← Constitution of Nepal, in Plain Words
Article 23: Against preventive detention
धारा २३: निवारक नजरबन्द विरुद्धको हक · Part 3, Fundamental Rights and Duties
In a social studies class, someone asks: can a person be locked up not for something they did, but to stop something they might do? Article 23 is about exactly that, and the limits on it.
What Article 23 says
Below, each part of Article 23 in the Constitution’s own words, in Nepali and in the official English translation, and with it what it means in plain words.
Only for an immediate threat
The Constitution
(१) नेपालको सार्वभौमसत्ता, भौगोलिक अखण्डता वा सार्वजनिक शान्ति र व्यवस्थामा तत्काल खलल पर्ने पर्याप्त आधार नभई कसैलाई पनि निवारक नजरबन्दमा राखिने छैन।
(1) No person shall be held under preventive detention unless there is a sufficient ground of the existence of an immediate threat to the sovereignty, territorial integrity or public law and order of Nepal.
In plain words
Everyone has the right not to be held in preventive detention (निवारक नजरबन्द) unless there is sufficient ground that Nepal’s sovereignty, its territorial integrity, or public peace and order would be disturbed immediately.
Nepali: सार्वजनिक शान्ति र व्यवस्था, public peace and order (the translation says “public law and order”).
The family must be told
The Constitution
(२) उपधारा (१) बमोजिम निवारक नजरबन्दमा रहेको व्यक्तिका स्थितिको बारेमा निजको परिवारका सदस्य वा नजिकको नातेदारलाई कानून बमोजिम तत्काल जानकारी दिनु पर्नेछ।
तर शत्रु देशको नागरिकका हकमा यो उपधारा लागू हुने छैन।
(2) Information about the situation of a person who is held under preventive detention pursuant to clause (1) shall be given immediately to his or her family members or relatives.
Provided that this clause shall not apply to a citizen of an enemy State.
In plain words
When a person is held in preventive detention, their family members or close relatives must be told about the person’s situation at once, as a law sets out. The proviso says this clause doesn’t apply to a citizen of an enemy State.
Nepali: कानून बमोजिम, as a law sets out (the translation leaves these words out).
Compensation for wrongful detention
The Constitution
(३) निवारक नजरबन्दमा राख्ने अधिकारीले कानून विपरीत वा बदनियतपूर्वक कुनै व्यक्तिलाई नजरबन्दमा राखेमा त्यस्तो व्यक्तिलाई कानून बमोजिम क्षतिपूर्ति पाउने हक हुनेछ।
(3) In case the authority having power to hold a person under preventive detention holds any person under preventive detention contrary to law or in bad faith, such person shall have the right to obtain compensation in accordance with law.
In plain words
If the authority that orders preventive detention holds a person against the law or in bad faith, that person has the right to compensation, as a law sets out.
Under Article 23(1), which of these is a ground the clause names for preventive detention?
Pick an answer to see why.
The law that carries it out
The Public Security Act, 2046 (सार्वजनिक सुरक्षा ऐन, २०४६), amended seven times since, most recently in 2075, sets out how preventive detention works. In plain words, it says:
- Who orders it. The “local authority”, the Chief District Officer (प्रमुख जिल्ला अधिकारी) or, in their absence, the officer acting for them, may order a person held for a set time at a set place, if there is proper and sufficient ground that the person must be stopped from doing something that could immediately disturb Nepal’s sovereignty, territorial integrity or public peace and order (sections 2.1.3 and 3.1).
- The family within 24 hours. The Chief District Officer must tell a family member or close relative about the person’s situation within twenty-four hours; its proviso: not for a citizen of an enemy state (section 3.1क).
- The reasons, in writing. The order must give its reasons and grounds, and be given to the person (section 4.1).
- The district court within 24 hours. The district court of the district where the detention order was made must be told, with a copy of the order, within twenty-four hours (section 4.2).
- Cancelled when the reason ends. If the reason no longer exists, the order must be cancelled within twenty-four hours (section 4.3).
- How long. An order lasts up to ninety days (section 5.1). Up to six months needs the Home Ministry’s approval (section 5.2.1). For longer than six months, the Home Ministry asks an advisory committee (section 5.2.2), chaired by a sitting Supreme Court justice (section 7); if the committee advises that the period should be extended, the order lasts up to twelve months from its date (section 5.2.2).
- Courts. No question may be raised in any court against an order issued under the Act (section 11). Section 12क.1, on compensation (below), begins “notwithstanding anything written in section 11”.
- Release. The person is released in front of the district judge or, in their absence, the court’s registrar (श्रेस्तेदार), and as far as possible a family member, a close relative or a person they choose (section 12).
- Compensation. A person who thinks they were held against the Act or in bad faith may complain to the district court, while still held or within thirty-five days of release (section 12क.1). If the complaint is proven, the court must order reasonable compensation from the Government of Nepal, weighing how long the person was held, their age, their standing in society, the money they lost and other things (section 12क.2).
- Departmental action. An official who issued an order in bad faith, or did not tell the family as section 3.1क requires, faces departmental action and punishment (section 13).
What it means in your day
- The Act speaks of stopping a person from doing something that could immediately disturb Nepal’s sovereignty, territorial integrity or public peace and order (section 3.1). The proviso to keeps preventive detention apart from the 24-hour rule for arrests.
- Even so, the family must be told (Article 23(2); Act, section 3.1क), the person must get the reasons in writing (Act, section 4.1), and a court must be told (Act, section 4.2).
- Wrongful detention gives a right to compensation (Article 23(3)); under the Act, the complaint goes to the district court while the person is held or within thirty-five days of release (section 12क.1).
Can it be switched off?
Yes. Article 23 is not on the list of rights that cannot be suspended (the proviso to ), so when a state of emergency is declared it may be suspended, all three clauses, while the emergency lasts. The same proviso says the right to seek the remedy of habeas corpus (बन्दी प्रत्यक्षीकरणको उपचार) shall not be suspended.
This page explains what the Constitution and the Act say. It is not legal advice.
Getting help
For compensation, the Public Security Act names the first step: a complaint to the district court, while the person is held or within thirty-five days of release (section 12क.1). If you think your rights, or someone else’s, have been violated:
- National Human Rights Commission (राष्ट्रिय मानव अधिकार आयोग), set up by , takes complaints of human rights violations (). Its hotline is +977-1-5010000, open 24 hours, holidays too, and it takes complaints online at nhrcnepal.org.
- Free legal aid. gives any indigent party the right to free legal aid. Under the Legal Aid Act, 2054, every district has a District Legal Aid Committee (जिल्ला कानूनी सहायता समिति), chaired by the district’s government attorney, for people whose yearly income is below the amount the rules set, and for victims of gender-based violence or armed conflict.
- The courts. gives the right to apply to the High Court () or the Supreme Court () to enforce the fundamental rights. A lawyer can explain how.
Where these facts come from
- नेपालको संविधान, Nepal Law Commission: the official Nepali text, as amended up to the Second Amendment, 2077 (PDF of Bhadra 2081): Article 23, quoted; Article 273(10), read
- The Constitution of Nepal, Nepal Law Commission’s English translation, as amended up to the Second Amendment (PDF, 2024): Article 23, quoted; Articles 20, 46, 133, 144, 248, 249, 273, read
- सार्वजनिक सुरक्षा ऐन, २०४६ (Public Security Act), Nepal Law Commission: sections 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 11, 12, 12क and 13, and its list of amendments
- कानूनी सहायता सम्बन्धी ऐन, २०५४ (Legal Aid Act), Nepal Law Commission: sections 2, 3 and 7
- National Human Rights Commission, Nepal: hotline and online complaints
