Skip to content

← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words

How the levels work together

भाग २०: संघ, प्रदेश र स्थानीय तह बीच अन्तरसम्बन्ध · Part 20, Interrelations between Federation, Province and Local Level · Articles 231–237

On the highway, a truck of vegetables passes from one Province into the next. Part 20 of the Constitution says how the Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels deal with each other: whose laws apply where, who may give whom directions, how disputes are settled, and what may not be done to goods carried and services provided between them.

Where each level’s laws apply

A federal law may be made to apply to the whole of Nepal or, if needed, only to some part of it (). In the same way, a provincial law may be made to apply to the whole of the Province or, as needed, only to some part of it ().

The Provinces have their own list of powers, Schedule 6 (). If two or more Provinces ask the Government of Nepal for a law on a matter in Schedule 6, the Federal Parliament may make the laws needed. Such a law applies only to the Provinces concerned ().

Cooperation, and directions

The relations between the Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels are to rest on the principles of cooperation, co-existence and coordination (सहकारिता, सहअस्तित्व र समन्वय) ().

The Government of Nepal may, as the Constitution and federal law set out, give a Provincial Council of Ministers necessary directions on matters of national importance and on matters that need to be coordinated among the Provinces. Following such directions is the duty of the Provincial Council of Ministers concerned ().

The Government of Nepal may also, either itself or through the Provincial Government, give a Rural Municipal Executive or Municipal Executive (गाउँ कार्यपालिका वा नगर कार्यपालिका) the help it needs and necessary directions, as the Constitution and federal law set out. Following such directions is the duty of the Rural Municipal Executive or Municipal Executive ().

When a Province is warned, suspended or dissolved

gives the President a power for one kind of situation:

Warn, suspend or dissolve

The Constitution

(३) कुनै प्रदेशमा नेपालको सार्वभौमसत्ता, भौगोलिक अखण्डता, राष्ट्रियता वा स्वाधीनतामा गम्भीर असर पर्ने किसिमको कार्य भएमा राष्ट्रपतिले त्यस्तो प्रदेश मन्त्रिपरिषदलाई आवश्यकता अनुसार सचेत गराउन, प्रदेश मन्त्रिपरिषद र प्रदेश सभालाई बढीमा छ महीनासम्म निलम्बन गर्न वा विघटन गर्न सक्नेछ।

(3) In case any type of act that may seriously undermine the sovereignty, territorial integrity, nationality or independence of Nepal is carried out in any Province, the President may, as required, warn such Provincial Council of Ministers, suspend the Provincial Council of Ministers and the Provincial Assembly for a period not exceeding six months or dissolve them.

In plain words

If any act is done in a Province that may seriously harm Nepal’s sovereignty, territorial integrity, nationality or independence, the President may, as needed, warn that Province’s Council of Ministers; suspend its Council of Ministers and Provincial Assembly for at most six months; or dissolve them.

Nepali: भौगोलिक अखण्डता, geographical integrity (the translation says “territorial integrity”).

Clause (4) then sets a time limit:

Thirty-five days to approve

The Constitution

(४) उपधारा (३) बमोजिम कुनै प्रदेश मन्त्रिपरिषद र प्रदेश सभा निलम्बन वा विघटन गरेकोमा त्यस्तो कार्य पैंतीस दिन भित्र संघीय संसदको तत्काल कायम रहेको सम्पूर्ण सदस्य संख्याको बहुमतबाट अनुमोदन गराउनु पर्नेछ।

(4) Any suspension or dissolution of any Provincial Council of Ministers and the Provincial Assembly shall be approved by a majority of the total number of the then members of the Federal Parliament within thirty-five days.

In plain words

When a Provincial Council of Ministers and Provincial Assembly are suspended or dissolved under clause (3), the step must be approved within thirty-five days, by a majority of all the members the Federal Parliament has at the time.

If the Federal Parliament approves a dissolution, an election to the Provincial Assembly is held in that Province within six months (). If the Federal Parliament does not approve the suspension or dissolution, it stops having effect by itself (स्वतः निष्क्रिय) (the proviso to ).

If a suspension is approved under clause (4), Federal Rule (संघीय शासन) applies in that Province for the whole of the suspension and until the Provincial Assembly election under clause (5) is held (). While Federal Rule lasts, the Federal Parliament may make laws on the matters in the Provinces’ list, Schedule 6. Those laws stay in force until the Provincial Assembly concerned repeals them by making another law ().

Provinces and each other

sets out how Provinces deal with each other:

  • One Province must help carry out another Province’s legal provisions or judicial and administrative decisions or orders ().
  • A Province may exchange information and consult with another Province on matters of common concern, stake and interest (साझा चासो, सरोकार र हित), coordinate with it on their work and laws, and extend help to each other ().
  • A Province must, as its own provincial law sets out, give residents of another Province equal security, treatment and facilities ().

The Inter-Province Council

For political disputes between the levels, sets up a council.

Who sits on the Council

The Constitution

(१) संघ र प्रदेश बीच तथा प्रदेश—प्रदेश बीच उत्पन्न राजनीतिक विवाद समाधान गर्न देहाय बमोजिमको एक अन्तर प्रदेश परिषद रहनेछः—

(क) प्रधानमन्त्री — अध्यक्ष

(ख) नेपाल सरकारका गृहमन्त्री — सदस्य

(ग) नेपाल सरकारका अर्थमन्त्री — सदस्य

(घ) सम्बन्धित प्रदेशका मुख्यमन्त्री — सदस्य

(1) There shall be an Inter-Province Council as follows to settle political disputes arising out between the Federation and a Province and between Provinces:-

(a) Prime Minister - Chairperson

(b) Minister for Home Affairs of the Government of Nepal - Member

(c) Minister for Finance of the Government of Nepal - Member

(d) Chief Ministers of the concerned Province - Member

In plain words

To settle political disputes (राजनीतिक विवाद) between the Federation and a Province, and between Provinces, there is an Inter-Province Council. The Prime Minister chairs it. Its members are the Government of Nepal’s Minister for Home Affairs and Minister for Finance, and the Chief Ministers of the Provinces concerned.

The Council meets as needed (). It may invite to its meeting the Government of Nepal’s minister for the matter in dispute, the minister of the Province concerned, and an expert (). The Council sets its own rules for how its meetings are run (). For clause (2), the Nepali says the meeting is held (बस्नेछ) as needed, where the translation says the Council “may meet”.

Who chairs the Inter-Province Council?

Pick an answer to see why.

Keeping all three levels in step

The Federal Parliament makes the laws needed to keep the Federation, the Provinces and the Local Levels coordinated ().

Within a Province, the Provincial Assembly may keep the Province, the Rural Municipalities and the Municipalities coordinated, and, if a political dispute arises, settle it in coordination with the Rural Municipality and Municipality concerned and the District Coordination Committee (जिल्ला समन्वय समिति) (). The process and procedure for settling those disputes are as provincial law sets out ().

Goods and services between Provinces

, headed Inter-Province Commerce (अन्तर प्रदेश व्यापार), applies whatever is said elsewhere in the Constitution (यस संविधानमा अन्यत्र जुनसुकै कुरा लेखिएको भए तापनि). It is quoted whole here.

No blocks, no levies, no discrimination

The Constitution

यस संविधानमा अन्यत्र जुनसुकै कुरा लेखिएको भए तापनि एक प्रदेश वा स्थानीय तहबाट अर्को प्रदेश वा स्थानीय तहको क्षेत्रमा हुने वस्तुको ढुवानी वा सेवाको विस्तार वा कुनै प्रदेश वा स्थानीय तहको क्षेत्रमा हुने वस्तुको ढुवानी वा सेवाको विस्तारमा कुनै किसिमको बाधा अवरोध गर्न वा कुनै कर, शुल्क, दस्तुर वा महसूल लगाउन वा त्यस्तो सेवा वा वस्तुको ढुवानी वा विस्तारमा कुनै किसिमको भेदभाव गर्न पाइने छैन।

Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in this Constitution, it is prohibited to make any type of obstruction to the carriage of goods or extension of services by a Province or Local Level to another Province or Local Level or to the carriage of goods or extension of services to any Province or Local Level or to levy tax, fee or charge thereon or to make any type of discrimination on the carriage or extension of such services or goods.

In plain words

Whatever the rest of the Constitution says, the carrying of goods or provision of services from one Province or Local Level into another’s area, or in the area of any Province or Local Level, may not be obstructed in any way, may not have any tax, fee, charge or tariff put on it, and may not be discriminated against in any way.

Nepali: कर, शुल्क, दस्तुर वा महसूल, four kinds of levy (the translation names three: “tax, fee or charge”).

The Constitutional Bench is not affected

Nothing in Part 20 affects the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court under (). That Bench hears, among other cases, disputes about jurisdiction between the Federation and a Province, between Provinces, between a Province and a Local Level, and between Local Levels ().

What it means in your day

  • Goods from another Province. Goods carried and services provided from one Province or Local Level into another may not be obstructed, taxed or charged, or discriminated against ().
  • Living in another Province. A Province must give residents of another Province equal security, treatment and facilities, as its own law sets out ().
  • Federal Rule in the news. If a Province’s government and Assembly are suspended, the step must be approved by the Federal Parliament within thirty-five days (), and Federal Rule applies there for the suspension and until the Provincial Assembly election ().
  • A dispute between a Province and the Federation. A political dispute goes to the Inter-Province Council (); a dispute about jurisdiction can go to the Supreme Court’s Constitutional Bench ( and ).
Getting help

If you think your rights, or someone else’s, have been violated:

  • National Human Rights Commission (राष्ट्रिय मानव अधिकार आयोग), set up by , takes complaints of human rights violations (). Its hotline is +977-1-5010000, open 24 hours, holidays too, and it takes complaints online at nhrcnepal.org.
  • Free legal aid. gives any indigent party the right to free legal aid. Under the Legal Aid Act, 2054, every district has a District Legal Aid Committee (जिल्ला कानूनी सहायता समिति), chaired by the district’s government attorney, for people whose yearly income is below the amount the rules set, and for victims of gender-based violence or armed conflict.
  • The courts. gives the right to apply to the High Court () or the Supreme Court () to enforce the fundamental rights. A lawyer can explain how.
Where these facts come from

← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words