animal’s life, are passed on to its young (inheritance of acquired characters). Each generation adds a little more change, so over many generations the species changes and in the end becomes a new species.
Examples: the giraffe’s neck lengthened by stretching to reach high leaves; the duck’s webbed feet from paddling; the loss of the snake’s legs and the shrinking of the human appendix by disuse.
(Modern biology rejects the second step: changes acquired by use or disuse are not inherited.)
Describe one example from nature that supports Lamarckism, highlighting how environmental factors influence evolutionary adaptations in a species.
Answer
The giraffe, Lamarck’s own example. The ancestors of giraffes were short-necked animals that ate leaves from low trees. When the environment changed and low leaves became scarce, they had to stretch their necks and forelegs to reach leaves higher up. By continual stretching, each giraffe’s neck grew a little longer, and (Lamarck said) its young inherited the longer neck. Over many generations of this, the long neck and legs of today’s giraffe developed. So, in Lamarck’s view, a change in the environment (scarce low leaves) created a need, the need led to use, and use led to an inherited adaptation.
(This is how Lamarck explained it; Darwin explained the same neck by natural selection among giraffes born with different necks, which is the accepted explanation.)
Discuss the criticisms faced by Lamarckism and provide examples or evidence that contradict Lamarck’s proposed mechanisms of evolution.
Answer
- a.Organisms don’t always become larger: some lines have become smaller, as plants from giant tree ferns and clubmosses to the shrubs, herbs and grasses that came later.
- b.New organs can’t appear by need or will: no animal grows wings because it wants to fly.
- c.Acquired characters are not inherited: Weismann cut off the tails of mice for five generations, and all 901 young had normal tails. Ears pierced, the tails of dogs docked and boys circumcised for many generations have never produced young born that way.
- d.What use builds is not passed on: a blacksmith’s or wrestler’s muscles, built by work, are not inherited by his children.
- e.Weismann’s germplasm theory: only changes in the germ cells, which make eggs and sperm, can be inherited; changes in body cells die with the body.
- f.Genetics shows that characters are inherited through genes, which change only by random mutation, not in response to need.
What is genetic recombination and how does it contribute to evolution?
Answer
Genetic recombination is the reshuffling of the genes of two parents into new combinations in their offspring, in sexual reproduction. It happens by (i) crossing over between homologous chromosomes in meiosis, (ii) independent assortment of chromosomes into gametes, and (iii) random fusion of gametes at fertilization.
Contribution to evolution: it makes every offspring a new combination of alleles, different from its parents and siblings, so it is the main source of the variation within a population. Natural selection acts on this variation: new combinations that suit the environment are favored. Recombination doesn’t create new alleles (mutation does), but it puts existing alleles together in new ways, some of which are better adapted, and so speeds up evolution.
Differentiate between chromosomal mutation and gene mutation with examples.
Answer
| Chromosomal mutation | Gene mutation |
|---|---|
| a change in the structure or number of chromosomes | a change in the DNA sequence of a single gene |
| large; can be seen under a microscope | small; can’t be seen under a microscope |
| affects many genes at once | affects one gene |
| kinds: deletion, duplication, inversion, translocation; aneuploidy and polyploidy | kinds: substitution, insertion, deletion of bases |
| examples: Down syndrome (an extra chromosome 21); bread wheat (polyploid, six sets) | example: sickle-cell anemia (one base substituted in the hemoglobin gene) |
Explain the concept of neo-Lamarckism and how it addresses some of the limitations of classical Lamarckism. Provide examples or evidence supporting the neo-Lamarckian perspective on evolution.
Answer
Neo-Lamarckism is the modified form of Lamarck’s theory put forward by later biologists. It dropped Lamarck’s inner vital force and the idea that organs arise from need or will, and held instead that the environment acts directly on organisms, and through them on their germ cells, causing heritable changes. In this way it tried to answer Weismann’s objection: a change becomes heritable only if it reaches the germ cells. It also recognized that an organism’s characters result from the interaction of heredity and environment.
Evidence often cited:
- a.Mutations caused by the environment: X-rays, ultraviolet light and some chemicals damage the DNA of germ cells, and the changes are inherited.
- b.Bacteria take up genes from their surroundings and pass them on (transformation).
- c.Epigenetic inheritance: chemical marks on genes set by the environment (diet, stress) are passed on for a few generations in some plants and in worms.
However, none of these changes is directed by the organism’s needs, and none passes on a body change acquired by use or disuse, so modern biology explains evolution by mutation and natural selection, not by neo-Lamarckism.
Explain Darwin’s concept of “survival of the fittest” and how it contributes to the process of natural selection.
Answer
Since more young are born than can survive, there is a struggle for existence. Individuals vary, and some variations make an individual better fitted to its surroundings: better at finding food, escaping enemies, resisting disease or attracting mates. These “fittest” individuals are more likely to survive and reproduce, while the less fit die early or leave fewer young. The phrase “survival of the fittest” (Herbert Spencer’s) names this. Because many variations are inherited, the young of the fittest carry their useful characters, which become commoner in each generation. This sorting by the environment, with no aim, is natural selection; over many generations it changes the species. The fittest are those that leave the most young, not simply the strongest.
Describe one example of natural selection in nature, highlighting how it influences the evolution of a species.
Answer
Industrial melanism in the peppered moth (Biston betularia). Before the Industrial Revolution, most peppered moths in Britain were pale, matching the lichen-covered bark they rested on; a black form was rare. Soot from factories killed the lichens and darkened the bark. Pale moths now stood out and were eaten by birds more often, while black ones were hidden and survived to breed. The allele for black color became commoner, and by 1895 about 98% of the moths near Manchester were black. When clean-air laws cleaned the air, the bark became pale again, and the pale form became common once more. The moth population changed as its surroundings changed, through the different survival of its two inherited forms: natural selection.
(Another example: mosquitoes resistant to DDT, which multiplied when DDT killed the rest.)
Discuss the role of mutation in driving evolution according to the modern synthetic theory (neo-Darwinism).
Answer
- a.A mutation is a sudden, heritable change in the genetic material: in a gene (substitution, insertion or deletion of bases) or in chromosomes (changes in structure or number).
- b.Mutations are the only source of new alleles; all genetic variation comes from them in the end. Recombination then reshuffles these alleles into new combinations.
- c.Mutations are random: they don’t arise because they would be useful. Most are harmful or neutral; a few are useful in certain surroundings.
- d.Natural selection acts on the variation mutations provide: useful mutations increase in frequency, harmful ones are removed. Example: a mutation that lets bacteria survive an antibiotic spreads where the antibiotic is used.
- e.Mutations in genes that control development, and chromosomal changes such as polyploidy (which can create a new plant species at once, as in bread wheat), can lead to new species.
So mutation supplies the raw material of evolution, and selection, drift and isolation shape it.
Compare and contrast Darwinism with Lamarckism, focusing on their key principles and how they explain the mechanisms of evolution.
Answer
Alike: both say that species change gradually over many generations, that new species arise from old ones, and that organisms come to fit their environment.
| Lamarckism | Darwinism |
|---|---|
| proposed by Lamarck, 1809 | proposed by Darwin (and Wallace), 1858–1859 |
| based on the inheritance of acquired characters | based on natural selection |
| variation arises in response to need, by use and disuse of organs | variations already exist, arising by chance, and are not caused by need |
| the environment changes the organism directly | the environment selects among organisms that differ |
| every individual changes in the same direction | only the individuals with useful variations survive and reproduce |
| no role for a struggle for existence or for overproduction | overproduction and the struggle for existence are central |
| example: the giraffe’s neck lengthened by stretching | example: long-necked giraffes survived droughts and left more young |
| disproved (acquired characters are not inherited) | accepted, and joined with genetics in the modern synthetic theory |
Explain the concept of genetic drift and provide examples of bottlenecks and founder effects, highlighting their significance in the evolution of populations.
Answer
Genetic drift (the Sewall Wright effect) is the random change in allele frequencies from one generation to the next, by chance, not by natural selection: which individuals happen to breed and which of their alleles happen to be passed on. It acts in every population but is strongest in small ones, where an allele can be lost or become universal by chance alone.
- a.Bottleneck effect: a disaster cuts a large population down to a few survivors, who carry only a chance sample of its alleles. Example: the northern elephant seal was hunted to a few dozen in the 1890s; it now numbers over 200,000, but they are nearly identical genetically. The cheetah is another example.
- b.Founder effect: a few individuals found a new, isolated population, which carries only their alleles. Example: the Amish of Pennsylvania, descended from about 200 founders, one of whom carried the rare allele for Ellis–van Creveld syndrome; the syndrome is now far commoner among them than elsewhere.
Significance: drift can change a population’s allele frequencies quickly, regardless of usefulness; it reduces genetic diversity, which makes a population less able to adapt to new diseases or surroundings; and in small isolated populations it can make them different from their parent population, helping new species to form. It explains why some harmful alleles are common in some small populations.
What is the bottleneck effect, and how does it impact genetic diversity?
Answer
The bottleneck effect is a kind of genetic drift that occurs when a large population is suddenly reduced to a few individuals by a disaster (flood, epidemic, overhunting). The survivors carry only a random sample of the original population’s alleles; many alleles are lost. When the population grows again, it is built from that small sample, so its allele frequencies differ from the original population’s and its genetic diversity is much lower. A population with low diversity has less variation for natural selection to act on, and is less able to adapt to new diseases and changes. Example: the northern elephant seal and the cheetah, which are both genetically very uniform.
Explain the founder effect with an example.
Answer
The founder effect is a kind of genetic drift that occurs when a few individuals from a large population start a new population in a new place. The founders carry only a small, chance sample of the parent population’s alleles, so the new population has different allele frequencies and less diversity than the parent. A rare allele carried by a founder can become common in the new population.
Example: the Amish of Pennsylvania (USA) descend from about 200 founders who emigrated from Europe in the 1700s and married mostly among themselves. One founder carried a rare allele causing Ellis–van Creveld syndrome (short limbs and extra fingers); today the syndrome is far commoner among the Amish than in any other population.
What are the main criticisms of Darwin’s theory of natural selection?
Answer
- a.It had no explanation of heredity: Darwin did not know how variations are inherited, nor how they arise.
- b.It could not explain how small variations, not yet useful, would be preserved and built up into a useful organ.
- c.It could not explain the over-specialization of some organs, such as the huge tusks of elephants or the antlers of some deer.
- d.It explained the survival of the fittest, but not the arrival of the fittest: where the useful variations first came from.
- e.It did not distinguish between somatic variations (not inherited) and germinal variations (inherited).
These gaps were filled by genetics, in the modern synthetic theory: variations come from mutation and recombination, are inherited through genes, and only germinal changes are passed on.
