← Checking What You Hear, in Practice
Numbers and charts · 35 of 73
Read the numbers on a chart’s side
Some evidence
Do this
- Before you look at the bars, read the numbers up the side.
- Does it start at 0? On a bar chart, it should, or the bars’ lengths lie.
- Read the top of the two bars and work out the real gap yourself.
- Check the years shown too: are they the whole story?
How the trick works
A bar’s length stands for its value, so cutting off the bottom makes a small difference look large. Say two schools pass 90% and 92%. Start the axis at 88 and one bar looks twice as tall (our own example). In online experiments, this changed how big people thought a difference was, even when they knew the axis was cut. A cut axis isn’t always a lie: on line charts it can show real small changes. Some evidence: crowd-sourced studies, from one research team.
Try it today
Find a chart in a newspaper or an ad. Read its axis, and redraw it from zero in your notebook. Ten minutes.
Where these facts come from
- Correll, M. and others, Truncating the Y-axis: threat or menace?, 2019.
General information, not professional advice. No page can fit every situation. You use it at your own risk: see our terms. Spotted a mistake, or know something better? Tell us.
