Skip to content

← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words

Choosing judges

भाग ११: न्यायपालिका · Part 11, Judiciary · Articles 153–156

On the news on a phone, a reporter says new judges have been appointed to the High Courts. The Constitution says who appoints them, and the body that recommends them first: the Judicial Council. A second body, the Judicial Service Commission, deals with the officers of the Judicial Service.

The Judicial Council

Judges are appointed by the President (the Supreme Court’s Justices, ) or by the Chief Justice (the High Courts’ and District Courts’ judges, and ), each on a body’s recommendation. For every judge but the Chief Justice, that body is the Judicial Council (न्याय परिषद).

Who sits on the Judicial Council

The Constitution

(१) यस संविधान बमोजिम न्यायाधीशको नियुक्ति, सरुवा, अनुशासन सम्बन्धी कारबाही, बर्खासी र न्याय प्रशासन सम्बन्धी अन्य विषयको सिफारिस गर्न वा परामर्श दिन एउटा न्याय परिषद रहनेछ, जसमा देहाय बमोजिमका अध्यक्ष र सदस्यहरू रहनेछन्ः—

(क) प्रधान न्यायाधीश —अध्यक्ष

(ख) संघीय कानून तथा न्याय मन्त्री —सदस्य

(ग) सर्वोच्च अदालतका वरिष्ठतम न्यायाधीश एक जना —सदस्य

(घ) राष्ट्रपतिले प्रधानमन्त्रीको सिफारिसमा नियुक्त गरेको एक जना कानूनविद् —सदस्य

(ङ) नेपाल बार एसोसिएशनको सिफारिसमा राष्ट्रपतिद्वारा नियुक्त कम्तीमा बीस वर्षको अनुभव प्राप्त वरिष्ठ अधिवक्ता वा अधिवक्ता —सदस्य

(1) There shall be a Judicial Council to make recommendation or give advice, in accordance with this Constitution, on the appointment of, transfer of, disciplinary action against, and dismissal of, Judges, and other matters relating to the administration of justice, which shall consist of the following as its chairperson and members:

(a) The Chief Justice - Chairperson

(b) The Federal Minister for Law and Justice - Member

(c) The senior-most Justice of Supreme Court - Member

(d) One jurist appointed by the President on recommendation of the Prime Minister - Member

(e) A senior advocate or advocate who has gained at least twenty years of experience, appointed by the President on recommendation of the Nepal Bar Association - Member

In plain words

There is a Judicial Council to recommend or advise, as the Constitution sets out, on judges’ appointment, transfer, disciplinary action and dismissal, and on other matters of the administration of justice. It has five members: the Chief Justice, who chairs it; the Federal Minister for Law and Justice; the most senior Justice of the Supreme Court; a jurist the President appoints on the Prime Minister’s recommendation; and a senior advocate or advocate with at least twenty years’ experience, whom the President appoints on the Nepal Bar Association’s recommendation.

The jurist and the advocate, members (d) and (e), have a term of four years, and their pay and facilities are the same as a Supreme Court Justice’s (). They are removed from office on the same grounds and in the same way as a Supreme Court Justice (); those grounds are in .

Complaints against judges

  • The chairperson and a member of the Judicial Council may study a case linked to a complaint about any judge, and report on it to the Council ().
  • If a first inquiry into a complaint about a judge shows that a detailed inquiry by an expert is needed, the Council may form an inquiry committee ().
  • If a judge, other than one who can be removed by impeachment under the Constitution, abuses their authority through corruption, the Council may investigate and bring a case, as a law sets out ().

Records of who could be appointed

The Judicial Council must prepare up-to-date records of the people qualified to be appointed Chief Justice or Justices of the Supreme Court, and Chief Judges or Judges of the High Courts (). Its other work, duties and powers are as a federal law sets out ().

Who chairs the Judicial Council?

Pick an answer to see why.

The Judicial Service Commission

A second body, the Judicial Service Commission (न्याय सेवा आयोग), recommends on the gazetted officers of the Federal Judicial Service (संघीय न्याय सेवा).

Appointing the courts’ officers

The Constitution

(१) नेपाल सरकारले कानून बमोजिम संघीय न्याय सेवाको राजपत्रांकित पदमा नियुक्ति, सरुवा, बढुवा गर्दा वा त्यस्तो पदमा बहाल रहेको कुनै कर्मचारीलाई विभागीय सजाय गर्दा न्याय सेवा आयोगको सिफारिस बमोजिम गर्नेछ।

तर संघीय सरकारी सेवामा बहाल नरहेको व्यक्तिलाई संघीय न्याय सेवाको राजपत्रांकित पदमा नयाँ भर्नाद्वारा स्थायी नियुक्ति गर्दा वा संघीय न्याय सेवाको राजपत्र अनङ्कित पदबाट सोही सेवाको राजपत्रांकित पदमा बढुवा गर्दा नेपाल सरकारले लोक सेवा आयोगको सिफारिस बमोजिम गर्नु पर्नेछ।

स्पष्टीकरणः यस धाराको प्रयोजनका लागि संघीय न्याय सेवाको राजपत्रांकित पदमा नियुक्ति गर्दा लिइने खुला र आन्तरिक प्रतियोगितात्मक परीक्षा लोक सेवा आयोगले लिनेछ।

(1) The Government of Nepal shall, in appointing, transferring or promoting gazetted officers of the Federal Judicial Service or taking departmental action concerning such officers in accordance with law, act on recommendation of the Judicial Service Commission.

Provided that the Government of Nepal shall consult the Public Service Commission for new permanent appointments to gazetted posts of the Federal Judicial Service from persons who are not already in the Federal Government Service or for promotions from non-gazetted posts of the Federal Judicial Service to gazetted ones of that Service.

Explanation: For the purposes of this Article, the Public Service Commission shall hold open and internal competitive examinations to be held for appointments to Gazetted posts of the Federal Judicial Service.

In plain words

When the Government of Nepal, as a law sets out, appoints, transfers or promotes the Federal Judicial Service’s gazetted officers, or gives one of them a departmental punishment, it acts on the Judicial Service Commission’s recommendation. But for a new permanent appointment to a gazetted post of someone not already in the federal government service, or a promotion from a non-gazetted post of the service to a gazetted one, the Government must act on the Public Service Commission’s recommendation. The Public Service Commission holds the open and internal competitive examinations for appointments to the service’s gazetted posts.

Nepali: लोक सेवा आयोगको सिफारिस बमोजिम, on the Public Service Commission’s recommendation (the translation says “consult the Public Service Commission”); विभागीय सजाय, departmental punishment (the translation says “departmental action”).

The Judicial Service Commission has five members ():

  • the Chief Justice, who chairs it ();
  • the Federal Minister for Law and Justice ();
  • the most senior Justice of the Supreme Court ();
  • the Chairperson of the Public Service Commission ();
  • the Attorney General ().

Its other work, duties, powers and procedures are as a federal law sets out (). It also holds the examinations for District Judges (), and reports every year to the President ().

Pay and conditions, and the Provinces

The pay, facilities and conditions of service of the Federal Judicial Service’s employees are as a federal Act (संघीय ऐन) sets out (). How a Provincial Judicial Service Commission is formed, and the pay, facilities and conditions of service of a Provincial Judicial Service’s employees, are as a federal law sets out ().

What it means in your day

  • When the news says a person has been appointed a judge, other than the Chief Justice, the Judicial Council recommended them first (, , and ).
  • When a complaint is made against a judge, the Judicial Council may study it, and may form an inquiry committee ( and (5)).
  • When the Public Service Commission advertises an examination for a gazetted post in the Judicial Service, that is the explanation to .
Getting help

If you think your rights, or someone else’s, have been violated:

  • National Human Rights Commission (राष्ट्रिय मानव अधिकार आयोग), set up by , takes complaints of human rights violations (). Its hotline is +977-1-5010000, open 24 hours, holidays too, and it takes complaints online at nhrcnepal.org.
  • Free legal aid. gives any indigent party the right to free legal aid. Under the Legal Aid Act, 2054, every district has a District Legal Aid Committee (जिल्ला कानूनी सहायता समिति), chaired by the district’s government attorney, for people whose yearly income is below the amount the rules set, and for victims of gender-based violence or armed conflict.
  • The courts. gives the right to apply to the High Court () or the Supreme Court () to enforce the fundamental rights. A lawyer can explain how.
Where these facts come from

← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words